RE: Cummings - Protheroe - 11-15-2020
So we're agreed that Dominic Cummings actually isn't the evil genius you've all been wetting yourselves over for 12 months?
Revisionism on WBA Unofficial. Who'd have thought it?
RE: Cummings - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-15-2020
(11-15-2020, 10:53 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: (11-15-2020, 10:45 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (11-15-2020, 10:40 AM)Brentbaggie Wrote: I think there is a great deal of difference between being highly educated and intelligent. There is often no correlation between the two.
I actually think you can be both. What you omit is what agenda. Which even modern history proves can be very tyrannical indeed, in spite of intelligence or education.
I never said you couldn't be both - the word "often" I use advisedly. Boris is theoretically highly educated but, as we are led to believe, lazy and lacking attention to detail, which doesn't seem very intelligent in a Prime Minister. Corbyn went to Shrewsbury School and so was in one sense similarly highly educated, but dim as fuck with regard to understanding what might be seen as inappropriate or costly in terms of policy or appointment of personnel. Cameron - another Etonian - was arrogant enough to imagine he knew the public mood - and he didn't. Repeat, etc.
I don’t disagree with a word!
Cameron was also a serial delegator.
RE: Cummings - Derek Hardballs - 11-15-2020
(11-15-2020, 10:34 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: You didn't in fairness, but others did; while you labour other points other posters have raised, and subsequently continue to run away from.
And if it's centrist Wolves in Sheep's clothing that you wish to hold up and exemplify, look no further than Mr Blair and his administration.
Blair will mostly be remembered for Iraq - which would have followed the same inevitable course - regardless of whether it was he, John Major, or anyone else for that matter. Which is a shame, because it overshadows his modernising of a fickle, hypocritical and frankly dinosaur party - bogged down in past-struggles and the type of political oneupmanship that rendered it entirely unelectable throughout the 1980s - and after that then guiding us somehow through the erstwhile worst financial crisis in history. How strange that once his party vanished, they are back to the 1980s again, and with a fuck-load of unacceptably offensive baggage in tow.
I am a centrist through and through. Blair represented me fairly well, although not to a tee; I could see him for exactly what he was. He was the least worst, which is why he got my first vote, and not a Tory party which represents my interests far better. That doesn't mean that I will vote for them while they continue to ride roughshod over our civil liberties as they are doing. But would Sir Queer be any better? Fuck no! Not right now, at least.
Politics is devisive enough as it is, and that is precisely why I have no time for those who cannot see the other POV. And ironically, and to bring full-circle, that could well be now why Cummins is ahead of Slav in the dole queue.
I think there is a danger of mythologising Cummings abilities. He was backed to the hilt by friendly media such as the Sun, Telegraph, Mail, even TV media repeated ‘sources close to the’ without any scrutiny. Repeating verbatim lines fed to them. Without those media outlets and owners support I very much doubt his influence would have been as effective. He was a useful maverick for others world view.
His tenure within government has produced a string of poor decisions, u turns, cronyism, warring factions, a new level of lying and a complete failure or wilful decision to keep people divided. So intelligent yes but with a very limited political range.
RE: Cummings - hudds - 11-15-2020
Reading some of Cummings' musings, he appears educated and very intelligent. I am not able to gainsay some of his esoteric stuff since I don't fully understand it. He may get things wrong for all I know but he thinks about them.
He is an oddball, not being committed to a political party and contemptuous within the Leave movement of the ERG and Faragists.
He probably supports the Dings.
RE: Cummings - Protheroe - 11-15-2020
(11-15-2020, 11:18 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think there is a danger of mythologising Cummings abilities
I'm pretty sure you've spent months on here doing exactly that.
You should have bet on him being sacked, as well as shorting HBOS shares in early 2008. You're a fucking genuis Dekka.
RE: Cummings - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-15-2020
(11-15-2020, 11:18 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-15-2020, 10:34 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: You didn't in fairness, but others did; while you labour other points other posters have raised, and subsequently continue to run away from.
