RE: Booooo - Corberan out!!! - Tom Joad - 12-01-2024
(12-01-2024, 07:40 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I'm a huge Corberan fan and with the resources he's had available he's done a great job, tactically for the majority of the two years he's been here he's proven himself as the best manager we've had since Roy.
Do I back him to sort it out? I think he's earned the chance. He's dealt with injuries and we currently have a good chunk of our best attacking players out of form. One who seems to have gone AWOL is Grady, he was key last season and looked like he was getting back to the Grady of old. We're almost halfway through the season and I can't remember him playing.
CC has had to turn over a good chunk of the playing squad and thanks to the loaning out of Kipre (cheers Steve), we arguably lost him a year before we would have liked and even with Heggem's great form, Kipre is proving a huge miss.
I still think given the limitations of our squad the way CC approaches matches for the most part will see us win more points than not. We're hard to beat first and foremost and I'd fear that if the dissenting voices got their way we'd start leaking goals and losing games - which is worse than what is currently being served up.
Our current predicament has also got me thinking that given the way the modern game works, unless you're one of the top clubs, the shelf life of a manager seems to be about two years. It's so hard with the financial constraints faced by many clubs to build season on season and show continued progress. One name I see mentioned a lot in the Carlos comparisons is Carrick, his Boro team went backwards last season before he was well backed again in the summer. Perhaps inadvertently that shows us the way forward? If we do have a season of minimal progress but we're a year further along in terms of recovering our financial position and with promising youngsters performing well, maybe its time we can afford to give Carlos.
Sacking him because we've not scored as many goals as we'd liked or because there are just better teams in the league or because there's people who thought Bruce copped too much flack would still in my opinion be a huge mistake.
Top post.
RE: Booooo - Corberan out!!! - Birdman1811 - 12-01-2024
Excellent point on Carrick, they had an awful season last season, but they trusted him and knew they could back him in the summer.
RE: Booooo - Corberan out!!! - SW4Baggie - 12-01-2024
(12-01-2024, 01:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Excellent point on Carrick, they had an awful season last season, but they trusted him and knew they could back him in the summer.
I think there was also an understanding that Carrick operated under a ridiculous injury crisis last year - their numbers out made us look fully fit all season!
There have been concerns about Carrick’s ability to mix it up, and his insistence on playing in one way regardless of who is available but overall he’s still well regarded by the majority of their fans.
RE: Booooo - Corberan out!!! - Jacko - 12-01-2024
(12-01-2024, 07:40 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I'm a huge Corberan fan and with the resources he's had available he's done a great job, tactically for the majority of the two years he's been here he's proven himself as the best manager we've had since Roy.
Do I back him to sort it out? I think he's earned the chance. He's dealt with injuries and we currently have a good chunk of our best attacking players out of form. One who seems to have gone AWOL is Grady, he was key last season and looked like he was getting back to the Grady of old. We're almost halfway through the season and I can't remember him playing.
CC has had to turn over a good chunk of the playing squad and thanks to the loaning out of Kipre (cheers Steve), we arguably lost him a year before we would have liked and even with Heggem's great form, Kipre is proving a huge miss.
I still think given the limitations of our squad the way CC approaches matches for the most part will see us win more points than not. We're hard to beat first and foremost and I'd fear that if the dissenting voices got their way we'd start leaking goals and losing games - which is worse than what is currently being served up.
Our current predicament has also got me thinking that given the way the modern game works, unless you're one of the top clubs, the shelf life of a manager seems to be about two years. It's so hard with the financial constraints faced by many clubs to build season on season and show continued progress. One name I see mentioned a lot in the Carlos comparisons is Carrick, his Boro team went backwards last season before he was well backed again in the summer. Perhaps inadvertently that shows us the way forward? If we do have a season of minimal progress but we're a year further along in terms of recovering our financial position and with promising youngsters performing well, maybe its time we can afford to give Carlos.
Sacking him because we've not scored as many goals as we'd liked or because there are just better teams in the league or because there's people who thought Bruce copped too much flack would still in my opinion be a huge mistake.
This is a superb post.
RE: Booooo - Corberan out!!! - Squid - 12-01-2024
(12-01-2024, 02:43 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (12-01-2024, 01:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Excellent point on Carrick, they had an awful season last season, but they trusted him and knew they could back him in the summer.
I think there was also an understanding that Carrick operated under a ridiculous injury crisis last year - their numbers out made us look fully fit all season!
