WBAUnofficial
The Current Squad Thread - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: The Current Squad Thread (/showthread.php?tid=5116)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: The Current Squad Thread - Ed Hopper - 07-24-2019

(07-24-2019, 08:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-24-2019, 07:52 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Why are people still going on about Gayle? Look at the numbers. We had him on loan last season. One season’s wages, subsidised by Newcastle, costing us around £30k/week so around £1.5m.  

He’s on £55k/week at Newcastle and he’s not going to give that up. A 4-year contract would cost £10m in wages plus £15m to buy him.  That’s £25m it, amortised over 4 years, £6.25m per annum, or £120k/week, which is 4 times what he cost us last season with no long term risk.

Unless Newcastle are willing to send him out on loan again (and it seems very unlikely that they would), then Gayle is completely unaffordable to us and to just about every Championship club.

It’s not happening.  Move on.

Agree completely.

No doubt that Gayle from a football perspective is a perfect fit for us this season.

But unless we can take him on loan again (and I have no idea on the length of his current contract with Newastle), the longer term outcomes of buying Gayle outweigh the short term gains.

Unfortunately for Gayle he seems to be one of those players who are not quite good enough for the premiership but are excellent in the championship. And with him this season, entering his 30s, which club in the championship, can afford to take him on permanently - a player who may get you up but is probably not good enough to keep you there.
I’m surprised a bigger team haven’t gone for Gayle. If he was playing for a Man U or similar he’d excel with his movement and finishing, plus he’s get more chances. Playing in the perm for palace and the toon probably doesn’t afford you that many chances


RE: The Current Squad Thread - Shabby Russian - 07-24-2019

(07-24-2019, 08:12 AM)Ed Hopper Wrote:
(07-24-2019, 08:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(07-24-2019, 07:52 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Why are people still going on about Gayle? Look at the numbers. We had him on loan last season. One season’s wages, subsidised by Newcastle, costing us around £30k/week so around £1.5m.  

He’s on £55k/week at Newcastle and he’s not going to give that up. A 4-year contract would cost £10m in wages plus £15m to buy him.  That’s £25m it, amortised over 4 years, £6.25m per annum, or £120k/week, which is 4 times what he cost us last season with no long term risk.

Unless Newcastle are willing to send him out on loan again (and it seems very unlikely that they would), then Gayle is completely unaffordable to us and to just about every Championship club.

It’s not happening.  Move on.

Agree completely.

No doubt that Gayle from a football perspective is a perfect fit for us this season.

But unless we can take him on loan again (and I have no idea on the length of his current contract with Newastle), the longer term outcomes of buying Gayle outweigh the short term gains.

Unfortunately for Gayle he seems to be one of those players who are not quite good enough for the premiership but are excellent in the championship. And with him this season, entering his 30s, which club in the championship, can afford to take him on permanently - a player who may get you up but is probably not good enough to keep you there.
I’m surprised a bigger team haven’t gone for Gayle. If he was playing for a Man U or similar he’d excel with his movement and finishing, plus he’s get more chances. Playing in the perm for palace and the toon probably doesn’t afford you that many chances

I suppose they may take the view that at the highest level, good defenders can keep Gayle quiet - he just might not be good enough.


RE: The Current Squad Thread - Dumbo - 07-24-2019

(07-24-2019, 08:12 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(07-24-2019, 08:01 AM)TartanRug Wrote:
(07-24-2019, 07:09 AM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(06-19-2019, 05:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: So our squad as it stands:

GK - Johnstone, Bond

RB - Furlong, Nyom

CB - Hegazi, Bartley, Ajayi, O’Shea

LB - Gibbs, Townsend

CM - Livermore, Brunt, Field, Harper

RM/LM/ARM/ALM/ACM - HRK, Phillips, Burke, Edwards, Leko, Krovinovic

FW - Zohore

So currently our (debatable) first team (excluding those players leaving) is:

Johnstone

Furlong
Hegazi
Ajayi
Gibbs

Livermore
Brunt

Edwards
Krovinovic
Phillips

Zohore


Bench: Bond, Townsend, Bartley, Field, Harper, HRK, Burke

This squad, as it stands would struggle for a top half finish, plenty of quality and quantity still required. 5 or 6 still required with probably 4 of those going straight into the starting XI as a minimum.

Agreed, still far too limited goal threat from that side.

Lack of goals is definitely still an issue.

Plus we really can’t be going into another season with Livermore/Brunt as our starting MCs...

Lack of goals is an issue but CM is not far off.

Livermore, Harper, Ajai, Field, Brunt, Krov….plus it's obvious Bilic wants another one, hence the Sawyers bid.


