![]() |
|
Unsurprising revelations... - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Unsurprising revelations... (/showthread.php?tid=42142) |
RE: Unsurprising revelations... - Protheroe - 07-20-2026 (07-20-2026, 01:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So you’re now arguing that the hundreds of beds lost and the deficit that hospices are facing is just for marketing and lobbying reasons. According to Proth this is just ‘marketing’ No Dekka those pressures are real and felt across the health and care sector. It would be lovely to do more of this sterling work. However, you're not telling me where the money is coming from because you never do. You won't enter into a conversation about whether any extra funding should go to say, disabled children's services rather than palliative care for the elderly because you never do. I'm not boasting about what I do for this or any other cause, I'm explaining that I put my money and time where my mouth is (as does the rest of my family) - do you? RE: Unsurprising revelations... - Paddock - 07-21-2026 (07-20-2026, 01:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm not boasting about what I do for this or any other cause, I'm explaining that I put my money and time where my mouth is (as does the rest of my family) - do you? You appear to put most of your time into this forum. How to continuously move away from uncomfortable topics onto safer ground until everyone else gives up out of the sheer pointlessness of it all. Repeat ad-infinitum without the faintest hint of self-awareness. Alfred Adler would have had a field day. As a regular reader of these threads, I normally observe your comments with wry amusement, not for anything you have said, but for what they reveal about the underlying psyche. I am not usually inclined to comment but, since this is a topic of particular importance to me, one in which I have considerable experience - until recently I was one of the “voluntary individuals” (we tend to refer to ourselves as ‘volunteers’) - and since I find your comments particularly sickening……. The source of funding is not “the founding principle” of the hospice movement; it is not even a founding principle. You appear to be projecting your own ideological beliefs (proving post #16) onto an organisation which has no such beliefs. It is your own bullshit, which you have attempted to establish as fact and used for petty point scoring against other posters. A decent person might apologise to those posters….you? Nobody will be surprised to learn that the founding principles of the hospice movement relate to the holistic management of ‘total pain’. How they were originally funded is irrelevant to their principles, then and now. We have ‘learned’ from you that hospices are “perfectly well funded by voluntary donations” HOORAH! whilst simultaneously “deficits are common, capacity can often be cut” BOO! Students of your work will notice something of a paradox, as though your diatribe “lacks intellectual consistency and rigour.” You have avoided addressing the very pertinent link posted by Derek, which is rather revealing, since it contains facts which contradict your false narrative that charitable donations are a sufficient source of funding. In addition to those closed beds, and vastly reduced hospice-at-home visits, hospices are closing other services across the country. Until recently, I worked in a hospice. I no longer do so because the building in which those multiple, mostly voluntary services were provided is no longer affordable. Counselling for the terminally ill CLOSED, counselling for the bereaved CLOSED, peer support groups CLOSED, social activities for the ill and their carers CLOSED, complementary therapy CLOSED – the list goes on. I am sure my colleagues, who can no longer provide those voluntary services, and the smaller number of people who have lost paid employment, would be fascinated by your insightful comments. No doubt too, the former recipients of those services, suffering with cancer, Alzheimer’s, PSP, Huntingtons and a host of other conditions will be compensated for their loss by the knowledge that they are helping to preserve “the founding principle”. Discovered your lack of humanity yet? Your position has moved all over the place to a point where it seems you agree that hospices are not, after all, “perfectly well funded” but to deflect from being wrong you have created a straw man argument about state control which precisely nobody has asked for nor suggested. It is as transparent as it is pathetic. In addition, you demand to know where the money will come from - a nice safe haven for you. When similarly challenged by Derek on the Belfast thread you failed to provide any detail. Is your own trite answer not sufficient this time? “It’s remarkable what can be achieved when the political will is there” You are the type of hypocritical fool who Clarence Darrow once described perfectly “He doesn’t think, he knows”. See if you can repress the Pavlovian response to pick on some barely relevant point to argue with because you need to ‘win’. Instead, maybe have a think about that need and reflect on the number of posts you have made on this thread and the unconscious processes driving your behaviour. Be curious about yourself, do indeed “look in the mirror”. Don’t expect any engagement from me however – this would be a waste of my time and I have already wasted too much; whilst you seem to have limitless time for “onanist (sic) pontification”, I do not. Well done on the volunteering. RE: Unsurprising revelations... - tHEgLASSdOORS - 07-21-2026 What