WBAUnofficial
Palmer on the way? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Palmer on the way? (/showthread.php?tid=30680)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26


RE: Palmer on the way? - Derek Hardballs - 07-29-2023

(07-29-2023, 04:33 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Palmer is off, the deal was accepted last night, the "rumoured" figure and it is only that is £3m rising to £5m with add ons etc

My concern here, and I tried to warn everybody about Miles, utterly clueless in that position, is we're selling players way beyond market value, it's as if any bid which comes in is accepted. We are entitled to say no to Luton, others bids will come in. When you see the figure being banded around for Trafford you should be looking at at least 7-8m for Palmer, at least

For the record he also doesn't want to leave but we've accepted the bid!

Interest in a few others, Furlong, TGH, Grady, Chalobah, Griffiths etc and we'll look to move at least another 1-2 on before the window shuts

As per Manc we're actively in for a couple of strikers, only one likely to come in but we've spoke to clubs about a couple

Be real interesting to see if CC was fully aware of what's happened with Palmer

Cuzer

I think anyone paying even a cursory glance at the club knows we are fecked and that Miles was a cheap lazy option.

Selling Palmer is guaranteeing that we lose at least 5-10pt more than if he was here come the end of the season. This it a getting very silly now.


RE: Palmer on the way? - Lightnin - 07-29-2023

(07-29-2023, 04:33 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Palmer is off, the deal was accepted last night, the "rumoured" figure and it is only that is £3m rising to £5m with add ons etc

My concern here, and I tried to warn everybody about Miles, utterly clueless in that position, is we're selling players way beyond market value, it's as if any bid which comes in is accepted. We are entitled to say no to Luton, others bids will come in. When you see the figure being banded around for Trafford you should be looking at at least 7-8m for Palmer, at least

For the record he also doesn't want to leave but we've accepted the bid!

Interest in a few others, Furlong, TGH, Grady, Chalobah, Griffiths etc and we'll look to move at least another 1-2 on before the window shuts

As per Manc we're actively in for a couple of strikers, only one likely to come in but we've spoke to clubs about a couple

Be real interesting to see if CC was fully aware of what's happened with Palmer

Cuzer

Is Button not going anymore?


RE: Palmer on the way? - TartanRug - 07-29-2023

(07-29-2023, 04:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-29-2023, 04:33 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Palmer is off, the deal was accepted last night, the "rumoured" figure and it is only that is £3m rising to £5m with add ons etc

My concern here, and I tried to warn everybody about Miles, utterly clueless in that position, is we're selling players way beyond market value, it's as if any bid which comes in is accepted. We are entitled to say no to Luton, others bids will come in. When you see the figure being banded around for Trafford you should be looking at at least 7-8m for Palmer, at least

For the record he also doesn't want to leave but we've accepted the bid!

Interest in a few others, Furlong, TGH, Grady, Chalobah, Griffiths etc and we'll look to move at least another 1-2 on before the window shuts

As per Manc we're actively in for a couple of strikers, only one likely to come in but we've spoke to clubs about a couple

Be real interesting to see if CC was fully aware of what's happened with Palmer

Cuzer

I think anyone paying even a cursory glance at the club knows we are fecked and that Miles was a cheap lazy option.

Selling Palmer is guaranteeing that we lose at least 5-10pt more than if he was here come the end of the season. This it a getting very silly now.

It's becoming clearer by the week that all we can hope for is to stay up.


RE: Palmer on the way? - igorbalis - 07-29-2023

desperate times, although trying to stay positive Griffiths is younger and hopefully still improving, it's at the other end of the pitch that worries me, hopefully bring someone in on loan before next week.


RE: Palmer on the way? - Shabby Russian - 07-29-2023

Surprised that people think we should be getting north of 5m for Palmer.

No criticism of him, but he has less than a season of chpionship appearances under his belt. Nor is he seen as having the potential of Trafford and to a lesser extent Griffiths.

I would expect a minimum of £8m for Griffiths, but Palmer if we get a guaranteed 3m for him  with the potential for more, that seems to me a fair fee.

Whether we should be accepting the deal is another matter altogether, and very much depends on how it allows us to shape the squad, and the confidence we have in the other keepers in the squad. 

Like any deal it could be a disaster.

Bur it could also be a masterstroke, allowing us to bring extra  quality and giving the opportunity to Griffiths to realise his potential and be a player we could sell for 20m next summer.

Or it could be a bit meh.


