WBAUnofficial
Nigel Farage's Bank Account - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Nigel Farage's Bank Account (/showthread.php?tid=30588)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Nigel Farage's Bank Account - Ted Maul - 07-27-2023

(07-27-2023, 08:45 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-27-2023, 06:39 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Are you daft - the leader is about the leak of data and the resignation of the CEO causing shares to crash. The leak of data was the problem, the bank should have simply stuck to its original decision of offering him a different non-premium account.

Talk about getting the issue mixed up and being ‘wholly wrong’.

<sigh>

Not my words. God help us all if you're in, or ever find yourself in a position where you influence these type of decisions. 

"As a reputation management exercise, the Coutts review of Nigel Farage’s account with the bank went about as badly as it possibly could.
The minutes of the bank’s wealth reputational risk committee, which Mr Farage obtained by the simple legal expedient of a subject access request, reveal that executives were worried that having Mr Farage as a customer might reflect badly on the bank’s wish to be seen as “inclusive”.

So they concocted a case for closing his account, which mentioned the modesty of the amount of money in it, but which mainly rested on the perception of Mr Farage by much of liberal opinion as a xenophobe.

From this original misjudgement, further errors followed. Dame Alison Rose, the chief executive of Coutts’s parent, NatWest, in an unattributable conversation at a City dinner gave Simon Jack, the BBC’s business editor, to believe that the account had been closed because it did not meet the threshold required.

Not only did this disclose confidential details of Mr Farage’s account, but it was doubly misleading. Many of Coutts’s customers are allowed to keep accounts that fall below the threshold, especially if, as in Mr Farage’s case, the drop is expected to be temporary. But critically, as the minutes reveal, this was not the main reason for closing Mr Farage’s account.

When Dame Alison admitted on Tuesday that she was the source of the BBC’s misleading report, NatWest’s chair, Sir Howard Davies, and the other directors decided that the double blow to the banking group’s reputation had not been serious enough. Not only had it closed someone’s account because of their political views and its chief executive had caused an untrue version of events to be published, but its board now decided to stand by Dame Alison, declaring that it had “full confidence” in her.

By then, the public relations disaster had become so great that some members of the board realised the position they had taken on Tuesday morning was unsustainable. The prime minister and the chancellor had expressed their concern. They did so not because they represent the British people, who own 39 per cent of NatWest, but because ministers have rightly chosen to stay out of operational matters. And they did so in defence of the universal principle of free speech – that services should not be denied to anyone on account of their political beliefs.

A further board meeting was convened on Zoom for 11pm on Tuesday night to bow to the inevitable. Dame Alison would step down “by mutual consent”.
Thus ends the main drama of a salutary tale for our times. There will be aftershocks, as Mr Farage calls for the rest of the NatWest board to resign, and the opposition accuse ministers of being readier to defend the former leader of Ukip and the Brexit Party than the “ordinary” victims of other forms of corporate malpractice.

But it is almost universally accepted that Coutts was wrong to “de-bank” Mr Farage, adding a crime against the English language to its other offences to be taken into consideration. If Coutts had been a private members’ club, with a boutique banking service attached, it might have been able to argue that it would be entitled to choose who to accept or reject as a member.

But as a mere bank, especially an “inclusive” one, and especially one that is a subsidiary of the semi-nationalised NatWest, it could not deny a service to someone on grounds of their politics. Mr Farage is not a terrorist or a money launderer. The Independent disagrees with many of his opinions. Indeed, we disagree with him so much that he was, for a time, a regular Independent columnist. When we say we believe in freedom of expression, we mean it.

When Coutts reviewed Mr Farage’s account, one executive pointed out that its customer might go public about the snub, and that this might be a problem for the bank. To which someone should have said, “You think?” and shut down the exercise.

Let us hope that any British company tempted to take virtue signalling too far has learned the lesson of this case study in how to destroy a corporate reputation."


Even the Indy can separate the individual from the issue. You can't. I've read some one-eyed shite on here over the years, hell I've posted a lot myself - but your myopia on this is simply breathtaking.

Blimey! That's quite the defence for Nigel fucking Farage.


RE: Nigel Farage's Bank Account - Shabby Russian - 07-27-2023

In short.

Despite disliking Farages politics, on this issue he is more in the right than the wrong.


RE: Nigel Farage's Bank Account - Protheroe - 07-27-2023

(07-27-2023, 09:08 AM)baggy1 Wrote: You can argue as much 'opinion piece' as you like, ultimately a business can choose who it deals with. One thing we do agree on is the mishandling of this whole situation from the review process to the data leak - I would like to say that to find people as naive as that in positions of power is beyond belief but I see that day in day out.

