WBAUnofficial
Improvement - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Improvement (/showthread.php?tid=15744)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: Improvement - Baggie_Nick - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 01:00 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 12:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 10:32 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Ah OK fair enough

100% one of the biggest failings this summer was not buying a holding midfielder, I’m at a loss to think how anybody at the club thought we would be OK this season without adding one

Cuzer

Agree. Plus someone thought we would get by without a proper no. 9. Whether it was Slav or Dowling, failure to fill these 2 positions is to blame for our being unable to compete.
As someone else said, no one is without blame for us being so ill prepared for a season of such importance.

In fairness, most clubs get by without a traditional number 9 in this league... Fulham have one but rarely play him and Sheff Utd have plenty but can’t score.

Not adding a defensive midfielder was what killed us.

A multitude of sins.

A DM as you said but not improving the defence was criminal. We needed experience and a goalscorer - Deeney would have been a decent punt.

It's telling that our two most expensive signings can't get a game.

Slav got the bullet and rightly so. Dowling should be sacked before the rebuilding process begins.


RE: Improvement - Tom Joad - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 01:00 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 12:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 10:32 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Ah OK fair enough

100% one of the biggest failings this summer was not buying a holding midfielder, I’m at a loss to think how anybody at the club thought we would be OK this season without adding one

Cuzer

Agree. Plus someone thought we would get by without a proper no. 9. Whether it was Slav or Dowling, failure to fill these 2 positions is to blame for our being unable to compete.
As someone else said, no one is without blame for us being so ill prepared for a season of such importance.

In fairness, most clubs get by without a traditional number 9 in this league... Fulham have one but rarely play him and Sheff Utd have plenty but can’t score.

Not adding a defensive midfielder was what killed us.

It's the 2. Old fashioned, I know, but the spine is still massively important unless you are Man City or Liverpool. A no. 9 means we play 20 yards further forward and although we can change formation and do without, it has to be an option. .


RE: Improvement - Birdman1811 - 02-21-2021

Old style goal scorers are disappearing from the game at the moment, their time will come again.

As for Dowling, questions have to be asked of his performance in the summer, it's hard when the manager isn't reading from the same book, but his job is to work with the manager and build the squad we need, irrespective of manager.


RE: Improvement - SW4Baggie - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 01:04 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 01:00 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 12:54 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-21-2021, 10:32 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Ah OK fair enough

100% one of the biggest failings this summer was not buying a holding midfielder, I’m at a loss to think how anybody at the club thought we would be OK this season without adding one

Cuzer

Agree. Plus someone thought we would get by without a proper no. 9. Whether it was Slav or Dowling, failure to fill these 2 positions is to blame for our being unable to compete.
As someone else said, no one is without blame for us being so ill prepared for a season of such importance.

In fairness, most clubs get by without a traditional number 9 in this league... Fulham have one but rarely play him and Sheff Utd have plenty but can’t score.

Not adding a defensive midfielder was what killed us.

A multitude of sins.

A DM as you said but not improving the defence was criminal. We needed experience and a goalscorer - Deeney would have been a decent punt.

It's telling that our two most expensive signings can't get a game.

Slav got the bullet and rightly so. Dowling should be sacked before the rebuilding process begins.

Deeney would have offered absolutely nothing IMO... he would have been someone to bring on for the last 10 mins for the ball to stick to, but by then we’d be 3-down!

We had some experience in Ivanovic, unfortunately he is shit.

Our defence needed shielding more than anything.


RE: Improvement - Squid - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 01:10 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Old style goal scorers are disappearing from the game at the moment, their time will come again.

As for Dowling, questions have to be asked of his performance in the summer, it's hard when the manager isn't reading from the same book, but his job is to work with the manager and build the squad we need, irrespective of manager.

Hammond didn't last a relegation season, Dowling may have to do a lot of talking to ensure the same doesn't happen.

I suspect the board not wanting the hassle of recruiting a new DoF may work in his favour.

And considering the board's previous attempt at recruitment was Terrano, that may not be a bad thing.


RE: Improvement - Cuzer - 02-21-2021

If you want Appleton, Dowling stays, they are the best if best mates

Cuzer


RE: Improvement - Baggie_Nick - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 01:25 PM)Cuzer Wrote: If you want Appleton, Dowling stays, they are the best if best mates

Cuzer

No ta.


