RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - albion_pigeon - 04-11-2019
(04-11-2019, 08:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Just wondered as there seems to be quite a few underwhelmed by our link with the PNE boss who they want.
We don’t want dinosaurs
We don’t want a manager with a blip in their CV
We want them to be young and fking hungry
We want them to play a way we think is the right way
From the list above it’s obvious the job spec is impossible or near to, to please everyone but perhaps fellow posters can give realisticnames of better suited.
You do realise people are paid thousands a week to answer this exact question don't you? I go to work and get paid to do my job, not someone else's.
I'm not happy with Neil as I refuse to believe he's the best choice out of the thousands of coaches out there. It's looks pretty fucking lazy to me.
As others have said I'll get behind him 100% percent if appointed.
RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Hopalong - 04-11-2019
(04-11-2019, 05:19 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: (04-11-2019, 04:57 PM)Hopalong Wrote: (04-11-2019, 09:12 AM)Sliced Wrote: Sacking BD at the point we did could've thrown us into a spiral and absolute chaos, Shan did well to at least ensure we're not going to drop out of the playoffs. Getting anyone in at this point and expecting them to take us up through the playoffs with about 4 games worth of preparation prior and not a full contingent to choose from is a ridiculous ask.
However I'm happy we're at least getting someone in with some football management experience and a decent enough CV. Those who are complaining undoubtedly only had one or two in mind (probably Wagner or Jokanovic) and anyone outside of these would have been given the same reaction. I understand this as making such a bold (or IMO ridiculous) decision to sack a manager in 4th with a few weeks of the season left could have possibly been justified by getting in a spectacular alternative. Alex Neil isn't this, however at this point I would say he's in the top 4 of the realistic options out there.
The goalposts have moved. Alex Neil wouldn't have been acceptable a few weeks ago, but we're such a clusterfuck that now it seems like a decent option.
Why would Alex Neil want the poison chalice that's the Albion job? In fact he's already distanced himself from it. 
I don't buy that the managerial job at the Albion is a poisoned chalice.
Yes, we're tight. But at least that means we're a financially stable club, that doesn't need to flash sale our assets just to keep the club alive.
We have enough playing staff with sellable value to allow any manager to be appointed, and mould a squad in his own image.
I know with each season at this level, promotion gets more and more difficult, but going into next season we have a good enough chance to go up, to be attractive to a new manager.
We have a promising academy which is starting to produce some excellent talent.
We have top training facilities, a good stadium, which produces a loud atmosphere, and we generally have a patient and understanding fan base.
Is the job 'that' bad? There are worse clubs to manage, out there.
Note the winkey! 
(04-11-2019, 01:03 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: (04-11-2019, 11:57 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: Odd position Neil is in. A lot of assumptions being made?
The media was reporting he was Celtic bound. But atm it's all speculation.
We could do worse, depends if Jenkins and Dowling back him.
Who ever comes in has a massive task to complete.
We basically need a complete new team, we cannot continue with the failures we have.
Nice to see Shan stating hoof the ball out of defence stop messing about and I'm glad he has said it in public.
This puts the onus where it belongs with the players.
Just how do you propose we get a new team? Take the current ones to a car boot sale? Pop in Squads R Us? Shedding quality players is one thing but replacing is another ball ache game. We struggled to attract quality when we were top half of the Prem. All these shit players everyone keeps slagging off would be most welcome at other clubs. Majority on here were shouting to fuck off Rondon all last season. We won't get him back now and he's still our player ffs. They ain't as shite as you think. Players have been berated on here while being picked to represent their countries.
5 loanees returned;
Barry, Brunt, Morrison, Mears, Hoolahan OOC;
Rondon, Dawson, Hegazi, Burke, Gibbs, Livermore, Phillips, Rodriquez sold.
Now we probably won't see all those listed above but that's 18 players who could be gone and with wages about 100m to play with!
I'd be OK with Neil but long way to go to get him.
They'll probably beat us Saturday for one thing!
RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - TETLEY74 - 04-11-2019
(04-11-2019, 10:39 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm underwhelmed but I can and will get behind it.
Same here but if it is him will give him my full support and benefit of the doubt I just hope for 2 things who ever comes in
1. The board and fans give them time to completely rebuild the club top to bottom wether we go up or not and not get on their backs at the first sign of a bad run, we've been there before and it doesn't end well.,2/3 years imho to rebuild properly.
2. Whoever it is as soon as they get in sort out the clique & fuggin egos and put them in their place or fugg them off.
RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Remi_Moses - 04-11-2019
(04-11-2019, 07:48 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (04-11-2019, 10:39 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm underwhelmed but I can and will get behind it.
Same here but if it is him will give him my full support and benefit of the doubt I just hope for 2 things who ever comes in
1. The board and fans give them time to completely rebuild the club top to bottom wether we go up or not and not get on their backs at the first sign of a bad run, we've been there before and it doesn't end well.,2/3 years imho to rebuild properly.
2. Whoever it is as soon as they get in sort out the clique & fuggin egos and put them in their place or fugg them off.
T74 +100%
RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Mancbaggies - 04-11-2019
(04-11-2019, 08:16 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (04-11-2019, 07:48 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (04-11-2019, 10:39 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm underwhelmed but I can and will get behind it.
Same here but if it is him will give him my full support and benefit of the doubt I just hope for 2 things who ever comes in
1. The board and fans give them time to completely rebuild the club top to bottom wether we go up or not and not get on their backs at the first sign of a bad run, we've been there before and it doesn't end well.,2/3 years imho to rebuild properly.
