![]() |
|
Problems ignored - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Problems ignored (/showthread.php?tid=30440) |
RE: Problems ignored - Borin' Baggie - 07-04-2023 (07-04-2023, 05:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-03-2023, 08:09 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(07-03-2023, 08:02 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:(07-03-2023, 07:58 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:(07-03-2023, 07:50 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I’ve only had a quick Google on this, so I may be wrong, but it suggests it’s very expensive to own a car in the Netherlands. Is that (part of) the reason public transport and bikes are popular? If so, that goes back to me talking about the working classes being priced out of car ownership. Is that the real reason people use bikes and public transport more? I genuinely don’t know. Am I serious? You're the one having a whinge at policies that make it ever so slightly more difficult to drive a car, calling the fundamental liberal idea of utility "Stalinist" for some stupid reason, ridiculing a car designed specifically to provide independence to less abled people that has capacity to operate where larger cars can't and acting like there's some conspiracy going around acting as though everyone who isn't pushing car-first policies wants to effectively ban cars and restrict the usage of cars. That is clearly not a scooter, it's able to take advantage of a wider range of urban infrastructure than a normal car and it's clearly not dangerous. Do you not understand that providing greater options for people who can't drive or would prefer not to drive is also covered by expanding freedom through enabling opportunities, or do you disregard other peoples freedoms because you don't like them doing things that you wouldn't do? And yet I'm apparently the one who has strange ideas of liberalism. RE: Problems ignored - Protheroe - 07-04-2023 I'm all for opening up opportunities and expanding freedoms, but all your remedies for opening up opportunities and expanding freedoms create constraints for others' freedoms. You also seem happy to ghettoise transport for wheelchair users into that appalling thing which probably travels at walking pace and with panel gaps big enough to get your fist into. As if wheelchair users don't have enough to put up with. Very odd. RE: Problems ignored - Borin' Baggie - 07-04-2023 (07-04-2023, 10:25 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm all for opening up opportunities and expanding freedoms, but all your remedies for opening up opportunities and expanding freedoms create constraints for others' freedoms. You also seem happy to ghettoise transport for wheelchair users into that appalling thing which probably travels at walking pace and with panel gaps big enough to get your fist into. As if wheelchair users don't have enough to put up with. What the hell are you on about? How is expanding wheelchair friendly provisions through expanded pedestrian infrastructure, as well as people with other disabilities like visual or hearing impairment, and providing a solution for people with limited mobility to take advantage of expanding other infrastructure ghettoising transport? Are you genuinely incapable of understanding that expanded infrastructure for pedestrians and cyclists can be compatible with expanding provisions for transport for wheelchair users and that it involves a safe car that can take advantage of a greater scope of infrastructure? Do you think a car that is designed for wheelchair users but still meets all modern EU car safety requirements is inherently unsafe or something? Do you consider it problematic that a car has been designed to expand the freedom of choice for wheelchair users through enabling them to take advantage of cycle infrastructure or something? Jesus wept. Drop the car is king bullshit. Other European countries have proven that you can expand pedestrian and cycling infrastructure without reducing access to wheelchair users. And you know what, if you want to use a bigger adapted vehicle you still can because you're not banned from using other cars, disabled parking is still a thing there and disabled drivers still get expanded parking priority for roadside parking like they do here. Almost as though it's not infringing on the freedoms of disabled people to drive or be driven, hmm curious that people have already thought about solutions to accommodate provisions for quality of life instead of just whining about it. Do you genuinely think that expanded walking and cycling infrastructure is a pretext to ban private cars or something? RE: Problems ignored - Derek Hardballs - 07-04-2023 (07-04-2023, 08:51 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:(07-04-2023, 08:03 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(07-04-2023, 07:51 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:(07-03-2023, 07:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-03-2023, 07:15 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: "positive freedoms" I agree that there should be a clamp down on dangerous and poor driving. Fine the beep out of people who park on the pavements etc and yes in certain places like high streets make the area pedestrian only. The problem I see is those pushing for change the hardest are over zealous and have little or no understanding of the barriers and challenges some people face, where their car is a necessity not a luxury item. It’s ok for those able bodied, healthy, middle class who can use public transport such as trains or bike, work at home and not carry equipment etc but anyone with any real, lived experience of trying to get to places who do have mobility/wheelchair, significant disabilities currently will tell you it’s difficult or near impossible to travel without a car and not just to the edges of towns but they need to get into heart of them. Making it even harder for them is discriminatory and surely something that ordinarily those who consider themselves progressive would be against. There are so many flaws to the argument that people with mobility issues can use small, electric cars or similar to get about in the U.K. this includes the cost of buying them, the lack of mobility charities that offer them, the fact many have families and carers who travel with them, many don’t actually drive themselves and need help to use a vehicle. The equipment they need to bring with them etc. Parking is a joke in most towns for the disabled where ramps etc are needed etc now let alone after we have painted a tail on a zebra crossing and grown a pumpkin in the grit box. All I ask is for those with specific disabilities and or those who care for them that make having a car a necessity not a luxury to be listened to and to be properly catered for with parking that is easy to use, easy to access and where they need to go. I’m sceptical that those who just want to get rid of cars from towns and cities will want to listen given the debate already seems completely polarised. RE: Problems ignored - Protheroe - 07-04-2023 (07-04-2023, 10:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Drop the car is king bullshit. Why, when it is what the majority of people use and prefer for personal transport? The car is king. That's not an argument, it's an observation. For those of us outside the rarified liberal uplands of Cotton Lane, and who don't have the dubious pleasure of spending our evenings chattering with social workers and their clients in the Prince of Wales - that's the vast majority of people - would rather travel in private, comfortable, air conditioned comfort. Feel free to provide alternatives, but the redesigning of neighbourhoods, discriminatory use of road space, removal of public parking provision and other situational measures do impact on the free choice most people would rather make. Yes, cars have their externalities and yes, other road users need safe spaces but transportation policy - just like housing policy - is in the hands of extremists. RE: Problems ignored - Borin' Baggie - 07-04-2023 (07-04-2023, 12:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-04-2023, 10:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Drop the car is king bullshit. Horse tripe. First, you live in fucking Hagley pal, don't pretend as though you're some saviour of the working classes. You ridiculed buses further up, don't pretend as though you're not a smarmy middle class MCW that sees things as beneath you. The problem with public transport is the public, who said that? Which demographics predominantly use buses? Secondly, redesigning of neighbourhoods? I'm sorry, do you think most central urban areas in the UK were designed for the car or something? Those neighbourhoods were already redesigned to sideline transit, cycling and pedestrians over the car. Pavements were narrowed, cycle lanes, railway alignments and tramways torn up. Ernest Marples literally instigated plans to tear up neighbourhoods as transport secretary to prioritise cars, surely coincidental that he and his family owned a tarmac business I'm sure. Need I also mention that the West Midlands Plan, the postwar Whitehall plan to cripple the economies of Birmingham and Coventry, used ring road infrastructure as a means to restrict economic opportunities for expansion by introducing a physical barrier? How liberal that is. Finally, you are completely ignorant of logistics. Do you want higher density developments in the UK? More housing? How do you think that marries with cars? Why do you think dense population centres focus on pedestrian access and transit, from London to your beloved Singapore? Even in the car-centric US, Australia and Canada. If you're planning out city infrastructure you focus on logistics, it is basic common sense, and unfortunately for your delicate sensibilities cars need to be deprioritised. It may not matter to you in rural Worcestershire but lack of access to public transport in poorer wards in Birmingham is one of the biggest factors affecting employment as there's a lack of choice in transit in-turn restricting access to jobs, and as this isn't the US the core road networks around the major employment centres were laid out before cars existed and when the most common mode of transport was walking. You're living in cuckoo land if you think we can densify and build more housing while simultaneously prioritise cars over pedestrians, not every town in the UK is laid out like Milton Keynes was. And if that means one-way streets, bus/tram gates, wider pavements and cycle/pedestrian filters then tough shit, you can't have your cake and still eat it. The gall of you to accuse anyone else of being an extremist. Do you think it's somehow practical to flatten large UK cities and integrate modal separation or something? If cities like Birmingham want to densify their city centres to bring them in line with other cities in the UK or Europe where are the cars supposed to go? There's already solutions designed to mitigate and oftentimes enhance wheelchair access in other countries as I've pointed out, you can't wilfully ignore it. And that's without moving into the basic practicalities of safety, need I remind you that Amsterdam's shift towards pedestrianisation and cycling infrastructure was triggered by kindermoord, a.k.a. cars running over kids? The same thing is happening in Birmingham right now, that's what has triggered Birmingham City Council to accelerate pedestrian access plans. And I'd rather move in that direction than the car-centric shithshow in the US where pedestrians have no right of way and you are liable to be fined for crossing the road outside of a designated junction, because what a great endorsement of freedom of that is. RE: Problems ignored - Birdman1811 - 07-04-2023 I posted this before about public transport. I'll give up my car and use Public Transport when these conditions are met. Here in the South West, actually have a network that can be considered useful Public Transport. Plymouth is better, but Cornwall basically hasn't got one. Guarantee it'll be on time, every time, I am in my car, so public transport needs to be. I never have to sit next to someone who has poor hygiene, is annoying, takes up more space than needed, or will try to talk to me. Actually, be available when I need it, it often starts too late and finishes far too early to be useful for me. Cost less than using my car, it currently doesn't for most journeys I take. Certainly haven't changed since, and I know so many like me. It's not just about making it convenient. Cost, the experience itself and the public all stop public transport being really viable in this country. I use the bus very rarely, I've seen 4 fights on the bus this year already. Why would I choose that over using my own car? Regardless of any other factor? RE: Problems ignored - Borin' Baggie - 07-04-2023 (07-04-2023, 03:17 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Here in the South West, actually have a network that can be considered useful Public Transport. Plymouth is better, but Cornwall basically hasn't got one. ![]() That also doesn't show lines that were previously doubled that are now singled. Thankfully some are coming/have come back into existence and others are in a practical state to convert to other forms of transit (like metros) but not all of them. The problem with regional transport options has, is and always will be because of Whitehall meddling - not just affecting public transport but also roads. The Treasury are outright malicious on investment and the DfT are inept. Who's the genius that stopped the electrification of the Great Western Mainline one stop short of Bristol Temple Meads? Why is it easier to drive from the Midlands to Norfolk via the M25 than point-point? RE: Problems ignored - Birdman1811 - 07-04-2023 Absolutely. RE: Problems ignored - Protheroe - 07-04-2023 (07-04-2023, 12:31 PM)Borin' Baggieie Wrote: don't pretend as though you're not a smarmy middle class MCW that sees things as beneath you. I've never pretended that Dear. ![]() Nor are you hiding the fact that your top down approach to transport planning ignores the preferences of most people. You haven't and can't address that point. |