RE: Improvement - richbaggie - 02-21-2021

(02-20-2021, 11:47 PM)Baggie_Nick Wrote:
(02-20-2021, 11:43 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(02-20-2021, 09:59 PM)Squid Wrote:
(02-20-2021, 09:26 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Slav earned a shot in the Prem, he was bewildered by the lack of investment and player decisions being made by Dowling without his sign off

He was desperate for 2 fullbacks and was denied, had no interest in Kipre yet we brought him

Busted flush my arse

Up to the job? Maybe not but Sam’s not showed he is yet either, with a better squad and a better balanced squad than Bilic had

Cuzer

Neither Dowling or the board are to blame for the team crumbling psychologically and physically post lockdown.

As for "Bewildered by the lack of investment", which part of we cannot spend money we don't have did he not understand?

Why did he insist on Ivanovic?

Why did he ask for Krov to return even though we didn't need him?

Why did he turn Snodgrass down?

Why did he treat a perfectly serviceable centre back (Kipre) like poo on his shoe?

Why were we so, so unfit?

None of that is the fault of the board.

Did you not see the interview open Croatia when he was lost for wards when he was told what we had to spend?

Did you see Hegazi sold behind his back when he had put him in the team and we recorded our first clean sheet

Krovinovic doesn’t become a bad player overnight, Ivanovic hasn’t worked, he is the first manager to get a player in which didn’t work out? 

I don’t dislike Kipre but when a a manager wants to spend 1m on a loan midfielder or 2 full backs and Dowling signs Kipre what does that say to the manager?

It works both ways but I won’t have bollocks like a busted flush being thrown at Slav, if Slav would have stayed and been given some money to wheel and deal in Jan we would of probably had more points than we have now in all honesty

Those Leeds, Arsenal and Villa performances were torrid, would we had been any worse under Slav? Not a chance


Cuzer

Telling.

So Hegazi WAS sold behind his back? I thought so. Only more than a few on here have disputed that and used it as a stick to beat Slav with.

The club said otherwise. So the club lied?
 
He 100% was not sold behind his back.

He told the club to sell either Bartley or Hegazi once we had secured Ivanovic.

Did he change his mind at the last minute? Maybe. But he had shown zero confidence in him at any stage of his time here so the hissy fit was absolutely ridiculous given he was happy to see him sold and had hardly played him.

Fed up of seeing how Bilic was wronged here, its utter bollocks.


RE: Improvement - Birdman1811 - 02-21-2021

Slav is a poor manager. We scraped our way up despite being clear favourites with Leeds from any viewpoint. 2nd half of the season, especially after lockdown was sackable form alone.

We've sacked, rightly, for less. Don't get what so many fans saw in him in all honestly, he's now back in football obscurity, where being a motivator alone may be enough.


RE: Improvement - clem4england - 02-21-2021

(02-21-2021, 01:10 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Old style goal scorers are disappearing from the game at the moment, their time will come again.

As for Dowling, questions have to be asked of his performance in the summer, it's hard when the manager isn't reading from the same book, but his job is to work with the manager and build the squad we need, irrespective of manager.
Spot on pal.

The fact that we have a large team (scouting, recruitment, TD, coaches) and none of them appear to have thought that a number 9, holding midfielder or right-back was a must when pretty much everyone I know did is disgusting.

If Bilic wouldn't recognise these needs or wouldn't accept the Recruitment Team's suggestions, he should have been sacked as he couldn't work within the remit of the role / had lost their confidence. The fact he wasn't dismissed means Dowling carries the can for the dreadful buys as far as I am concerned.

(02-21-2021, 01:42 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Slav is a poor manager. We scraped our way up despite being clear favourites with Leeds from any viewpoint. 2nd half of the season, especially after lockdown was sackable form alone.

We've sacked, rightly, for less. Don't get what so many fans saw in him in all honestly, he's now back in football obscurity, where being a motivator alone may be enough.
Ditto. His managerial record suggests you are right. Interestingly, I work with two Hammers: both loved him as a player, are very fond of him and hoped he did well with us; both think he is a limited manager and that BFS was a better manager for them. They may be an exception but, having spoken to them separately about it, their opinions were pretty much identical.