WBAUnofficial
England v SL - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: England v SL (/showthread.php?tid=34813)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: England v SL - richbaggie - 09-09-2024

(09-09-2024, 10:07 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-09-2024, 10:00 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(09-09-2024, 09:51 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm not ignoring the previous 5 Tests, no. But let's not pretend we've just beat two good Nations by playing a wonderful faultless brand of cricket, eh?

Let's see how it fairs against Australia next winter. I have a strong suspicion we'll see a similar result to what happened against the last good Nation we faced, India.

We've played really well for 5 tests with a better version of Bazball. It's been measured and thoughtful, attacking without being gung ho. This last test, under Pope, has been a mess but yiu are suggesting that this is the way we are going to approach the Aussies.
How would you like to approach them if not bazball mk2.
Approach them by playing to the conditions, play each ball on its merit and don't gift wickets away. 

No silly decelerations that gives the opposition a chance. And fields that won't leak runs. Wickets will come with good, sensible, bowling.

Which is how we've played 5 out of 6 tests this summer. Even Jonathan Agnew, who wasn't a fan of the earlier style, has been applauding it.


RE: England v SL - Ted Maul - 09-09-2024

(09-09-2024, 10:18 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(09-09-2024, 10:07 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-09-2024, 10:00 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(09-09-2024, 09:51 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm not ignoring the previous 5 Tests, no. But let's not pretend we've just beat two good Nations by playing a wonderful faultless brand of cricket, eh?

Let's see how it fairs against Australia next winter. I have a strong suspicion we'll see a similar result to what happened against the last good Nation we faced, India.

We've played really well for 5 tests with a better version of Bazball. It's been measured and thoughtful, attacking without being gung ho. This last test, under Pope, has been a mess but yiu are suggesting that this is the way we are going to approach the Aussies.
How would you like to approach them if not bazball mk2.
Approach them by playing to the conditions, play each ball on its merit and don't gift wickets away. 

No silly decelerations that gives the opposition a chance. And fields that won't leak runs. Wickets will come with good, sensible, bowling.

Which is how we've played 5 out of 6 tests this summer. Even Jonathan Agnew, who wasn't a fan of the earlier style, has been applauding it.

It's a perfectly valid criticism of this team to point out that even when we win we throw wickets away and that in this test match our attitude and approach has been borderline disrespectful given how we talk about "saving test cricket".


RE: England v SL - richbaggie - 09-09-2024

(09-09-2024, 10:34 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-09-2024, 10:18 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(09-09-2024, 10:07 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-09-2024, 10:00 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(09-09-2024, 09:51 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I'm not ignoring the previous 5 Tests, no. But let's not pretend we've just beat two good Nations by playing a wonderful faultless brand of cricket, eh?

Let's see how it fairs against Australia next winter. I have a strong suspicion we'll see a similar result to what happened against the last good Nation we faced, India.

We've played really well for 5 tests with a better version of Bazball. It's been measured and thoughtful, attacking without being gung ho. This last test, under Pope, has been a mess but yiu are suggesting that this is the way we are going to approach the Aussies.
How would you like to approach them if not bazball mk2.
Approach them by playing to the conditions, play each ball on its merit and don't gift wickets away. 

No silly decelerations that gives the opposition a chance. And fields that won't leak runs. Wickets will come with good, sensible, bowling.

Which is how we've played 5 out of 6 tests this summer. Even Jonathan Agnew, who wasn't a fan of the earlier style, has been applauding it.

It's a perfectly valid criticism of this team to point out that even when we win we throw wickets away and that in this test match our attitude and approach has been borderline disrespectful given how we talk about "saving test cricket".

And it's perfectly valid to point out that this match has been very different to the previous 5 and it's clear that the approach of the 1st 5 tests this summer is the way Stokes and McCullum want us to play.

It seems harsh to judge a summer and the future on one bad performance.


RE: England v SL - Josh1873 - 09-09-2024

I haven't judged the summer. I'm judging the whole tenure of McCullum. I don't doubt it's been somewhat successful in restoring pride to the National side, in so far as we've won series against sides we should be winning series against, with respect to the likes of Sri Lanka and West Indes, but we've also struggled, still, against the likes of India and Australia. Albeit we gave India a couple of thumpings when we finished the COVID affected series.

I am very aware I'm in the minority, I'm self aware of that. But for me, I can hand on heart say I haven't enjoyed this style as much as the majority of people have. If I want to see batsman throw wickets away and try and hit every ball for a boundary I'll got and watch the T20. You need more about you in the Test environment, and that's why I love the format.

Everything England have done over the last 3 years or so, has been to disregard everything I like about red ball cricket in favour of bringing in whiteball mentality. It's worked to a degree, granted, but it hasn't really moved us any closer to our ultimate aim - beating Australia in Australia. I genuinely don't believe this style will work down under.

Hopefully I'm wrong. I just can't see it.

What we did in white ball cricket was superb. That was a real revolution that moved the format on. I genuinely don't believe we've achieved that at red ball level. Otherwise other nations would be copying us. They haven't because Test cricket hasn't changed much in over 100 years in that you need to play to the conditions and play with respect of the opposition and those conditions, be able to 'dig in' during tough conditions and good bowling. And that will be the case for as long as we have Test cricket. That's the beauty of the format to me.

In fairness to McCullum he was appointed to do exactly what he's done and he's done the job the ECB and Rob Key wanted. My issue isn't with him, or the players, at all. They're doing what they're coached and asked to do, and McCullum is doing what he was brought into to do. And it's somewhat worked.

It's just a style I don't enjoy. That's on me, but it's an opinion I'm entitled to!


