RE: Seriously breathtaking - fuzzbox - 10-30-2023
(10-30-2023, 01:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (10-30-2023, 10:19 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (10-29-2023, 11:56 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (10-29-2023, 11:29 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (10-28-2023, 05:54 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Some will seek refuge in any flimsy justification. Unfortunately they are posters on this board too.
It really is sad to see folk justify this blatant support for racist officers. By association they label themselves as racists too, in my book.
It's clear cut that the motivation to donate (in most cases) is based on prejudices. Those that attempt to justify or excuse such behaviour are those that accept such. £112k in 3 days!
That is just plain offensive. If someone disagrees with you, you skip all the stages and go straight to nuclear and 'label' them racists. Excellent work, you've done exactly what the organisers wanted. You do more harm than good with this attitude.
Your stance on this is beyond offensive, in my eyes. It's not a far reach to conclude on the motives of the person who set it up and many of the donors.
You're scratching around with flimsy justifications to fit your thinking. I can't think of any similar kind of crowd funding ... they tend to be genuine and non controversial. I don't see a rush to contribute to the new and very "timely"? crowd funding for the grenfell victims ... also set up with an apparent police focus. I think that would be more deserving of donations (if genuine) than such a racially motivated one.
https://www.justgiving.com/crowdfunding/policevoice-uk-grenfelltower
I'm sorry you feel this way. I really don't think such a confrontational attitude will help anyone.
I tried to explain my thinking. I even provided a link to Searchlight where you can read studies and research about the use of these campaigns as a way to 'convert' people by making them feel alienated by facing a backlash.
Did you read them? I thought they were quite detailed and although you don't know of any (and nor did I before I researched it), they provide a lot of real life examples of dubious fundraisers. To me, they made a lot of sense. But, even if you don't agree with their work or their conclusions, I think it's a bit harsh to call them 'flimsy'.
Most of my charity funding and, I suppose interest, is focused on scholarships for people from disadvantaged background, regardless of race. Although, of course, that does sometimes come into it. However, because of my ethnicity and profession, I'm also a member of two boards - one in the USA and one in the UK (Until the end of this year) which aim to promote a more ethnically diverse presence at the senior levels of the legal profession. From this work, I've been able to see that I don't have all the answers and there is more than one way to tackle the issue of racism.
However, the one that almost never works - and there is plenty of evidence - is labelling people racist. That only pushes them in that direction.
**Just to be sure it's clear, I didn't say the organisers didn't have an 'agenda'. In fact, quite the opposite! That's why - and I feel like I'm labouring this - I don't think people should give them the outrage they are looking for. I also didn't say that some of the people who donate weren't racist. I'm sure some are! I was saying - and still believe - not all those who donate are racist. Although, if we're not careful, that's exactly what some of them will become.
As ever Fuzzbox, you've nailed it.
We live in a truly freaky time and one of bewildering intolerance from people who disagree slightly with what is considered 'the right' opinion.
Internet algorithms, the difficulty of discussing sensitive subjects on a messageboard or social media generally creates an awful shouting match.
It is also why we have the madness of Trump, still broadly loved by half of America, despite being a truly repulsive character, who any sensible person can see has no values.
Being mixed race, I think you Fuzzbox have an insight that most of us white guys don't, and your heritage allows you to say things that most of us can't say, as you've walked a path most of us on here won't due to our skin colour.
We have to start having sensible conversations again about things that we disagree on, or we have a real shitshow of a future. How we find the conditions to do that is another much larger question.
Thanks for your kind words. Not that it matters, and I probably wouldn't mention it but for the context of this thread - I'm not mixed race. At least, no more than anyone else! As far back as I can probably look, I'm West Indian heritage.
RE: Seriously breathtaking - Spandaubaggie - 10-30-2023
(10-30-2023, 02:19 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (10-30-2023, 01:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (10-30-2023, 10:19 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (10-29-2023, 11:56 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (10-29-2023, 11:29 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: That is just plain offensive. If someone disagrees with you, you skip all the stages and go straight to nuclear and 'label' them racists. Excellent work, you've done exactly what the organisers wanted. You do more harm than good with this attitude.
Your stance on this is beyond offensive, in my eyes. It's not a far reach to conclude on the motives of the person who set it up and many of the donors.
You're scratching around with flimsy justifications to fit your thinking. I can't think of any similar kind of crowd funding ... they tend to be genuine and non controversial. I don't see a rush to contribute to the new and very "timely"? crowd funding for the grenfell victims ... also set up with an apparent police focus. I think that would be more deserving of donations (if genuine) than such a racially motivated one.
https://www.justgiving.com/crowdfunding/policevoice-uk-grenfelltower
I'm sorry you feel this way. I really don't think such a confrontational attitude will help anyone.
I tried to explain my thinking. I even provided a link to Searchlight where you can read studies and research about the use of these campaigns as a way to 'convert' people by making them feel alienated by facing a backlash.
Did you read them? I thought they were quite detailed and although you don't know of any (and nor did I before I researched it), they provide a lot of real life examples of dubious fundraisers. To me, they made a lot of sense. But, even if you don't agree with their work or their conclusions, I think it's a bit harsh to call them 'flimsy'.
