WBAUnofficial
Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final (/showthread.php?tid=41589)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Hudds2 - 05-17-2026

(05-17-2026, 01:37 PM)KRO Wrote: Yeah spot on about the mess they’re in now.
Madness to not come up with a standard punishment after Bielsa and Leeds did it

(05-17-2026, 12:27 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 12:21 PM)KRO Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 12:04 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 11:26 AM)Sliced Wrote: But Grealish does that on the pitch, while the referee is watching. If a player fouls another one, then he gets punished, if he dives then he should be punished (although referees are, in my opinion, not doing their jobs anywhere near as well as they should be for these things). This was done behind closed doors after all teams agreed. A players actions are monitored and in theory they should be punished, the financial aspect of the game are monitored and clubs are punished, so the circumstances are a bit different.

As I say, I think in the regular season if the game was awarded as a 3-0 to Boro no one would really bat an eyelid. The reason it's a big deal now is because a 3-0 victory for Boro would knock Saints out of the promotion match, but this is the game when they got caught doing it so it is what it is. They shouldn't have done it.

Spot on Slice. I cannot believe anyone is trying to equate diving in game as the same as spying on opposition during training. Admittedly it's Josh and a Bluenose, so they could be on the wind up, but it's ridiculous to compare the two situations.

They have cheated, and by the sounds of further rumours today, it sounds like Ekhart has planned it throughout this season. They should be hit hard. End of.

I’m not equating the same. Diving is way worse and influences results of games and sometimes subsequent games of players get red carded due to cheating/diving players, more than watching a team train does imo. You disagree.
Regardless of which is subjectively "worse" in terms of severity of cheating, the rules were put in place to outlaw spying after the Leeds situation, so that stands on its own terms.  For credible enforcement, the result of the first game ought to be 3-0 Boro.

Would you say that if your team should be playing at Wembley in a play Off Final next Saturday and had spied?
Because I’d be fucking fuming at that punishment. And on the other hand if Blues had lost I wouldn’t be blaming it on someone watching our training and set pieces that get headed away by the bloke on the near post far too often
Non sequitur. I am going on the rules, not what ifs. But I would be livid if the Albion had breached the rules and put us at risk.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Josh1873 - 05-17-2026

It's good to know I'm not on a hill alone. Gutted it's with a Bluenose, though.

If I had had to pick one of the following, in order to prepare a team for a match:

46 games worth of footage showing how that team sets up across a season, how they react to a varying number of scenarios, how individuals play against actual opposition.

Or grainy footage from a kid's phone of a 1 hour training session.

I know which one gives me the best and ultimate information in preparation against that opponent.

As I've stated on numerous times, Saints have acted ridiculously, deserve punishment, but I can't help but feel there's a massive overreaction to what is an attempt to gain minimal information which in all likelihood has had nothing to do with the actual outcome on the pitch - not that the outcome matters, it's still cheating, and it absolutely needs dealing with.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Dial M for Mick - 05-17-2026

(05-17-2026, 03:37 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: It's good to know I'm not on a hill alone. Gutted it's with a Bluenose, though.

If I had had to pick one of the following, in order to prepare a team for a match:

46 games worth of footage showing how that team sets up across a season, how they react to a varying number of scenarios, how individuals play against actual opposition.

Or grainy footage from a kid's phone of a 1 hour training session.

I know which one gives me the best and ultimate information in preparation against that opponent.

As I've stated on numerous times, Saints have acted ridiculously, deserve punishment, but I can't help but feel there's a massive overreaction to what is an attempt to gain minimal information which in all likelihood has had nothing to do with the actual outcome on the pitch - not that the outcome matters, it's still cheating, and it absolutely needs dealing with.

If they didn't think it would make a difference, they wouldn't do it and when you consider the run they've been on, it probably did.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - tHEgLASSdOORS - 05-17-2026

(05-17-2026, 03:37 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: It's good to know I'm not on a hill alone. Gutted it's with a Bluenose, though.

If I had had to pick one of the following, in order to prepare a team for a match:

46 games worth of footage showing how that team sets up across a season, how they react to a varying number of scenarios, how individuals play against actual opposition.

Or grainy footage from a kid's phone of a 1 hour training session.

I know which one gives me the best and ultimate information in preparation against that opponent.