RE: Palmer on the way? - MrFizz - 07-29-2023

(07-29-2023, 04:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Surprised that people think we should be getting north of 5m for Palmer.

No criticism of him, but he has less than a season of chpionship appearances under his belt. Nor is he seen as having the potential of Trafford and to a lesser extent Griffiths.

I would expect a minimum of £8m for Griffiths, but Palmer if we get a guaranteed 3m for him  with the potential for more, that seems to me a fair fee.

Whether we should be accepting the deal is another matter altogether, and very much depends on how it allows us to shape the squad, and the confidence we have in the other keepers in the squad. 

Like any deal it could be a disaster.

Bur it could also be a masterstroke, allowing us to bring extra  quality and giving the opportunity to Griffiths to realise his potential and be a player we could sell for 20m next summer.

Or it could be a bit meh.

In Pearcey we trust.

Oh, feck. Big Grin


RE: Palmer on the way? - johntoewba - 07-29-2023

(07-29-2023, 04:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Surprised that people think we should be getting north of 5m for Palmer.

No criticism of him, but he has less than a season of chpionship appearances under his belt. Nor is he seen as having the potential of Trafford and to a lesser extent Griffiths.

I would expect a minimum of £8m for Griffiths, but Palmer if we get a guaranteed 3m for him  with the potential for more, that seems to me a fair fee.

Whether we should be accepting the deal is another matter altogether, and very much depends on how it allows us to shape the squad, and the confidence we have in the other keepers in the squad. 

Like any deal it could be a disaster.

Bur it could also be a masterstroke, allowing us to bring extra  quality and giving the opportunity to Griffiths to realise his potential and be a player we could sell for 20m next summer.

Or it could be a bit meh.

Or it could be massive shitshow which is exactly what it is. Take your blinkers off we are fucked


RE: Palmer on the way? - SW4Baggie - 07-29-2023

(07-29-2023, 04:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Surprised that people think we should be getting north of 5m for Palmer.

No criticism of him, but he has less than a season of chpionship appearances under his belt. Nor is he seen as having the potential of Trafford and to a lesser extent Griffiths.

I would expect a minimum of £8m for Griffiths, but Palmer if we get a guaranteed 3m for him  with the potential for more, that seems to me a fair fee.

Whether we should be accepting the deal is another matter altogether, and very much depends on how it allows us to shape the squad, and the confidence we have in the other keepers in the squad. 

Like any deal it could be a disaster.

Bur it could also be a masterstroke, allowing us to bring extra  quality and giving the opportunity to Griffiths to realise his potential and be a player we could sell for 20m next summer.

Or it could be a bit meh.

Agree with this. Palmer is a good keeper and we noticeably improved with him but he still has flaws and has very little football above league one level. Had he been 5-6 years younger, sure the bid would be higher, but 4-5m is probably about right. Since we are desperate and it’s Luton playing the poverty card, we will probably accept lower than that. 

I think we all know we need to sell, the frustrating thing is that the fact we are selling for such low fees means it’s now costing us the ability to sign replacements. An extra million for O’Shea and another £2m on Palmer would ensure we could actually pay a fee to replace them with someone we could sell in 12 months time.

Appreciate we are inexperienced behind the scenes but there’s no excuse for not having a decent idea of what a player is worth.


RE: Palmer on the way? - TartanRug - 07-29-2023

(07-29-2023, 04:47 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Surprised that people think we should be getting north of 5m for Palmer.

No criticism of him, but he has less than a season of chpionship appearances under his belt. Nor is he seen as having the potential of Trafford and to a lesser extent Griffiths.

I would expect a minimum of £8m for Griffiths, but Palmer if we get a guaranteed 3m for him  with the potential for more, that seems to me a fair fee.

Whether we should be accepting the deal is another matter altogether, and very much depends on how it allows us to shape the squad, and the confidence we have in the other keepers in the squad. 

Like any deal it could be a disaster.

Bur it could also be a masterstroke, allowing us to bring extra  quality and giving the opportunity to Griffiths to realise his potential and be a player we could sell for 20m next summer.

Or it could be a bit meh.

Do you really think we'll see a penny of this (pathetic) fee? It will go towards paying off the debt.


RE: Palmer on the way? - Spandaubaggie - 07-29-2023

We all knew an asset or two would be sold before the transfer window.

Also expected one of the two saleable keepers to go.

Whilst disappointed I can accept this was likely to be the way. If we sell any more of the decent guys then I’ll really begin to worry.

It is really about scouting well and ingenuity until we get a good owner again.

Welcome to a new world of readjustment of expectations.