WBAUnofficial
New manager - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: New manager (/showthread.php?tid=15577)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: New manager - Big Daddy Cool - 02-09-2021

McInnes was poor at Bristol City. Wouldn't be mentioned if he'd never have played for us.


RE: New manager - SW4Baggie - 02-09-2021

(02-09-2021, 02:38 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 02:23 PM)Squid Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 12:58 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 11:19 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 07:30 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Eddie Howe would be the ideal for me. But doubt he would touch us with a barge pole.

Then you have the usual pair of McInnes and Appleton, both have shown they are finally ready.

Then you have the unfinished business club; Steve Clarke and Big Dave.

We all know however it will be somebody none of us expected.

In what parallel universe is McInnes “ready”?

Took over Aberdeen in 2013. 

11/12 - 9th
12/13 - 8th

13/14 - 3rd
14/15, 15/16, 16/17, 17/18 - 2nd
18/19 - 4th
19/20 - 4th
20/21 - 5th so far, in a very peculiar season, especially with Jimmy Krankies rules. 

I would say the dramatic upturn in their finishes, and the level of experience gained stand him in good stead.

While I applaud the statistics, there is one issue:

This is Scottish football. Aberdeen are the 5th biggest club in Scotland and they're planning on reducing their seating capacity to 15,000 "to improve the atmosphere". Jack Fitzwater is a regular starter for an SPL team.

I have also heard that his football is of the more agricultural variety and Albion fans have little patience with that. That's an issue, because we really need to have patience with whoever we bring in next.

Unfortunately, we seem to have a habit of making managers lose the plot.

I do agree with the facts presented, but he took them over as an under achieving club and made them perform  by and large above their station. And even now he is bang on the money, but is under pressure. 
Also regarding Scotland. They have produced more than their fair share of coaching talent over the years.

I am not sure we, are a fan base that really require a purist, visionary. But we do want a coach and team to get behind and be proud of. 
When ever I have seen Aberdeen, the defend well  are aggressive  always look fit, and play forward quickly and get players into the box. That works for me.

McInnes has spent too long at Aberdeen... he had an excellent early impact and probably should have jumped a couple seasons ago when Championship offers were happening. I think the Bristol City nightmare (which was more to do with off the field issues than anything else) has made him overly cautious. I think he’s got a steady job in Aberdeen and probably doesn’t want to select another clusterfuck but his recent performance means he’s dropped off a lot of radars.

I think the McInnes ship has sailed for us. He’d be someone I’d consider if we didn’t have the money to make an immediate return. 

Eddie Howe will be at Celtic when they sack off Lennon. It’s pretty much done and dusted, a couple titles there will remove the blight of last season from his CV.

Some decent suggestions in Cook and Robins, and Clarke’s would be an interesting appointment!  

Appleton still ticks the most boxes, and at least he’s a little more interesting than the Shakespeare/Pearson roundabout


RE: New manager - Tom Joad - 02-09-2021

Peachy Wrote:
backsidebaggie Wrote:
Tom Joad Wrote:I don't get the Eddie Howe lovefest. Spent a load of money, had cheats diving all over the pitch and gets homesick when they play away.
I also don't understand why BFS won't stay if we drop? I reckon he'll take a wage for as long as we offer him one. He's been unemployed long enough.
I really hope that someone, somewhere behind those Astle gates, has a list of suitable candidates for when we are ready to appoint a new manager but right now I'm looking forward to seeing us play with a midfield for the first time this season.

I agree. Must admit I'm shocked at how many think BFS will definitely be gone.

In his first press conference, they asked him about his record of never getting relegated. His answer was something like he'd be hurt if it happened but would feel much better if he brought us back up. That suggests that he is certainly open to it. He ain't getting another prem job! Of course, all this depends if Albion get rid of him.

I'm not saying he'll stay, but I think there's a reasonable chance.

I fail to see how he keeps his job if he takes us down with a whimper. We were 2 points from safety when he arrived and we have been abysmal so far. 

If we settle down and start winning games and looking like a side that wants to play then fair enough take that into next season. If however we continue this regression for the next 4 or 5 games he simply has to go.

The precedent has been set with Pardews sacking.