As I've stated on numerous times, Saints have acted ridiculously, deserve punishment, but I can't help but feel there's a massive overreaction to what is an attempt to gain minimal information which in all likelihood has had nothing to do with the actual outcome on the pitch - not that the outcome matters, it's still cheating, and it absolutely needs dealing with.

Let’s send someone 6 hours up north to break a rule for something that will have no impact?


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Peachy - 05-17-2026

(05-17-2026, 03:12 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 01:37 PM)KRO Wrote: Yeah spot on about the mess they’re in now.
Madness to not come up with a standard punishment after Bielsa and Leeds did it

(05-17-2026, 12:27 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 12:21 PM)KRO Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 12:04 PM)Peachy Wrote: Spot on Slice. I cannot believe anyone is trying to equate diving in game as the same as spying on opposition during training. Admittedly it's Josh and a Bluenose, so they could be on the wind up, but it's ridiculous to compare the two situations.

They have cheated, and by the sounds of further rumours today, it sounds like Ekhart has planned it throughout this season. They should be hit hard. End of.

I’m not equating the same. Diving is way worse and influences results of games and sometimes subsequent games of players get red carded due to cheating/diving players, more than watching a team train does imo. You disagree.
Regardless of which is subjectively "worse" in terms of severity of cheating, the rules were put in place to outlaw spying after the Leeds situation, so that stands on its own terms.  For credible enforcement, the result of the first game ought to be 3-0 Boro.

Would you say that if your team should be playing at Wembley in a play Off Final next Saturday and had spied?
Because I’d be fucking fuming at that punishment. And on the other hand if Blues had lost I wouldn’t be blaming it on someone watching our training and set pieces that get headed away by the bloke on the near post far too often
Non sequitur. I am going on the rules, not what ifs. But I would be livid if the Albion had breached the rules and put us at risk.

Exactly.....

My mate is a Saints season ticket holder and he is absolutely fuming that the club have put themselves in this position. He is expecting the worst and he has a ticket for the final.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - KRO - 05-17-2026

(05-17-2026, 03:12 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 01:37 PM)KRO Wrote: Yeah spot on about the mess they’re in now.
Madness to not come up with a standard punishment after Bielsa and Leeds did it

(05-17-2026, 12:27 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 12:21 PM)KRO Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 12:04 PM)Peachy Wrote: Spot on Slice. I cannot believe anyone is trying to equate diving in game as the same as spying on opposition during training. Admittedly it's Josh and a Bluenose, so they could be on the wind up, but it's ridiculous to compare the two situations.

They have cheated, and by the sounds of further rumours today, it sounds like Ekhart has planned it throughout this season. They should be hit hard. End of.

I’m not equating the same. Diving is way worse and influences results of games and sometimes subsequent games of players get red carded due to cheating/diving players, more than watching a team train does imo. You disagree.
Regardless of which is subjectively "worse" in terms of severity of cheating, the rules were put in place to outlaw spying after the Leeds situation, so that stands on its own terms.  For credible enforcement, the result of the first game ought to be 3-0 Boro.

Would you say that if your team should be playing at Wembley in a play Off Final next Saturday and had spied?
Because I’d be fucking fuming at that punishment. And on the other hand if Blues had lost I wouldn’t be blaming it on someone watching our training and set pieces that get headed away by the bloke on the near post far too often
Non sequitur. I am going on the rules, not what ifs. But I would be livid if the Albion had breached the rules and put us at risk.

The EFL did just that and said you’d breached PSR limits, and almost everyone here defended the club and blamed the EFL instead. So pardon me for not believing you about your thoughts on rules and being livid with Albion had breached the same rules and put you at risk of sanctions


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Josh1873 - 05-17-2026

(05-17-2026, 04:16 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 03:37 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: It's good to know I'm not on a hill alone. Gutted it's with a Bluenose, though.

If I had had to pick one of the following, in order to prepare a team for a match:

46 games worth of footage showing how that team sets up across a season, how they react to a varying number of scenarios, how individuals play against actual opposition.

Or grainy footage from a kid's phone of a 1 hour training session.

I know which one gives me the best and ultimate information in preparation against that opponent.

As I've stated on numerous times, Saints have acted ridiculously, deserve punishment, but I can't help but feel there's a massive overreaction to what is an attempt to gain minimal information which in all likelihood has had nothing to do with the actual outcome on the pitch - not that the outcome matters, it's still cheating, and it absolutely needs dealing with.

