WBAUnofficial
The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... (/showthread.php?tid=6356)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - Malcolm Tucker - 09-02-2019

(09-02-2019, 07:52 AM)Cunningham1979 Wrote: Very good shot stopper
Excellent distribution 

Wretched on crosses
Low on confidence 

The fact remains that SJ has cost us more points this season that he has gained. In judging him as a Championship goalkeeper, NOTHING else matters. I would stick with him for now but he is one more error away from a spell out of the firing line. There is a decent keeper in there but his confidence must be very low

It's not a fact at all. He was partly to blame for the Forest goal, as well as being at fault for the second on Saturday. These two goals have cost us a grand total of zero points. 

People trying to blame him for the Millwall goal are off their heads. The ball went past the far post over the height of the crossbar. There's barely a keeper on the planet who could've claimed that.

He's also saved a penalty at Derby, which gained us a point....


RE: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - Midget In A Pinstripe Suit - 09-02-2019

(09-02-2019, 08:46 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(09-02-2019, 07:52 AM)Cunningham1979 Wrote: Very good shot stopper
Excellent distribution 

Wretched on crosses
Low on confidence 

The fact remains that SJ has cost us more points this season that he has gained. In judging him as a Championship goalkeeper, NOTHING else matters. I would stick with him for now but he is one more error away from a spell out of the firing line. There is a decent keeper in there but his confidence must be very low

It's not a fact at all. He was partly to blame for the Forest goal, as well as being at fault for the second on Saturday. These two goals have cost us a grand total of zero points. 

People trying to blame him for the Millwall goal are off their heads. The ball went past the far post over the height of the crossbar. There's barely a keeper on the planet who could've claimed that.

He's also saved a penalty at Derby, which gained us a point....

Quite right. Some of the ways people are managing to blame him for anything are staggering.


RE: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - backsidebaggie - 09-02-2019

I think Bilic thinks he's definitely our number 1 and isn't even close to dropping him. His penalty record is excellent, and despite those looking for faults every game, he only makes the odd cock up, like most goalies. He hasn't cost us points this season, he's gained us one at Derby with the pen save, and I think he'd have to repeat saturday's error about 6 times in the next 10 games to get dropped, which isn't going to happen.


RE: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - Super_Slav - 09-02-2019

(09-02-2019, 12:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I think Bilic thinks he's definitely our number 1 and isn't even close to dropping him. His penalty record is excellent, and despite those looking for faults every game, he only makes the odd cock up, like most goalies. He hasn't cost us points this season, he's gained us one at Derby with the pen save, and I think he'd have to repeat saturday's error about 6 times in the next 10 games to get dropped, which isn't going to happen.

Agree.

I believe privately Bilic doesn’t quite understand why Johnstone is heavily criticised by our fanbase. See Bilic reaction on BBC WM pre match v Blackburn when told many fans blamed Johnstone for the Reading goal.


RE: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - oldun - 09-02-2019

(09-02-2019, 12:13 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote: I think Bilic thinks he's definitely our number 1 and isn't even close to dropping him. His penalty record is excellent, and despite those looking for faults every game, he only makes the odd cock up, like most goalies. He hasn't cost us points this season, he's gained us one at Derby with the pen save, and I think he'd have to repeat saturday's error about 6 times in the next 10 games to get dropped, which isn't going to happen.

Sounds like he's  a marmite gk, we are not going to agree on him, so Slavin will decide


RE: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - Super_Slav - 09-02-2019

The divide in the fan base regarding Johnstone is similar to when we had Scott Carson


RE: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - Fall Out Boy - 09-02-2019

When we signed him, I wished we'd got Henderson from United instead. He's gone to Sheffield United and done very well.

I don't think Johnstone is a bad keeper on the whole; I just think he's no Ben Foster, or even a Russell Hoult, and for the money we spent we could have done much better.


RE: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - Tom Joad - 09-02-2019

(09-02-2019, 12:32 PM)Super_Slav Wrote: The divide in the fan base regarding Johnstone is similar to when we had Scott Carson

TBF, I think we all agreed on that one.


RE: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - Duffers - 09-02-2019

(09-02-2019, 12:32 PM)Fall Out Boy Wrote: When we signed him, I wished we'd got Henderson from United instead. He's gone to Sheffield United and done very well.

I don't think Johnstone is a bad keeper on the whole; I just think he's no Ben Foster, or even a Russell Hoult, and for the money we spent we could have done much better.

Henderson is only on loan at Sheffield United.


RE: The best criticism of Johnstone I've heard so far... - SW4Baggie - 09-02-2019

(09-02-2019, 12:32 PM)Fall Out Boy Wrote: When we signed him, I wished we'd got Henderson from United instead. He's gone to Sheffield United and done very well.

I don't think Johnstone is a bad keeper on the whole; I just think he's no Ben Foster, or even a Russell Hoult, and for the money we spent we could have done much better.

I think the money is probably a very good point. 

We paid £6m for Johnstone, and the fact there aren't many clubs in this division with a £6m+ keeper means he will always get a lot more stick than say Bond or Al-Habsi will given they were free transfers.

It's also worth noting that SJ has had the equivalent of 3 full seasons' games at this level, as well as a couple seasons worth in League One, which means a lot of the basic errors we see should have been ironed out of his game, or at least show some improvement.