I can also say with some certainly that if fans were in the stadiums Big Sam would have been getting dogs abuse for the past 3 or 4 weeks and the pressure on him, and in turn the board, would be huge.
Yes, but that wasn't the point. I was just wondering what the evidence was for the claim that BFS won't be here next year?
Regarding the negative results.  If we continue to go backwards, of course he will need to go. But on a "New manager" thread I was just saying that having made the appointment, having signed BFS's players, Albion now need to give him a some time to see if he can make a fist of it. We're pretty much doomed, to change managers now wouldn't bode well.


RE: New manager - Peachy - 02-09-2021

(02-09-2021, 04:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 02:38 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 02:23 PM)Squid Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 12:58 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 11:19 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: In what parallel universe is McInnes “ready”?

Took over Aberdeen in 2013. 

11/12 - 9th
12/13 - 8th

13/14 - 3rd
14/15, 15/16, 16/17, 17/18 - 2nd
18/19 - 4th
19/20 - 4th
20/21 - 5th so far, in a very peculiar season, especially with Jimmy Krankies rules. 

I would say the dramatic upturn in their finishes, and the level of experience gained stand him in good stead.

While I applaud the statistics, there is one issue:

This is Scottish football. Aberdeen are the 5th biggest club in Scotland and they're planning on reducing their seating capacity to 15,000 "to improve the atmosphere". Jack Fitzwater is a regular starter for an SPL team.

I have also heard that his football is of the more agricultural variety and Albion fans have little patience with that. That's an issue, because we really need to have patience with whoever we bring in next.

Unfortunately, we seem to have a habit of making managers lose the plot.

I do agree with the facts presented, but he took them over as an under achieving club and made them perform  by and large above their station. And even now he is bang on the money, but is under pressure. 
Also regarding Scotland. They have produced more than their fair share of coaching talent over the years.

I am not sure we, are a fan base that really require a purist, visionary. But we do want a coach and team to get behind and be proud of. 
When ever I have seen Aberdeen, the defend well  are aggressive  always look fit, and play forward quickly and get players into the box. That works for me.

McInnes has spent too long at Aberdeen... he had an excellent early impact and probably should have jumped a couple seasons ago when Championship offers were happening. I think the Bristol City nightmare (which was more to do with off the field issues than anything else) has made him overly cautious. I think he’s got a steady job in Aberdeen and probably doesn’t want to select another clusterfuck but his recent performance means he’s dropped off a lot of radars.

I think the McInnes ship has sailed for us. He’d be someone I’d consider if we didn’t have the money to make an immediate return. 

Eddie Howe will be at Celtic when they sack off Lennon. It’s pretty much done and dusted, a couple titles there will remove the blight of last season from his CV.

Some decent suggestions in Cook and Robins, and Clarke’s would be an interesting appointment!  

Appleton still ticks the most boxes, and at least he’s a little more interesting than the Shakespeare/Pearson roundabout

Interesting Re Howe SW4. I'd not thought about him and Celtic. Funny story..... Last week I was walking my dogs down to the beach in Poole and a young boxer dog ran over and tried to hump my young lab. The owner sprinted over to pull it off and apologised and it was Eddie Howe! He's a nice bloke. Didn't talk footie, just dogs, but I'd be very surprised if he uprooted his young family from the area personally. Especially North of the border. 

I think he will get the Palace job personally. Looks a good fit to me.


RE: New manager - SW4Baggie - 02-09-2021

(02-09-2021, 05:42 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 02:38 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 02:23 PM)Squid Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 12:58 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Took over Aberdeen in 2013. 

11/12 - 9th
12/13 - 8th

13/14 - 3rd
14/15, 15/16, 16/17, 17/18 - 2nd
18/19 - 4th
19/20 - 4th
20/21 - 5th so far, in a very peculiar season, especially with Jimmy Krankies rules. 

I would say the dramatic upturn in their finishes, and the level of experience gained stand him in good stead.

While I applaud the statistics, there is one issue:

This is Scottish football. Aberdeen are the 5th biggest club in Scotland and they're planning on reducing their seating capacity to 15,000 "to improve the atmosphere". Jack Fitzwater is a regular starter for an SPL team.

