![]() |
|
Retained list - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Retained list (/showthread.php?tid=41588) |
RE: Retained list - man in the corner shop - 05-16-2026 So Dike goes as a free agent Wasn't it £7m we paid for him in 2022? And Grant seems likely to go. That was £15m wor it? Grady was £12m and went on a free We have pissed some money away. RE: Retained list - Josh1873 - 05-16-2026 I do think we overpaid for Grant, but he's given us a good few years of quality service, in fairness. Dike was a good signing, and that fee is probably about right. It's no one's fault he has suffered long-term injuries. You can't blame the club for that. Grady was superb in his loan spell, probably overpaid, too, but I don't think anyone questioned the signing at the time? Again, easy to be critical in hindsight, but I don't think the club can be criticised for that signing, either. RE: Retained list - man in the corner shop - 05-16-2026 Fair points Josh And Oli Burke £15m Zahore £9m Soon get up to a "massive waste of money XI" Grady was on fire on loan but was never as good for us when he signed permanently imo. And deteriorated badly when Pereira went. Never to reach the same heights again. A shame. RE: Retained list - SeanFlynnsPressUps - 05-16-2026 There's no question that Grant cost far too much money but I think Albion fans have the wrong idea of him and I don't really understand it. He scored 18 in a season off the left, and people think his best season was when he came back from Cardiff because he "works hard". I don't want to see Grant working hard, I want to see him finding space, receiving the ball and scoring goals. Before his injury this season he was criminally wasted by an Albion midfield who refused to play balls beyond defenders, meaning he was making runs into the box for nothing time and again. Meanwhile when Johnston plays he's happy to pick it up with the defence in front of him and everyone ooohs and Aaaahs while he jinks past three defenders and gets tackled by a fourth. In the formation we are playing at the moment Grant is a versatile player who can either take up the role Price is playing on the left or support the striker. Give him that role on the left and he can score from range or make those late runs into the box like price but he will make runs in behind when we're in possession. If we get the best out of Grant, Maja, Heggebo and Price next season that's a huge potential for goal return without any incomings. RE: Retained list - Man from delmonte - 05-16-2026 (05-16-2026, 08:28 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote: So Dike goes as a free agent For all the stick he’s taken over the years I’d say Grant has given us the most value for money out of those three. With Dike it’s just so unfortunate and I think anyone can be blamed for his signing ultimately not working out. RE: Retained list - SW4Baggie - 05-16-2026 I can see why Grant is someone we are making an offer… he’s 28, generally good availability (this season has been a one off, he’s usually good for around 40 games a season) and he combines being willing to follow a managers instructions with having enough quality to make things happen… he’s not a flashy or exciting player any more - at Hudds and in the Bruce season he was an exciting attacking option - but he’s adapted his game to be more solid. My reason for not offering Grant a contract is he’s 29 in September and this will be his last chance to get a decent 3 year deal on good wages, and I wouldn’t want us offering him the kind of money I think he’d be expecting. Maja is a hugely talented player. Keep him fit and he’s good for 15 goals a season, and he can dovetail better with Heggebø than Dike. His injuries have been the result of nasty tackles, not through any weakness on his part. I’m sad to see Dike go, but we have to trust the judgement of those who know his body better than us. If he goes back to the MLS I hope he does well… it would be sad to see him go to another Champ side and flourish as I do think if he can stay fit he’s another 15-20 goal a season player at this level. He literally had everything. RE: Retained list - HawkingsHalfpint - 05-16-2026 Funny how opinions change. I’ve no Maja (excuse the pun) issue with that list. Dike was a tough one, but one of those you’re damned if you do, and damned if you don’t. For me, I didn’t see enough after his return to warrant a big new contract (he wouldn’t have been cheap), but his overall return - through no fault of his own - hasn’t been enough for a club like us. Some fresh blood would be better. Maja is a bit of a surprise, because he hardly seemed to be playing for a new contract at a glance. But his style is his own, I suppose, and with service knows where the net is (remember how prolific he was with Fellows here?). He isn’t the ‘dog after a stick’ type players some of our fans love to see, and a different player to Heggebø who is the workhorse of the two. His game is more about intelligent runs and finding space at the right time than the others, but some just don’t see that. Probably cheaper than Dike too, but I can see why they had to choose one and not the other, and he’s probably the cheaper and less risky option. I was worried for Dike every time he pulled on a shirt - I don’t want 3 more years of that. Plus, two new strikers won’t be easy to find on our budget, so if he’s happy and the coaches like what they see, there are enough goals in him to warrant an extension. Grant was keeping MJ out at the start of last season, can run both flanks, has goals in him and can play as a back-up forward. No brainer to make an offer. Shame about Jed, because of his presence as a character. But again he won’t be cheap, and I just think his legs have gone now. Fit two weeks, then out for three. We can’t progress with ‘big’ players like that, sad as I am to see him leave. If this list allows us to fill a few gaps and bring in someone fitter and more prolific than Dike, I’m OK with it. Just hope Maja doesn’t turn out to be a mistake, but we’ve not seen him get decent service this term. The better wingers were out when he decided he was fit enough. Two Villa rejects and a taped-together Jed don’t constitute that decent service. I’d move heaven and earth to sign Imray. Just what we need there. RE: Retained list - SW4Baggie - 05-16-2026 Agree HH… Imray makes the whole system tick… if we can’t entice him back, and if rumours are to be trusted, he’s our top target but we aren’t top of the list currently, we need to be scouring Europe for a similar profile player. Including Hindolo and Jama we are letting 6 attacking options depart this summer, and whilst we don’t need 6 new ones through the door, we will need at least 4 we can rely on to stay fit for 30-40 games a season. Maja and Grant are the two most likely to do that so I can see why we’ve prioritised offering them new terms. I just how it leaves enough in the bank for Imray, 2 more forward players and a GK. Ideally we need another central midfielder too! RE: Retained list - wba13 - 05-16-2026 (05-16-2026, 09:39 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Agree HH… Imray makes the whole system tick… if we can’t entice him back, and if rumours are to be trusted, he’s our top target but we aren’t top of the list currently, we need to be scouring Europe for a similar profile player. For me we also need a Keeper and a back up left back also. Keep O’Leary if he excepts being back up,as I’ve said before Sell Griffiths he seems to have hit a wall with us and is not improving, I rated him premiership potential a few years ago but he doesn’t seem to have developed with us. Could be crap coaching I don’t know but I would now sell. RE: Retained list - SW4Baggie - 05-16-2026 (05-16-2026, 09:46 AM)wba13 Wrote:(05-16-2026, 09:39 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Agree HH… Imray makes the whole system tick… if we can’t entice him back, and if rumours are to be trusted, he’s our top target but we aren’t top of the list currently, we need to be scouring Europe for a similar profile player. I mentioned GK… I think MO’L is OK for this season coming but it is a position we could improve upon, but may not be a priority for spending this time round. For LB I’d be looking at Joel Bagan at Cardiff. He’s 24, out of contract and has had a very good season leading him to be called up for the RoI squad. He’s a tad more defensive than Styles but similar profile in terms of versatile and a solid 7/10 every week. |