WBAUnofficial
Brexit deal sorted - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Brexit deal sorted (/showthread.php?tid=14515)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16


RE: Brexit deal sorted - Fido - 12-28-2020

(12-28-2020, 10:36 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-28-2020, 08:59 AM)Fido Wrote:
(12-28-2020, 08:32 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-27-2020, 08:59 PM)Loanee Wrote: Let’s cut the bitterness & petty sniping, let’s list the positive outcomes of the deal & how it makes us better off, I’ll go first (everyone else feel free to contribute):

1 - blue passports

Mad how this thread went from one of the busiest on this site to absolute silence when this question got asked.

Without bringing “sides of buses” into it I wonder what we will save on contributions to the mammoth EU budget. I assume there is some kind of divorce settlement still but you’d think this would be an upside at some point.

How much have we spent on Brexit so far?
How much will business have to spend on red tape (the red tape that was erm supposed to be cut after Brexit)
How many extra staff will be needed to control our borders? 

Simple question is the deal better than what we already had before Brexit?

I don't know. This seems to be a bit of a bête noire with you so I'd assume you'd have collated some kind of numbers around this? 

As a longer term financial upside it's clear that money will be saved by not contributing to the EU budget. Whether this is off-set by losses elsewhere we'd need some sort of input, I suppose.


RE: Brexit deal sorted - Logic1 - 12-28-2020

(12-27-2020, 08:02 PM)JOK Wrote:
(12-27-2020, 10:13 AM)Logic1 Wrote:
(12-27-2020, 09:42 AM)JOK Wrote:
(12-26-2020, 07:38 PM)Logic1 Wrote: My hope though is that this will be a jolting to the EU to reform. Then, at a later date, once the Farage's of this world are having their nappies cleaned in their care homes (paid for by my generations taxes) we can rejoin.
Good luck with that! If you mean reforming for the better. The last 53 years have proved contrary to that.

The generation that paid for your education, health care and child allowance, you mean?
No doubt you are in the 60-80 year old generation. The biggest spongers in uk history. No tuition fees, massive property price rises, low retirement ages, massive debt put on my generation and now you get the vaccine first. Furthermore, you lot took us out of the EU that lowers our long run growth rate. If you don't think people like me, (30-40 age bracket) and the generations after me aren't pissed off then you are deluded. No doubt we will be paying for a national care service for you as well.

Free tuition fees   8% of the population went to university in the 1960s the other 92% started work at 15 years old and began paying taxes and NI. Not quite the entire generation “sponging” then.
Because I didn’t have the opportunity to go to university in my youth, I paid for my two degrees as an adult whilst earning a living, working full time and providing for my family.
It’s estimated that only 17% of students will pay back their loans. Some will never even make a repayment due to below threshold earnings.  The vast majority of Tuition fees will never be repaid.

Low retirement ages. Funny, how come I have to wait until I’m 66? Longer than what I was told when I started work

I think you’ll find it is the War generation and those in the front line services (mostly Gen X )  getting the vaccine first. And that’s so you can get back to the pub.

Massive debt! Which generation paid off the debt incurred by the previous generation that allowed a second catastrophic war in 20 years to come about? And they had to pay off the debts from the war before and the recession. Succeeding generations paying for debts incurred before them is not exactly a new phenomenon.

So, all Boomers voted to quit your Shangri La and all Gen X voted remain? I should just  check that.

So, you will have you pay for our “care service”! Then how come all my 99 year old mother’s assets and pensions are being ploughed into her care home?  And so will mine!

Only 25% of Brits who live abroad are in Europe. Only 66% of those are of working age. Latest, approximate,  figures suggest under 785,000 Brits live in Europe. So that is 518,000. Out of a population of 68 million that means, if my maths is correct, just 0.76% of the population take advantage of ‘Freedom of Movement’ to work and study

I’m fully aware your particular brood of generation are p**ed off, you’re p**ed off at everything that doesn’t go your way. I bet your parents would be so proud if they knew you called then the Greatest spongers in history. I wonder which generation prompted the use of the term ‘Bank of Mom and Dad’. Which generation is providing lots of free child care? Yep, we are terrible Spongers. Thankfully, the vast majority of your generation aren’t all full of ageist bile like you.