I have also heard that his football is of the more agricultural variety and Albion fans have little patience with that. That's an issue, because we really need to have patience with whoever we bring in next.

Unfortunately, we seem to have a habit of making managers lose the plot.

I do agree with the facts presented, but he took them over as an under achieving club and made them perform  by and large above their station. And even now he is bang on the money, but is under pressure. 
Also regarding Scotland. They have produced more than their fair share of coaching talent over the years.

I am not sure we, are a fan base that really require a purist, visionary. But we do want a coach and team to get behind and be proud of. 
When ever I have seen Aberdeen, the defend well  are aggressive  always look fit, and play forward quickly and get players into the box. That works for me.

McInnes has spent too long at Aberdeen... he had an excellent early impact and probably should have jumped a couple seasons ago when Championship offers were happening. I think the Bristol City nightmare (which was more to do with off the field issues than anything else) has made him overly cautious. I think he’s got a steady job in Aberdeen and probably doesn’t want to select another clusterfuck but his recent performance means he’s dropped off a lot of radars.

I think the McInnes ship has sailed for us. He’d be someone I’d consider if we didn’t have the money to make an immediate return. 

Eddie Howe will be at Celtic when they sack off Lennon. It’s pretty much done and dusted, a couple titles there will remove the blight of last season from his CV.

Some decent suggestions in Cook and Robins, and Clarke’s would be an interesting appointment!  

Appleton still ticks the most boxes, and at least he’s a little more interesting than the Shakespeare/Pearson roundabout

Interesting Re Howe SW4. I'd not thought about him and Celtic. Funny story..... Last week I was walking my dogs down to the beach in Poole and a young boxer dog ran over and tried to hump my young lab. The owner sprinted over to pull it off and apologised and it was Eddie Howe! He's a nice bloke. Didn't talk footie, just dogs, but I'd be very surprised if he uprooted his young family from the area personally. Especially North of the border. 

I think he will get the Palace job personally. Looks a good fit to me.

The dirty bugger.

That's a fair comment on the uprooting his family... the move to Burnley didn't really work, but you'd have to question what the point of moving to Palace would be. He's not going to do anything he didn't do with Bournemouth, and like half the PL, they only have a limited shelf life in the PL.

If he goes to Celtic he will have the chance to win silverware and get European football under his belt.


RE: New manager - Squid - 02-09-2021

(02-09-2021, 06:12 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 05:42 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 02:38 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 02:23 PM)Squid Wrote: While I applaud the statistics, there is one issue:

This is Scottish football. Aberdeen are the 5th biggest club in Scotland and they're planning on reducing their seating capacity to 15,000 "to improve the atmosphere". Jack Fitzwater is a regular starter for an SPL team.

I have also heard that his football is of the more agricultural variety and Albion fans have little patience with that. That's an issue, because we really need to have patience with whoever we bring in next.

Unfortunately, we seem to have a habit of making managers lose the plot.

I do agree with the facts presented, but he took them over as an under achieving club and made them perform  by and large above their station. And even now he is bang on the money, but is under pressure. 
Also regarding Scotland. They have produced more than their fair share of coaching talent over the years.

I am not sure we, are a fan base that really require a purist, visionary. But we do want a coach and team to get behind and be proud of. 
When ever I have seen Aberdeen, the defend well  are aggressive  always look fit, and play forward quickly and get players into the box. That works for me.

McInnes has spent too long at Aberdeen... he had an excellent early impact and probably should have jumped a couple seasons ago when Championship offers were happening. I think the Bristol City nightmare (which was more to do with off the field issues than anything else) has made him overly cautious. I think he’s got a steady job in Aberdeen and probably doesn’t want to select another clusterfuck but his recent performance means he’s dropped off a lot of radars.

I think the McInnes ship has sailed for us. He’d be someone I’d consider if we didn’t have the money to make an immediate return. 

Eddie Howe will be at Celtic when they sack off Lennon. It’s pretty much done and dusted, a couple titles there will remove the blight of last season from his CV.

Some decent suggestions in Cook and Robins, and Clarke’s would be an interesting appointment!  

