WBAUnofficial
'Working people' - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: 'Working people' (/showthread.php?tid=35450)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: 'Working people' - Tom Joad - 11-01-2024

(11-01-2024, 10:03 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Planning a further tax grab in 2 years is a sure fire way to lose the next election, but it will need this, even the OBR suggest this. This will in turn fuel higher interest rates again. You can see the clusterfuck of the next 5 years opening up in front of your very eyes. In 2 years time they can't blam a "£22bn black hole" or "14 years of Tory mismanagement". It will all be on them.

If there were to be some real investment you could argue the case, but all the cash that has been spunked is not conditional on any reform (which is badly needed - even FGK admitted that) or any announcement of major infrastructure projects that weren't already planned.

A bit difficult to plan any major infrastructure projects when you have to clear up the mess created by paying bogus companies during furlough and building half of a white elephant. I'm content with someone stopping the rot however temporarily before taking the time to plan for the future. Almost as if this is correct, both of the bodies Proth sited pretty much state the above.


RE: 'Working people' - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-01-2024

(11-01-2024, 10:12 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 10:03 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Planning a further tax grab in 2 years is a sure fire way to lose the next election, but it will need this, even the OBR suggest this. This will in turn fuel higher interest rates again. You can see the clusterfuck of the next 5 years opening up in front of your very eyes. In 2 years time they can't blam a "£22bn black hole" or "14 years of Tory mismanagement". It will all be on them.

If there were to be some real investment you could argue the case, but all the cash that has been spunked is not conditional on any reform (which is badly needed - even FGK admitted that) or any announcement of major infrastructure projects that weren't already planned.

A bit difficult to plan any major infrastructure projects when you have to clear up the mess created by paying bogus companies during furlough and building half of a white elephant. I'm content with someone stopping the rot however temporarily before taking the time to plan for the future. Almost as if this is correct, both of the bodies Proth sited pretty much state the above.

There was no "black hole" - the OBR confirmed that.

This lot should be in Watership Down. They've had 14 years to plan, but they are just rabbits staring into the headlights. When the £40bn has gone, the begging bowl will come out again - only this time they will have no choice other than to go to "working people" to keep the lights on. 

Show us the plans, show us where the money is going to go.


RE: 'Working people' - Protheroe - 11-01-2024

(11-01-2024, 10:01 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 09:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There is nothing quite like missing the point.

This government was elected with a promise to grow the economy. There is no commentator whatsoever, nor even the OBR who believes any of the measures in the Budget will be anything but growth killers. This isn't doom-mongering it's in the government figures.

Yes, the government needed to raise a substantial amount of money to even keep spending rising in real terms for the next couple of years. But Employers NIC is cynical self defeating way to do so - especially as it directly effects employees in future years. This isn't doom-mongering it's accepted by Rachel Reeves.

And in Years 3-5 of this government there is already a planned return to austerity for non-protected departments. This isn't doom-mongering it's in the government figures.

I'll summarise the above.
 I was wrong, the budget wasn't a disaster, independent observers admit the economy was wrecked and finally someone in government is doing something positive about it. With a further 4 and a half years of this government things may or may not improve but we have stepped in the right direction. Me and Kit Kat would have preferred to stick with the people that destroyed the country so we refuse to recognise some people with the best interests of the majority are now in charge.
Oh, and "They're all the same".
There you go.

Keep your head in the sand and your arse in the air ready for your next shafting in two years time, by then the effects of this Budget on wages and employment will be clear.

And FWIW the personal stuff is a complete misrepresentation of what I've been saying on here for almost 5 years.


RE: 'Working people' - chasetownbaggie - 11-01-2024

£40b extra raised and it's not cost me a penny - and that probably applies to the vast majority of the country. Commitments to invest in regions and certain industrial sectors. Big injection in NHS to help reduce the waiting lists. I thought it was a very good budget.


RE: 'Working people' - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-01-2024

(11-01-2024, 10:35 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: £40b extra raised and it's not cost me a penny - and that probably applies to the vast majority of the country. Commitments to invest in regions and certain industrial sectors. Big injection in NHS to help reduce the waiting lists. I thought it was a very good budget.

