WBAUnofficial
Shilen Patel - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Shilen Patel (/showthread.php?tid=34575)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: Shilen Patel - Kit Kat Chunky - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 12:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 12:23 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Patel is a very successful and ethical business man. To spend many millions and not have a plan for the club is laughable. Of course there's a plan. It will be disclosed as and when he feels the need to. He has earned that right.

Like I said it's as if some folk are looking for a stick to beat him with from the outset.

No one is beating the owner with any stick. No one has said the new owner hasn’t got a plan, no one is finding it difficult on here to understand we need to reduce costs and no one has said they want to know the intricacies of any plan that may be put in place. 

What is laughable is the idea that you can’t ask the question whether we shall be perhaps heading down the Ashworth DoF model, if we might be expanding our scouting network abroad etc at this stage. 

The defensive ‘how dare you ask the new owner such question’s’ is a really weird position to take as a fan on a messageboard set up to discuss erm the WBA FC and top five yawn bands of all time.  

This is not a criticism or a moan it’s just curiosity to see what type football model we may take moving forward. Just to help people not go off on one again. 

RS this wasn’t specifically aimed at you but I can’t be arsed to put it as a separate reply now Wink

+1


RE: Shilen Patel - Fulham Fallout - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 12:23 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Patel is a very successful and ethical business man. To spend many millions and not have a plan for the club is laughable. Of course there's a plan. It will be disclosed as and when he feels the need to. He has earned that right.

Like I said it's as if some folk are looking for a stick to beat him with from the outset.

Part of the takeover process involved Patel submitting forecast financial statements to the EFL for the next 3 years. 

No doubt the high level of which he doesn’t want to share with the fans as it won’t make enjoyable reading. 

So yes, there have been plans, long before the deal was authorised.


RE: Shilen Patel - Tom Joad - 08-01-2024

I personally don't think it would be ideal if the owner came out and said. "I'll probably sack all the scouting staff and appoint a Director of Football". Or " If Carlos goes I know just the man who......" I think we all knew what needed to happen, it's just the Internet is full of people who need easy answers. So far, the owner has done exactly as he said in his last statement. I'm hoping we might get another statement, probably at the end of the window.


RE: Shilen Patel - SW4Baggie - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 01:31 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 12:23 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote: Patel is a very successful and ethical business man. To spend many millions and not have a plan for the club is laughable. Of course there's a plan. It will be disclosed as and when he feels the need to. He has earned that right.

Like I said it's as if some folk are looking for a stick to beat him with from the outset.

Part of the takeover process involved Patel submitting forecast financial statements to the EFL for the next 3 years. 

No doubt the high level of which he doesn’t want to share with the fans as it won’t make enjoyable reading. 

So yes, there have been plans, long before the deal was authorised.

I think those plans are nothing more than proof of finance for us as an ongoing concern. With our debts and losses it’s a positive he was able to satisfy those needs so easily


RE: Shilen Patel - TartanRug - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 02:58 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I personally don't think it would be ideal if the owner came out and said. "I'll probably sack all the scouting staff and appoint a Director of Football". Or " If Carlos goes I know just the man who......"  I think we all knew what needed to happen, it's just the Internet is full of people who need easy answers. So far, the owner has done exactly as he said in his last statement. I'm hoping we might get another statement, probably at the end of the window.

I think that would be helpful. It would be good if he at some point if he had a Q&A session either at the club with fans or on WM or something like that, he doesn't have to reveal anything top secret or that it isn't appropriate to discuss at the time. Would help keep fans onside and keep the positivity of the new ownership going IMHO


RE: Shilen Patel - Fulham Fallout - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 03:07 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 02:58 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I personally don't think it would be ideal if the owner came out and said. "I'll probably sack all the scouting staff and appoint a Director of Football". Or " If Carlos goes I know just the man who......"  I think we all knew what needed to happen, it's just the Internet is full of people who need easy answers. So far, the owner has done exactly as he said in his last statement. I'm hoping we might get another statement, probably at the end of the window.

I think that would be helpful. It would be good if he at some point if he had a Q&A session either at the club with fans or on WM or something like that, he doesn't have to reveal anything top secret or that it isn't appropriate to discuss at the time. Would help keep fans onside and keep the positivity of the new ownership going IMHO

If you saw the S4A questions posed and the answers, you’d know there’d be lots of questions the fans would ask that are sensitive. Eg what are the terms of the MSD loan?


RE: Shilen Patel - Woodman scoreboard - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 10:55 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: The kind of response I expected from most.  Always go straight to the extreme end of any argument to ridicule someone when it's not what has been said at all.  Why do people feel the need to win the internet every 5 minutes. 

The letter in June addressed nothing really other than to say he knew we had to work to different financial constraints.

"In short, that means we will need to be resourceful, process-driven, and open-minded to get the most out of the flexibility we have or can create in the market. It is never easy to restock a squad, but this summer is also an opportunity to build a foundational sporting philosophy and practices for long-term success. It has been a full-scale collaboration amongst our recruitment staff, Carlos and his coaches, and management to find and secure players representing our game model and long-term vision."

That's mostly waffle with a bit of management speak thrown in.

No one needs to know the intricate detail, just enough of his vision and how he sees us operating in the future, I don't see that as giving anything.  Maybe I have no right to ask and just have to accept that our recruitment will be "resourceful", "process-driven" and "flexible".  You'd assume that's a fucking given for every club, it's hardly a strategy.

