WBAUnofficial
Be honest, who? - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Be honest, who? (/showthread.php?tid=38393)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: Be honest, who? - Wxm_Albion - 08-20-2025

I can understand the criticism of the current government the feelings of neglect by major political parties.

However I cannot understand how anyone could arrive at the conclusion that Reform is the answer and that Farage has their best interests at heart.

I wish I had the optimism of those who don't think Reform could get a majority - the cult of Farage is strong and he plays the propaganda game very well. I hope that actually having some responsibility & accountability in the Councils they control will expose them for the charlatans they are but won't hold my breath.

If there were an election tomorrow I would vote Labour. The current leadership are weak and uninspiring, but a vote for anyone else is effectively a vote for Farage.


RE: Be honest, who? - tHEgLASSdOORS - 08-20-2025

Current Labour are the very definition of #LeastWorst. And it’s a fookin low bar. The criticism on here of the handling of things like WFA, PIP and Waspi is all very valid, all need tackling but have been such a shambles they’ve become impossible hot potatoes for the foreseeable. But they have at least bought SOME stability and SOME decent changes. Far from good enough, for me, but I’ll make that call in 4 years time.

The greatest shame is that we do actually need reform, just not Reform.


RE: Be honest, who? - Ted Maul - 08-20-2025

(08-20-2025, 07:37 AM)Wxm_Albion Wrote: I can understand the criticism of the current government the feelings of neglect by major political parties.

However I cannot understand how anyone could arrive at the conclusion that Reform is the answer and that Farage has their best interests at heart.

I wish I had the optimism of those who don't think Reform could get a majority - the cult of Farage is strong and he plays the propaganda game very well. I hope that actually having some responsibility & accountability in the Councils they control will expose them for the charlatans they are but won't hold my breath.

If there were an election tomorrow I would vote Labour. The current leadership are weak and uninspiring, but a vote for anyone else is effectively a vote for Farage.

Welcome new poster. Very reasonable first post. You want to knock that on the head, makes you stand out like a sore thumb.


RE: Be honest, who? - Rowie60 - 08-20-2025

(08-20-2025, 07:37 AM)Wxm_Albion Wrote: I can understand the criticism of the current government the feelings of neglect by major political parties.

However I cannot understand how anyone could arrive at the conclusion that Reform is the answer and that Farage has their best interests at heart.

I wish I had the optimism of those who don't think Reform could get a majority - the cult of Farage is strong and he plays the propaganda game very well. I hope that actually having some responsibility & accountability in the Councils they control will expose them for the charlatans they are but won't hold my breath.

If there were an election tomorrow I would vote Labour. The current leadership are weak and uninspiring, but a vote for anyone else is effectively a vote for Farage.

Exactly the way I feel at the moment. Can't help feeling it would be a complete disaster with Reform leading the country. "Stop the boats" is a valid issue, but it blinds people to what overall problems the country faces.


RE: Be honest, who? - tHEgLASSdOORS - 08-20-2025

Three sane and reasoned contributions before 9am. What’s going on here.

Also found myself in some agreement with Hughies summary. If we had a PR system, I’d be very tempted to vote Lib Dem. Though I do wonder if they’d have enough calibre and experience to run a government, they are most in tune with many things.


RE: Be honest, who? - Shabby Russian - 08-20-2025

(08-19-2025, 11:37 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Never Reform, never Tory, never Labour under the current leadership so that leaves the Lib Dem’s as my only realistic option. However if I was in say the Bristol area I’d happily vote Green.

i'd happily vote Green in any area.

Bit concerned if Polanski wins leadership contest (and i think he will win). Completely relaxed by the introduction of a left wing party, but if Polanski is leader think he might put off some Green voters and he will be fishing in the same pond as the new left party.


RE: Be honest, who? - DemonicBaggie - 08-20-2025

(08-20-2025, 07:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(08-20-2025, 07:37 AM)Wxm_Albion Wrote: I can understand the criticism of the current government the feelings of neglect by major political parties.

However I cannot understand how anyone could arrive at the conclusion that Reform is the answer and that Farage has their best interests at heart.