There is one massive point in all of this that is being completely ignored and it is in the piece you link "And they did so in defence of the universal principle of free speech – that services should not be denied to anyone on account of their political beliefs" - the simple fact is he wasn't denied services, he was offered alternative services that weren't premium. However because the narrative is all about his political views then that nugget of fact keeps being ignored.

Are you fucking blind?

So they concocted a case for closing his account, which mentioned the modesty of the amount of money in it, but which mainly rested on the perception of Mr Farage by much of liberal opinion as a xenophobe.

Not only did this disclose confidential details of Mr Farage’s account, but it was doubly misleading. Many of Coutts’s customers are allowed to keep accounts that fall below the threshold, especially if, as in Mr Farage’s case, the drop is expected to be temporary. But critically, as the minutes reveal, this was not the main reason for closing Mr Farage’s account.


RE: Nigel Farage's Bank Account - baggy1 - 07-27-2023

Alright, I'll cede on this point. Something that I'd like you to take note of for future discussions.

The bank, and it's review committee and CEO, have been appalling in their handling of the whole situation. They did have the right, under their own rules, to offer Farage alternative banking facilities, which they did, but to not apply that consistently across all customers was the weakness in their point. I will point out that the '1000s of other customers' referred to is still a figure that hasn't been confirmed.

To then follow that up with leaking his information to the press was against the law and should rightly be followed up by the ICO and whether that results in fines for the company, I would expect that as a minimum, and personal sanctions for the CEO, I would expect being disqualified as a directed as a minimum, who knows.

The point still stands though, he hasn't been denied services so to keep repeating that and now set off on a crusade as he is needs to be challenged. If that is allowed to carry on then it will distort where the real issues are here.


RE: Nigel Farage's Bank Account - WorcsWBA - 07-27-2023

Let's face it Farage yearns to be the centre of attention, so is probably struggling with his only relevance being to sit in a pub on the south coast with a metaphorical pitchfork and torch whinging about asylum seekers. Therefore he's seized his opportunity, as a consequence of the press mystifyingly still being so eager to report everything he says and does, and will no doubt be like a dog with a bone over it for weeks to come.

He's a horrible, detestable man.

The media obsessing over this affair, given all the infinitely more important things going on in the world, is a disgrace but nevertheless true to type.


RE: Nigel Farage's Bank Account - Protheroe - 07-27-2023

(07-27-2023, 09:56 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Alright, I'll cede on this point. Something that I'd like you to take note of for future discussions.

The bank, and it's review committee and CEO, have been appalling in their handling of the whole situation. They did have the right, under their own rules, to offer Farage alternative banking facilities, which they did, but to not apply that consistently across all customers was the weakness in their point. I will point out that the '1000s of other customers' referred to is still a figure that hasn't been confirmed.

To then follow that up with leaking his information to the press was against the law and should rightly be followed up by the ICO and whether that results in fines for the company, I would expect that as a minimum, and personal sanctions for the CEO, I would expect being disqualified as a directed as a minimum, who knows.

The point still stands though, he hasn't been denied services so to keep repeating that and now set off on a crusade as he is needs to be challenged. If that is allowed to carry on then it will distort where the real issues are here.

He has been denied services. NatWest refused to offer to replace his business account.

Yes. They do have the right to withdraw services from anyone they want - but it is clear from the minutes of the meeting that the withdrawal of services was far more about him and his views than it was about commercials.

As it is their Reputational Risk committee has trashed their reputation. Bravo them.


RE: Nigel Farage's Bank Account - Derek Hardballs - 07-27-2023

I wouldn’t take his money either.


RE: Nigel Farage's Bank Account - JOK - 07-28-2023

(07-27-2023, 09:08 AM)baggy1 Wrote: There is one massive point in all of this that is being completely ignored and it is in the piece you link "And they did so in defence of the universal principle of free speech – that services should not be denied to anyone on account of their political beliefs" - the simple fact is he wasn't denied services, he was offered alternative services that weren't premium. However because the narrative is all about his political views then that nugget of fact keeps being ignored.

He was offered a personal account only at the, almost literally, last minute by phone when he threatened to go public.

And you seem to ignore the massive Fort Knox bullion of the political implications of their actions.

(07-27-2023, 07:56 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: [Image: F1_bvpRWAAI4Zb2?format=jpg&name=small]

From the renowned lefty newspaper the Telegraph.