Most of my charity funding and, I suppose interest, is focused on scholarships for people from disadvantaged background, regardless of race. Although, of course, that does sometimes come into it. However, because of my ethnicity and profession, I'm also a member of two boards - one in the USA and one in the UK (Until the end of this year) which aim to promote a more ethnically diverse presence at the senior levels of the legal profession. From this work, I've been able to see that I don't have all the answers and there is more than one way to tackle the issue of racism.
However, the one that almost never works - and there is plenty of evidence - is labelling people racist. That only pushes them in that direction.
**Just to be sure it's clear, I didn't say the organisers didn't have an 'agenda'. In fact, quite the opposite! That's why - and I feel like I'm labouring this - I don't think people should give them the outrage they are looking for. I also didn't say that some of the people who donate weren't racist. I'm sure some are! I was saying - and still believe - not all those who donate are racist. Although, if we're not careful, that's exactly what some of them will become.
As ever Fuzzbox, you've nailed it.
We live in a truly freaky time and one of bewildering intolerance from people who disagree slightly with what is considered 'the right' opinion.
Internet algorithms, the difficulty of discussing sensitive subjects on a messageboard or social media generally creates an awful shouting match.
It is also why we have the madness of Trump, still broadly loved by half of America, despite being a truly repulsive character, who any sensible person can see has no values.
Being mixed race, I think you Fuzzbox have an insight that most of us white guys don't, and your heritage allows you to say things that most of us can't say, as you've walked a path most of us on here won't due to our skin colour.
We have to start having sensible conversations again about things that we disagree on, or we have a real shitshow of a future. How we find the conditions to do that is another much larger question.
Thanks for your kind words. Not that it matters, and I probably wouldn't mention it but for the context of this thread - I'm not mixed race. At least, no more than anyone else! As far back as I can probably look, I'm West Indian heritage. I kind of get what you mean chap. It's a strangely label conscious time. Who knows what the right and wrong things to say are?
As the playright Tom Stoppard said most people self-cancel.
I think most people I know are scared of expressing opinions outside a small circle of people they are comfortable with, for fear of saying the wrong thing.
RE: Seriously breathtaking - rsbaggy2 - 10-30-2023
I await the next crowdfunding appeal. I sincerely hope not but it wouldn't surprise me.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-67259635
RE: Seriously breathtaking - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-30-2023
I see the fund has reached £135K. It should now be turned off.
We are told all the funds will go the disgraced officers families, to help support their lives (nothing about legal bills, appeal costs etc). This should be more than enough money. The officers have been found guilty of racist offences by the police board, but their families haven't. This will give breathing space for the families to restructure their lives, and move on.
I haven't contributed, I wouldn't contribute. Nobody crowdfunded me on the 2 occasions I was made redundant. I do think it is a legitimate appeal to help the families, and I don't consider the contributors to be racist. Yes some may be, but many others will not want to see families potentially out on the street because of this.
I would agree that the officers should have behaved better, and shouldn't be in the job if they can't treat everyone with equal respect. I think Fuzz had a bad experience with the police in the past, and I certainly have in the last 20 years. For me the bigger issue here is police standards and accountability, which by my own experience is shockingly bad - as a white male.
RE: Seriously breathtaking - fuzzbox - 10-30-2023
(10-30-2023, 04:16 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: I await the next crowdfunding appeal. I sincerely hope not but it wouldn't surprise me.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-67259635
Honestly wouldn't surprise me. It only takes a couple of people ten minutes to set it up and then all they need to do is sit back and watch.
There'll no doubt be hints that the real facts have been 'hushed up' as a vendetta by an unnamed 'power' with a 'secret agenda' to undermine 'British Society' and that if you don't stand 'proud' you could be the next victim. It's like a macabre version of the old game of cliche bingo we used to play in meetings. The one thing it won't mention directly will be race. That's not who they are after.
Of course, we have to also keep in mind he has been charged, not convicted. But you're right - a 'freedom fund' sounds likely.
Again on a plus note, there's been plenty of research into the finances of out-and-out racist organisations. They are all pretty much penniless with far, far fewer members than you would imagine.
RE: Seriously breathtaking - CarlosCorbewrong - 10-30-2023
The 'clever' response from the left would be to set one up fir this guy: https://www.google.com/amp/s/news.sky.com/story/amp/paedophile-police-officer-had-more-than-200-victims-12991000
RE: Seriously breathtaking - Brentbaggie - 10-30-2023
(10-30-2023, 02:19 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (10-30-2023, 01:48 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (10-30-2023, 10:19 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: (10-29-2023, 11:56 AM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: (10-29-2023, 11:29 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: That is just plain offensive. If someone disagrees with you, you skip all the stages and go straight to nuclear and 'label' them racists. Excellent work, you've done exactly what the organisers wanted. You do more harm than good with this attitude.
Your stance on this is beyond offensive, in my eyes. It's not a far reach to conclude on the motives of the person who set it up and many of the donors.