“Humans are capable of an incredible depth of ingratitude. Most never think about the debt we owe to our industrial predecessors. Except when the things they gave are suddenly taken away”. Prof. Patrick Allitt. Ph.D.
I'm going to destroy this post now. It just goes to show what a sponging, self-interested generation you lot are.

1) The decision to increase student numbers and let it be financed by debt, was the decision of the baby boomer Prime Minister, Tony Blair. So you lot caused that.

2) My retirement age = 68 and will likely go up so stop fucking moaning.

3) Yes the war generation go first but you have to be older than 93 to have fought. So fair enough, you go 2nd. When will I receive mine - 2022?

4) You didn't pay off the war debt, it was inflated away.

5) How come your assets are being paid for to finance care homes - why not? Will that be any different for my generation? I doubt it? Also, haven't you hugely benefited from massive property price rises and final salary pensions to finance it?

6) Your point about the low proportion of Brits working and living in the EU is just bloody selfish. Just because they are a minority, doesn't give you a license to restrict their freedom and future freedoms.

7) You forgot to mention all of the pollution that your lot have pumped up in to the atmosphere.

8) You go on about leaving school at 15 but at least there were jobs - we now have record youth unemployment.

9) The generation entering the labour market now will be the first generation that will have lower mortality rate than their parents.

10) I definitely do make this argument to my parents but they are not selfish like you. They voted to remain in order to allow the young the freedoms they all benefited from.


RE: Brexit deal sorted - ChamonixBaggie - 12-28-2020

In reply to Fido and to save cluttering up the page with long quoted posts -

fullfact.org finds that that "cost" (in terms of what has actually been spent and the GDP loss incurred based on pre-2016 trends) by the end of 2020 will be around £200 billion. During our time as members up until we left, our contributions will have been around £222 billion (adjusted). As such, it can reasonably be argued that Brexit has already cost in 4 years almost as much as we paid in EU subs in 47 years. This of course doesn't take into account GDP loss going forward from 2020, which will continue to be significant.

I don't think even the most ardent Brexiteer on here would argue against the point that the UK will be poorer as a result of Brexit. The £350m a week to the NHS promised by the Leave campaigned is A) not true in the first place and B) a drop in the ocean of lost revenue and costs incurred.

The people who voted for it would argue that there are other benefits that make up for this. I would disagree but thats life. It's certainly harmed my industry and cost a few hundred British jobs, including several friends. The disaster capitalists who instigated the whole thing are laughing all the way to bank however.


RE: Brexit deal sorted - The liquidator - 12-28-2020

With all you're money logic nothing should worry you....


RE: Brexit deal sorted - hudds - 12-28-2020

(12-28-2020, 10:36 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-28-2020, 08:59 AM)Fido Wrote:
(12-28-2020, 08:32 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(12-27-2020, 08:59 PM)Loanee Wrote: Let’s cut the bitterness & petty sniping, let’s list the positive outcomes of the deal & how it makes us better off, I’ll go first (everyone else feel free to contribute):

1 - blue passports

Mad how this thread went from one of the busiest on this site to absolute silence when this question got asked.

Without bringing “sides of buses” into it I wonder what we will save on contributions to the mammoth EU budget. I assume there is some kind of divorce settlement still but you’d think this would be an upside at some point.

How much have we spent on Brexit so far?
How much will business have to spend on red tape (the red tape that was erm supposed to be cut after Brexit)
How many extra staff will be needed to control our borders? 

Simple question is the deal better than what we already had before Brexit?
In terms of trade with the EU, it can't be "better" than being in the same club.  There was never any prospect of "frictionless" trade (in goods) even with a deal: the import/export entries and compliance with customs procedures are the consequence. 

To give just one example, I have clients who land oil (fuel) into tank storage at coastal terminals from the ARA (EU).  Hitherto, this was subject to the intra-EU excise movement and control system (EMCS) which has the same effect as sending goods from say Manchester to Brum.  Simple.  Now, the product has to be subject to an EU export declaration, then an import declaration to UK Customs, then entered into the UK excise suspense system (I got agreement from HMRC that the "full" panoply of entering the product to the UK "stand alone" EMCS would not be necessary if the product is loaded directly at the tank farm (a load of extra work for me for that)).   It's all a load of pointless red tape and comes with a cost.  The "benefit" should be no need for the Intrastat return as the import entries should pick up that data but it's a minimal "dividend".