RE: The Current Squad Thread - boingingbaggie - 07-24-2019

No no no no to Brunt starting. Please.

He's been a great player for us but its time to move on, particularly in central midfield. He'll play a part as a squad player but shouldn't be anything more IMO


RE: The Current Squad Thread - Duffers - 07-24-2019

I’d imagine Sawyers and either Harper or Livermore would be the starting two in central midfield.


RE: The Current Squad Thread - SW4Baggie - 07-24-2019

I think I’d rather us go all out for Gayle, than bring 2 strikers in on reflection.

We’d then have to give Edwards / Burke game time, which could well be the making of them. Edwards is ready IMO and needs to be given opportunities.

No one had heard of Dan James this time last season, but after being pressed into action, hes now at United. Not saying Edwards will become a £20m player overnight, but we’ll never know whilst he’s 5th choice.


RE: The Current Squad Thread - Remi_Moses - 07-24-2019

The game appeared to have developed an opinion that players are over the hill at 30 which is a shame. If Gayle was 2 years younger he would be ideal. I'm not so sure it's as black and white as many think it is. Barry did OK for us Ronaldo still and Messi are no spring chickens either. Are we going to spend the same amount of money on 2 forwards that's really the question.


RE: The Current Squad Thread - EastMidsBaggie - 07-24-2019

Really look light on goals and forwards- need a statement signing in that area to push us into real contention.


RE: The Current Squad Thread - Pragmatist - 07-24-2019

(07-24-2019, 08:47 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The game appeared to have developed an opinion that players are over the hill at 30 which is a shame. If Gayle was 2 years younger he would be ideal. I'm not so sure it's as black and white as many think it is. Barry did OK for us Ronaldo still and Messi are no spring chickens either. Are we going to spend the same amount of money on 2 forwards that's really the question.

I’m not sure that’s the issue. I agree with you that many players over 30 have still got a lot to offer, especially with modern medical standards in football. 

The issue is purely financial. If you buy a 25 year old on a 4-year contract for £15m, there is every chance that you will get that money back (give or take a bit) when selling the player at 28 or 29. There is therefore unlikely to be a loss on the transfer fee outlay.  But if you buy a 30 year old for £15m then there will be no resale value, and therefore the entire £15m outlay is not recoverable. That’s £3.75m a year lost.  All this of course on top of the wages (the same in both instances).

That’s why buying Gayle would be financial madness unless Newcastle were virtually giving him
away, and that’s why Maupay at 22 would be massively better value.

Take the transfer fee out of the equation and I suspect we could afford Gayle’s wages.  Sadly he’s not available on a free transfer and as he was quite late into the game he can’t be blamed for not wanting to take a pay cut.

It is possible as the transfer window nears its closing date that Newcastle might do a reduced deal, pay off his contract etc allowing him to go for less and earn less, but we can’t afford to wait and take that gamble. Rest assured that we’d be competing with other clubs if those circumstances arose!


RE: The Current Squad Thread - Remi_Moses - 07-24-2019

(07-24-2019, 09:19 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(07-24-2019, 08:47 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: The game appeared to have developed an opinion that players are over the hill at 30 which is a shame. If Gayle was 2 years younger he would be ideal. I'm not so sure it's as black and white as many think it is. Barry did OK for us Ronaldo still and Messi are no spring chickens either. Are we going to spend the same amount of money on 2 forwards that's really the question.

I’m not sure that’s the issue. I agree with you that many players over 30 have still got a lot to offer, especially with modern medical standards in football. 

The issue is purely financial. If you buy a 25 year old on a 4-year contract for £15m, there is every chance that you will get that money back (give or take a bit) when selling the player at 28 or 29. There is therefore unlikely to be a loss on the transfer fee outlay.  But if you buy a 30 year old for £15m then there will be no resale value, and therefore the entire £15m outlay is not recoverable. That’s £3.75m a year lost.  All this of course on top of the wages (the same in both instances).

That’s why buying Gayle would be financial madness unless Newcastle were virtually giving him
away, and that’s why Maupay at 22 would be massively better value.

Take the transfer fee out of the equation and I suspect we could afford Gayle’s wages.  Sadly he’s not available on a free transfer and as he was quite late into the game he can’t be blamed for not wanting to take a pay cut.

It is possible as the transfer window nears its closing date that Newcastle might do a reduced deal, pay off his contract etc allowing him to go for less and earn less, but we can’t afford to wait and take that gamble. Rest assured that we’d be competing with other clubs if those circumstances arose!

Agreed and Maupay would be better long term value. 
One thing is for sure we sort of agree on is we need a player who is going to score 25 goals.
I'm surprised Bilic hasn't gone in for a few more unknown gems? Filip does looks the pick of our new signings atm.