Ashworth was very good with communication and open about how he wanted us to run, the ideas behind it all etc.  I'm hoping for something similar from Shilen (or for him to employ someone to do that role), which would be a good PR move on the eve of a season and people can see (as expected) quality players leaving and an awful lot of replacing to do.

Sell high buy low for a few seasons until we have. Got rid of ffp .....I don't think it's nothing he has said and rely on the academy to prop us up .


RE: Shilen Patel - Kit Kat Chunky - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 03:14 PM)Fulham Fallout Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 03:07 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 02:58 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: I personally don't think it would be ideal if the owner came out and said. "I'll probably sack all the scouting staff and appoint a Director of Football". Or " If Carlos goes I know just the man who......"  I think we all knew what needed to happen, it's just the Internet is full of people who need easy answers. So far, the owner has done exactly as he said in his last statement. I'm hoping we might get another statement, probably at the end of the window.

I think that would be helpful. It would be good if he at some point if he had a Q&A session either at the club with fans or on WM or something like that, he doesn't have to reveal anything top secret or that it isn't appropriate to discuss at the time. Would help keep fans onside and keep the positivity of the new ownership going IMHO

If you saw the S4A questions posed and the answers, you’d know there’d be lots of questions the fans would ask that are sensitive. Eg what are the terms of the MSD loan?

We have to be realistic, FF. S4A always ask questions that they know the company will not answer. I would have hoped he could say though "It makes no sense to repay the loans now" (which he has said) "but don't worry, I will ensure they are fully repaid before they expire", for example. At the moment we don't know if he plans to repay them, extend them, refinance them. He has been silent on the matter.


RE: Shilen Patel - CA Baggie - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 11:40 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 08:25 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Come on man, step up a bit now.  

We’re all grateful for you coming in and getting rid of our Chinese nightmare and almost all of us understand the pressures we face this season.  High earners have to go, players with a value or approaching end of contracts too and we know we won’t replace with the same, they will hopefully be up and coming players in the main.

We need to see that there’s a plan in place,  a DoF who will overhaul the scouting system that is based on the club, not the individual manager, an ethos of how the club will play that can run through the club etc.  CC is a good coach and well liked but the reality is I doubt he’s fully unpacked all the boxes at his house, he’d go this afternoon if the right offer came his way.  And eventually it will.

I may be being impatient but just an idea would help, I have faith that you’ll do the right thing for us, the PR is certainly better than Lai’s.  We’ve made a couple of leftfield signings that don’t seem to follow the historical workings of Ian Pearce, I hope we’re not being too CC centric.  It can’t revolve around him.

Give us a vision of how you see it working so that it doesn’t become blind faith.  Keep the morale high of the fan base with off field improvements as I suspect on the pitch might be a difficult season as people need to adjust to our new standing. We have a fan base where most 30 and under don’t remember anything other than PL or expectation of promotion. The natives are ugly enough without the mood getting ugly too.

Laughing at this. 

Read his articles. 

There is most definitely a plan! First time in years.

What's the plan Ronald?  I know so far it's to move high earners and players with value on to adhere to FFP.  

What's the vision of what we'll look like after that?  Are re going to continue to rely on Ian Pearce to source players, is CC going to do it or are we looking to appoint a DoF?  Are we going to create a playing style that runs through the club so that we can seamlessly appoint managers to fit the squad the club has or are we going to continue to lurch from one playing style to another so that the squad doesn't fit the latest incumbent?

There must be a plan beyond just complying with FFP, I'm merely thinking now is the time to share it.


RE: Shilen Patel - Woodman scoreboard - 08-01-2024

(08-01-2024, 03:28 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 11:40 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote:
(08-01-2024, 08:25 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Come on man, step up a bit now.  

We’re all grateful for you coming in and getting rid of our Chinese nightmare and almost all of us understand the pressures we face this season.  High earners have to go, players with a value or approaching end of contracts too and we know we won’t replace with the same, they will hopefully be up and coming players in the main.

We need to see that there’s a plan in place,  a DoF who will overhaul the scouting system that is based on the club, not the individual manager, an ethos of how the club will play that can run through the club etc.  CC is a good coach and well liked but the reality is I doubt he’s fully unpacked all the boxes at his house, he’d go this afternoon if the right offer came his way.  And eventually it will.

I may be being impatient but just an idea would help, I have faith that you’ll do the right thing for us, the PR is certainly better than Lai’s.  We’ve made a couple of leftfield signings that don’t seem to follow the historical workings of Ian Pearce, I hope we’re not being too CC centric.  It can’t revolve around him.

Give us a vision of how you see it working so that it doesn’t become blind faith.  Keep the morale high of the fan base with off field improvements as I suspect on the pitch might be a difficult season as people need to adjust to our new standing. We have a fan base where most 30 and under don’t remember anything other than PL or expectation of promotion. The natives are ugly enough without the mood getting ugly too.

Laughing at this. 

Read his articles. 

There is most definitely a plan! First time in years.

What's the plan Ronald?  I know so far it's to move high earners and players with value on to adhere to FFP.  

What's the vision of what we'll look like after that?  Are re going to continue to rely on Ian Pearce to source players, is CC going to do it or are we looking to appoint a DoF?  Are we going to create a playing style that runs through the club so that we can seamlessly appoint managers to fit the squad the club has or are we going to continue to lurch from one playing style to another so that the squad doesn't fit the latest incumbent?

There must be a plan beyond just complying with FFP, I'm merely thinking now is the time to share it.

Until we comply with ffp which is the most important thing at the moment it's only 6 months in look at man utd 10 years on and still a mess