There have been concerns about Carrick’s ability to mix it up, and his insistence on playing in one way regardless of who is available but overall he’s still well regarded by the majority of their fans.
All that being said, if they don't finish in the playoffs this season, he won't be managing them in the next.
RE: Booooo - Corberan out!!! - Derek Hardballs - 12-01-2024
(12-01-2024, 08:24 PM)Squid Wrote: (12-01-2024, 02:43 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (12-01-2024, 01:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Excellent point on Carrick, they had an awful season last season, but they trusted him and knew they could back him in the summer.
I think there was also an understanding that Carrick operated under a ridiculous injury crisis last year - their numbers out made us look fully fit all season!
There have been concerns about Carrick’s ability to mix it up, and his insistence on playing in one way regardless of who is available but overall he’s still well regarded by the majority of their fans.
All that being said, if they don't finish in the playoffs this season, he won't be managing them in the next.
Exactly, CC and Carrick will be judged on if they finish in the playoffs imo. Long term projects are as rare as a modest Villa fan.
RE: Booooo - Corberan out!!! - Jacko - 12-01-2024
(12-01-2024, 08:24 PM)Squid Wrote: (12-01-2024, 02:43 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (12-01-2024, 01:25 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Excellent point on Carrick, they had an awful season last season, but they trusted him and knew they could back him in the summer.
I think there was also an understanding that Carrick operated under a ridiculous injury crisis last year - their numbers out made us look fully fit all season!
There have been concerns about Carrick’s ability to mix it up, and his insistence on playing in one way regardless of who is available but overall he’s still well regarded by the majority of their fans.
All that being said, if they don't finish in the playoffs this season, he won't be managing them in the next.
He will unless he gets poached.
RE: Booooo - Corberan out!!! - ElbowGrease1973 II - 12-01-2024
(12-01-2024, 08:11 PM)Jacko Wrote: (12-01-2024, 07:40 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I'm a huge Corberan fan and with the resources he's had available he's done a great job, tactically for the majority of the two years he's been here he's proven himself as the best manager we've had since Roy.
Do I back him to sort it out? I think he's earned the chance. He's dealt with injuries and we currently have a good chunk of our best attacking players out of form. One who seems to have gone AWOL is Grady, he was key last season and looked like he was getting back to the Grady of old. We're almost halfway through the season and I can't remember him playing.
CC has had to turn over a good chunk of the playing squad and thanks to the loaning out of Kipre (cheers Steve), we arguably lost him a year before we would have liked and even with Heggem's great form, Kipre is proving a huge miss.
I still think given the limitations of our squad the way CC approaches matches for the most part will see us win more points than not. We're hard to beat first and foremost and I'd fear that if the dissenting voices got their way we'd start leaking goals and losing games - which is worse than what is currently being served up.
Our current predicament has also got me thinking that given the way the modern game works, unless you're one of the top clubs, the shelf life of a manager seems to be about two years. It's so hard with the financial constraints faced by many clubs to build season on season and show continued progress. One name I see mentioned a lot in the Carlos comparisons is Carrick, his Boro team went backwards last season before he was well backed again in the summer. Perhaps inadvertently that shows us the way forward? If we do have a season of minimal progress but we're a year further along in terms of recovering our financial position and with promising youngsters performing well, maybe its time we can afford to give Carlos.
Sacking him because we've not scored as many goals as we'd liked or because there are just better teams in the league or because there's people who thought Bruce copped too much flack would still in my opinion be a huge mistake.
This is a superb post.
It certainly is.
It's premature to talk about sacking King Carlos, but we do need to get more wins. Ironically had we lost half of the last 10 games and won the other half, there would be less pressure on the Manager. Yet unbeaten in 10, and there's call for his head. Just shows it's all about winning.
Last season we were nicking games, but this season we're just falling short. We need the under performing players to step up. It's a long season, and I'm still backing King Carlos to turn things around.
RE: Booooo - Corberan out!!! - Tom Joad - 12-02-2024
Of this run, I would say Luton A, Sunderland A, Burnley H and Blackburn A were all good points earned.
Millwall, Cardiff and Preston were a disappointment.
Norwich gave us a game while Oxford was a lack of focus at the death. Plus of course, we won at Hull.
All in all, we have looked more likely to win and not lose in the bulk of those games. We need to tweak things a bit not chuck the babby out with the bathwerter.
RE: Booooo - Corberan out!!! - baggpuss - 12-24-2024
Took a while - but looks like it is happening!
|