The vast majority of the country will carry the cost of this budget. Either by Employer NI costs either being passed on to the end user (which in turn the OBR has said is inflationary, leading to "higher for longer" interest rates), or supressed wage claims next year which Thieves has openly admitted could happen.

And don't start me off on the loss of WFA for many who need it.


RE: 'Working people' - Tom Joad - 11-01-2024

(11-01-2024, 10:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 10:01 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 09:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There is nothing quite like missing the point.

This government was elected with a promise to grow the economy. There is no commentator whatsoever, nor even the OBR who believes any of the measures in the Budget will be anything but growth killers. This isn't doom-mongering it's in the government figures.

Yes, the government needed to raise a substantial amount of money to even keep spending rising in real terms for the next couple of years. But Employers NIC is cynical self defeating way to do so - especially as it directly effects employees in future years. This isn't doom-mongering it's accepted by Rachel Reeves.

And in Years 3-5 of this government there is already a planned return to austerity for non-protected departments. This isn't doom-mongering it's in the government figures.

I'll summarise the above.
 I was wrong, the budget wasn't a disaster, independent observers admit the economy was wrecked and finally someone in government is doing something positive about it. With a further 4 and a half years of this government things may or may not improve but we have stepped in the right direction. Me and Kit Kat would have preferred to stick with the people that destroyed the country so we refuse to recognise some people with the best interests of the majority are now in charge.
Oh, and "They're all the same".
There you go.

Keep your head in the sand and your arse in the air ready for your next shafting in two years time, by then the effects of this Budget on wages and employment will be clear.

And FWIW the personal stuff is a complete misrepresentation of what I've been saying on here for almost 5 years.
Apologies if you think I'm being personal, just joshing, but no offence was intended. On the budget itself, I think it was a compromise and a step in the right direction.  They'll have a few more budgets so let's judge then. I will repeat, I genuinely  hear no outrage from the business owners I know.


RE: 'Working people' - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-01-2024

(11-01-2024, 11:15 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 10:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 10:01 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 09:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There is nothing quite like missing the point.

This government was elected with a promise to grow the economy. There is no commentator whatsoever, nor even the OBR who believes any of the measures in the Budget will be anything but growth killers. This isn't doom-mongering it's in the government figures.

Yes, the government needed to raise a substantial amount of money to even keep spending rising in real terms for the next couple of years. But Employers NIC is cynical self defeating way to do so - especially as it directly effects employees in future years. This isn't doom-mongering it's accepted by Rachel Reeves.

And in Years 3-5 of this government there is already a planned return to austerity for non-protected departments. This isn't doom-mongering it's in the government figures.

I'll summarise the above.
 I was wrong, the budget wasn't a disaster, independent observers admit the economy was wrecked and finally someone in government is doing something positive about it. With a further 4 and a half years of this government things may or may not improve but we have stepped in the right direction. Me and Kit Kat would have preferred to stick with the people that destroyed the country so we refuse to recognise some people with the best interests of the majority are now in charge.
Oh, and "They're all the same".
There you go.

Keep your head in the sand and your arse in the air ready for your next shafting in two years time, by then the effects of this Budget on wages and employment will be clear.

And FWIW the personal stuff is a complete misrepresentation of what I've been saying on here for almost 5 years.
Apologies if you think I'm being personal, just joshing, but no offence was intended. On the budget itself, I think it was a compromise and a step in the right direction.  They'll have a few more budgets so let's judge then. I will repeat, I genuinely  hear no outrage from the business owners I know.

My Accountant employs 60 people. He tells me it is going to cost him £40K a year. Guess how he proposes to fund this?


RE: 'Working people' - Tom Joad - 11-01-2024

(11-01-2024, 11:21 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 11:15 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 10:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 10:01 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 09:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote: There is nothing quite like missing the point.

This government was elected with a promise to grow the economy. There is no commentator whatsoever, nor even the OBR who believes any of the measures in the Budget will be anything but growth killers. This isn't doom-mongering it's in the government figures.