You're scratching around with flimsy justifications to fit your thinking. I can't think of any similar kind of crowd funding ... they tend to be genuine and non controversial. I don't see a rush to contribute to the new and very "timely"? crowd funding for the grenfell victims ... also set up with an apparent police focus. I think that would be more deserving of donations (if genuine) than such a racially motivated one.
https://www.justgiving.com/crowdfunding/policevoice-uk-grenfelltower
I'm sorry you feel this way. I really don't think such a confrontational attitude will help anyone.
I tried to explain my thinking. I even provided a link to Searchlight where you can read studies and research about the use of these campaigns as a way to 'convert' people by making them feel alienated by facing a backlash.
Did you read them? I thought they were quite detailed and although you don't know of any (and nor did I before I researched it), they provide a lot of real life examples of dubious fundraisers. To me, they made a lot of sense. But, even if you don't agree with their work or their conclusions, I think it's a bit harsh to call them 'flimsy'.
Most of my charity funding and, I suppose interest, is focused on scholarships for people from disadvantaged background, regardless of race. Although, of course, that does sometimes come into it. However, because of my ethnicity and profession, I'm also a member of two boards - one in the USA and one in the UK (Until the end of this year) which aim to promote a more ethnically diverse presence at the senior levels of the legal profession. From this work, I've been able to see that I don't have all the answers and there is more than one way to tackle the issue of racism.
However, the one that almost never works - and there is plenty of evidence - is labelling people racist. That only pushes them in that direction.
**Just to be sure it's clear, I didn't say the organisers didn't have an 'agenda'. In fact, quite the opposite! That's why - and I feel like I'm labouring this - I don't think people should give them the outrage they are looking for. I also didn't say that some of the people who donate weren't racist. I'm sure some are! I was saying - and still believe - not all those who donate are racist. Although, if we're not careful, that's exactly what some of them will become.
As ever Fuzzbox, you've nailed it.
We live in a truly freaky time and one of bewildering intolerance from people who disagree slightly with what is considered 'the right' opinion.
Internet algorithms, the difficulty of discussing sensitive subjects on a messageboard or social media generally creates an awful shouting match.
It is also why we have the madness of Trump, still broadly loved by half of America, despite being a truly repulsive character, who any sensible person can see has no values.
Being mixed race, I think you Fuzzbox have an insight that most of us white guys don't, and your heritage allows you to say things that most of us can't say, as you've walked a path most of us on here won't due to our skin colour.
We have to start having sensible conversations again about things that we disagree on, or we have a real shitshow of a future. How we find the conditions to do that is another much larger question.
Thanks for your kind words. Not that it matters, and I probably wouldn't mention it but for the context of this thread - I'm not mixed race. At least, no more than anyone else! As far back as I can probably look, I'm West Indian heritage.
In which case you're almost certainly Scottish!
RE: Seriously breathtaking - WorcsWBA - 10-30-2023
(10-30-2023, 04:43 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I see the fund has reached £135K. It should now be turned off.
We are told all the funds will go the disgraced officers families, to help support their lives (nothing about legal bills, appeal costs etc). This should be more than enough money. The officers have been found guilty of racist offences by the police board, but their families haven't. This will give breathing space for the families to restructure their lives, and move on.
I haven't contributed, I wouldn't contribute. Nobody crowdfunded me on the 2 occasions I was made redundant. I do think it is a legitimate appeal to help the families, and I don't consider the contributors to be racist. Yes some may be, but many others will not want to see families potentially out on the street because of this.
I would agree that the officers should have behaved better, and shouldn't be in the job if they can't treat everyone with equal respect. I think Fuzz had a bad experience with the police in the past, and I certainly have in the last 20 years. For me the bigger issue here is police standards and accountability, which by my own experience is shockingly bad - as a white male.
Obviously there should be crowdfunds set up for the families of everyone who's sacked for gross misconduct then. I wonder how much they'd raise compared to this one...
RE: Seriously breathtaking - Kit Kat Chunky - 10-30-2023
(10-30-2023, 07:12 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (10-30-2023, 04:43 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I see the fund has reached £135K. It should now be turned off.
We are told all the funds will go the disgraced officers families, to help support their lives (nothing about legal bills, appeal costs etc). This should be more than enough money. The officers have been found guilty of racist offences by the police board, but their families haven't. This will give breathing space for the families to restructure their lives, and move on.
I haven't contributed, I wouldn't contribute. Nobody crowdfunded me on the 2 occasions I was made redundant. I do think it is a legitimate appeal to help the families, and I don't consider the contributors to be racist. Yes some may be, but many others will not want to see families potentially out on the street because of this.
I would agree that the officers should have behaved better, and shouldn't be in the job if they can't treat everyone with equal respect. I think Fuzz had a bad experience with the police in the past, and I certainly have in the last 20 years. For me the bigger issue here is police standards and accountability, which by my own experience is shockingly bad - as a white male.
Obviously there should be crowdfunds set up for the families of everyone who's sacked for gross misconduct then. I wonder how much they'd raise compared to this one...
I didn't say there should be . I ts a free country, any one can set one up. If they set one up for victims of police misconduct I think ov would raise more than the present one has.
Many from all walks of life, of differing creeds and colours have a dislike of the police. That tells a story.
|