WBAUnofficial
Genuinely, where do we go from here? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Genuinely, where do we go from here? (/showthread.php?tid=24391)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Genuinely, where do we go from here? - Bob Fossil - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 10:00 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:57 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:38 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: We were half a season into doing this but then took a huge risk because Jordan Hugill kept missing sitters essentially.

This is he most confusing thing for me Ted, if he'd have managed to score some of the chances it would have obviously improved the results but also the confidence of the team. This and Val's stubbornness in not changing formation to suit the players or the opposition every now and again are what have led to the '4 year project' being thrown out at the 1st sign of an issue. 4 year fucking project chucked in the bin after 6 months, I ask ya.

The same morons now saying we need to give Bruce time to sort the mess out. The mess that was created by our own impatience and entitlement. 

As I've said, we're getting what we deserve now.

Not true though is it? Not even remotely. 
The mess was created by Val and his inept signings and compounded by his inflexibility. The fact that Bruce is also rubbish and has just carried on where Val left off, does not make Val the messiah. The fact that you would lay the blame at fans who have followed the club for decades, through thick and thin, in order to defend someone who was at the club for 6 months and had us in a downward spiral is just beyond bizarre.

The truth is we would likely be where we are whichever of them were in charge because they have the same group of players. In that sense Bruce gets some sympathy because he inherited them, whereas Val had 2 windows, but both are culpable. The fans most certainly are not.

Bob, do you seriously believe Val was happy with Hugill and Reach FFS?

He was given Mowatt who he wanted, he was then told loans and free's were his sum lot until January when it would be reviewed

We did well to get Dike, who then got injured, he was desperate for a midfielder which we didn't deliver and then he got sacked

This wasn't of "Val's doing" I think it's clear to see now he was getting way more out of these primadonna's than most managers would, still, we have no patience do we

Cuzer
Yes 100%.

Why would the club go to the trouble of recruiting him and then go "Oh by the way, you have no say in the players we bring in, we have a secret society that does that, so you get what you're given". Makes no sense whatsoever.

He thought Livermore and Mowatt would be his midfield 2 so he bought in the equally limited, carbon copy, Molumby as cover. He saw Townsend as his left wingback so bought Reach in as cover with the added bonus of flexibility in other areas. He saw 3 of Robinson, Grant, Phillips and Diangana as making up his front 3, but, knowing that he subs them at 60 mins, needed someone else off the bench so bought in Hugill.

I'm not saying he wouldn't have preferred to spend £30m on other options, but he knew at the interview stage that that wasn't an option, and it would be freebies and loans, same as 90% of the division. Other managers just made better loans and freebies than he did.

I would say that he dramatically overestimated the quality of the squad he inherited, but so did I, so I do sympathise in that sense.


RE: Genuinely, where do we go from here? - Man from delmonte - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 10:49 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 10:44 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 10:41 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: I remember when Albion fans turned on the board in 1999 when we lost 5-1 to Crewe, It got worse with the defeat against Blues (22 years ago on Thursday) being a watershed.

Looked at the table we are higher when we lost to Crewe then we are currently

Look at the team that day

Phil Whitehead, Paul Holmes, Daryl Burgess, Matt Carbon, Jason Van Blerk, Kevin Kilbane, Mario Bortolazzi, Enzo Maresca, Richard Sneekes, Mark Angel, Lee Hughes

Subs: Graham Potter, Shaun Murphy (Who was booed by Albion fans), Brian Quailey


What would a combined team of that and yesterday result in?

Hughes, Maresca, Kilbane and Sneekes are all better than anything we currently have…

I was just looking at that and thinking about the creativity in there. I was at that Crewe game, and just looked it up but that was a Monday as well. I said to my mate at the time we were the youngest there and that there were no kids - they were dire times but this feels a whole lot worse, at that time I felt we'd hit the bottom, I don't think we are there yet with this lot.
The biggest failing of that 98/99 side was the lack of a decent ball winner in midfield. Other than Sean Flynn no-one was capable of putting a tackle in. That side with a McInnes type midfielder would have got in the play offs. They were a frustating team to watch, sometimes brilliant and at other times awful. I enjoyed that period far more though than this current crop.