a post that is. Have a turbo exalt. RE: Unsurprising revelations... - Protheroe - 07-21-2026 (07-21-2026, 11:29 AM)Paddock Wrote:(07-20-2026, 01:45 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I'm not boasting about what I do for this or any other cause, I'm explaining that I put my money and time where my mouth is (as does the rest of my family) - do you? That's a very insightful post and you clearly care very deeply. I am sorry that those services have ceased because the building is unaffordable. Where people have lost their jobs / vocations I'm truly sorry about that. I don't agree with your contention about principles of funding, and I don't agree with your contention about what will happen to control should state funding increase. The state generally spreads its control through direct management or regulation if it is holding the purse strings. I would worry that the very essence of hospice care would be denuded very quickly if the state becomes the dominant provider of funds - the NHS is hardly a shining example of care in any setting let alone palliative care. I also worry that charitable donations would also fall steeply if hospices were viewed as a state enterprise. That view is drawn from personal experience - the contrast in the end of life care / deaths of several loved ones in hospices / hospitals. Maybe my experience of the NHS has brutalised me, I know I'm not alone in that in my own family let alone wider society. I am very happy for you to disagree with me, but that is my view. Let me leave you with this. Today, our new PM has "found" £650m to cut VAT on fuel bills, most of us don't need it - for those that do it'll hardly address any of the fuel poverty or other hardships they face. I'm so lacking in humanity that I complained about exactly the same costly untargeted £billions in bungs last time, let alone the £billions in Covid relief to those who didn't need it or obtained it fraudulently. £650m also is about the total funding annually received by hospices from taxpayers. Those lobbying for additional state funding for hospices would probably see a £30 million or £60 million annual increase in funding as very welcome. To raise an additional £60 million would be just the £45 benefit received of just 1.2 million households who don't need a VAT cut. Again. I'd be prepared to put my £45 where my mouth is for something my family has benefitted from on multiple occasions. I'd like as many of the dying to receive the dignified death my mum and dad received. I am sorry if the way that care is funded offends people as it seems it does. I am sorry if you find my motivation sickening, but I doubt you'd find it as sickening as the NHS's "care" of my father before we virtually kidnapped him from hospital. RE: Unsurprising revelations... - JeezArseChrist - 07-21-2026 Fantastic post Paddock, you've managed to brilliantly articulate mine and I'm sure many others thoughts on Prothetic, I had to log in for the first time in ages because, that post describes my exact feelings when reading Proths posts, though I do wonder if that at this stage in life he might just have devolved into a twisted bitter WUM. RE: Unsurprising revelations... - Tom Joad 25 - 07-21-2026 That's some post, Paddock. Well said. Sums up the tories motto, I'm all right, if someone else isn't it is clearly their fault. RE: Unsurprising revelations... - man in the corner shop - 07-21-2026 Paddock picks up far more eloquently points I have raised about Proth in the past - lack of insight, never wrong, whatabouttery, tendency to superiority, etc. Proth is an important contributor to this bored imo. He has gone full on daily mail recently and I am diametrically opposed to his world view and view of human nature. But I don't come here for an echo chamber. Though I am very grateful to posters who share my outlook on things. Proper, decent, mons one and all Despite his recent uber fascism....let hungry kids starve, white kids are more important than brown kids, hospices can rely on charity etc, he often posts good stuff that challenges my thinking. And I need that - because I am not always right (except about the centrist dads and Mowbray )As for the hospices, I have posted before- I have known many CEOs of hospices over the years and not one of them had ever said that they want to exist solely on fundraising. They have all said that they don't want 100% NHS funding as too many strings would be attached by way of contracts and service specifications. They have all said that they want to remain independent with an element of state funding and to be financially sustainable in the long term. That truth is a million miles from the fantasy, rigid, dogma that Proth has posted which is based upon no reality but solely upon his fundamental belief that the state should fund nothing and everyone should fend for themselves in some hideous kind of Hayekian dystopia. All posted from the leafy, insulated Hagley dacha. Well I give a fuck about other people. And tax me as much as you like if it makes everyone else's life better. Because, guess what, that will make my life better. RE: Unsurprising revelations... - Derek Hardballs - 07-21-2026 Paddock, just to say thank you for the outstanding reply, and I hope you get your shoe back. RE: Unsurprising revelations... - man in the corner shop - 07-21-2026 (07-21-2026, 08:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Paddock, just to say thank you for the outstanding reply, and I hope you get your shoe back. Not this again for Proth RE: Unsurprising revelations... - Ted Maul - 07-22-2026 Good posting all round imo. |