WBAUnofficial
Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey (/showthread.php?tid=35552)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - Protheroe - 11-05-2024

(11-05-2024, 05:31 PM)Fido Wrote:
(11-05-2024, 05:24 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: On the opening post, Proth is right to call out Starmer for his backtracking on pledges made in his leadership election.

I know some think that the Starmer campaign team were super clever and adopted a perfect strategy. Pretend to be more left wing than they were and move to the right once elected.

But to my mind it just demonstrates a deep cynicism, that is embedded in uk politics.

And I'm not sure how this cynicism will work for Starmer. The number of voters willing to vote for him and his party at the GE was telling. He has very little goodwill with the British electorate. They've noted how shallow he is.

Completely agree. Winning because you are not someone else is not a ringing endorsement for any politician, especially when you don’t know what they really stand for. Still early doors, mess from Tories and so on but you’re absolutely right about how shallow politics is in this country nowadays.

I suspect this is the reason this government will end up being one the most unpopular ever in short order.


RE: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - baggy1 - 11-05-2024

All Labour needed to do was get into power by not being the Tories and not stopping them. If it appears that Starmer is still not cutting it with the electorate then they will bring in someone who will get the vote. You’re all running around suggesting Labour will be the same in 4 years when you’re not looking at Kemi to be Tory leader in 12 months.


RE: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-05-2024

(11-05-2024, 09:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All Labour needed to do was get into power by not being the Tories and not stopping them. If it appears that Starmer is still not cutting it with the electorate then they will bring in someone who will get the vote. You’re all running around suggesting Labour will be the same in 4 years when you’re not looking at Kemi to be Tory leader in 12 months.

Labour can't be the same in 4 years if they want a second term. Can the Tories be better in 4 years time? It could be an election when nobody votes.


RE: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - Derek Hardballs - 11-05-2024

(11-05-2024, 05:24 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: On the opening post, Proth is right to call out Starmer for his backtracking on pledges made in his leadership election.

I know some think that the Starmer campaign team were super clever and adopted a perfect strategy. Pretend to be more left wing than they were and move to the right once elected.

But to my mind it just demonstrates a deep cynicism, that is embedded in uk politics.

And I'm not sure how this cynicism will work for Starmer. The number of voters willing to vote for him and his party at the GE was telling. He has very little goodwill with the British electorate. They've noted how shallow he is.

When did they pretend to be in any way shape or form ‘left wing’? They were always campaigning on a Tory-lite ticket. The rest I agree with, Labour won because they weren’t the Tories at the last election, they failed to inspire anyone with their policies be they a lie or the truth.


RE: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - Borin' Baggie - 11-06-2024

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ckg74614608o

As I said, the £250 rise is nowhere near enough


RE: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - Protheroe - 11-06-2024

Perhaps closing the "universities" with the worst outcomes for students and directing resources towards those that provide optimal outcomes would be a better approach. Not all students need to attend an institution in this day and age after all anyway.


RE: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - Borin' Baggie - 11-06-2024

(11-06-2024, 08:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Perhaps closing the "universities" with the worst outcomes for students and directing resources towards those that provide optimal outcomes would be a better approach. Not all students need to attend an institution in this day and age after all anyway.

It's uneconomical for universities to run technical courses for home students. Departments focused on technical courses, like engineering, are the ones that are bleeding money. Universities that are focused on those - mostly ex-polys for historical reasons as polytechnics were about providing those technical courses - lose more money as a result. 

Saying "not all students need to attend an institution" is something I profoundly disagree with. Those institutions existed 50 years ago under a different name and there's nowhere else providing technical training for technical roles.


RE: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - Fido - 11-06-2024

(11-06-2024, 08:59 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-06-2024, 08:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Perhaps closing the "universities" with the worst outcomes for students and directing resources towards those that provide optimal outcomes would be a better approach. Not all students need to attend an institution in this day and age after all anyway.

It's uneconomical for universities to run technical courses for home students. Departments focused on technical courses, like engineering, are the ones that are bleeding money. Universities that are focused on those - mostly ex-polys for historical reasons as polytechnics were about providing those technical courses - lose more money as a result. 

Saying "not all students need to attend an institution" is something I profoundly disagree with. Those institutions existed 50 years ago under a different name and there's nowhere else providing technical training for technical roles.

I think he's on about the numbers of students needing to attend rather than the specifics for certain courses.


RE: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - Borin' Baggie - 11-06-2024

(11-06-2024, 09:05 AM)Fido Wrote:
(11-06-2024, 08:59 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-06-2024, 08:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Perhaps closing the "universities" with the worst outcomes for students and directing resources towards those that provide optimal outcomes would be a better approach. Not all students need to attend an institution in this day and age after all anyway.

It's uneconomical for universities to run technical courses for home students. Departments focused on technical courses, like engineering, are the ones that are bleeding money. Universities that are focused on those - mostly ex-polys for historical reasons as polytechnics were about providing those technical courses - lose more money as a result. 

Saying "not all students need to attend an institution" is something I profoundly disagree with. Those institutions existed 50 years ago under a different name and there's nowhere else providing technical training for technical roles.

I think he's on about the numbers of students needing to attend rather than the specifics for certain courses.

But that's my point. There's no alternative, the only apprenticeships actually worth anything for a lot of technical roles that we have skills shortages for are degree apprenticeships, and the degree part is a core part of that. As a result they're highly competitive. Technical courses that were provided by polytechnics still exist, just at a university so functionally there's no difference. How else do you get training? Level 4/5 apprenticeships are horribly mismanaged as they are for trades and aren't appropriate for more broadly technical roles.

There's massive skills shortages in the energy sector, almost entirely technical roles and the vast majority of those technical roles will need an equivalent of a level qualification as they're engineering roles. Closing the institutions that provide those level 6 qualifications doesn't help that, does it?


RE: Tuition Fees - a Starmerian Journey - Protheroe - 11-06-2024

(11-06-2024, 09:15 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-06-2024, 09:05 AM)Fido Wrote:
(11-06-2024, 08:59 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(11-06-2024, 08:43 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Perhaps closing the "universities" with the worst outcomes for students and directing resources towards those that provide optimal outcomes would be a better approach. Not all students need to attend an institution in this day and age after all anyway.

It's uneconomical for universities to run technical courses for home students. Departments focused on technical courses, like engineering, are the ones that are bleeding money. Universities that are focused on those - mostly ex-polys for historical reasons as polytechnics were about providing those technical courses - lose more money as a result. 

Saying "not all students need to attend an institution" is something I profoundly disagree with. Those institutions existed 50 years ago under a different name and there's nowhere else providing technical training for technical roles.

I think he's on about the numbers of students needing to attend rather than the specifics for certain courses.

But that's my point. There's no alternative, the only apprenticeships actually worth anything for a lot of technical roles that we have skills shortages for are degree apprenticeships, and the degree part is a core part of that. As a result they're highly competitive. Technical courses that were provided by polytechnics still exist, just at a university so functionally there's no difference. How else do you get training? Level 4/5 apprenticeships are horribly mismanaged as they are for trades and aren't appropriate for more broadly technical roles.

There's massive skills shortages in the energy sector, almost entirely technical roles and the vast majority of those technical roles will need an equivalent of a level qualification as they're engineering roles. Closing the institutions that provide those level 6 qualifications doesn't help that, does it?

The courses I'd be closing to attendance are those outside elite Universities that provide little value to the individual or society. There are plenty of them.