![]() |
|
The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector (/showthread.php?tid=35835) |
RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - man in the corner shop - 12-07-2024 I think it is odd that Derek hasn't said "only build on brownfield sites" but folk are inventing that he has....... RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Protheroe - 12-07-2024 (12-07-2024, 01:17 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Stop putting words in my mouth… I have given a number of options even on this thread not just brownfield sites. You as is your level of imagination only want to go for the laziest, cheapest and most profitable options, you couldn’t careless how it affects the communities that already live in struggling areas and you offer absolutely no solutions. Great, I'm glad you support the creation of new towns and urban extensions. Bravo. I'm not sure what's hypocritical about providing much needed homes for rent when there's a national shortage of supply? Perhaps you could explain. RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-07-2024 (12-07-2024, 04:54 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I think it is odd that Derek hasn't said "only build on brownfield sites" but folk are inventing that he has....... Nobodies said that CS. Dekka suggested that should be the 1st option, in a limited supply world you go for what gives you the most return for your investment (that shouldn’t just be read financially btw). If you need to build 1.5m homes and you can go brownfield that will provide 5k at the cost of 10k elsewhere you will go for the latter - that is what is being highlighted. RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Derek Hardballs - 12-07-2024 (12-07-2024, 05:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(12-07-2024, 01:17 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Stop putting words in my mouth… I have given a number of options even on this thread not just brownfield sites. You as is your level of imagination only want to go for the laziest, cheapest and most profitable options, you couldn’t careless how it affects the communities that already live in struggling areas and you offer absolutely no solutions. You aren’t providing anything you’re profiting from having houses you clearly have no need for. You aren’t doing anything to help the housing crisis. I’ve never had a problem with new towns, shrinking town centres or building in appropriate places as I said numerous times. I do have a problem with lazy, top down decisions where working class, built up areas only green spaces are earmarked for crap, poorly made shoebox housing whilst more affluent areas with green spaces, leisure facilities and other amenities are left alone or a few five bedroom detached houses are built. Labour are being lazy, classist, dictatorial and acting like champagne socialist on this… dare to speak out in a poorer area and the cry of nimbyiism is shouted even from the PM, it won’t affect them, they have their kids in good schools, big house with green spaces close by, good transport links/ access to cars, health care and agency to move. It’s smack of ‘we know what’s best… and judging by Starmers first five months he and his colleagues have been in power that’s very debatable… (12-07-2024, 05:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote:(12-07-2024, 04:54 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I think it is odd that Derek hasn't said "only build on brownfield sites" but folk are inventing that he has....... To clarify you want to build on limited green spaces used for both agriculture and leisure in built up areas in working class areas cuz it’s cheap and maximises profits for the developers. Excellent long term thinking… you’ll be part of the cabinet soon… is transport still available? RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-07-2024 No, to clarify that’s not what has been said RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Derek Hardballs - 12-07-2024 (12-07-2024, 05:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote: No, to clarify that’s not what has been said To clarify that’s what will happen. RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - man in the corner shop - 12-07-2024 I have found the FT to be the voice of reason on may issues over the past years https://www.ft.com/content/3ae5ce5d-a990-444c-b6f3-05710f27b10e RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - baggy1 - 12-07-2024 (12-07-2024, 06:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(12-07-2024, 05:38 PM)baggy1 Wrote: No, to clarify that’s not what has been said That isn't down to me or even my wishes. And just to clarify, as we seem to be clarifying here, I was brought up within a mile of Dudley town centre and up until about 25 years ago I was living in a two bedroomed terrace in Old Hill, so please spare me the working class back country 'you'll never understand' story, I'm at least as black country working class upbringing as you are. the reason I highlight the edge of town / county / urban area developments like Dickens Heath is because they offer everything you are talking about needing and not further overcrowding built up areas, and it might be a surprise to you but they do have trains and stations in the countryside. RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Protheroe - 12-07-2024 (12-07-2024, 05:29 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You aren’t doing anything to help the housing crisis. I'm doing more than you are. I've also campaigned to support an infill development of 140 houses being built on a scrubby field 1/4 mile up the road - much against the wishes of the people who live opposite in 1990s houses on roads called Greenmeadow and The Meadows. The irony, eh? RE: The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector - Kit Kat Chunky - 12-08-2024 (12-06-2024, 08:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Just test the logic there a bit, if you build 1000 houses does that mean that 2000 cars appear from nowhere?, Do the people using the services just start to use those services when the houses are built, as if they have not been using services before? Will there be more children for schools or the same amount of children moved from an overcrowded school to the new school? Is the land really agricultural or just land that is being sat on whilst the value increases? Maybe the reason for the building on flood planes (that bit I agree) is that the better areas are being restricted by NIMBYs. Are you familiar with S106 agreements for developments of this size, together with Social Housing requirements on these sites? The National Housebuilders are sat on landbanks that they will not develop because there isn't 20% profit in them. They can change Planning all they like, but housebuilders have no appetite to step up. The plan is flawed. |