Appleton still ticks the most boxes, and at least he’s a little more interesting than the Shakespeare/Pearson roundabout

Interesting Re Howe SW4. I'd not thought about him and Celtic. Funny story..... Last week I was walking my dogs down to the beach in Poole and a young boxer dog ran over and tried to hump my young lab. The owner sprinted over to pull it off and apologised and it was Eddie Howe! He's a nice bloke. Didn't talk footie, just dogs, but I'd be very surprised if he uprooted his young family from the area personally. Especially North of the border. 

I think he will get the Palace job personally. Looks a good fit to me.

The dirty bugger.

That's a fair comment on the uprooting his family... the move to Burnley didn't really work, but you'd have to question what the point of moving to Palace would be. He's not going to do anything he didn't do with Bournemouth, and like half the PL, they only have a limited shelf life in the PL.

If he goes to Celtic he will have the chance to win silverware and get European football under his belt.

I though Bilic might be the next Celtic manager. They'd love him up there.


RE: New manager - Ministry Of Silly Signings - 02-09-2021

(02-09-2021, 05:42 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 02:38 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 02:23 PM)Squid Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 12:58 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Took over Aberdeen in 2013. 

11/12 - 9th
12/13 - 8th

13/14 - 3rd
14/15, 15/16, 16/17, 17/18 - 2nd
18/19 - 4th
19/20 - 4th
20/21 - 5th so far, in a very peculiar season, especially with Jimmy Krankies rules. 

I would say the dramatic upturn in their finishes, and the level of experience gained stand him in good stead.

While I applaud the statistics, there is one issue:

This is Scottish football. Aberdeen are the 5th biggest club in Scotland and they're planning on reducing their seating capacity to 15,000 "to improve the atmosphere". Jack Fitzwater is a regular starter for an SPL team.

I have also heard that his football is of the more agricultural variety and Albion fans have little patience with that. That's an issue, because we really need to have patience with whoever we bring in next.

Unfortunately, we seem to have a habit of making managers lose the plot.

I do agree with the facts presented, but he took them over as an under achieving club and made them perform  by and large above their station. And even now he is bang on the money, but is under pressure. 
Also regarding Scotland. They have produced more than their fair share of coaching talent over the years.

I am not sure we, are a fan base that really require a purist, visionary. But we do want a coach and team to get behind and be proud of. 
When ever I have seen Aberdeen, the defend well  are aggressive  always look fit, and play forward quickly and get players into the box. That works for me.

McInnes has spent too long at Aberdeen... he had an excellent early impact and probably should have jumped a couple seasons ago when Championship offers were happening. I think the Bristol City nightmare (which was more to do with off the field issues than anything else) has made him overly cautious. I think he’s got a steady job in Aberdeen and probably doesn’t want to select another clusterfuck but his recent performance means he’s dropped off a lot of radars.

I think the McInnes ship has sailed for us. He’d be someone I’d consider if we didn’t have the money to make an immediate return. 

Eddie Howe will be at Celtic when they sack off Lennon. It’s pretty much done and dusted, a couple titles there will remove the blight of last season from his CV.

Some decent suggestions in Cook and Robins, and Clarke’s would be an interesting appointment!  

Appleton still ticks the most boxes, and at least he’s a little more interesting than the Shakespeare/Pearson roundabout

Interesting Re Howe SW4. I'd not thought about him and Celtic. Funny story..... Last week I was walking my dogs down to the beach in Poole and a young boxer dog ran over and tried to hump my young lab. The owner sprinted over to pull it off and apologised and it was Eddie Howe! He's a nice bloke. Didn't talk footie, just dogs, but I'd be very surprised if he uprooted his young family from the area personally. Especially North of the border. 

I think he will get the Palace job personally. Looks a good fit to me.
Sure I read somewhere that Howes move to Burnley turned bad because his Dad was taken ill & died, he was travelling back to the south coast after games etc.


RE: New manager - Pragmatist - 02-09-2021

(02-09-2021, 06:27 PM)Squid Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 06:12 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 05:42 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 02:38 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: I do agree with the facts presented, but he took them over as an under achieving club and made them perform  by and large above their station. And even now he is bang on the money, but is under pressure. 
Also regarding Scotland. They have produced more than their fair share of coaching talent over the years.

