RE: Pete Lowe - baggy1 - 03-25-2025
(03-25-2025, 12:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-25-2025, 10:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: In isolation that is potentially on the table, but weighed against the damage caused by tariffs if they didn’t then that might be an option to consider. Again it’s just paper talk on what might be and we’ve seen the panic that speculation brings.
I’ll ask again - how would you tax these billionaires
What, the speculation that was either leaked by government or the government could have quashed if it wasn’t true. Or the fact they are still going to cut billions of pounds of support for the disabled and sick? The only people to blame for that are your party and it’s still not acceptable and it’s still punching down.
I would introduce a wealth tax and if they leave they leave, you cannot have a democracy that is beholden to what you’re essentially describing as blackmail. As I said Labour are bullies they’ve made a political choice to go after the poorest in society rather than those with the broadest shoulders. You have millionaires who are actively saying tax is more but they are ignored because Reform/Tory rhetoric is what Labours focus groups, think tanks and advisers think the public want to hear.
Could you explain this vague notion of a wealth tax. Are you talking about total wealth, global wealth, income or what. And how do you get at the value of that wealth? It won’t be their bank balance at NatWest I guarantee you.
I don’t think anyone disagrees with your direction Dekka but the real world is very different to what you are suggesting.
RE: Pete Lowe - Derek Hardballs - 03-25-2025
(03-25-2025, 02:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (03-25-2025, 12:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-25-2025, 10:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: In isolation that is potentially on the table, but weighed against the damage caused by tariffs if they didn’t then that might be an option to consider. Again it’s just paper talk on what might be and we’ve seen the panic that speculation brings.
I’ll ask again - how would you tax these billionaires
What, the speculation that was either leaked by government or the government could have quashed if it wasn’t true. Or the fact they are still going to cut billions of pounds of support for the disabled and sick? The only people to blame for that are your party and it’s still not acceptable and it’s still punching down.
I would introduce a wealth tax and if they leave they leave, you cannot have a democracy that is beholden to what you’re essentially describing as blackmail. As I said Labour are bullies they’ve made a political choice to go after the poorest in society rather than those with the broadest shoulders. You have millionaires who are actively saying tax is more but they are ignored because Reform/Tory rhetoric is what Labours focus groups, think tanks and advisers think the public want to hear.
Could you explain this vague notion of a wealth tax. Are you talking about total wealth, global wealth, income or what. And how do you get at the value of that wealth? It won’t be their bank balance at NatWest I guarantee you.
I don’t think anyone disagrees with your direction Dekka but the real world is very different to what you are suggesting.
You are reaching Proth like levels of supporting the indefensible and patronising those that don’t agree with you over the last few weeks B1. If Labour are simply to follow traditional tried and failed policies of the last 14yrs which they are by and large when it comes to the economy then they are just Tories. People voted for change not Labour which is why the polls show how fragile their support is.
Here are some people who want change but their opinions are ignored as it might upset the Tory/Reform optics Labour are so keen court and their think tanks and advisers advocate, because at the heart of this government is a massive hole where their principles once were.
The wrong type of millionaire… for Labour anyway
RE: Pete Lowe - Protheroe - 03-25-2025
(03-25-2025, 03:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-25-2025, 02:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (03-25-2025, 12:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-25-2025, 10:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: In isolation that is potentially on the table, but weighed against the damage caused by tariffs if they didn’t then that might be an option to consider. Again it’s just paper talk on what might be and we’ve seen the panic that speculation brings.
I’ll ask again - how would you tax these billionaires
What, the speculation that was either leaked by government or the government could have quashed if it wasn’t true. Or the fact they are still going to cut billions of pounds of support for the disabled and sick? The only people to blame for that are your party and it’s still not acceptable and it’s still punching down.
I would introduce a wealth tax and if they leave they leave, you cannot have a democracy that is beholden to what you’re essentially describing as blackmail. As I said Labour are bullies they’ve made a political choice to go after the poorest in society rather than those with the broadest shoulders. You have millionaires who are actively saying tax is more but they are ignored because Reform/Tory rhetoric is what Labours focus groups, think tanks and advisers think the public want to hear.
Could you explain this vague notion of a wealth tax. Are you talking about total wealth, global wealth, income or what. And how do you get at the value of that wealth? It won’t be their bank balance at NatWest I guarantee you.
I don’t think anyone disagrees with your direction Dekka but the real world is very different to what you are suggesting.
You are reaching Proth like levels of supporting the indefensible and patronising those that don’t agree with you over the last few weeks B1. If Labour are simply to follow traditional tried and failed policies of the last 14yrs which they are by and large when it comes to the economy then they are just Tories. People voted for change not Labour which is why the polls show how fragile their support is.
Here are some people who want change but their opinions are ignored as it might upset the Tory/Reform optics Labour are so keen court and their think tanks and advisers advocate, because at the heart of this government is a massive hole where their principles once were.
The wrong type of millionaire… for Labour anyway
That's unfair on us both Dekka. I have spelled out exactly what I'd suggest in the form of LVT. It's the *ONLY* way you can effectively institute a Wealth Tax. If you disagree then spell out what you mean. All this Tax Justice bollocks is pie in the sky, overly complex, would have major disincentives for investment and other stupid and counter productive effects.
