WBAUnofficial
Natalie Elphicke MP - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Natalie Elphicke MP (/showthread.php?tid=33635)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Protheroe - 05-13-2024

(05-13-2024, 07:44 PM)Ossian Wrote: Did you not notice that the post was about the electoral system, not the parties?

I did. The problem is the outcome is likely to be worse as it currently is in Germany where the government can't please any of the people any of the time.

If it's a choice between tweedledumb and tweedumber in the next election here, I dread to think how little real reform could actually get done if the government of the day were to be dependent on the whims of the Nats, exceptionally nutty Greens or the llliberals who I understand are now in favour of burning Christians at the stake in Sutton & Cheam.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Borin' Baggie - 05-14-2024

You understand wrong then.

Fuck me, imagine being so blinkered that you don't see the issue with someone that has said they would struggle to not have their faith influence their voting behaviour being an MP for a liberal party, failed to disclose their past affiliation to a political group that wants this country to be a Christian theocracy during the selection process to the local party membership and was celebrating Fidesz politicians at the last general election. Would you feel comfortable campaigning for someone like that as a self-professed "liberal"? Especially on a thread relating to Labour not doing their due diligence and admitting a disgusting apologist for sexual assault into their Parliamentary party.

Also, FYI, Ed Davey is literally a church going Anglican.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Pontificator - 05-14-2024

(05-13-2024, 05:13 PM)Ossian Wrote: What we are seeing - not for the first time - is the inherent weakness of FPTP.

The electoral system exercises a gravitational pull on both of the potential parties of government; right now it just happens to be the Tories' turn to spiral out of control and Labour's to return to orbit. We need something better; just a pity we don't seem to want it.

In fact it is the strength of FPTP. The main parties need to be centre ground coalitions, broad churches as it were, so the horse trading is done before the GE. PR would give inadequate politicians like Clegg, Farron, Swinson, Davey etc undeserved power and make majorities impossible. Fascists and cranks sitting on the green benches and the largest party unable to deliver a manifesto.  No thanks.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - HawkingsHalfpint - 05-14-2024

(05-12-2024, 04:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote: That's spot on. All politics is simply managerialism these days. There's no soaring oratory, no attempt to win philosophical arguments. Those days are gone, for now.

Starmer is as much a victim of the system that created the opportunity for him as Major, Blair, Brown, Cameron, May or Sunak. I'm not sure what he's doing that so upsets you beyond trying to get elected.

Every time I pay my company's ERS NI bill it makes me sick to the pit of my stomach that I am - in some small way - paying David Cameron's salary. The world would be a better place had his heel-less father pulled out all those years ago. A more stupid female has, for sure, but a more stupid male has never led this country. 

And now - at a time of dreadful, uncertain geopolitical turmoil - he is foreign secretary. It's akin to getting Bruce and Pardew back and telling Corberan he must work with them. 

Anyway - back to topic - politics cheapens itself once again. Labour really should have avoided this one. They don't need to score points on the cheap and it amazes me that they have done so in this instance quite so opportunistically. It doesn't say much for Steamer's ability to gauge opinion beyond being the opposition.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Fido - 05-14-2024

(05-14-2024, 12:04 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You understand wrong then.

Fuck me, imagine being so blinkered that you don't see the issue with someone that has said they would struggle to not have their faith influence their voting behaviour being an MP for a liberal party, failed to disclose their past affiliation to a political group that wants this country to be a Christian theocracy during the selection process to the local party membership and was celebrating Fidesz politicians at the last general election. Would you feel comfortable campaigning for someone like that as a self-professed "liberal"? Especially on a thread relating to Labour not doing their due diligence and admitting a disgusting apologist for sexual assault into their Parliamentary party.

Also, FYI, Ed Davey is literally a church going Anglican.

An actual religious one or a social club/this might win me some votes one?


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Shabby Russian - 05-14-2024

(05-14-2024, 05:40 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(05-13-2024, 05:13 PM)Ossian Wrote: What we are seeing - not for the first time - is the inherent weakness of FPTP.

The electoral system exercises a gravitational pull on both of the potential parties of government; right now it just happens to be the Tories' turn to spiral out of control and Labour's to return to orbit. We need something better; just a pity we don't seem to want it.

