WBAUnofficial
When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: When will the lockdown get more strict?? (/showthread.php?tid=9860)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Derek Hardballs - 04-11-2020

Whilst we all get mad at those not abiding by the governments instructions we do seem to be blindly ignoring or worse accepting the following:

The lack of PPE equipment for Dr’s, Nurses, Care staff, those working in supermarkets, deliveries, transport

The failure up until now to test people in anywhere near the required number

The failure to close airports for anything other than repatriation

The failure to quarantine / test people entering the country


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-11-2020

(04-11-2020, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whilst we all get mad at those not abiding by the governments instructions we do seem to be blindly ignoring or worse accepting the following:

The lack of PPE equipment for Dr’s, Nurses, Care staff, those working in supermarkets, deliveries, transport

The failure up until now to test people in anywhere near the required number

The failure to close airports for anything other than repatriation

The failure to quarantine / test people entering the country

I agree entirely DH. Half-hearted, half-baked approach by the government. It's not PC to question anything they do.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Derek Hardballs - 04-11-2020

(04-11-2020, 09:19 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-11-2020, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whilst we all get mad at those not abiding by the governments instructions we do seem to be blindly ignoring or worse accepting the following:

The lack of PPE equipment for Dr’s, Nurses, Care staff, those working in supermarkets, deliveries, transport

The failure up until now to test people in anywhere near the required number

The failure to close airports for anything other than repatriation

The failure to quarantine / test people entering the country

I agree entirely DH. Half-hearted, half-baked approach by the government. It's not PC to question anything they do.

Anyone who asks reasonable questions is branded unhelpful at best at worst a traitor. By not asking these questions doesn’t solve the problems, perhaps scrutiny concentrates minds to solve them?


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Fulham Fallout - 04-11-2020

(04-11-2020, 09:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Whilst we all get mad at those not abiding by the governments instructions we do seem to be blindly ignoring or worse accepting the following:

The lack of PPE equipment for Dr’s, Nurses, Care staff, those working in supermarkets, deliveries, transport

The failure up until now to test people in anywhere near the required number

The failure to close airports for anything other than repatriation

The failure to quarantine / test people entering the country

You forgot to add the decision to adopt herd immunity in the first instance when every other country affected had gone for a lockdown approach.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - fuzzbox - 04-11-2020

There is no chance we can contain this virus. It's debatable whether we should even try. We can only ensure we give ourselves the best chance possible of giving effective care to those seriously affected. Which I think is what we are trying to do. 

We can't just hope there will be a vaccine. There probably will be, but we don't know that for certain and we should plan accordingly. The 'herd' approach is the only sustainable way - at the moment - to move forward. The new evidence of a higher than expected number of asymptomatic carriers makes this even more certain. 

The mistake was to adopt this approach and ignore everything else. It should have been the long term aim whilst still being mindful of short term resources.

I think that's what they are now trying to do (A bit late, which I think is accepted opinion)

The lockdown and herd immunity is not an either/or decision. They are both meant to work together. One for the short term and one for the long term.

More controversially, it means people breaking the 'lockdown' isn't an absolute disaster. It was always expected and was factored in. The government isn't naive enough to think there isn't a minority of selfish or stupid idiots in our community. As long as it's a minority, it's more irritating to the rest of us than a disaster that they continue to flout the laws. It's not about trying to stop the spread - they can't - they're just trying to slow it. So if the majority obey, the strategy is working.

Let's face it, we're going to have to go back to work regardless of whether the virus has run its course. The country can't afford to keep subsidising us and the gilt market is already becoming expensive. If the money stops, the death caused by that will dwarf the deaths caused by the virus.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Derek Hardballs - 04-11-2020

(04-11-2020, 10:37 AM)fuzzbox Wrote: There is no chance we can contain this virus. It's debatable whether we should even try. We can only ensure we give ourselves the best chance possible of giving effective care to those seriously affected. Which I think is what we are trying to do. 

We can't just hope there will be a vaccine. There probably will be, but we don't know that for certain and we should plan accordingly. The 'herd' approach is the only sustainable way - at the moment - to move forward. The new evidence of asymptomatic carriers makes this even more certain. 

The mistake was to adopt this approach and ignore everything else. It should have been the long term aim whilst still being mindful of short term resources.

I think that's what they are now trying to do (A bit late, in my opinion)

The lockdown and herd immunity is not an either/or decision. They are both meant to work together. One for the short term and one for the long term.

More controversially, it means people breaking the 'lockdown' isn't an absolute disaster. It was always expected and was factored in. The government isn't naive enough to think there isn't a minority of selfish or stupid idiots in our community. As long as it's a minority, it's more irritating to the rest of us than a disaster that they continue to flout the laws. It's not about trying to stop the spread - they can't - they're just trying to slow it. So if the majority obey, the strategy is working.

