WBAUnofficial
Coventry - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Coventry (/showthread.php?tid=33416)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: Coventry - CaptainFantastico - 04-21-2024

Goal line tech and serious foul play. Leave the rest to human based decisions as it always has been. Ups and downs of errors are part of the game


RE: Coventry - Duffers - 04-21-2024

(04-21-2024, 07:51 PM)wbamitch Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 05:39 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 05:35 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 05:30 PM)Duffers Wrote: Whether he was offside by millimetres or not is irrelevant.

VAR was supposed to intervene in the event of “clear and obvious errors” by the officials. That was the mandate.

How can that call possibly be a clear and obvious error when it’s that tight?

The mandate for offside is you go by the lines not clear and obvious. Offside is offside 1 millimetre or 1 foot.

No but if you have to draw lines and measure to the milimetre then the decision to award or not is neither clear nor obvious. Ergo VAR should not, by its own definition, intervene.

Said before that VAR should only ever be used in exceptional circumstances. You should only be seeing one or two VAR decisions a week across all fixtures. Not three or four per game.

I agree with you that it shouldn’t be used as frequently as it is, but what would you suggest defines clear and obvious for offsides? They have to work with something, and no matter what you introduce there will be times where somebody is a millimetre offside

My view is that if an offside can’t be spotted by the naked eye in real time then give the attacking team the benefit of the doubt. Anything that involves drawing lines on the field and measuring to the milimetre does not fit the definition of clear and obvious.

There’s an element of common sense that needs to be involved. It’s usually pretty obvious which decisions are tight 50/50 calls and which are obviously wrong.


RE: Coventry - chasetownbaggie - 04-21-2024

I only saw the last 20 or so minutes of normal time. Cov were tremendous but then I do rate them. They gave us 2 good games this season and I have been keen that they miss the play-offs because they are one team I fear. Feel very sorry for them that they lost after such a stirring comeback.

And if we do get promoted, fancy a cheeky bid for Ellis Simms Wink


RE: Coventry - CaptainFantastico - 04-21-2024

(04-21-2024, 08:29 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: I only saw the last 20 or so minutes of normal time. Cov were tremendous but then I do rate them. They gave us 2 good games this season and I have been keen that they miss the play-offs because they are one team I fear. Feel very sorry for them that they lost after such a stirring comeback.

And if we do get promoted, fancy a cheeky bid for Ellis Simms Wink

Agreed Chasetown, a very welcome blessing if they miss out


RE: Coventry - chasetownbaggie - 04-21-2024

Btw, I'm a big supporter of VAR, but I have to question why all 3 VAR officials are from the NW. Hmmmm...


RE: Coventry - sickParrot - 04-21-2024

(04-21-2024, 09:06 PM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: Btw, I'm a big supporter of VAR, but I have to question why all 3 VAR officials are from the NW. Hmmmm...

If they were from London, that would be suspicious.  Big Grin


RE: Coventry - Pragmatist - 04-22-2024

(04-21-2024, 08:28 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 07:51 PM)wbamitch Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 05:39 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 05:35 PM)wba13 Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 05:30 PM)Duffers Wrote: Whether he was offside by millimetres or not is irrelevant.

VAR was supposed to intervene in the event of “clear and obvious errors” by the officials. That was the mandate.

How can that call possibly be a clear and obvious error when it’s that tight?

The mandate for offside is you go by the lines not clear and obvious. Offside is offside 1 millimetre or 1 foot.

No but if you have to draw lines and measure to the milimetre then the decision to award or not is neither clear nor obvious. Ergo VAR should not, by its own definition, intervene.

Said before that VAR should only ever be used in exceptional circumstances. You should only be seeing one or two VAR decisions a week across all fixtures. Not three or four per game.

I agree with you that it shouldn’t be used as frequently as it is, but what would you suggest defines clear and obvious for offsides? They have to work with something, and no matter what you introduce there will be times where somebody is a millimetre offside

My view is that if an offside can’t be spotted by the naked eye in real time then give the attacking team the benefit of the doubt. Anything that involves drawing lines on the field and measuring to the milimetre does not fit the definition of clear and obvious.

There’s an element of common sense that needs to be involved. It’s usually pretty obvious which decisions are tight 50/50 calls and which are obviously wrong.

The “clear and obvious” requirement doesn’t apply to offsides, which is binary


RE: Coventry - shadman - 04-22-2024

The “clear and obvious” requirement doesn’t apply to offsides, which is binary.

Yes. And I haven't read the whole thread so this point may have been made, but lino's are told not to raise theirs flags - especially close calls.


RE: Coventry - CaptainFantastico - 04-22-2024

If they insist on continuing with offside calls being done on VAR a better and easier rule would be for a player to be onside if both players have any part of their body in the same section of lines drawn. It would also uphold the original point of what the rule was for and not punish the attacking team for minor margins


RE: Coventry - Duffers - 04-22-2024

(04-22-2024, 05:21 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 08:28 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 07:51 PM)wbamitch Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 05:39 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(04-21-2024, 05:35 PM)wba13 Wrote: The mandate for offside is you go by the lines not clear and obvious. Offside is offside 1 millimetre or 1 foot.

No but if you have to draw lines and measure to the milimetre then the decision to award or not is neither clear nor obvious. Ergo VAR should not, by its own definition, intervene.

Said before that VAR should only ever be used in exceptional circumstances. You should only be seeing one or two VAR decisions a week across all fixtures. Not three or four per game.

I agree with you that it shouldn’t be used as frequently as it is, but what would you suggest defines clear and obvious for offsides? They have to work with something, and no matter what you introduce there will be times where somebody is a millimetre offside

My view is that if an offside can’t be spotted by the naked eye in real time then give the attacking team the benefit of the doubt. Anything that involves drawing lines on the field and measuring to the milimetre does not fit the definition of clear and obvious.

There’s an element of common sense that needs to be involved. It’s usually pretty obvious which decisions are tight 50/50 calls and which are obviously wrong.

The “clear and obvious” requirement doesn’t apply to offsides, which is binary

It's binary in the same way that somebody decides if a foul or a handball is a yes or no.

Offsides are not as binary as you think. There are different factors and play and different interpretations of what body part of offside, when the ball was released, whether they are active, first/second phase, etc. It isn't like goal line tech where the process can be entirely automated down to a yes/no decision.

As I said yesterday you are still relying on human interpretation - the video team to stop to the precise milisecond the ball leaves the players' foot and for the lines to be drawn in precisely the right place. This still leaves the process open to individual interpretation and creates potential for human error. Unlike goal line tech which can give a definitive answer with no human involvement (unless you're at Villa Park).