There will be some marginal other benefits but overall nobody in their right minds would choose extra red tape and cost  for trade with the EU.  I don't have a single client who isn't annoyed ranging from irritated/vexed to downright furious (mainly the latter).

Now, this may not matter if the end game is to be "sovereign" and have blue passports and be exceptional and not have loads of EU immigrants  etc etc and to try to have better trade deals with other states/blocs as a small country that we currently enjoy already as part of the EU bloc.  For such folk, leaving the despised EU is really all that matters and for many of those, it's a flicking of the vees to Westminster. 

I'm better off by miles with all the extra work and will retire next year after I have harvested loads more stonking fees - I will have had enough by March I reckon from the almost certain chaos and uncertainty and will take a view from there.  The house is now paid for and I can put my feet up.

Bon chance, UK.


RE: Brexit deal sorted - Tom Joad - 12-28-2020

Ossian Wrote:
Loanee Wrote:Let’s cut the bitterness & petty sniping, let’s list the positive outcomes of the deal & how it makes us better off, I’ll go first (everyone else feel free to contribute):

1 - blue passports

At the risk of being accused of trivialisation, I'd like to know what, for example, happens to agriculture post Brexit. It is just an example, by the way, I have no personal involvement beyond an interest in those areas where environmental issues potentially come into conflict with land use.

Does the price of home reared lamb go through the roof when the CAP subsidies cease? Bearing in mind it's pretty eye-watering already. Or do the small farmers just go out of business (to the eventual benefit of the ranchers with their vast acreages?). What, if anything, replaces the EU LIFE funding for projects to arrest and then reverse the effects of deforestation and flooding? I'm sure some of the communities under water right now would be interested to know the answer to that one.

The devil will, as always, be in the detail and most of us need a bit of a steer because we're unlikely to be wading through twelve hundred odd sheets of close typeface finding the answers for ourselves.
These are my concerns. However, twas always thus.  We now need to somehow find some decent politicians that are brave enough to not ignore these concerns. How on Earth could it ever be practical to buy lamb from the furthest place on the planet, than get it from down the road?  Further; We need to jump head first into green research. The answers are all simple but we've spent hugely on the wrong areas of "going green".  There is no reason to continually build on flood plains. There is no reason we shouldn't fit every new house (and every extension) with solar roof tiles, More wave and solar energy is required. And a big one, the modern internal combustion engine is probably a lot cleaner (and absolutely more practical) than electric cars. Given that is a lost cause, we need to be first to find a better battery solution to the current (totally wrong) one.


RE: Brexit deal sorted - Protheroe - 12-28-2020

(12-28-2020, 11:17 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: In reply to Fido and to save cluttering up the page with long quoted posts -

fullfact.org finds that that "cost" (in terms of what has actually been spent and the GDP loss incurred based on pre-2016 trends) by the end of 2020 will be around £200 billion. During our time as members up until we left, our contributions will have been around £222 billion (adjusted). As such, it can reasonably be argued that Brexit has already cost in 4 years almost as much as we paid in EU subs in 47 years. This of course doesn't take into account GDP loss going forward from 2020, which will continue to be significant.

I don't think even the most ardent Brexiteer on here would argue against the point that the UK will be poorer as a result of Brexit. The £350m a week to the NHS promised by the Leave campaigned is A) not true in the first place and B) a drop in the ocean of lost revenue and costs incurred.

The people who voted for it would argue that there are other benefits that make up for this. I would disagree but thats life. It's certainly harmed my industry and cost a few hundred British jobs, including several friends. The disaster capitalists who instigated the whole thing are laughing all the way to bank however.

The UK will not be poorer in absolute terms. The OBR projects that growth would be 4% lower than it might otherwise have been over 15 years. No-one will notice that at all, and certainly won't be "poorer". We've just absorbed an 8.5% reduction in GDP in six months FFS.

(12-27-2020, 08:59 PM)Loanee Wrote: Let’s cut the bitterness & petty sniping, let’s list the positive outcomes of the deal & how it makes us better off, I’ll go first (everyone else feel free to contribute):

1 - blue passports


2. The abandonment of the EU's regulation obsessed precautionary principal in favour of innovation and regulatory reform - particularly in financial services.