RE: Pete Lowe - Derek Hardballs - 03-25-2025
(03-25-2025, 03:11 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (03-25-2025, 03:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-25-2025, 02:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (03-25-2025, 12:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-25-2025, 10:13 AM)baggy1 Wrote: In isolation that is potentially on the table, but weighed against the damage caused by tariffs if they didn’t then that might be an option to consider. Again it’s just paper talk on what might be and we’ve seen the panic that speculation brings.
I’ll ask again - how would you tax these billionaires
What, the speculation that was either leaked by government or the government could have quashed if it wasn’t true. Or the fact they are still going to cut billions of pounds of support for the disabled and sick? The only people to blame for that are your party and it’s still not acceptable and it’s still punching down.
I would introduce a wealth tax and if they leave they leave, you cannot have a democracy that is beholden to what you’re essentially describing as blackmail. As I said Labour are bullies they’ve made a political choice to go after the poorest in society rather than those with the broadest shoulders. You have millionaires who are actively saying tax is more but they are ignored because Reform/Tory rhetoric is what Labours focus groups, think tanks and advisers think the public want to hear.
Could you explain this vague notion of a wealth tax. Are you talking about total wealth, global wealth, income or what. And how do you get at the value of that wealth? It won’t be their bank balance at NatWest I guarantee you.
I don’t think anyone disagrees with your direction Dekka but the real world is very different to what you are suggesting.
You are reaching Proth like levels of supporting the indefensible and patronising those that don’t agree with you over the last few weeks B1. If Labour are simply to follow traditional tried and failed policies of the last 14yrs which they are by and large when it comes to the economy then they are just Tories. People voted for change not Labour which is why the polls show how fragile their support is.
Here are some people who want change but their opinions are ignored as it might upset the Tory/Reform optics Labour are so keen court and their think tanks and advisers advocate, because at the heart of this government is a massive hole where their principles once were.
The wrong type of millionaire… for Labour anyway
That's unfair on us both Dekka. I have spelled out exactly what I'd suggest in the form of LVT. It's the *ONLY* way you can effectively institute a Wealth Tax. If you disagree then spell out what you mean. All this Tax Justice bollocks is pie in the sky, overly complex, would have major disincentives for investment and other stupid and counter productive effects.
They are successful millionaires who are flying in the face of traditional post Thatcher Tory values I’m not surprised you don’t agree with them, or that Reeves is slavishly following Tory policy dogmatically.
RE: Pete Lowe - Protheroe - 03-25-2025
(03-25-2025, 03:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: They are successful millionaires who are flying in the face of traditional post Thatcher Tory values I’m not surprised you don’t agree with them, or that Reeves is slavishly following Tory policy dogmatically.
If you're referring to the Patriotic Millionaires they're perfectly at liberty to pay more of their own money to the State. In reality they're cunts, because they want to force everyone else to do so under state coercion.
RE: Pete Lowe - Ted Maul - 03-25-2025
(03-25-2025, 04:33 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (03-25-2025, 03:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: They are successful millionaires who are flying in the face of traditional post Thatcher Tory values I’m not surprised you don’t agree with them, or that Reeves is slavishly following Tory policy dogmatically.
If you're referring to the Patriotic Millionaires they're perfectly at liberty to pay more of their own money to the State. In reality they're cunts, because they want to force everyone else to do so under state coercion.
Wanting to create and fund public services that work for all makes you a "cunt" nowadays.
RE: Pete Lowe - Derek Hardballs - 03-25-2025
(03-25-2025, 04:39 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-25-2025, 04:33 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (03-25-2025, 03:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: They are successful millionaires who are flying in the face of traditional post Thatcher Tory values I’m not surprised you don’t agree with them, or that Reeves is slavishly following Tory policy dogmatically.
If you're referring to the Patriotic Millionaires they're perfectly at liberty to pay more of their own money to the State. In reality they're cunts, because they want to force everyone else to do so under state coercion.
Wanting to create and fund public services that work for all makes you a "cunt" nowadays.
Welcome to Proth’s and increasingly centrist dad Labour world it seems.
RE: Pete Lowe - Protheroe - 03-25-2025
(03-25-2025, 04:39 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Wanting to create and fund public services that work for all makes you a "cunt" nowadays.
No. Forcing other people to pay more tax than they currently do, because you want to pay more tax yourself makes you a cunt. Just pay extra yourself, and don't be a cunt. Job done.
RE: Pete Lowe - Borin' Baggie - 03-25-2025
(03-25-2025, 05:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (03-25-2025, 04:39 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Wanting to create and fund public services that work for all makes you a "cunt" nowadays.
No. Forcing other people to pay more tax than they currently do, because you want to pay more tax yourself makes you a cunt. Just pay extra yourself, and don't be a cunt. Job done.
Are you an 18th century Whig or something?
RE: Pete Lowe - Protheroe - 03-25-2025
No, I'm just likely to pay over £500,000 in business and personal taxation this year - and wondering how long it will be until I can't be arsed anymore.
|