RE: Double jabs to watch the football - Lightnin - 07-25-2021
(07-25-2021, 08:43 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (07-25-2021, 08:39 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: If the vaccine is so great at reducing transmission then how can you explain that cases are increasing rapidly in Gibraltar where over 99% of the population have been fully jabbed since early May?
Gibraltar's last seven days:
24,24,26,34,40,34,12
Statistics can show almost anything, they've conducted 10 tests per person who lives there. More testing pretty much always equals more infections. Not exactly the rapid increase you suggested.
Because Gibraltar has hardly any border control and the Spanish that work in Gib just walk in and out every single day. Spain is still on the amber list too isn’t it?
RE: Double jabs to watch the football - baggiebuckster - 07-25-2021
It is rapid when they went from the beginning of March to the end of June with an average of about 1 a day.
RE: Double jabs to watch the football - Sotv - 07-25-2021
(07-25-2021, 07:42 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-25-2021, 07:05 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (07-25-2021, 06:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (07-25-2021, 05:47 PM)DJPunkRoc Wrote: In any other year ‘Star of David’ would have won post of the year but, this year, it’s up against ‘The Tories got us to the Euro semis’ so will probably just disappear into the ether
Arf 
You can either take medical advice from the world's leading scientists, epidemiologists and virologists or you can take advice from Laurence Fox, Lee Hurst, David Icke, Katie Hopkins, Right Said Fred and Piers Corbyn...
If you think it’s one choice or the other regarding medical advice, and there’s no in between (let alone the concerns on creeping), you are beyond help. That is absurd. There are pages of discussion about all the nuanced positions on the politics forum and you know it. You just love lumping people into groups.
There’s many people who are pro vaccines but pro choice and anti passport. There’s many who are pro vaccine but would just like more long term data on this one. There’s many more nuanced positions. The actual discussion was about the passport, not who you take medical advice off. What a ridiculous comment you have just made.
Lighten up it was a tongue in cheek comment.
Do you want to try and get the virus under control or are you happy to let people catch it like they would catch a cold at a cinema, football match, concert, pub, restaurant etc? Do you want to deny those who are vulnerable to the virus never to go to see a football match, convert, play?
Younger people and Covid
(07-25-2021, 07:14 PM)Sotv Wrote: (07-25-2021, 05:56 PM)Duffers Wrote: (07-25-2021, 05:44 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: (07-25-2021, 05:39 PM)MassDebater Wrote: As I said earlier, if you have mental health issues you can be sectioned. For your own good, and for the good of everyone else. Are you advocating that people who make dangerous decisions that can affect themselves and others, should be allowed to keep doing so? Do you think people who are dangerous and are prescribed medicine and are made to take it, should have the right to not take it!? Personally I think it's the more accurate comparison.
It's people loudly voicing your concerns that help stop people from getting the vaccine, as I said to two people who I actually know that promote this medical autonomy bollix, "I'll be a bit sad if you get covid and die after refusing the vaccine, but if you refuse the vaccine, get it and then pass it onto someone I care about and they die, well then it'll be a vengeance of biblical proportions that you get'
I think the level of danger required to get someone sectioned is way higher than not wanting to have the vaccine. I don’t think this is a fair comparison to an infectious disease, no. Particularly given the vaccine doesn’t stop you passing it on (I know it reduces it).
But tbf if you think medical autonomy is bollox, fair enough, I doubt we’ll agree on that. But I do agree the Holocaust is a silly distasteful comparison.
Out of interest, how far would you go? Ban from all shops? Supermarket? Banned from leaving house?
Some people do have legitimate concerns, like the ones you have articulated in this thread. The problem comes when idiots start banging on about stars of David like in this thread, or the silly twat in Trafalgar Square yesterday preaching about hanging Drs and nurses, the rational side of the argument just vanishes.
That's about right. I've had both jabs and was happy tondo so but am looking on with some concern at what now appears to be coercion by the back door. To make some of the comparisons though are just daft and show an inability to put an argument together without jumping straight to an extreme.
Another thing that I can't fathom is people saying that if you don't have the vaccine you are putting others at risk, whilst we also get told that you can still pass the virus on if you have been vaccinated so therefore you're still putting people at risk.
You are 60% less likely to pass the virus on if you have had both jabs. Those odds seem a lot more preferable than letting anyone and everyone go to an event. Thanks for clearing that up, I'll have a look for some.links as I've a few vaccine sceptic friends who just need a nudge in the right direction
Edit just found this backing up what you say. Both me and the Mrs are double jabbed but she started feeling crap the other day. She has done 3 home tests, 2 coming back as positive, the other negative. Even though it seems she is less likely to pass it on ( me and the kids have been testing and are clear so far) she is isolating in the bedroom and the rest of us will have to quarantine.
Trying to wfh and study for an exam I did have booked for Friday but will now have to rearrange will be interesting!
https://www.bmj.com/content/373/bmj.n1112
RE: Double jabs to watch the football - MassDebater - 07-25-2021
(07-25-2021, 08:52 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: It is rapid when they went from the beginning of March to the end of June with an average of about 1 a day.
Like I say statistics can be used to show almost anything. The whole of Europe will no doubt be surging very soon. This Delta variant spreads more rapidly, which is the answer to your question (no border control, delta variant Spanish surge, fewer vaccinations in Spain and relaxed / no border controls)
RE: Double jabs to watch the football - MassDebater - 07-25-2021
This will help too: https://www.gov.uk/government/news/latest-react-1-study-findings-show-covid-19-infection-rates-three-times-lower-for-double-vaccinated-people
"Infection rates for double vaccinated under-65s are 3 times lower than in unvaccinated under-65s, demonstrating the impact of the vaccination roll out"
"It also shows that both doses of a COVID-19 vaccine can reduce symptomatic infection by almost 80%."
|