WBAUnofficial
Letter from Shilen - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Letter from Shilen (/showthread.php?tid=41927)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Letter from Shilen - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-27-2026

What he’s done to keep us going out of existence is fairly straightforward. We were effectively insolvent and in total hoc to a loan. We aren’t any more.

Car crash is harsh IMO. There’s a lot of very poor decisions mixed with some stuff that’s been progressive and effective. He appears to be correcting the former and building on the latter.


RE: Letter from Shilen - CarlosCorbewrong - 06-27-2026

Hopefully.

The money lending (I’m assuming it’s a director/holding company loan) is the one saving grace because, let’s face it, the footballing side (appointments, squad balance, AI led player recruitment, El Presidente) and the PSR breach can only really be described as a car crash.

I’m genuinely grateful for the financial bailout they’ve given us. But, like Josh, I’ll wait and see what happens this year before getting too excited. As you said - sensible foundations to build on. Hopefully.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Josh1873 - 06-27-2026

If we'd have gotten relegated due to the PSR breach, then car crash would be fair. He's gotten lucky Morrison stepped in, and stepped up, in honesty.

Like I've said previously, there's no malice, or anything with Patel. He genuinely seems invested and wants to be successful, which is more than Lai, who just wanted out as soon as China blocked the finances, and in essence washed his hands with us.

Anyway, last season is last season. It can't be changed. I sincerely hope the words come into frustration and we get a positive upcoming season. It won't be for want of trying, that's something I appreciate.


RE: Letter from Shilen - richbaggie - 06-27-2026

Bit of rewriting going on with PSR. We didn’t get away with it, we didn't get it wrong. We did absolutely everything asked of us working closely with the EFL only for compliance to move the goalpost after the event.
We would have very easily have won any court proceedings if appealed but sensibly chose not to waste money for a victory that wouldn't have brought anything but satisfaction of being proven right all along.

The club handled an extremely challenging financial situation brilliantly. The issues last year were caused by poor managerial decisions.


RE: Letter from Shilen - CarlosCorbewrong - 06-27-2026

I’m not sure how you can say that with such confidence Rich. No arbitration panel - to my knowledge - has completely wiped out a EFL penalty - they’ve reduced the penalty but never completely sided with the clubs.

I think!


RE: Letter from Shilen - Tom Joad 25 - 06-27-2026

Has Tom Brady built those chimneys yet? Are Wolves in the Champions League?
I'd sooner a guy walk in to our club and prevent almost certain administration. Even at the price of a very poor season - not just directly as a fault of managerial appointments- but surely equally due to having to sell our best players? We knew this. Patel could not simply come in Manchester City style and sign x,y and z for £ zillions. We all knew exactly where we stood, PSR and financially, 12 months ago yet are now bleating over something that was almost inevitably due to happen.
The actions people want to see have actually been put in place. It is detailed in the letter. It is the consequences of the actions that we are all interested in but they won't happen today, or next week. Patel HAS talked a good game but I'd sooner that than someone come in promising golden elephants and champions league games. I'll save any criticism for when I see how things pan out from here.


RE: Letter from Shilen - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-27-2026

Great post TJ. Fair and accurate.

And I’d say some of the signings, MJ, Heggebo, Campbell, Diakite, Heggem, Price have been more than decent.

Car crash is way over the top bordering on an insult, for me.

However close to the bone it was, last seasons aims realistically were to stay in the championship and clear the psr. We did that.


RE: Letter from Shilen - Josh1873 - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 10:14 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Bit of rewriting going on with PSR. We didn’t get away with it, we didn't get it wrong. We did absolutely everything asked of us working closely with the EFL only for compliance to move the goalpost after the event.
We would have very easily have won any court proceedings if appealed but sensibly chose not to waste money for a victory that wouldn't have brought anything but satisfaction of being proven right all along.

The club handled an extremely challenging financial situation brilliantly. The issues last year were caused by poor managerial decisions.

No issues with that, but to sail so close to the wind, you're asking for trouble with any miscalculations and/or misinterpretations, aren't you? 

Would you not have some leeway in, just in case? Or is it common practice to max out the PSR threshold? 

I have sympathy with the club with the way EFL changed their rules retrospectively, but I'm also uncomfortable knowing the club relied on an interpretation that they clearly weren't 100% on, hence why they contacted the league to seek clarification. Why give the authorities the chance? Maybe that's me oversimplifying it, and being overly critical.


RE: Letter from Shilen - tHEgLASSdOORS - 06-27-2026

Sailing close to the wind is what we had to do to have a realistic chance of survival. That’s fairly obvious.


RE: Letter from Shilen - richbaggie - 06-27-2026

(06-27-2026, 10:26 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: I’m not sure how you can say that with such confidence Rich. No arbitration panel - to my knowledge - has completely wiped out a EFL penalty - they’ve reduced the penalty but never completely sided with the clubs.

I think!

The EFL case was a mess procedural wise, which is why the club were relaxed all along. I am paraphrasing here but a KC told me at the time that the club could have destroyed their case if they chose to do so.