WBAUnofficial
Karlan Grant - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Karlan Grant (/showthread.php?tid=29607)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Karlan Grant - Calgary_Baggie - 04-16-2023

(04-16-2023, 01:39 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: I think Grant’s poor body language is the main cause of the criticism against him.  He’s clearly not a bad player, although currently short on confidence.  Needs to be played in the right role - which he hasn’t been over most of the past year mainly through the long-term injury to Dike and us not having had another striker last season.

He has a golden chance now to perform well over the last 5 games. If he does, then we have a realistic chance of the play-offs.

The main problem with Grant, as has been stated by the vast majority on here, is that the side may as well be down to ten men when he's having a stinker. And he's had plenty of those. The amount of games where he is completely anonymous...


RE: Karlan Grant - Derek Hardballs - 04-16-2023

(04-16-2023, 01:28 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: With the exception of Robson they were all finished by one bad injury, Robson's injuries were mainly in the early part of his career

We seem to sign players with poor injury records and then are surprised when they are injured here (Bryan and Ancihebe) As other have pointed out older players struggle to come back once they get injured and we have been ruthless in the past with players like this (Mulumby). We have been unlucky with both Dike and Mowatt who were injury free prior to joining us

Overall though a lot of this is down to signing older players, it is hardly surprising the likes of Rogic and Kelly are injured often.

I agree to a certain extent but we brought in older players in the last two windows because we are skint / spent out and the squad wasn’t big enough. Once when we had more cash than most in the Championship we could be ruthless now we are desperate. The choice was throw kids in or try and get some players that are proven but for whatever reason without a club. I would probably have gone down playing the younger players route but it’s not a guaranteed route to success.


RE: Karlan Grant - Pragmatist - 04-16-2023

(04-16-2023, 02:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 01:28 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: With the exception of Robson they were all finished by one bad injury, Robson's injuries were mainly in the early part of his career

We seem to sign players with poor injury records and then are surprised when they are injured here (Bryan and Ancihebe) As other have pointed out older players struggle to come back once they get injured and we have been ruthless in the past with players like this (Mulumby). We have been unlucky with both Dike and Mowatt who were injury free prior to joining us

Overall though a lot of this is down to signing older players, it is hardly surprising the likes of Rogic and Kelly are injured often.

I agree to a certain extent but we brought in older players in the last two windows because we are skint / spent out and the squad wasn’t big enough. Once when we had more cash than most in the Championship we could be ruthless now we are desperate. The choice was throw kids in or try and get some players that are proven but for whatever reason without a club. I would probably have gone down playing the younger players route but it’s not a guaranteed route to success.

Neither route has any guarantees. Personally I’d rather sign more young, hungry players like Mulumby and BTA and seek out more talent like BTA from the lower leagues. If we set criteria like aiming to sign no new players over 25 and not paying any transfer fees over £1.5m until we get back to the Premier League, and then maybe supplement with a couple of experienced 30 year olds with leadership credentials and good fitness records then I’d be very comfortable with that, alongside using the loan market as proactively as possible.  And of course making the most of our Academy.


RE: Karlan Grant - Kit Kat Chunky - 04-16-2023

Not sure we will be signing any players for £1.5M fees any time soon.


RE: Karlan Grant - Derek Hardballs - 04-16-2023

(04-16-2023, 02:26 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 02:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 01:28 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: With the exception of Robson they were all finished by one bad injury, Robson's injuries were mainly in the early part of his career

We seem to sign players with poor injury records and then are surprised when they are injured here (Bryan and Ancihebe) As other have pointed out older players struggle to come back once they get injured and we have been ruthless in the past with players like this (Mulumby). We have been unlucky with both Dike and Mowatt who were injury free prior to joining us

Overall though a lot of this is down to signing older players, it is hardly surprising the likes of Rogic and Kelly are injured often.

I agree to a certain extent but we brought in older players in the last two windows because we are skint / spent out and the squad wasn’t big enough. Once when we had more cash than most in the Championship we could be ruthless now we are desperate. The choice was throw kids in or try and get some players that are proven but for whatever reason without a club. I would probably have gone down playing the younger players route but it’s not a guaranteed route to success.

Neither route has any guarantees. Personally I’d rather sign more young, hungry players like Mulumby and BTA and seek out more talent like BTA from the lower leagues. If we set criteria like aiming to sign no new players over 25 and not paying any transfer fees over £1.5m until we get back to the Premier League, and then maybe supplement with a couple of experienced 30 year olds with leadership credentials and good fitness records then I’d be very comfortable with that, alongside using the loan market as proactively as possible.  And of course making the most of our Academy.

That’s going to be a very big IF we get back to the Prem within those parameters sadly.