I wish I had the optimism of those who don't think Reform could get a majority - the cult of Farage is strong and he plays the propaganda game very well. I hope that actually having some responsibility & accountability in the Councils they control will expose them for the charlatans they are but won't hold my breath.

If there were an election tomorrow I would vote Labour. The current leadership are weak and uninspiring, but a vote for anyone else is effectively a vote for Farage.

Welcome new poster. Very reasonable first post. You want to knock that on the head, makes you stand out like a sore thumb.

Yup, welcome to a voice of reason.

FWIW I'd vote Green in an election. As far as Labour goes, I see the current leadership in a Jekyll and Hyde sort of guise.
Domestically they've had a propensity for really pissing people off from the outset, with the hitting down on pensioners and the disabled. The latest plans to roll back environmental protections to enable building projects is equally philistine.
On the international stage however I believe Starmer has conducted himself well. He's had to find ways to work with the enfant terrible of world politics, whilst picking his way through two vicious and destabilising wars. He's probably a much better diplomat than a party leader. 
As for Reform, it's just the UK aping what has happened in the US - farage is, after all, an open admirer of trump. Unfortunately trump's electoral success has emboldened parties across Europe to embrace naked nationalism and reject progressive philosophies. It's not an inspiring prospect.


RE: Be honest, who? - Tom Joad - 08-20-2025

(08-19-2025, 05:51 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(08-19-2025, 05:41 PM)Pipkins Wrote: For those whom have said they would leave if Reform ended up at No 10

Can I ask where would your country of choice be?

Denmark or the Netherlands. Leaning to the former as there's no obligation to give up your British citizenship to become a Danish citizen but there is to become a Dutch citizen.

I would say Switzerland but given how impossible it is to emigrate there without an EU or EEA passport (thanks Brexit) even in a high-demand industry as a B1 German and B2 French speaker that's likely off the table. I've turned down a couple of offers in South Australia as well so that's an option as well if Reform get in. Maybe Germany or Canada as well, and the other Nordic countries and Ireland aren't off the table depending on job offers but I've not seriously looked into those countries.
Some lads I worked with worked were also  on contracts in Switzerland. The stories they told me were astounding. They were loving it until one day they were told to leave the hotel, someone else (much richer) booked, and was given their rooms. They also had stories of Swiss registered cars flouting the laws in EU countries with complete knowledge the Swiss authorities bin any other nations enquiries into certain violations. 
From my experience,  Australia was hardly the land of woke too. If social conscience is a part of your reason for leaving, it might be worth making some alternative plans..... Rolleyes


RE: Be honest, who? - Borin' Baggie - 08-20-2025

It's not social conscience TJ, it's Reform's fiscal idiocy creating a system of instability that I really cannot be bothered to deal with. This is a party that support borrowing to fund tax cuts and spending billions of public money on new CCGTs makes sense while saying they'd fund that by cutting money that isn't even government spending but private investment.

I'm not close to retirement unfortunately so the capacity for me to insulate my finances from that are limited and I just cannot be arsed.


RE: Be honest, who? - Tom Joad - 08-20-2025

(08-20-2025, 04:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's not social conscience TJ, it's Reform's fiscal idiocy creating a system of instability that I really cannot be bothered to deal with. This is a party that support borrowing to fund tax cuts and spending billions of public money on new CCGTs makes sense while saying they'd fund that by cutting money that isn't even government spending but private investment.

I'm not close to retirement unfortunately so the capacity for me to insulate my finances from that are limited and I just cannot be arsed.
Your quote: "Reform's fiscal idiocy" - or irresponsibility as I'd term it - needs to be fully exposed. By that I mean on a platform where all can see it. Sadly many are taken in by the confidence in which Reform offer easy answers. My own experience - of pubs, worksites, media outlets etc.- tells me Reform are going to get a lot of votes. Like with Brexit, the voters won't all be racists and won't all be idiots but what they will all have in common is a feeling of being ignored, or taken for granted, by the traditional parties. Labour aren't totally bad but they have boxed themselves in,  have little direction and the worst PR I've ever known for a political party. Brighter alternatives though are thin on the ground.