I am not sure we, are a fan base that really require a purist, visionary. But we do want a coach and team to get behind and be proud of. 
When ever I have seen Aberdeen, the defend well  are aggressive  always look fit, and play forward quickly and get players into the box. That works for me.

McInnes has spent too long at Aberdeen... he had an excellent early impact and probably should have jumped a couple seasons ago when Championship offers were happening. I think the Bristol City nightmare (which was more to do with off the field issues than anything else) has made him overly cautious. I think he’s got a steady job in Aberdeen and probably doesn’t want to select another clusterfuck but his recent performance means he’s dropped off a lot of radars.

I think the McInnes ship has sailed for us. He’d be someone I’d consider if we didn’t have the money to make an immediate return. 

Eddie Howe will be at Celtic when they sack off Lennon. It’s pretty much done and dusted, a couple titles there will remove the blight of last season from his CV.

Some decent suggestions in Cook and Robins, and Clarke’s would be an interesting appointment!  

Appleton still ticks the most boxes, and at least he’s a little more interesting than the Shakespeare/Pearson roundabout

Interesting Re Howe SW4. I'd not thought about him and Celtic. Funny story..... Last week I was walking my dogs down to the beach in Poole and a young boxer dog ran over and tried to hump my young lab. The owner sprinted over to pull it off and apologised and it was Eddie Howe! He's a nice bloke. Didn't talk footie, just dogs, but I'd be very surprised if he uprooted his young family from the area personally. Especially North of the border. 

I think he will get the Palace job personally. Looks a good fit to me.

The dirty bugger.

That's a fair comment on the uprooting his family... the move to Burnley didn't really work, but you'd have to question what the point of moving to Palace would be. He's not going to do anything he didn't do with Bournemouth, and like half the PL, they only have a limited shelf life in the PL.

If he goes to Celtic he will have the chance to win silverware and get European football under his belt.

I though Bilic might be the next Celtic manager. They'd love him up there.

Benitez to Celtic

Lampard to Palace

Howe - might struggle if he won’t uproot his family


RE: New manager - Squid - 02-09-2021

(02-09-2021, 09:25 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 06:27 PM)Squid Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 06:12 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 05:42 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(02-09-2021, 04:34 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: McInnes has spent too long at Aberdeen... he had an excellent early impact and probably should have jumped a couple seasons ago when Championship offers were happening. I think the Bristol City nightmare (which was more to do with off the field issues than anything else) has made him overly cautious. I think he’s got a steady job in Aberdeen and probably doesn’t want to select another clusterfuck but his recent performance means he’s dropped off a lot of radars.

I think the McInnes ship has sailed for us. He’d be someone I’d consider if we didn’t have the money to make an immediate return. 

Eddie Howe will be at Celtic when they sack off Lennon. It’s pretty much done and dusted, a couple titles there will remove the blight of last season from his CV.

Some decent suggestions in Cook and Robins, and Clarke’s would be an interesting appointment!  

Appleton still ticks the most boxes, and at least he’s a little more interesting than the Shakespeare/Pearson roundabout

Interesting Re Howe SW4. I'd not thought about him and Celtic. Funny story..... Last week I was walking my dogs down to the beach in Poole and a young boxer dog ran over and tried to hump my young lab. The owner sprinted over to pull it off and apologised and it was Eddie Howe! He's a nice bloke. Didn't talk footie, just dogs, but I'd be very surprised if he uprooted his young family from the area personally. Especially North of the border. 

I think he will get the Palace job personally. Looks a good fit to me.

The dirty bugger.

That's a fair comment on the uprooting his family... the move to Burnley didn't really work, but you'd have to question what the point of moving to Palace would be. He's not going to do anything he didn't do with Bournemouth, and like half the PL, they only have a limited shelf life in the PL.

If he goes to Celtic he will have the chance to win silverware and get European football under his belt.

I though Bilic might be the next Celtic manager. They'd love him up there.

Benitez to Celtic

Lampard to Palace

Howe - might struggle if he won’t uproot his family

Bristol City job might come up soonish for Howe.

Palace seems a bit of a comedown for Lampard.


RE: New manager - Lightnin - 02-10-2021

Tony Mowbray, doing a decent job at Blackburn.