WBAUnofficial
5 worst Albion managers of your generation - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation (/showthread.php?tid=23966)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation - Protheroe - 02-03-2022

Little - most depressed I've ever been as an Albion fan

Robson - I turned to my mate on the day of the Great Escape shaking my head and saying the prick was with us for another season, how much better it would have been if he'd walked away then.

Pulis - why on Earth we ever employed him, Hateful man, hateful football. No excuse for those scenes in the cup at the Villa, but playing the way he did against a team there for the taking was risible.

Gould - obviously.

Pepe Mel - a high line with a pedestrian Diego Lugano away at Villa. FFS.


RE: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation - BaggieTom89 - 02-03-2022

(02-02-2022, 09:17 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: How is Pulis on anyones list?

Agree entirely it obviously ended very sour his last season but the job he did in his first 18 months/ 2 years was much needed.

We can only dream of switching off the last 10 premier league games when we've hit 40 points these days!

He's easily top 5 for me (since mid 90s) not bottom 5.


RE: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation - MassDebater - 02-03-2022

(02-03-2022, 09:46 AM)BaggieTom89 Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 09:17 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: How is Pulis on anyones list?

Agree entirely it obviously ended very sour his last season but the job he did in his first 18 months/ 2 years was much needed.

We can only dream of switching off the last 10 premier league games when we've hit 40 points these days!

He's easily top 5 for me (since mid 90s) not bottom 5.

I hated him, but he doesn't even get on mine! He kept us up, and yep would've took us down in the end. No way was he worse than a load of others though, Premiership vs Divs2 / 3 different World.


RE: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation - Hopalong - 02-03-2022

(02-02-2022, 09:18 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: Stiles 
Saunders 
Little
Pardew
Allardyce

Stiles wasn’t that bad in v difficult circumstances at the time, and certainly shouldn’t be on there at the exclusion of Val or Pulis.
[/quote]

Loffin  Big Grin


RE: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation - Jacobthebaggie - 02-03-2022

The 6/7 managers since Pulis have more reason to be in the top 5 shitters table. Derided massively while here along with Peace yet here we are again since their departures. Loving the green grass ffs


RE: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation - Bob Fossil - 02-03-2022

Gould
Saunders
Little
Talbot
Pardew

As much as I'd love to put Pulis in there, he did the job he was paid to do.

As for Val, he gets the vote for most frustrating, as, I think, had he adapted a bit and tried a different formation, he could have taken us up.
He does get the special award though for "Worst In-Game Management Ever"


RE: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation - BaggieTom89 - 02-03-2022

(02-03-2022, 09:48 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(02-03-2022, 09:46 AM)BaggieTom89 Wrote:
(02-02-2022, 09:17 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: How is Pulis on anyones list?

Agree entirely it obviously ended very sour his last season but the job he did in his first 18 months/ 2 years was much needed.

We can only dream of switching off the last 10 premier league games when we've hit 40 points these days!

He's easily top 5 for me (since mid 90s) not bottom 5.

I hated him, but he doesn't even get on mine! He kept us up, and yep would've took us down in the end. No way was he worse than a load of others though, Premiership vs Divs2 / 3 different World.

Exactly. When you remember how poor we were at the back the 3-0 leads we chucked away vs Cardiff, Spurs etc he made us solid and hard to beat. many good victories against the big boys.

Unfortunately the reality is when the results are coming you accept the style. When you have a perceived negative style and the results drop off its a very quick demise.

I still look back to that pre-season and the signings we made and wonder how it all went so wrong.


RE: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation - Lurker#3 - 02-03-2022

Brian little (not much memory thankfully)
Pardew
AFI
Mel
Bilic


RE: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation - Ilkleybaggie - 02-03-2022

Gould - the darkest days
Saunders - ripped the team apart, probably forced to, but served up dross
Talbot - started well but then decided we had to play hoofball
Irvine - just soooo boring, without the redeeming feature of being even slightly effective
Wylie - brought in a goalkeeper to be first team coach, as I recall it.


RE: 5 worst Albion managers of your generation - BaggieTom89 - 02-03-2022

My Worst 5:

Brian Little
Denis Smith
Pepe Mel- Nice guy and shafted not allowing backroom team but we were so naive.
Alan Pardew
Val- Toss up with him and Buckley but think Val has had more advantages than Buckley did and quality of football and stubbornness to try nothing new swings it.