Let's face it, we're going to have to go back to work regardless of whether the virus has run its course. The country can't afford to keep subsidising us and the gilt market is already becoming expensive. If the money stops, the death caused by that will dwarf the deaths caused by the virus.

Herd immunity only works with a vaccine otherwise you’ll looking at hundreds of thousands of deaths in the U.K. We can’t (hmm) just letting it rip through the population

Herd Immunity explanation


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - fuzzbox - 04-11-2020

(04-11-2020, 10:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Herd immunity only works with a vaccine otherwise you’ll looking at hundreds of thousands of deaths in the U.K. We can’t (hmm) just letting it rip through the population

Herd Immunity explanation

You're suggesting herd immunity and exclusion are an either/or question. They're not. Therefore, the death toll you're headlining with is just not true.

We haven't got a vaccine and we don't know for sure we ever will have. What happens if it mutates quicker and more often than we hope? Even if we develop a 'vaccine' it will probably not prevent infection, but will reduce the severity to suffers - rather like the flu virus. There will still be deaths, especially among the vulnerable, and the virus will continue to spread.

Whichever way, it's not definite (although likely) we'll be able to develop any sort of vaccine, so we need a plan in case.

How are you realistically going to contain the virus inside the short time we have until the money runs out? You know that people will flout the rules and that is going to get more common as time goes on. Containment to the point of extinction is unlikely to work. Especially if the amount of asymptomatic carriers proves to be correct.

It's not about 'letting it rip' through the population, it's about focusing on giving the best possible care to the most serious sufferers. 
But consider your alternative. There's absolutely no evidence that 'lock-down' by itself can remove a virus once it's got to this level. It's never been done. So why are we doing it?

It's not about eradicating the virus, it's about giving us breathing time to bring down the death rate.

No solution is 'brilliant' and there will be victims, but we do need to do something. Relying on 'lock-down' , which has never worked before, whilst hoping a vaccine might be found is just doing nothing. 

You're painting lock-down as the caring approach and herd immunity as the callous approach. I don't agree with this hypothesis.

In the end, lock down with a view to waiting for virus extinction will fail and still have the same result - relying on 'herd immunity'.

All we can do is slow the growth in the short term so we can care for the serious sufferers. Which is what we are doing. Anything other solution is just fantasy.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - backsidebaggie - 04-11-2020

(04-11-2020, 11:17 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-11-2020, 10:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Herd immunity only works with a vaccine otherwise you’ll looking at hundreds of thousands of deaths in the U.K. We can’t (hmm) just letting it rip through the population

Herd Immunity explanation

You're suggesting herd immunity and exclusion are an either/or question. They're not. Therefore, the death toll you're headlining with is just not true.

We haven't got a vaccine and we don't know for sure we ever will have. What happens if it mutates quicker and more often than we hope? Even if we develop a 'vaccine' it will probably not prevent infection, but will reduce the severity to suffers - rather like the flu virus. There will still be deaths, especially among the vulnerable, and the virus will continue to spread.

Whichever way, it's not definite (although likely) we'll be able to develop any sort of vaccine, so we need a plan in case.

How are you realistically going to contain the virus inside the short time we have until the money runs out? You know that people will flout the rules and that is going to get more common as time goes on. Containment to the point of extinction is unlikely to work. Especially if the amount of asymptomatic carriers proves to be correct.

It's not about 'letting it rip' through the population, it's about focusing on giving the best possible care to the most serious sufferers. 
But consider your alternative. There's absolutely no evidence that 'lock-down' by itself can remove a virus once it's got to this level. It's never been done. So why are we doing it?

It's not about eradicating the virus, it's about giving us breathing time to bring down the death rate.

No solution is 'brilliant' and there will be victims, but we do need to do something. Relying on 'lock-down' , which has never worked before, whilst hoping a vaccine might be found is just doing nothing. 

You're painting lock-down as the caring approach and herd immunity as the callous approach. I don't agree with this hypothesis.

In the end, lock down with a view to waiting for virus extinction will fail and still have the same result - relying on 'herd immunity'.

All we can do is slow the growth in the short term so we can care for the serious sufferers. Which is what we are doing. Anything other solution is just fantasy.

Indeed. Lockdown isn’t about getting rid of the virus, it’s about managing it to ensure the uk can cope with numbers seriously ill in terms of hospital beds and intensive care. It will go through the population, and herd immunity then happens naturally. This is different from a herd immunity ‘plan’ from the start.

You’re right that containment to exclusion is not possible. I’m afraid anyone who thinks that is going to be disappointed. The lockdown and measures taken are about managing it.