Yes, the government needed to raise a substantial amount of money to even keep spending rising in real terms for the next couple of years. But Employers NIC is cynical self defeating way to do so - especially as it directly effects employees in future years. This isn't doom-mongering it's accepted by Rachel Reeves.

And in Years 3-5 of this government there is already a planned return to austerity for non-protected departments. This isn't doom-mongering it's in the government figures.

I'll summarise the above.
 I was wrong, the budget wasn't a disaster, independent observers admit the economy was wrecked and finally someone in government is doing something positive about it. With a further 4 and a half years of this government things may or may not improve but we have stepped in the right direction. Me and Kit Kat would have preferred to stick with the people that destroyed the country so we refuse to recognise some people with the best interests of the majority are now in charge.
Oh, and "They're all the same".
There you go.

Keep your head in the sand and your arse in the air ready for your next shafting in two years time, by then the effects of this Budget on wages and employment will be clear.

And FWIW the personal stuff is a complete misrepresentation of what I've been saying on here for almost 5 years.
Apologies if you think I'm being personal, just joshing, but no offence was intended. On the budget itself, I think it was a compromise and a step in the right direction.  They'll have a few more budgets so let's judge then. I will repeat, I genuinely  hear no outrage from the business owners I know.

My Accountant employs 60 people. He tells me it is going to cost him £40K a year. Guess how he proposes to fund this?
You did know the economy was tanked and we need to raise more money? Or did you want another 5 years of heads in the sand. We have to start paying.


RE: 'Working people' - Protheroe - 11-01-2024

(11-01-2024, 11:58 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: You did know the economy was tanked and we need to raise more money? Or did you want another 5 years of heads in the sand. We have to start paying.

The State is tanked, not the economy which is pretty much running at full capacity.

It's HOW we pay for it Tom. 

As it is the Budget is landing businesses with additional costs which will increase prices for all, reduce employment opportunities and suppress wages. Capital taxes have become further distorted and disproportionately hit capital gains made by lower earners (riddle me that). 

By loading businesses with additional taxation you suppress growth (as the OBR states) meaning that you'll need even more of a tax grab in a couple of years which, if handled in the same cack-handed manner - will further suppress growth.

It would have been far more honest to have increased Income Tax by 3p. It would have truly signalled a break from the past and a direct tax on wealth to have introduced LVT. The latter in particular would serve to disincentivise the underuse of land thus aiding growth.

I know that most people on here want European levels of Taxation and gargantuan European state provision, however our tax base is much more narrow than all of our contemporaries. Whilst it remains that way you can't have what you want, until you accept that YOU will have to pay for it.


RE: 'Working people' - Kit Kat Chunky - 11-01-2024

(11-01-2024, 11:58 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 11:21 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 11:15 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 10:27 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-01-2024, 10:01 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I'll summarise the above.
 I was wrong, the budget wasn't a disaster, independent observers admit the economy was wrecked and finally someone in government is doing something positive about it. With a further 4 and a half years of this government things may or may not improve but we have stepped in the right direction. Me and Kit Kat would have preferred to stick with the people that destroyed the country so we refuse to recognise some people with the best interests of the majority are now in charge.
Oh, and "They're all the same".
There you go.

Keep your head in the sand and your arse in the air ready for your next shafting in two years time, by then the effects of this Budget on wages and employment will be clear.

And FWIW the personal stuff is a complete misrepresentation of what I've been saying on here for almost 5 years.
Apologies if you think I'm being personal, just joshing, but no offence was intended. On the budget itself, I think it was a compromise and a step in the right direction.  They'll have a few more budgets so let's judge then. I will repeat, I genuinely  hear no outrage from the business owners I know.

My Accountant employs 60 people. He tells me it is going to cost him £40K a year. Guess how he proposes to fund this?
You did know the economy was tanked and we need to raise more money? Or did you want another 5 years of heads in the sand. We have to start paying.

Yes.

What are you paying, exactly, over and above what you were before the budget? Why should small businesses wholly carry the burden? Reverse the NI reductions, add some Petrol duty, put a penny on Income Tax. Share the burden, don't cripple businesses instead. 1p on Employers NI, and share the rest around.