![]() |
|
Immigration - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Immigration (/showthread.php?tid=27347) |
RE: Immigration - Protheroe - 11-15-2022 (11-15-2022, 03:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: FoM had nothing to do with them Crucially we're not going to agree on that point. Marginal agricultural activities, marginal hospitality activities and marginal retail activities are / were massively dependent on migrant labour for their very survival. The vast majority of these marginal firms cannot and will not ever grow again, they are the living dead incarnate - look at large parts of the High Street in particular. We do not need these companies, they crowd out innovation, they redirect investment towards moribund activities, they stifle career progression so they're no good for employees, they provide no shareholder value. They need to die and hopefully this recession will kill them. Migrant labour via FoM (and low interest rates) was their life support. Turn it off. RE: Immigration - Borin' Baggie - 11-15-2022 Literally all your problems with marginal activity the root cause of the problem is a lack of investment into infrastructure and technology, not migrant labour. That problem with a lack of investment in infrastructure was there before 1973 and it is still there now, FoM didn't cause it and as shown by many Western European countries and now some Eastern European countries FoM is not a barrier to improved wages and productivity growth. Repressed labour markets in Japan have fucked wages and productivity there, working culture is still stupidly harsh despite severe labour shortages and low unemployment rates yet the median wage has gone down in nominal terms since 2008 and declined vs Sterling in spite of a stronger yen meaning greater buying power vs Sterling, explain that to me Proth? Repressed and restrictive labour markets in the Soviet Union decimated productivity there compared to open labour markets in the US and Australia. The bump in productivity in industrial centres like Birmingham and Leicester post-WW2 in spite of legislative restrictions were due to open immigration from India, like my grandparents, and the Caribbean where said industrial centres became the wealthiest regions per capita in the UK, explain that to me? Open markets = productivity growth, as has been demonstrated for centuries. Even after the Black Death, high levels of labour migration coincided with wage growth and increased rights in the areas the migrants were migrating to. I'm fed up of the UK hamstringing itself by doing something stupid that won't fix the problems while ignoring the things that actually cause the problems. I'm not sure if you've noticed but we don't have FoM and real wages are still going down - Sunak is going to be putting up the minimum wage on Thursday because the effect you're describing doesn't exist so the state is having to intervene. RE: Immigration - Protheroe - 11-15-2022 (11-15-2022, 04:52 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Literally all your problems with marginal activity the root cause of the problem is a lack of investment into infrastructure and technology, not migrant labour. No, not "literally all" the problems - overhanging debt is a huge contributor, as is terrible management. But migrant labour compounds all those problems. That's the entire point I've been trying to make. I have no problem with millions of people coming here from wherever if they are contributing to innovation, growth industries or public services. The problem is that far too many of them are employed by zombies that can only trade because of migrant labour, and are worthless to the country. RE: Immigration - Borin' Baggie - 11-15-2022 Terrible management feeds into lack of investment into infrastructure and technology. Debt overhang limits investment into infrastructure and technology. It all comes back to investment into infrastructure and technology via a feedback loop that the UK knows all too well. Migrant labour has nothing to do with that, the very fact that we have supposedly "full employment" yet that phenomenon exists is testament to that. RE: Immigration - Protheroe - 11-15-2022 Ok. You've ignored the point about compounding the problems (again) and I shan't bother repeating myself (again). RE: Immigration - Borin' Baggie - 11-16-2022 I've ignored it because it's a fallacy and isn't a cause of any problems so it doesn't compound - as demonstrated by Western European countries in the single market that you've continually ignored. RE: Immigration - Protheroe - 11-16-2022 But we're talking about the UK specifically. Which as you and I both know has very specific UK problems. Compounded by low skill low wage migration. I promised I wouldn't repeat myself but as you keep conflating the issue... RE: Immigration - Borin' Baggie - 11-16-2022 And I'm pointing out that the unique problems specific to the UK that need to be addressed have absolutely nothing to do with freedom of movement - as demonstrated by other western European countries. The UK doesn't exist in a vacuum. Problems don't get solved if people ignore what's causing those problems and attacking something that isn't causing the problem. RE: Immigration - Protheroe - 11-16-2022 Oh Jesus. It's like talking to my wife. I'll leave it there. RE: Immigration - Borin' Baggie - 11-16-2022 It's good to know your ignorance of how things actually work outside of you want them to work extends to the real world as well as this Albion messageboard. |