WBAUnofficial
How much is enough? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: How much is enough? (/showthread.php?tid=37752)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17


RE: How much is enough? - baggy1 - 06-20-2025

I’m guessing that Proth’s figure includes overtime as well as the NHS Consultant pay scale only goes up to £139k. Average salary is £104k according to the Daily Mail so it might be worth checking.


RE: How much is enough? - Protheroe - 06-20-2025

(06-20-2025, 06:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I’m guessing that Proth’s figure includes overtime as well as the NHS Consultant pay scale only goes up to £139k. Average salary is £104k according to the Daily Mail so it might be worth checking.

The Nuffield Trust, who know far more about this than you or me said in 2023:

"As a result, consultants’ basic NHS pay will be between £93,666 and £126,281, with average full-time NHS earnings likely to be around £143,100 once additional earnings are included to cover things such as on-call responsibility, medical awards, geographical allowances and additional activity."

In a period where household incomes are being stretched to breaking point it's obscene for some of the best paid public sector workers to be asking for a pay rise equivalent to the average wage.


RE: How much is enough? - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-20-2025

So, to be clear, you’re angry about people being disincentivised in some areas, but want us to lose our best trained medics to countries that will pay them the going rate?


RE: How much is enough? - man in the corner shop - 06-20-2025

"In a period where household incomes are being stretched to breaking point it's obscene for some of the best paid public sector workers to be asking for a pay rise equivalent to the average wage."

Straight outta Tufton St. Is it a Taxpayer's Alliance quote?

The average UK wage btw is £37.5k

And private sector wage growth is outstripping public sector wage growth

But let's not let the F A C T S get in the way of cultist dogma.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/employmentandemployeetypes/bulletins/averageweeklyearningsingreatbritain/may2025


RE: How much is enough? - Ted Maul - 06-20-2025

Proth might be talking Tufton St but this one is a classic case of the old 'optics'. How does it appear to your man down the pub when you've got people already earning 3x more than they do asking for a pay rise? And we continue to wonder why people purchased further towards Reform etc.


RE: How much is enough? - baggy1 - 06-20-2025

(06-20-2025, 07:14 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-20-2025, 06:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I’m guessing that Proth’s figure includes overtime as well as the NHS Consultant pay scale only goes up to £139k. Average salary is £104k according to the Daily Mail so it might be worth checking.

The Nuffield Trust, who know far more about this than you or me said in 2023:

"As a result, consultants’ basic NHS pay will be between £93,666 and £126,281, with average full-time NHS earnings likely to be around £143,100 once additional earnings are included to cover things such as on-call responsibility, medical awards, geographical allowances and additional activity."

In a period where household incomes are being stretched to breaking point it's obscene for some of the best paid public sector workers to be asking for a pay rise equivalent to the average wage.

Salary (your original post) does not equal pay. I’m just correcting the wording for you.

The request is a result of frozen pay for years which has led to a drain on the numbers of consultants. This has resulted in a shortage which in turn has resulted in overtime payments (more than the standard hourly rate) being paid. Pay the going rate, get the numbers up and reduce the overtime will result in a reduction in the overall cost.


RE: How much is enough? - Shabby Russian - 06-20-2025

(06-20-2025, 07:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Proth might be talking Tufton St but this one is a classic case of the old 'optics'. How does it appear to your man down the pub when you've got people already earning 3x more than they do asking for a pay rise? And we continue to wonder why people purchased further towards Reform etc.

What do you think the average Reform voter would make of the stat that the wealth of the richest man in the world, is around one third of the total GDP of an economically successful country of about 9 million people (Switzerland).

You can label that anyway you want, but what is, is unsustainable without a massive lurch to more authoritarian govt.

And in truth it really doesn't matter what the average Reform voter thinks, it's the opinion of donors to Reform that actually matters.


RE: How much is enough? - Ted Maul - 06-20-2025

(06-20-2025, 07:45 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(06-20-2025, 07:35 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Proth might be talking Tufton St but this one is a classic case of the old 'optics'. How does it appear to your man down the pub when you've got people already earning 3x more than they do asking for a pay rise? And we continue to wonder why people purchased further towards Reform etc.

What do you think the average Reform voter would make of the stat that the wealth of the richest man in the world, is around one third of the total GDP of an economically successful country of about 9 million people (Switzerland).

You can label that anyway you want, but what is, is unsustainable without a massive lurch to more authoritarian govt.

And in truth it really doesn't matter what the average Reform voter thinks, it's the opinion of donors to Reform that actually matters.

A) They don't understand.
B) It has no direct (obvious) impact to their lives.

People are seeing and hearing on a daily basis about the state the NHS is in, they go to hospitals and see staff hanging around, talking about holidays whilst appointments are running three hours behind (all things I've seen in the past 12-months), junior doctors striking for pay, now consultants who earn more than these people ever will, asking for more money, all the while becoming seemingly more and more unreachable in terms of getting an appointment with one.

I've worked in the NHS, I think it's brilliant but I think you're ignoring the 'reality' of what a lot of people are seeing and feeling if you think that this wont piss people off and further entrench them behind anyone who arrives on the scene and says things like "we should sack those who strike" etc.


RE: How much is enough? - Protheroe - 06-20-2025

(06-20-2025, 07:19 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: So, to be clear, you’re angry about people being disincentivised in some areas, but want us to lose our best trained medics to countries that will pay them the going rate?

If the tax cliff edges were removed then our best trained medics wouldn't need a 20% pay rise.

If medics choose to take their services overseas that's their right, but you're going to find over the course of this long 5 years with Labour that all kinds of state employees are going to hold hard-pressed average earners to ransom - who've got off pretty lightly in taxation terms in the last 20 years. The optics will be awful.

(06-20-2025, 07:30 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: The average UK wage btw is £37.5k

Take home is £27,000 Dear


RE: How much is enough? - baggy1 - 06-20-2025

(06-20-2025, 08:21 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-20-2025, 07:19 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: So, to be clear, you’re angry about people being disincentivised in some areas, but want us to lose our best trained medics to countries that will pay them the going rate?

If the tax cliff edges were removed then our best trained medics wouldn't need a 20% pay rise.

If medics choose to take their services overseas that's their right, but you're going to find over the course of this long 5 years with Labour that all kinds of state employees are going to hold hard-pressed average earners to ransom - who've got off pretty lightly in taxation terms in the last 20 years. The optics will be awful.

(06-20-2025, 07:30 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: The average UK wage btw is £37.5k

Take home is £27,000 Dear

You probably need to rework your figures on that one Proth. Removing the 100k - 125k removal of PA wouldn't result in an overall 20% pay increase.

And can you pick a number please instead of keep shifting the argument - do you want to talk about Salary, Pay including Overtime or Take Home Pay?