In fact it is the strength of FPTP. The main parties need to be centre ground coalitions, broad churches as it were, so the horse trading is done before the GE. PR would give inadequate politicians like Clegg, Farron, Swinson, Davey etc undeserved power and make majorities impossible. Fascists and cranks sitting on the green benches and the largest party unable to deliver a manifesto.  No thanks.

You are correct when you say that the two main parties are essentially coalitions, where the balance of the power in that coalition is determined before an election.

This is a problem not a cause of celebration. In a PR system we the electorate would have a far greater influence of the make up of that coalition. That's democratic. 

So from a left and centre left point of view, the electorate can determine how many social Democrats, greens or Marxists we want representing us in Parliament, and we will therefore influence the makeup of that coalition.

The current system allows a small number of people to effect the horse trading, and I suspect undue influence is given to large donirs to the party.

The end result is that significant elements of the electorate are under represented in Parliament, leading to an undermining of respect by the electorate for our electoral system, leading to greater political apathy and increasing the chances of a small, unrepresentative section of the electorate taking power, because of vastly reduced turnouts.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Derek Hardballs - 05-14-2024

I see I got the usual condescending reply by Proth. I’m just going to point out that some semblance of morality is needed in public office or you end up Johnson who then gets kicked out because he became a liability, dragging politics into the gutter with him. He created a moral vacuum that was filled with the very worst of MPs such as Dorries, Gullis, 30p Lee the list is long and depressing.

I'm accused of political naivety and yet the lack of scruples shown by Johnson and co has damaged the Tory party with voters as much as anything that has happened subsequently. Quite an achievement given the chaos, ineptness and mendacity shown by subsequent anointed PMs.

Returning to Starmer and Elphick, the point missed or ignored for ‘lobbing hand grenades’ purposes was he didn’t need to do it. He doesn’t need her for a vacuous political sugar fix, he would have gained just as much for declining her offer to join the Labour Party.

Morality in politics does matter, the lack of it eventually catches those in power up and eats away at parties that ignore it in the pursuit of ‘winning’. It’s naive to argue to the contrary.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Ossian - 05-14-2024

The idea that "the strength of FPTP" is that it's a safeguard against inadequate politicians gaining power is among the most bizarre propositions I've ever read on here. 

Or anywhere.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Fido - 05-14-2024

(05-14-2024, 07:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I see I got the usual condescending reply by Proth. I’m just going to point out that some semblance of morality is needed in public office or you end up Johnson who then gets kicked out because he became a liability, dragging politics into the gutter with him. He created a moral vacuum that was filled with the very worst of MPs such as Dorries, Gullis, 30p Lee the list is long and depressing.

I'm accused of political naivety and yet the lack of scruples shown by Johnson and co has damaged the Tory party with voters as much as anything that has happened subsequently. Quite an achievement given the chaos, ineptness and mendacity shown by subsequent anointed PMs.

Returning to Starmer and Elphick, the point missed or ignored for ‘lobbing hand grenades’ purposes was he didn’t need to do it. He doesn’t need her for a vacuous political sugar fix, he would have gained just as much for declining her offer to join the Labour Party.

Morality in politics does matter, the lack of it eventually catches those in power up and eats away at parties that ignore it in the pursuit of ‘winning’. It’s naive to argue to the contrary.

Let’s just agree on this point and move on.

(05-14-2024, 07:58 AM)Ossian Wrote: The idea that "the strength of FPTP" is that it's a safeguard against inadequate politicians gaining power is among the most bizarre propositions I've ever read on here. 

Or anywhere.

It’s a high price to keep out the odd extremist every couple of elections, faw shaw.


RE: Natalie Elphicke MP - Pontificator - 05-14-2024

(05-14-2024, 07:58 AM)Ossian Wrote: The idea that "the strength of FPTP" is that it's a safeguard against inadequate politicians gaining power is among the most bizarre propositions I've ever read on here. 

Or anywhere.

You can't have read much then.
Labour consenting to PR would finish them. 
There is no evidence whatsoever that a party/coalition could not form a UK rightwing ruling government under PR and dangerous politicians like Faridge and Tice could be front and centre... Meloni, Ben Gvir  No thanks.