And if it's centrist Wolves in Sheep's clothing that you wish to hold up and exemplify, look no further than Mr Blair and his administration.
Blair will mostly be remembered for Iraq - which would have followed the same inevitable course - regardless of whether it was he, John Major, or anyone else for that matter. Which is a shame, because it overshadows his modernising of a fickle, hypocritical and frankly dinosaur party - bogged down in past-struggles and the type of political oneupmanship that rendered it entirely unelectable throughout the 1980s - and after that then guiding us somehow through the erstwhile worst financial crisis in history. How strange that once his party vanished, they are back to the 1980s again, and with a fuck-load of unacceptably offensive baggage in tow.
I am a centrist through and through. Blair represented me fairly well, although not to a tee; I could see him for exactly what he was. He was the least worst, which is why he got my first vote, and not a Tory party which represents my interests far better. That doesn't mean that I will vote for them while they continue to ride roughshod over our civil liberties as they are doing. But would Sir Queer be any better? Fuck no! Not right now, at least.
Politics is devisive enough as it is, and that is precisely why I have no time for those who cannot see the other POV. And ironically, and to bring full-circle, that could well be now why Cummins is ahead of Slav in the dole queue.
I think there is a danger of mythologising Cummings abilities. He was backed to the hilt by friendly media such as the Sun, Telegraph, Mail, even TV media repeated ‘sources close to the’ without any scrutiny. Repeating verbatim lines fed to them. Without those media outlets and owners support I very much doubt his influence would have been as effective. He was a useful maverick for others world view.
His tenure within government has produced a string of poor decisions, u turns, cronyism, warring factions, a new level of lying and a complete failure or wilful decision to keep people divided. So intelligent yes but with a very limited political range.
He was pivotal (if you believe the papers you cite, but let's come back to that) in influencing the Brexit vote, and then getting it moving again after May had u-turned us into the ground. Once again, mythologising is a strong word that you are alleging of people who haven't done that. Just said that he is bright and influential, and that Boris clearly recognised that which is why he wasn't sacked when he should have been. Few said otherwise. I wasn't one of them. Go back and check if you like.
Polarising the argument doesn't make you sound any more assured of your standpoint. Which is descending into tribalism now. I have offered many exampes of how and why I can and can't abide by either side, but can make an informed, non-black, non-white judgement. It's a shame that you can't, because clearly it bothers you enough to look a little silly over.
And you can't exactly blame the papers for delivering the message. That's a little like blaming MTV for a music video you don't like. It is what it is, always has been and always will thus be.
RE: Cummings - Derek Hardballs - 11-15-2020
(11-15-2020, 11:27 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: (11-15-2020, 11:18 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (11-15-2020, 10:34 AM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: You didn't in fairness, but others did; while you labour other points other posters have raised, and subsequently continue to run away from.
And if it's centrist Wolves in Sheep's clothing that you wish to hold up and exemplify, look no further than Mr Blair and his administration.
Blair will mostly be remembered for Iraq - which would have followed the same inevitable course - regardless of whether it was he, John Major, or anyone else for that matter. Which is a shame, because it overshadows his modernising of a fickle, hypocritical and frankly dinosaur party - bogged down in past-struggles and the type of political oneupmanship that rendered it entirely unelectable throughout the 1980s - and after that then guiding us somehow through the erstwhile worst financial crisis in history. How strange that once his party vanished, they are back to the 1980s again, and with a fuck-load of unacceptably offensive baggage in tow.
I am a centrist through and through. Blair represented me fairly well, although not to a tee; I could see him for exactly what he was. He was the least worst, which is why he got my first vote, and not a Tory party which represents my interests far better. That doesn't mean that I will vote for them while they continue to ride roughshod over our civil liberties as they are doing. But would Sir Queer be any better? Fuck no! Not right now, at least.