RE: England v SL - richbaggie - 09-09-2024

(09-09-2024, 11:01 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I haven't judged the summer. I'm judging the whole tenure of McCullam. I don't doubt it's been somewhat successful in restoring pride to the National side, in so far as we've won series against sides we should be winning series against, with respect to the likes of Sri Lanka and West Indes, but we've also struggled, still, against the likes of India and Australia. Albeit we gave India a couple of thumpings when we finished the COVID affected series.

I am very aware I'm in the minority, I'm self aware of that. But for me, I can hand in heart say I haven't enjoyed this style as much as the majority of people have. If I want to see batsman throw wickets away and try and hit every ball for a boundary I'll got and watch the T20. You need more about you in the Test environment, and that's why I love the format.

Everything England have done over the last 3 years or so, has been to disregard everything I like about red ball cricket in favour of bringing in whiteball mentality. It's worked to a degree, granted, but it hasn't really moved us any closer to our ultimate aim - beating Australia in Australia. I genuinely don't believe this style will work down under.

Hopefully I'm wrong. I just can't see it.

You are judging it on the previous approach and not this summer and predicting defeat because of how we played before this summer.

I have that right?


RE: England v SL - Josh1873 - 09-09-2024

I don't think the approach has changed as much as you like to think.

We've played weaker sides this summer. I wouldn't judge too much on Test series wins v Windes and Sri Lanka.


RE: England v SL - Beachboysbaggie - 09-09-2024

(09-09-2024, 07:49 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(09-09-2024, 07:29 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(09-08-2024, 06:13 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: I agree with Josh a bit here in fairness and I don't advocate moving back to the type of cricket we played under Silverwood or Bayliss. There are a few things that have happened in this game that shouldn't be tolerated under any regime.

Ben Duckett is the best opener we've had since Cook or Strauss retired but he sits on three hundreds, it should be double that number. A player who regularly makes 60-80 and throws it away trying reverse scoops when the situation simply doesn't fall for it. His second innings dismissal would be a disgrace in any situation, it's not like we needed to go that hard in the best batting conditions of the match.

Harry Brook first innings visibly stroppy at the crease as he doesn't have the footwork or the patience to realise what the Sri Lankan plan to him is before cheaply getting out to it.

There have been some real positives to this team in the last three summers and we shouldn't overlook the fact that this conversation is happening during what looks like our first loss in five games. It's great that we have some stability and have found a stable of fast bowlers that have good pace and some variation. However, with all eyes on Australia we simply cannot go there and score flashy 80s on flat decks. The team that won there in 10-11 didn't have bags of pace but we did have batsmen who would cash in on flat decks. Still, it's an evolving approach and they've definitely earned enough time to try and get it right.

Excellent post. 

There's been some brilliant moments, and I understand what we're trying to do. I'm not denying it hasn't been positive moments. 

However, I just really dislike the arrogance of believing you don't need to play a varied style and the refusal to play to the conditions and the match situation. 

Why can't you be aggressive when it suits but then revert to sensible (not negative in any way) cricket. We had a lead of 70 with 3 days left. We didn't need to go at it at 100mph and give wickets away in a needless fashion. It's pig headed arrogance, and it's annoys me. 

As for improving results. Not when we face a competitive Test playing nations. 

Lost to India 4-1. Drew the Ashes. Drew a series v NZ. 

But it's OK. Because we beat Ireland in a one off Test, beat the worst Windies side in living memory and have beat a competitive Sri Lanka side, that we should be beating in the last two years. The aggressive style hasn't produced the dominant results people seem to make out. Yes it's better than the previous regime, but that was so bad it would have been impossible to not improve. 

I'm not sold on it. We seem to be intent on reinventing the wheel. We don't need that. We just need to be more pragmatic and sensible. We need to be more ruthless and not so stubborn and throw games away. Would Australia have gifted a game away like we have? No. They have the right mentality to go for the juggler and kill a game off when they're on top. That's nothing to with style but mentality.

It's great that they're trying something different and to be honest, we are watchable even if sometimes it's a bit of a hate watch. Point remains though, we absolutely will not regularly challenge the likes of India and Australia whilst our batters have such an obnoxious approach to giving away their wickets. We seem to have zero interest in grinding out a win anymore, we'd rather lose quickly.

Seems as though you're not alone in this Josh, a number of the prominent cricket writers have hammered England in their various columns overnight and this morning.

What about beating NZ at home, South Africa, winning 3-0 in Pakistan? Or aren’t those competitive test playing nations?
In our previous 2 series in India we lost 3-1 and 4-0, so it’s not as though we were tearing it up there with more conventional approaches than Bazball


RE: England v SL - richbaggie - 09-09-2024

(09-09-2024, 11:13 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't think the approach has changed as much as you like to think.

We've played weaker sides this summer. I wouldn't judge too much on Test series wins v Windes and Sri Lanka.

So articles being written by people with far more knowledge than us, talking about the change in the approach to a more measured approach whilst still looking to be positive are wrong and you are right?


RE: England v SL - Ted Maul - 09-09-2024

I've said it's been good but it's not immune from criticism.

Our approach in the first two tests last summer cost us the Ashes, not the weather and I'm concerned by the approach we've shown to this game. It's been arrogant and disrespectful.

We have found some good players and sometimes they're capable of better than what they're seemingly asked to go out and do.


RE: England v SL - richbaggie - 09-09-2024

(09-09-2024, 11:39 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: I've said it's been good but it's not immune from criticism.

Our approach in the first two tests last summer cost us the Ashes, not the weather and I'm concerned by the approach we've shown to this game. It's been arrogant and disrespectful.

We have found some good players and sometimes they're capable of better than what they're seemingly asked to go out and do.

It's clear we've played appallingly this test match but it's not right to base negativity around 1 bad performance in a dead rubber and ignore the positive changes made to the approach in the previous 5.