WBAUnofficial
The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector (/showthread.php?tid=35835)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-08-2024

That sounds like no matter what the solution the government put forward the builders are the ones that are responsible for restricting the growth of the housing stock. I think your ire is pointed in the wrong direction of that is the case chunk.

Angela Raynor came across well this morning and explained the process that the government are putting in place which sounds like a better proposal than is in place, if the builders are the ones that ultimately cause the blockage what can the government do?


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Borin' Baggie - 12-08-2024

(12-08-2024, 10:10 AM)baggy1 Wrote: That sounds like no matter what the solution the government put forward the builders are the ones that are responsible for restricting the growth of the housing stock. I think your ire is pointed in the wrong direction of that is the case chunk.

Angela Raynor came across well this morning and explained the process that the government are putting in place which sounds like a better proposal than is in place, if the builders are the ones that ultimately cause the blockage what can the government do?

Land value tax


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Protheroe - 12-08-2024

LVT is the solution to so many problems. You could scrap Business Rates, Council Tax, SDLT & IHT.


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Derek Hardballs - 12-08-2024

(12-07-2024, 06:14 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(12-07-2024, 06:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-07-2024, 05:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote: No, to clarify that’s not what has been said

To clarify that’s what will happen.

That isn't down to me or even my wishes. And just to clarify, as we seem to be clarifying here, I was brought up within a mile of Dudley town centre and up until about 25 years ago I was living in a two bedroomed terrace in Old Hill, so please spare me the working class back country 'you'll never understand' story, I'm at least as black country working class upbringing as you are.

the reason I highlight the edge of town / county / urban area developments like Dickens Heath is because they offer everything you are talking about needing and not further overcrowding built up areas, and it might be a surprise to you but they do have trains and stations in the countryside.

I’m not playing Top Trumps Working Class Edition, I’m not salt of the earth and my upbringing is more middle class but I do have working class roots and do live in a built up working class area. Those who live in those communities care about the place they live, the environment and amenities they can access and are rightly concerned that their views will be ignored by a Labour Government showing the same failings it did last time they were in power. Ignoring the views of areas that would traditionally have voted for them, telling them that they are x,y.z if they disagree and that they know best. This heavy handed and patronising approach will inevitably bite them on the arse at the next election. 

When communities feel things are foisted upon them and yet suggest they aren’t through lip service they will lose their trust and they will be punished at the ballot box. You may disagree but you have to take people with you but Labour are taking millions of us for granted and it will push communities into the arms of Reform Ltd. Labour were lent votes due to the appalling past 14yrs it was not due to their policies, if the Labour Party really think it was due to their policies they are even more tin eared than I thought.


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-08-2024

You brought up the status in life points not me.

It’s almost as if after 5 months Labour haven’t either solved all the problems or told everyone what they are going to do. We really are living in the social media age where everyone has to know everything immediately aren’t we.


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Derek Hardballs - 12-08-2024

(12-08-2024, 09:42 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You brought up the status in life points not me.

It’s almost as if after 5 months Labour haven’t either solved all the problems or told everyone what they are going to do. We really are living in the social media age where everyone has to know everything immediately aren’t we.

B1, I pointed out those living in more affluent areas will be cushioned from these policies and that it was not for others beyond those communities affected to sit in judgment on them, or for that matter Starmer as he did in his last piss poor speech. 

I haven’t suddenly become cynical of Starmer or the direction of the Labour Party, I was pointing out the lack of hope they were offering people and that if they don’t take people with them they will be a one term government. People simply voted against the circus that came before them, very few outside of the Labour Party were particularly enthusiastic about their policies… which let’s be honest are Tory-lite and increasingly heavy on populist rhetoric. 

I didn’t expect instant change for the better, I’m not a Tory or Reform voter but frankly I was left cold by Starmer’s election campaign and Starmerism seems to be falling into the same ‘we know best, so shut up you, nimby, racist, Corbynista, environmentalist’ (pick an insult) trap that Brown led the last Labour Party to.


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-09-2024

After a decade and a half of promises of things getting better and nothing happening I’m comfortable waiting to see what happens rather than get sound bites about sunlit uplands. If we’re in the same or worse position in 4 years time and Reform get the n on the back of bullshit then so be it. The only reason we still have got Farage around is because we didn’t let him own his last shitshow.


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Derek Hardballs - 12-09-2024

(12-09-2024, 10:28 AM)baggy1 Wrote: After a decade and a half of promises of things getting better and nothing happening I’m comfortable waiting to see what happens rather than get sound bites about sunlit uplands. If we’re in the same or worse position in 4 years time and Reform get the n on the back of bullshit then so be it. The only reason we still have got Farage around is because we didn’t let him own his last shitshow.

The main reason we potentially end up with Farage is the failure of the Tory and Labour Party. At the moment I think Labour’s messaging is appalling and whether you like it or not that does matter even at this early stage. If you want people to give them time then they should stop pointing fingers and starting fights with numerous groups like the disabled to civil servants… they may as well be the last shower of shite with messaging like that.


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-09-2024

What messaging are you expecting?


RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Derek Hardballs - 12-09-2024

(12-09-2024, 11:54 AM)baggy1 Wrote: What messaging are you expecting?

Oh I don’t know something where you try and bring most people with you… rather than pick fights, tell people it’s our way and then insult them if people disagree and generally act with ‘we know what’s best’ attitude. 

Step away from party politics and it’s pretty grim messaging currently.