Politics is devisive enough as it is, and that is precisely why I have no time for those who cannot see the other POV. And ironically, and to bring full-circle, that could well be now why Cummins is ahead of Slav in the dole queue.
I think there is a danger of mythologising Cummings abilities. He was backed to the hilt by friendly media such as the Sun, Telegraph, Mail, even TV media repeated ‘sources close to the’ without any scrutiny. Repeating verbatim lines fed to them. Without those media outlets and owners support I very much doubt his influence would have been as effective. He was a useful maverick for others world view.
His tenure within government has produced a string of poor decisions, u turns, cronyism, warring factions, a new level of lying and a complete failure or wilful decision to keep people divided. So intelligent yes but with a very limited political range.
He was pivotal (if you believe the papers you cite, but let's come back to that) in influencing the Brexit vote, and then getting it moving again after May had u-turned us into the ground. Once again, mythologising is a strong word that you are alleging of people who haven't done that. Just said that he is bright and influential, and that Boris clearly recognised that which is why he wasn't sacked when he should have been.
Polarising the argument doesn't make you sound any more assured of your standpoint. Which is descending into tribalism now. I have offered many exampes of how and why I can and can't abide by either side, but can make an informed, non-lback no-white judgement. It's a shame that you can't, because clearly it bothers you enough to look a little silly over.
And you can't exactly blame the papers for delivering the message. that's a bit like blaming MTV for a music video you don't like. It is what it is.
Tribalism? What have I said that is tribal in reply to you?
Mythologising, isn’t a strong word it’s simply suggesting that his influence should not be seen in isolation to what was going on around him be that the press or piss poor opposition.
The press aren’t neutral as well you know and far from deliver the meaaage they amplified and reinforced it. Delivering the message is simply client journalism without any scrutiny.
He’s got exceptional but limited skills perhaps he could be in a new Taken film.
(11-15-2020, 11:21 AM)Protheroe Wrote: (11-15-2020, 11:18 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I think there is a danger of mythologising Cummings abilities
I'm pretty sure you've spent months on here doing exactly that.
You should have bet on him being sacked, as well as shorting HBOS shares in early 2008. You're a fucking genuis Dekka.
Oh I don’t think what I said about him was a myth. I have always placed his role as a central character in Brexit (Ref and Election intrinsically linked). It takes exceptional ability to feck things up as much as we have for the last few years. Beanie hats off to him.
RE: Cummings - HawkingsHalfpint - 11-15-2020
Tribalism is when you beat the same drum when you don't know, understand (or in some cases, even like) the rhythm. Admittedly that goes on your other replies to other topics I've had limited involvement with. If that's unfair within the context and confines of this particular discourse, then I apologise for that; but I think you know what I'm taking about (I'm not the only one to say it).
Anyway, Cummins is a Roger character a la Lord of the Flies, no different to Mandy in many respects; just far less gifted (but gifted nonetheless as his CV shows). And you can't be as controversial and arrogant as he has been, and walk between the raindrops forever. But he will be back.
And the press is the press. It will dance to its paymasters and has done since 2010. It needs what they feed, just as they make use of its channels to communicate. What you choose to believe and to subscribe to from this, however, is entirely down to the individual.
BTW the film should be called Taken Up the Arse. Starring Bojo as whatshisface. He certainly has enough sprogs for Cummins to kidnap.
RE: Cummings - bradesbaggie - 11-15-2020
Cummings wanted us to crash out of the EU with no trade deal. Trump losing has put a UK/US deal on the long finger.
Johnson is going to have to do a deal with the EU and Cummings didn't like that. His walking out of No10 with the box was a signal to the ERG that their mad policies were crumbling.
RE: Cummings - bradesbaggie - 11-15-2020
Cummings wanted us to crash out of the EU with no trade deal. Trump losing has put a UK/US deal on the long finger.
Johnson is going to have to do a deal with the EU and Cummings didn't like that. His walking out of No10 with the box was a signal to the ERG that their mad policies were crumbling.
|