2. Whoever it is as soon as they get in sort out the clique & fuggin egos and put them in their place or fugg them off.
T74 +100%
Bang on
Fitness, energy and pace all priorities.
RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Remi_Moses - 04-11-2019
(04-11-2019, 08:17 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: (04-11-2019, 08:16 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (04-11-2019, 07:48 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (04-11-2019, 10:39 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm underwhelmed but I can and will get behind it.
Same here but if it is him will give him my full support and benefit of the doubt I just hope for 2 things who ever comes in
1. The board and fans give them time to completely rebuild the club top to bottom wether we go up or not and not get on their backs at the first sign of a bad run, we've been there before and it doesn't end well.,2/3 years imho to rebuild properly.
2. Whoever it is as soon as they get in sort out the clique & fuggin egos and put them in their place or fugg them off.
T74 +100%
Bang on
Fitness, energy and pace all priorities.
Exactly why Barnes looked like a world class player - because our players are simply no up to the task. Relegation and 3 managers + Shan shows the need for us to admit its time our current players (or most of them) are not capable of the level of football we require.
We need some leaders on the pitch - we never replaced Fletcher / Olsson & Evans IMO.
RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Mancbaggies - 04-11-2019
(04-11-2019, 08:36 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (04-11-2019, 08:17 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: (04-11-2019, 08:16 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (04-11-2019, 07:48 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (04-11-2019, 10:39 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm underwhelmed but I can and will get behind it.
Same here but if it is him will give him my full support and benefit of the doubt I just hope for 2 things who ever comes in
1. The board and fans give them time to completely rebuild the club top to bottom wether we go up or not and not get on their backs at the first sign of a bad run, we've been there before and it doesn't end well.,2/3 years imho to rebuild properly.
2. Whoever it is as soon as they get in sort out the clique & fuggin egos and put them in their place or fugg them off.
T74 +100%
Bang on
Fitness, energy and pace all priorities.
Exactly why Barnes looked like a world class player - because our players are simply no up to the task. Relegation and 3 managers + Shan shows the need for us to admit its time our current players (or most of them) are not capable of the level of football we require.
We need some leaders on the pitch - we never replaced Fletcher / Olsson & Evans IMO.
IMO, as well as the apparent confusion between the styles preached by GJ and DM, there seems a massive disparity between the levels of Barnes, Gibbs and Gayle - and then the rest of the plodders who lumber around nowhere near 1st or 2nd balls.
RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Remi_Moses - 04-11-2019
(04-11-2019, 09:32 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: (04-11-2019, 08:36 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (04-11-2019, 08:17 PM)Mancbaggies Wrote: (04-11-2019, 08:16 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote: (04-11-2019, 07:48 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Same here but if it is him will give him my full support and benefit of the doubt I just hope for 2 things who ever comes in
1. The board and fans give them time to completely rebuild the club top to bottom wether we go up or not and not get on their backs at the first sign of a bad run, we've been there before and it doesn't end well.,2/3 years imho to rebuild properly.
2. Whoever it is as soon as they get in sort out the clique & fuggin egos and put them in their place or fugg them off.
T74 +100%
Bang on
Fitness, energy and pace all priorities.
Exactly why Barnes looked like a world class player - because our players are simply no up to the task. Relegation and 3 managers + Shan shows the need for us to admit its time our current players (or most of them) are not capable of the level of football we require.
We need some leaders on the pitch - we never replaced Fletcher / Olsson & Evans IMO.
IMO, as well as the apparent confusion between the styles preached by GJ and DM, there seems a massive disparity between the levels of Barnes, Gibbs and Gayle - and then the rest of the plodders who lumber around nowhere near 1st or 2nd balls.
Oh so true - our complacency is the kiss of death.
RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - Derek Hardballs - 04-11-2019
(04-11-2019, 06:44 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: (04-11-2019, 08:53 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Just wondered as there seems to be quite a few underwhelmed by our link with the PNE boss who they want.
We don’t want dinosaurs
We don’t want a manager with a blip in their CV
We want them to be young and fking hungry
We want them to play a way we think is the right way
From the list above it’s obvious the job spec is impossible or near to, to please everyone but perhaps fellow posters can give realisticnames of better suited.
You do realise people are paid thousands a week to answer this exact question don't you? I go to work and get paid to do my job, not someone else's.
I'm not happy with Neil as I refuse to believe he's the best choice out of the thousands of coaches out there. It's looks pretty fucking lazy to me.
As others have said I'll get behind him 100% percent if appointed.
It was simply a talking point. Managers, coaches and players get paid thousands a week to manage, coach and play the game and yet we all have an opinion on where they are going wrong and who should be playing, what the coaches should be coaching and how the manager should manage. The question is as valid / pointless as the rest asked on here.
(04-11-2019, 07:48 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: (04-11-2019, 10:39 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I'm underwhelmed but I can and will get behind it.
Same here but if it is him will give him my full support and benefit of the doubt I just hope for 2 things who ever comes in
1. The board and fans give them time to completely rebuild the club top to bottom wether we go up or not and not get on their backs at the first sign of a bad run, we've been there before and it doesn't end well.,2/3 years imho to rebuild properly.
2. Whoever it is as soon as they get in sort out the clique & fuggin egos and put them in their place or fugg them off.
There is very little chance that the club will allow any manager years to rebuild unless they are getting positive results. A manager could spend years rebuilding it doesn’t mean the final build will have firm foundations or be better than the existing squad.
RE: For those criticising / sceptical about Neil please give your alternatives - chasetownbaggie - 04-12-2019
Still waiting for someone to answer the question in the thread title.
|