RE: Genuinely, where do we go from here? - wba13 - 03-01-2022

Well our last 10 matches played 10. Won 1 drew 2 lost 7 5 pts it’s pathetic after 10 games we had 22pts have we ever been on a worse run, probably but I can’t be bothered to look it up. For everyone blaming Val me included and his football wasn’t brilliant, but it now showing it’s the players and yes we’re are better with Livermore in the side.


RE: Genuinely, where do we go from here? - Man from delmonte - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 10:00 AM)Cuzer Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:57 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:41 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:38 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(03-01-2022, 08:02 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: We were half a season into doing this but then took a huge risk because Jordan Hugill kept missing sitters essentially.

This is he most confusing thing for me Ted, if he'd have managed to score some of the chances it would have obviously improved the results but also the confidence of the team. This and Val's stubbornness in not changing formation to suit the players or the opposition every now and again are what have led to the '4 year project' being thrown out at the 1st sign of an issue. 4 year fucking project chucked in the bin after 6 months, I ask ya.

The same morons now saying we need to give Bruce time to sort the mess out. The mess that was created by our own impatience and entitlement. 

As I've said, we're getting what we deserve now.

Not true though is it? Not even remotely. 
The mess was created by Val and his inept signings and compounded by his inflexibility. The fact that Bruce is also rubbish and has just carried on where Val left off, does not make Val the messiah. The fact that you would lay the blame at fans who have followed the club for decades, through thick and thin, in order to defend someone who was at the club for 6 months and had us in a downward spiral is just beyond bizarre.

The truth is we would likely be where we are whichever of them were in charge because they have the same group of players. In that sense Bruce gets some sympathy because he inherited them, whereas Val had 2 windows, but both are culpable. The fans most certainly are not.

Bob, do you seriously believe Val was happy with Hugill and Reach FFS?

He was given Mowatt who he wanted, he was then told loans and free's were his sum lot until January when it would be reviewed

We did well to get Dike, who then got injured, he was desperate for a midfielder which we didn't deliver and then he got sacked

This wasn't of "Val's doing" I think it's clear to see now he was getting way more out of these primadonna's than most managers would, still, we have no patience do we

Cuzer
The club must have clearly really wanted Reach as apparently he's one of our top paid players on over 20k p/w according to what I've read which is just baffling.


RE: Genuinely, where do we go from here? - TTM2 - 03-01-2022

The main issue is the players who have contracts outlasting the end of this season, nobody will want them on the money they’re on and they know it. They simply won’t go anywhere.

I deliberately stayed to the end to observe, the ones who are capable looked utterly dismayed and the ones who either don’t give a shit or dont think they are part of this clusterfuck just darted off down the tunnel. Grady looked utterly broken.

I kind of respect Robinson, Bartley & Fulong for staying on and approaching the crowd, I’m not sure how prepared they were for the utter dogs abuse they got.I’m not into giving abuse out at players, rather than the collective, but I can’t blame anyone who did.

It’s a mess.


RE: Genuinely, where do we go from here? - Tom Joad - 03-01-2022

(03-01-2022, 11:10 AM)TTM2 Wrote: The main issue is the players who have contracts outlasting the end of this season, nobody will want them on the money they’re on and they know it. They simply won’t go anywhere.

I deliberately stayed to the end to observe, the ones who are capable looked utterly dismayed and the ones who either don’t give a shit or dont think they are part of this clusterfuck just darted off down the tunnel. Grady looked utterly broken.

I kind of respect Robinson, Bartley & Fulong for staying on and approaching the crowd, I’m not sure how prepared they were for the utter dogs abuse they got.I’m not into giving abuse out at players, rather than the collective, but I can’t blame anyone who did.

It’s a mess.

Personally,  I thought the crowd were remarkably patient last night. I applauded Carroll as he went off, simply for his effort, many others did too. Then we walked out ourselves as some of the players skiddaddled, while some clapped the BRE. I didn't bother looking who did what  I'm not sure it counts for much.