This is a good article explaining the death rates. I’m not making light of things, but the fact is the death numbers are those dying with corona, not of corona. This article explains the context quite well.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-51979654


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - JOK - 04-11-2020

Ref; the ‘question’ of PPE supply. Here is an answer in a good article from a news source some on here swear by, so must be notable.

“Across the world, frontline medical staff are clamoring for face masks and other personal protective equipment (PPE). Even as China, the world’s main supplier, comes back onstream, companies around the globe are battling a host of obstacles, from illness to freight costs, from hoarding to a supply squeeze on filter fabric.”

“There are two main kinds of mask: ... the higher-standard respirators, often known by designations such as N95 or FFP (“filtering facepiece”), which are meant for medical procedures to protect workers from the droplets through which the virus spreads.
Demand for all of them has skyrocketed.”
““Trying to find a supplier who hasn’t sold out for the next six months is hard,” said Christopher Dobbing, the CEO and founder of Cambridge Mask Co., a small producer in Britain.”
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-health-coronavirus-masks-insight/as-virus-explodes-world-races-to-mask-up-idUSKBN21C2PE

GENEVA (REUTERS) -  “Demand for masks, gowns, gloves and other protective gear has risen up to 100-fold and prices have soared due to the China coronavirus, producing a “severe” disruption in global supply, the World Health Organisation (WHO) chief said...”

Another couple Of reports here:
WHO. World  shortage of PPE. Need for a 40% increase in manufacture.
https://www.who.int/news-room/detail/03-03-2020-shortage-of-personal-protective-equipment-endangering-health-workers-worldwide

“Before this pandemic, for instance, China produced approximately half the world’s face masks. As the infection spread across China, their exports came to a halt.”
https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMp2006141

Can we not accept this is not an easy or simple problem to solve? And it can’t be solved quickly by car seat manufacturers or fashion houses as medical PPE has to be regulated and to a high standard to be effective.
Or are we saying all government ministers, top civil servants, procurement officers and logistic experts are all either shambolically inefficient or colluding in extreme callousness? I, for one, do not believe, for one one minute, that anyone is willingly or wilfully “accepting the lack” (actually it’s a shortage) of PPE for our NHS staff.


RE: When will the lockdown get more strict?? - Derek Hardballs - 04-11-2020

(04-11-2020, 11:17 AM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(04-11-2020, 10:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Herd immunity only works with a vaccine otherwise you’ll looking at hundreds of thousands of deaths in the U.K. We can’t (hmm) just letting it rip through the population

Herd Immunity explanation

You're suggesting herd immunity and exclusion are an either/or question. They're not. Therefore, the death toll you're headlining with is just not true.

We haven't got a vaccine and we don't know for sure we ever will have. What happens if it mutates quicker and more often than we hope? Even if we develop a 'vaccine' it will probably not prevent infection, but will reduce the severity to suffers - rather like the flu virus. There will still be deaths, especially among the vulnerable, and the virus will continue to spread.

Whichever way, it's not definite (although likely) we'll be able to develop any sort of vaccine, so we need a plan in case.

How are you realistically going to contain the virus inside the short time we have until the money runs out? You know that people will flout the rules and that is going to get more common as time goes on. Containment to the point of extinction is unlikely to work. Especially if the amount of asymptomatic carriers proves to be correct.

It's not about 'letting it rip' through the population, it's about focusing on giving the best possible care to the most serious sufferers. 
But consider your alternative. There's absolutely no evidence that 'lock-down' by itself can remove a virus once it's got to this level. It's never been done. So why are we doing it?

It's not about eradicating the virus, it's about giving us breathing time to bring down the death rate.

No solution is 'brilliant' and there will be victims, but we do need to do something. Relying on 'lock-down' , which has never worked before, whilst hoping a vaccine might be found is just doing nothing. 

You're painting lock-down as the caring approach and herd immunity as the callous approach. I don't agree with this hypothesis.

In the end, lock down with a view to waiting for virus extinction will fail and still have the same result - relying on 'herd immunity'.

All we can do is slow the growth in the short term so we can care for the serious sufferers. Which is what we are doing. Anything other solution is just fantasy.

Herd immunity is in conjunction with a vaccine. It’s not just let everyone get it over a prolonged period and hope for the best. 

My figures are not made up they were what was predicted by the same experts modelling that the government has been following. That’s one of the reasons they changed tack to lock down (debatable) as the death toll was predicted to be extremely high. 

I understand that the measures are to enable the NHS to cope and that the virus isn’t going away but numbers of infections should be minimised to the maximum over an extended period. Not just a shrug of the shoulders and say oh well we’ve got enough capacity in staff and ventilators now everyone back to work for example. 

Barely a week ago people were sneering (the usual ones) at Spain and Italy’s approach and we are on course to be worse hit than them. So at some point questions should be asked as to our approach.