WBAUnofficial
This season tells me one thing… - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: This season tells me one thing… (/showthread.php?tid=39299)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Josh1873 - 11-10-2025

It's like the Blackpool lights in text form!


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Lurker#3 - 11-10-2025

(11-10-2025, 08:19 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: It's like the Blackpool lights in text form!

Blackpool was never as good as Walsall Arbo. Shame the council binned it. An absolute staple memory of my childhood that was.


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Fido - 11-10-2025

(11-10-2025, 08:20 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(11-10-2025, 08:19 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: It's like the Blackpool lights in text form!

Blackpool was never as good as Walsall Arbo. Shame the council binned it. An absolute staple memory of my childhood that was.

Same here. The aunt still lives over that way and it was an annual tradition when we were nippers.


RE: This season tells me one thing… - richbaggie - 11-10-2025

There's a really good comparison that could be made between Mason and Kieran McKenna at Ipswich. Both retired young due to injury and went down the coaching route and achieved the highest coaching badges available. Both picked up first jobs at relatively big clubs albeit Ipswich a division below but both rebooting with new owners.

I took a look at his start earlier. After a flying start in his first few games, they then struggled and tailed off in 2021. They had an awful start the season after and they wanted him out but they stuck with and they finished 11th. They then went on an incredible run as we know.

Now, I'm not saying Mason is as good as him. I genuinely don't know yet. I would imagine that he's had so many ideas flowing through his head these past few years of how he wants teams to play and how he would manage people. Hes now finding out which ideas work and what don't. He has and will continue to make mistakes because of his inexperience. At the moment, I am more relaxed than most in letting it play out, seeing if he can develop. Who knows, he may go the same way as Kieran McKenna or he might not have it in him to be a no.1. Give him time to find out....within reason.


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Sliced - 11-10-2025

(11-09-2025, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: … and that is, fans talk a good game about building squads over several seasons, with young ambitious players and giving head coaches an opportunity to build sides over two or three years. The reality is those that advocate this approach the most, are the quickest to want the head coach sacked when they don’t get instant success, and that in our case is being in the play-off positions all season it seems. Despite the fact if they had a manager (sexy foreign name perhaps) they wanted ‘consolidation’ in midtable would be fine. 

Every sentence uttered by the head coach is ripped to shreds, every sub is declared awful, every defeat is appalling, every victory is due to how poor the opponents are. I even get the feeling after yesterday’s result some are very disappointed we won just so their wish for a new manager would become a step closer. 

Did anyone really think this season regardless of the balance of the squad, or mistakes by a rookie head coach would see us do anything but us bobble along where we are now? Fans either want a ‘project’ or they don’t. They either want to show patience in the rebuilding process or they don’t, they either accept our overspending in the past is causing us to readjust to being one of ten clubs who could finish anywhere from 14th-5th depending upon injuries etc or they don’t. 

The reactions on here and at the ground suggest that what fans really want is a team never out the play-off positions, playing exciting football, scoring lots of goals and led by a manager who is charismatic, almost the finished product, and well someone they said we should have appointed/have lost instead.

That's the case right now, but it depends on the general feeling at the time. Earlier in the season when we were winning week in week out some fans were saying how much they loved Mason's press conferences.

And none of this is new btw, it's not unique to this season or to our club. The manager could say the same thing when things are going well vs when things are going badly and it will be spun by a lot of fans in whichever way they want.

What I will say is that I don't think there's as many fans on the extremes as is being made out. I would like to see us performing a bit better but I think leeway should be given to a manager who is in his first ever season of management.

I think there are more people like me than those who 'want us to lose' to get Mason out. I've seen more posts claiming this than I've seen posts from people actively saying they want this.


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Derek Hardballs - 11-10-2025

(11-10-2025, 09:45 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: … and that is, fans talk a good game about building squads over several seasons, with young ambitious players and giving head coaches an opportunity to build sides over two or three years. The reality is those that advocate this approach the most, are the quickest to want the head coach sacked when they don’t get instant success, and that in our case is being in the play-off positions all season it seems. Despite the fact if they had a manager (sexy foreign name perhaps) they wanted ‘consolidation’ in midtable would be fine. 

Every sentence uttered by the head coach is ripped to shreds, every sub is declared awful, every defeat is appalling, every victory is due to how poor the opponents are. I even get the feeling after yesterday’s result some are very disappointed we won just so their wish for a new manager would become a step closer. 

Did anyone really think this season regardless of the balance of the squad, or mistakes by a rookie head coach would see us do anything but us bobble along where we are now? Fans either want a ‘project’ or they don’t. They either want to show patience in the rebuilding process or they don’t, they either accept our overspending in the past is causing us to readjust to being one of ten clubs who could finish anywhere from 14th-5th depending upon injuries etc or they don’t. 

The reactions on here and at the ground suggest that what fans really want is a team never out the play-off positions, playing exciting football, scoring lots of goals and led by a manager who is charismatic, almost the finished product, and well someone they said we should have appointed/have lost instead.

That's the case right now, but it depends on the general feeling at the time. Earlier in the season when we were winning week in week out some fans were saying how much they loved Mason's press conferences.

