![]() |
|
Well done Mark Carney - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Well done Mark Carney (/showthread.php?tid=36901) |
RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-20-2025 And I'm suggesting that if a 0.25% cut was apparently enough to stop investment "collapsing", then perhaps it was unnecessary (it was). They couldn't have cut much further in any event, as you well know. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-20-2025 No, what you're doing is ignoring cause and effect. You are saying they're unnecessary because you want them to be unnecessary, the effects of a 0.25% rate cut from 0.5% is very different to a 0.25% rate cut from 6%. And they didn't want to cut further as that would have pushed inflation above their temporary target, the BoE literally spell this out in their documentation at the time. That's why they were content to keeping business investment flat instead of trying to push it to maintain the pre-Brexit vote trend. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-20-2025 If you want to swallow BoE propaganda because it suits your narrative then be my guest. That's all it is - their opinion. This is the same organisation that facilitated inflation to run above target (even before Ukraine) then let it run and is still now letting it run above target. The same organisaton that has cravenly led a policy for 17 years that locks the vast majority of under 50's out of asset accumulation. With that record they're not on the right side of history. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-20-2025 It's not swallowing "BoE propaganda" to call you out on your bullshit, you've offered zero factual basis for anything on this thread. You have ignored what happened at the BoC when Carney was there even though it's literally what you wanted, you attributed the effects QE to Carney when it was under Mervyn King that QE happened with the resultant asset price inflation, you're in denial about the effects of fiscal policy on inflation and acting like there was capacity to substantially raise rates with an average inflation rate of 1.4% between 2013 and 2020 caused by the shite fiscal policy you wanted which is well below target and you have ignored the cause and effect trying desperately to convince yourself that fucking flatlining is a justification for the effect being null when anyone with a brain knows that only works if you have a continuous rate of change which going from a positive incline to a flat line is categorically not. I don't think the BoE is clairvoyant as evidenced by my opinion on Mervyn King, what I do know is that you definitely don't because you are more interested in hating Carney because he called your beloved Brexit the pursuit of idiocy that it is instead of the facts. RE: Well done Mark Carney - man in the corner shop - 03-20-2025 No amount of evidence will convince a fool RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-21-2025 (03-20-2025, 03:57 PM)Borin'Â Baggie Wrote: It's not swallowing "BoE propaganda" to call you out on your bullshit, you've offered zero factual basis for anything on this thread. You have ignored what happened at the BoC when Carney was there even though it's literally what you wanted, you attributed the effects QE to Carney when it was under Mervyn King that QE happened with the resultant asset price inflation, you're in denial about the effects of fiscal policy on inflation and acting like there was capacity to substantially raise rates with an average inflation rate of 1.4% between 2013 and 2020 caused by the shite fiscal policy you wanted which is well below target and you have ignored the cause and effect trying desperately to convince yourself that fucking flatlining is a justification for the effect being null when anyone with a brain knows that only works if you have a continuous rate of change which going from a positive incline to a flat line is categorically not. You can think what you like. I never thought I'd hear someone who claims to be a liberal defend BoE policy since 2008. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-21-2025 Because someone who defended what the Bank of Canada did in response to 2008 (no QE and first country to raise interest rates) and chastised Mervyn King (the guy responsible for the QE you are attributing to Carney) in this very thread is defending BoE policy. Give over. All you've done in this thread is make shit up, including that pathetic comment. You don't have a clue, even when faced with the facts you lie and deflect. RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-21-2025 All I've done is disagree with you. I know you don't like dissent. Shall we talk about how net zero is about to bankrupt us all and shift our remaining heavy industry overseas too? RE: Well done Mark Carney - Borin' Baggie - 03-21-2025 All you've done is ignore facts, twist words and lie. Shall we talk about how net zero is the only way to manage energy prices in the long-term to limit exposure to the international and regional fossil fuel markets that have driven up energy costs and decimated heavy industry in Europe? RE: Well done Mark Carney - Protheroe - 03-21-2025 In the long term we are all dead. You've already admitted that we probably won't see the feted reduction in the cost of energy in my lifetime. In the meantime, with just about the highest industrial energy prices in the world our remaining energy intensive industries will be gone within 5 years. We cannot grow without cheaper energy. You cannot explain how we're supposed to get through this transition without further financial oppression, but you're not alone in that. |