Let’s send someone 6 hours up north to break a rule for something that will have no impact?

It is so odd. I genuinely believe that information gained watching training, whilst useful, really wouldn't impact the game that much, given all the other data available. As I've already said, Boro battered them the first leg, and should have won, but for wasteful finishing. 

I don't understand why Saints would even bother, allowing themselves to be put into this situation, when the info you're getting is apparently so skant.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - MrBater - 05-17-2026

(05-17-2026, 03:37 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: It's good to know I'm not on a hill alone. Gutted it's with a Bluenose, though.

If I had had to pick one of the following, in order to prepare a team for a match:

46 games worth of footage showing how that team sets up across a season, how they react to a varying number of scenarios, how individuals play against actual opposition.

Or grainy footage from a kid's phone of a 1 hour training session.

I know which one gives me the best and ultimate information in preparation against that opponent.

As I've stated on numerous times, Saints have acted ridiculously, deserve punishment, but I can't help but feel there's a massive overreaction to what is an attempt to gain minimal information which in all likelihood has had nothing to do with the actual outcome on the pitch - not that the outcome matters, it's still cheating, and it absolutely needs dealing with.

Again, why not both?

Study their season games combined with training for the match you're about to play....


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - Hudds2 - 05-17-2026

(05-17-2026, 05:11 PM)KRO Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 03:12 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 01:37 PM)KRO Wrote: Yeah spot on about the mess they’re in now.
Madness to not come up with a standard punishment after Bielsa and Leeds did it

(05-17-2026, 12:27 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 12:21 PM)KRO Wrote: I’m not equating the same. Diving is way worse and influences results of games and sometimes subsequent games of players get red carded due to cheating/diving players, more than watching a team train does imo. You disagree.
Regardless of which is subjectively "worse" in terms of severity of cheating, the rules were put in place to outlaw spying after the Leeds situation, so that stands on its own terms.  For credible enforcement, the result of the first game ought to be 3-0 Boro.

Would you say that if your team should be playing at Wembley in a play Off Final next Saturday and had spied?
Because I’d be fucking fuming at that punishment. And on the other hand if Blues had lost I wouldn’t be blaming it on someone watching our training and set pieces that get headed away by the bloke on the near post far too often
Non sequitur. I am going on the rules, not what ifs. But I would be livid if the Albion had breached the rules and put us at risk.

The EFL did just that and said you’d breached PSR limits, and almost everyone here defended the club and blamed the EFL instead. So pardon me for not believing you about your thoughts on rules and being livid with Albion had breached the same rules and put you at risk of sanctions
Hang on that is not the same thing. The belief was that we had worked within the rules and even then the EFL moved the 
Goalposts. If the club had erred literally in error I would blame the club anyway. We still dont know full situation. But if the club deliberately flouted the spying rules I would be livid for such an obvious breach.  Try again.


RE: Boro want Saints kicked out of playoff final - tHEgLASSdOORS - 05-17-2026

(05-17-2026, 05:11 PM)KRO Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 03:12 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 01:37 PM)KRO Wrote: Yeah spot on about the mess they’re in now.
Madness to not come up with a standard punishment after Bielsa and Leeds did it

(05-17-2026, 12:27 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(05-17-2026, 12:21 PM)KRO Wrote: I’m not equating the same. Diving is way worse and influences results of games and sometimes subsequent games of players get red carded due to cheating/diving players, more than watching a team train does imo. You disagree.
Regardless of which is subjectively "worse" in terms of severity of cheating, the rules were put in place to outlaw spying after the Leeds situation, so that stands on its own terms.  For credible enforcement, the result of the first game ought to be 3-0 Boro.

Would you say that if your team should be playing at Wembley in a play Off Final next Saturday and had spied?
Because I’d be fucking fuming at that punishment. And on the other hand if Blues had lost I wouldn’t be blaming it on someone watching our training and set pieces that get headed away by the bloke on the near post far too often
Non sequitur. I am going on the rules, not what ifs. But I would be livid if the Albion had breached the rules and put us at risk.

The EFL did just that and said you’d breached PSR limits, and almost everyone here defended the club and blamed the EFL instead. So pardon me for not believing you about your thoughts on rules and being livid with Albion had breached the same rules and put you at risk of sanctions

One is subjective and one is very black and white. It’s not really a comparison to make IMO