And none of this is new btw, it's not unique to this season or to our club. The manager could say the same thing when things are going well vs when things are going badly and it will be spun by a lot of fans in whichever way they want.

What I will say is that I don't think there's as many fans on the extremes as is being made out. I would like to see us performing a bit better but I think leeway should be given to a manager who is in his first ever season of management.

I think there are more people like me than those who 'want us to lose' to get Mason out. I've seen more posts claiming this than I've seen posts from people actively saying they want this.

I agree Slice, a lot of this is forever thus but I did find the constant threads after barely third of the season asking should Mason get sacked or who do you want as his replacement over the top. He’s had 14 games ffs, how can anyone be judged over such a short managerial career.


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Spandaubaggie - 11-10-2025

Always with everything in life there's a small proportion of people whose voices are disproportionately loud and others don't use the critical thinking skills to work out they don't talk for the majority.

EG the flags. Round me, in flag territory, I've spoken to several people against the flags going up, and barely met one person on their side, but our local Facebook page and the appearance of the flags would have you think we all love them, when the silent majority want rid.

It's the same with football. A loud 'Mason out' person makes more impression than 10 sitting there quietly, be it in the ground or social media.

In the heat of the moment I've thought he should be got rid, but honestly putting all the evidence of where we are as a club at the minute, then what next?

It's proven that in the past 15-20 years the shelf like of a football manager is far shorter as football has become more of a business with jobs dependent on it, and fans all can spout off on social media. It's gone down from 2.5yrs to 1.5. Those of us who remember the pre Prem days recall 3-5 years being usual for a manager.

As for us, I'm not happy where we are at the minute, but thought we played decent stuff on Saturday bearing in mind the pressure on the team.

Unless we go on a Norwich style run I think we have to back him. I certainly will, but the booers won't. Alas all clubs have them.


RE: This season tells me one thing… - tHEgLASSdOORS - 11-10-2025

Good post Spandau. I can’t recall being so ambivalent about whether we sack or keep a manager, it’s usually one extreme of the other. I still think he’s on very borrowed time but will support him and the team regardless and if he does end up with a long tenure I’ll be pleased for him and Albion


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Spandaubaggie - 11-10-2025

(11-10-2025, 10:18 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Good post Spandau. I can’t recall being so ambivalent about whether we sack or keep a manager, it’s usually one extreme of the other. I still think he’s on very borrowed time but will support him and the team regardless and if he does end up with a long tenure I’ll be pleased for him and Albion

Decent fans and decent people will want him to succeed, because it means a successful Albion. I'll happily admit if he proves me wrong as I was getting trigger happy and lost patience after the Charlton defeat.

Unfortunately though there's always gobshites so invested in their own self-importance that they'd rather he fail to be proven right.


RE: This season tells me one thing… - Sliced - 11-10-2025

(11-10-2025, 09:55 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-10-2025, 09:45 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(11-09-2025, 08:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: … and that is, fans talk a good game about building squads over several seasons, with young ambitious players and giving head coaches an opportunity to build sides over two or three years. The reality is those that advocate this approach the most, are the quickest to want the head coach sacked when they don’t get instant success, and that in our case is being in the play-off positions all season it seems. Despite the fact if they had a manager (sexy foreign name perhaps) they wanted ‘consolidation’ in midtable would be fine. 

Every sentence uttered by the head coach is ripped to shreds, every sub is declared awful, every defeat is appalling, every victory is due to how poor the opponents are. I even get the feeling after yesterday’s result some are very disappointed we won just so their wish for a new manager would become a step closer. 

Did anyone really think this season regardless of the balance of the squad, or mistakes by a rookie head coach would see us do anything but us bobble along where we are now? Fans either want a ‘project’ or they don’t. They either want to show patience in the rebuilding process or they don’t, they either accept our overspending in the past is causing us to readjust to being one of ten clubs who could finish anywhere from 14th-5th depending upon injuries etc or they don’t. 

The reactions on here and at the ground suggest that what fans really want is a team never out the play-off positions, playing exciting football, scoring lots of goals and led by a manager who is charismatic, almost the finished product, and well someone they said we should have appointed/have lost instead.

That's the case right now, but it depends on the general feeling at the time. Earlier in the season when we were winning week in week out some fans were saying how much they loved Mason's press conferences.

And none of this is new btw, it's not unique to this season or to our club. The manager could say the same thing when things are going well vs when things are going badly and it will be spun by a lot of fans in whichever way they want.

What I will say is that I don't think there's as many fans on the extremes as is being made out. I would like to see us performing a bit better but I think leeway should be given to a manager who is in his first ever season of management.

I think there are more people like me than those who 'want us to lose' to get Mason out. I've seen more posts claiming this than I've seen posts from people actively saying they want this.

I agree Slice, a lot of this is forever thus but I did find the constant threads after barely third of the season asking should Mason get sacked or who do you want as his replacement over the top. He’s had 14 games ffs, how can anyone be judged over such a short managerial career.

I agree, I don't think you can become a decent football manager until you've had a bad run and had to turn it around. It's easier to keep momentum when things are going for you