RE: Karlan Grant - Pragmatist - 04-16-2023

(04-16-2023, 03:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 02:26 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 02:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 01:28 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: With the exception of Robson they were all finished by one bad injury, Robson's injuries were mainly in the early part of his career

We seem to sign players with poor injury records and then are surprised when they are injured here (Bryan and Ancihebe) As other have pointed out older players struggle to come back once they get injured and we have been ruthless in the past with players like this (Mulumby). We have been unlucky with both Dike and Mowatt who were injury free prior to joining us

Overall though a lot of this is down to signing older players, it is hardly surprising the likes of Rogic and Kelly are injured often.

I agree to a certain extent but we brought in older players in the last two windows because we are skint / spent out and the squad wasn’t big enough. Once when we had more cash than most in the Championship we could be ruthless now we are desperate. The choice was throw kids in or try and get some players that are proven but for whatever reason without a club. I would probably have gone down playing the younger players route but it’s not a guaranteed route to success.

Neither route has any guarantees. Personally I’d rather sign more young, hungry players like Mulumby and BTA and seek out more talent like BTA from the lower leagues. If we set criteria like aiming to sign no new players over 25 and not paying any transfer fees over £1.5m until we get back to the Premier League, and then maybe supplement with a couple of experienced 30 year olds with leadership credentials and good fitness records then I’d be very comfortable with that, alongside using the loan market as proactively as possible.  And of course making the most of our Academy.

That’s going to be a very big IF we get back to the Prem within those parameters sadly.

I meant for the unavoidable rebuild (if we don’t get sold).  Spending big money (that we don’t have) versus the clubs with parachute payments and only 3 going up is the cause of so many Championship clubs having massive debts


RE: Karlan Grant - CaptainFantastico - 04-16-2023

I’m no lover of Grant but if we are to have any chance of capitalising on this farcical opportunity we have to still even now make the play offs his return couldn’t have come at a more vital time


RE: Karlan Grant - Calgary_Baggie - 04-16-2023

(04-16-2023, 03:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 02:26 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 02:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 01:28 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: With the exception of Robson they were all finished by one bad injury, Robson's injuries were mainly in the early part of his career

We seem to sign players with poor injury records and then are surprised when they are injured here (Bryan and Ancihebe) As other have pointed out older players struggle to come back once they get injured and we have been ruthless in the past with players like this (Mulumby). We have been unlucky with both Dike and Mowatt who were injury free prior to joining us

Overall though a lot of this is down to signing older players, it is hardly surprising the likes of Rogic and Kelly are injured often.

I agree to a certain extent but we brought in older players in the last two windows because we are skint / spent out and the squad wasn’t big enough. Once when we had more cash than most in the Championship we could be ruthless now we are desperate. The choice was throw kids in or try and get some players that are proven but for whatever reason without a club. I would probably have gone down playing the younger players route but it’s not a guaranteed route to success.

Neither route has any guarantees. Personally I’d rather sign more young, hungry players like Mulumby and BTA and seek out more talent like BTA from the lower leagues. If we set criteria like aiming to sign no new players over 25 and not paying any transfer fees over £1.5m until we get back to the Premier League, and then maybe supplement with a couple of experienced 30 year olds with leadership credentials and good fitness records then I’d be very comfortable with that, alongside using the loan market as proactively as possible.  And of course making the most of our Academy.

That’s going to be a very big IF we get back to the Prem within those parameters sadly.

Not a chance.


RE: Karlan Grant - Pragmatist - 04-17-2023

(04-16-2023, 07:54 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 03:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 02:26 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 02:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 01:28 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: With the exception of Robson they were all finished by one bad injury, Robson's injuries were mainly in the early part of his career

We seem to sign players with poor injury records and then are surprised when they are injured here (Bryan and Ancihebe) As other have pointed out older players struggle to come back once they get injured and we have been ruthless in the past with players like this (Mulumby). We have been unlucky with both Dike and Mowatt who were injury free prior to joining us

Overall though a lot of this is down to signing older players, it is hardly surprising the likes of Rogic and Kelly are injured often.

I agree to a certain extent but we brought in older players in the last two windows because we are skint / spent out and the squad wasn’t big enough. Once when we had more cash than most in the Championship we could be ruthless now we are desperate. The choice was throw kids in or try and get some players that are proven but for whatever reason without a club. I would probably have gone down playing the younger players route but it’s not a guaranteed route to success.

Neither route has any guarantees. Personally I’d rather sign more young, hungry players like Mulumby and BTA and seek out more talent like BTA from the lower leagues. If we set criteria like aiming to sign no new players over 25 and not paying any transfer fees over £1.5m until we get back to the Premier League, and then maybe supplement with a couple of experienced 30 year olds with leadership credentials and good fitness records then I’d be very comfortable with that, alongside using the loan market as proactively as possible.  And of course making the most of our Academy.

That’s going to be a very big IF we get back to the Prem within those parameters sadly.

Not a chance.

Although Luton or Millwall might….


RE: Karlan Grant - Gzbaggy - 04-17-2023

How did Brentford and Brighton do it?