3. The abandonment of the CAP in favour of payments based on stewardship of the environment, innovation in agricultural production and the abandonment of wholly uneconomic marginal farming.

3. Embracing tech giants and encouraging our own unicorns providing the research, tax  and regulatory environment for them to thrive.

4. Speedy trade deals with the rest of the world without being held back by the self interest of 26 other parties or the threat of a veto from Wallonia or Luxembourg.

5. Distancing ourselves from the guilt-ridden self destructive immigration policies that have debased civilised society in Germany, Sweden, Holland, Belgium and France (though admittedly Macro has finally woken up).

6. Being able to hold the government you voted for accountable for all its decisions - I'll stick my neck out now and predict that in the event the Libs, Labour & the SNP continue to fight the (lost) battles of 2016 then the Tories will be returned with a new leader in 2024 with a similar majority. I'll also wager a grand with anyone that there will be no serious movement to rejoin the EU during my lifetime.


RE: Brexit deal sorted - Logic1 - 12-28-2020

(12-28-2020, 01:03 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-28-2020, 11:17 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: In reply to Fido and to save cluttering up the page with long quoted posts -

fullfact.org finds that that "cost" (in terms of what has actually been spent and the GDP loss incurred based on pre-2016 trends) by the end of 2020 will be around £200 billion. During our time as members up until we left, our contributions will have been around £222 billion (adjusted). As such, it can reasonably be argued that Brexit has already cost in 4 years almost as much as we paid in EU subs in 47 years. This of course doesn't take into account GDP loss going forward from 2020, which will continue to be significant.

I don't think even the most ardent Brexiteer on here would argue against the point that the UK will be poorer as a result of Brexit. The £350m a week to the NHS promised by the Leave campaigned is A) not true in the first place and B) a drop in the ocean of lost revenue and costs incurred.

The people who voted for it would argue that there are other benefits that make up for this. I would disagree but thats life. It's certainly harmed my industry and cost a few hundred British jobs, including several friends. The disaster capitalists who instigated the whole thing are laughing all the way to bank however.

The UK will not be poorer in absolute terms. The OBR projects that growth would be 4% lower than it might otherwise have been over 15 years. No-one will notice that at all, and certainly won't be "poorer". We've just absorbed an 8.5% reduction in GDP in six months FFS.

(12-27-2020, 08:59 PM)Loanee Wrote: Let’s cut the bitterness & petty sniping, let’s list the positive outcomes of the deal & how it makes us better off, I’ll go first (everyone else feel free to contribute):

1 - blue passports


2. The abandonment of the EU's regulation obsessed precautionary principal in favour of innovation and regulatory reform - particularly in financial services.

3. The abandonment of the CAP in favour of payments based on stewardship of the environment, innovation in agricultural production and the abandonment of wholly uneconomic marginal farming.

3. Embracing tech giants and encouraging our own unicorns providing the research, tax  and regulatory environment for them to thrive.

4. Speedy trade deals with the rest of the world without being held back by the self interest of 26 other parties or the threat of a veto from Wallonia or Luxembourg.

5. Distancing ourselves from the guilt-ridden self destructive immigration policies that have debased civilised society in Germany, Sweden, Holland, Belgium and France (though admittedly Macro has finally woken up).

6. Being able to hold the government you voted for accountable for all its decisions - I'll stick my neck out now and predict that in the event the Libs, Labour & the SNP continue to fight the (lost) battles of 2016 then the Tories will be returned with a new leader in 2024 with a similar majority. I'll also wager a grand with anyone that there will be no serious movement to rejoin the EU during my lifetime.

You could do almost all of those things whilst in the EU and I don't remember them being discussed in detail during the referendum campaign. I thought we would have an extra 350m to spend on the NHS and immigration would fall (although, it is now higher than before).

Let's be honest, Brexit is all about making it easier for the ultra rich to avoid paying tax.


RE: Brexit deal sorted - The liquidator - 12-28-2020

You should be OK then


RE: Brexit deal sorted - Logic1 - 12-28-2020

(12-28-2020, 01:28 PM)The liquidator Wrote: You  should be OK then

I'll be fine mate, just feel sorry for the people who won't and I worry about my kids.