WBAUnofficial
The cricket - - - - - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The cricket - - - - (/showthread.php?tid=32438)



RE: The cricket - - - - - ElbowGrease1973 II - 01-27-2024

Nice to show some fight and application. I thought I'd be waking up to an innings defeat. Still think India will win by 7 or so wickets, but at least we've made a game of it.

Unsurprisingly, it's going to come down to the quality of the spinners. Our last world class one was Swanny, so it's a department we were always going to be second best in.


RE: The cricket - - - - - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-27-2024

Good performance by England to give us a sniff of a chance. It's the "what ifs" that niggle me:

What if we hadn't gifted India 50 odd runs by bowling Hartley unchanged for 9 overs with attacking fields while he was being battered?
What if Root had bowled more overs earlier in the innings?
What if we'd had a wily seamer to exploit reverse swing (Robinson, Anderson?) instead of the shock-jock Wood?
What if a fully fit and raring-to-go Liam Dawson had been there instead of a clearly-not-fit-yet Jack Leach?

Similar story to the Ashes. We showed over 5 Tests that we were good enough to beat Oz last summer, but could only square the series because of some poor tactical decisions and strange selections. 50 more runs on our lead and a better balanced bowling attack to get at India in the last innings and we'd be feeling really confident about this.


RE: The cricket - - - - - Fido - 01-27-2024

As far as “what ifs” go, “what if we’d scored more runs” takes the fuggin biscuit.


RE: The cricket - - - - - Beachboysbaggie - 01-27-2024

(01-24-2024, 10:27 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: No, I won't be getting up at 4.00am to listen, but I will tune in halfway through the first day.

I've been a stern critic of Rob Key and his off-the-wall selections for England. Will he prove me wrong starting tomorrow? Mark Wood is the only seamer in the line-up. Hardly a stock bowler though. If the Indian batters take a liking to one or more of the spinners we'll see a lot of overs bowled by part-timers like Root and - - - well who else? We desperately needed a seam bowling all-rounder, but that would have meant leaving out Bairstow or Foakes. Can't leave out Jonny, he's one of the gang.

What jars with me is the fact that the proven best spin bowler in England, Liam Dawson, has been left out because "he is probably not someone who wants to go around India as a 15th or 16th man. I don't think it's high on his agenda to be a replacement bowler". Yet we've picked Leach who hasn't played at all since injury and two blokes with barely two seasons of first class cricket behind them. Rob Key has essentially said "You don't have an England future, Liam Dawson".

Remember one of England's better players in the woeful World Cup finals? David Willey, informed halfway through the tournament that he wouldn't be offered a new central contract and responded by announcing his retirement from international cricket immediately afterwards. Wonderful motivation from the management there.

Rob Key is all about cliques, cronies, old pals' acts, keeping the band together. All the stuff that prevents English cricket from staying at the top for long. I'll be delighted when he's gone. This tour will either provide some shreds of evidence that his methods can work or (more likely IMO) be another well-deserved nail in the coffin of his career.

Why the anti-Key? Prior to his appointment we won 1 test in 18. He appointed McCullum and we’ve won I think 13 in 18 tests, playing some of the most exciting test cricket many of us have seen and encompassing an unprecedented 3-0 series win in Pakistan. We’ve also won the T20 World Cup during Key’s tenure. He’s given test debuts to Brook, Potts, Tongue and Ahmed, all of whom should be mainstays for years to come, and reintroduced Crawley and Duckett who are both blossoming into top test players. Who would you replacing him with?

And which seam bowling all rounder would you replace Bairstow with? There’s a reason why Bairstow keeps his place and it’s not because he’s “one of the gang”, it’s probably his average of 66 in 2022 and 40 in 2023 - after coming back from a career-threatening injury against the world champions while keeping wicket. Who would you plump for instead?


RE: The cricket - - - - - rsbaggy2 - 01-27-2024

Bairstow .... not overly liked on the county circuit.


RE: The cricket - - - - - backsidebaggie - 01-28-2024

(01-27-2024, 02:12 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Good performance by England to give us a sniff of a chance. It's the "what ifs" that niggle me:

What if we hadn't gifted India 50 odd runs by bowling Hartley unchanged for 9 overs with attacking fields while he was being battered?
What if Root had bowled more overs earlier in the innings?
What if we'd had a wily seamer to exploit reverse swing (Robinson, Anderson?) instead of the shock-jock Wood?
What if a fully fit and raring-to-go Liam Dawson had been there instead of a clearly-not-fit-yet Jack Leach?

Similar story to the Ashes. We showed over 5 Tests that we were good enough to beat Oz last summer, but could only square the series because of some poor tactical decisions and strange selections. 50 more runs on our lead and a better balanced bowling attack to get at India in the last innings and we'd be feeling really confident about this.

Leach got injured after bowling well on day 1.

Dawson should definitely be there, but not instead of Leach! He should be there instead of one of the other spinners.


RE: The cricket - - - - - SuperBob2002 - 01-28-2024

Rob Key is a massive bell end, tbf.


RE: The cricket - - - - - CA Baggie - 01-28-2024

It’s on, who’d have thought that. Win or lose from this position it will certainly change both teams mentality for the rest of the series.

And come on the Windies…


RE: The cricket - - - - - SuperBob2002 - 01-28-2024

I'm only following via keeping an eye on the score. How's the pitch looking? Is 230 a defendable score?

I'd expect us to lose from here, still, but what a great fightback that shows real character.


RE: The cricket - - - - - Albionmad - 01-28-2024

Windies pull off an amazing win in Australia. 
First test win in over 30 yrs in Aus.

2 quick wickets for England. 
Could be interesting