Can I just point out that Farage or GB news were not the ones who revealed the bank; that was your beloved BBC.

(07-26-2023, 08:53 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I think you should read both the report and the reason for the resignation JOK. You've fallen for the 'read everything on the internet from accounts that have the same view as me' mistake and not actually read the report.

And the reason that the CEO resigned was for the data privacy breach and not the decision.

I have a question for you though - what are your thoughts these days on the covid vaccine?

That’s a bit rich; your lap dog often tries to ridicule me for researching and referencing multiple sources. My views and opinions are not formed by Guardian and BBC headlines alone.


What has the Covid vaccine got to do with this particular price of bacon?

Here is a question for you in the light of all the revelations; was Farage’s account “Full of shit”?

(07-26-2023, 08:46 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(07-26-2023, 08:39 AM)JOK Wrote:
(07-20-2023, 07:27 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Turns out he is full of shit after all, qu’elle surprise.

The part of the report that said his account was commercially viable included ‘whilst he had a mortgage with them’. He paid off his mortgage and made his account not commercially viable, presumably because of the lack of charges / fees the bank could make whilst there were no mortgage interest payments.

Commercial decision after all - who’d have thought that he was bullshitting all along.

So “full of sh*t” the CEO of the banking group was pressured to apologies and subsequently forced to resign many days later for an action that a teller would have summarily dismissed the next day for. So “full of sh*t” that the BBC have apologised for reporting false information! So “full of sh*t” the CEO admitted that the account was closed for political reasons.
 
I see the BBC finally ‘woke’ up to report Farage’s accounts closing. After ignoring the story for days, it decided to ‘report’ on it to kindly give Coutts version of events by disclosing someone’s personal financial information. Not very ethical of both organizations.
Turns out Coutts were lying and their ex-customer had his account closed because he didn’t “align with their values.” Not for commercial reasons!
BBC’s Simon Jack posted Coutts lie the morning after sitting next to Alison Rose, CEO of Nat West, at a posh nosh. Coincidence?
So much for the much vaunted ‘fact checking’ department!
 
I think, in the light of recent day’s revelations, you have fell off that limb.

(07-20-2023, 07:58 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sunak running to Farage’s aid is cringeworthy. Of all the problems in the country this is the one these numpties feel is worth urgent and vociferous action.

Has Johnson handed over his WhatsApp messages yet?

If you don’t see this as important and just want to dismiss as “culture war”, which is extremely important to very many, then you are clearly in agreement with the attack on free speech and civil liberty. Just because it has happened to one of the focuses of your hate, you find it acceptable. I bet if happened to one of your Stalinist, wet dream, crushes we would have had at least ten threads from you by now.

Re; your WhatsApp messages question, have you answered any of the Myriad of questions I have put to you?

1

Brilliant, insightful, informative reasoned argument as usual.  

Why are you frightened to engage?


RE: Nigel Farage's Bank Account - Derek Hardballs - 07-28-2023

Two…or 2


RE: Nigel Farage's Bank Account - baggy1 - 07-28-2023

In answer to your question JOK, yes the Farage account of events was full of shit. The conjecture and histrionics was typical Farage -

examples of the shit spouted by Farage:
"You can't exist in the world without a bank account, you effectively become a non-person". He was offered a bank account.
"The establishment are trying to force me out of the UK by closing my bank accounts" He was offered a bank account.
The decision may "fundamentally affect [his] future career and whether [he] can even go on staying living here in this country" This is histrionics

The bank report identified the reputational risks of being associated with Farage, something that they are entitled to do as they do get to choose who the interact in business with. Let's not forget this is a business arrangement and both parties have the right to exit that contract, the fact that NatWest have a portion of their shares owned by the state doesn't make them a state bank.

The focus of Farage's commentary is around him being cancelled because of his political views. This is simply not the case, he was being downgraded as a PEP to low risk with a view to removing PEP status entirely at the next planned review; he has been viewed on his personal 'controversial' views of which he has many from climate denial to his views on Russia. Again this, aligned with the public knowledge of him banking with Coutts, posed them risks to their reputation - this is simply a fact.

The commentary around 'there are many others that don't have the funds' is a valid point, however taking into account the combined 'under-funded' accounts and 'reputational risk' elements he does step into a different grouping than just the list of 'under-funded' accounts.

As to your point about who revealed who he banked with, this was already in the public domain - The Times reported in 2019 that fact and this has been repeated on social media widely.

In answer to the original question of was Farage's account 'full of shit' - I think the evidence above shows that it was. It was based on a lot of faux outrage and standing up for the common man. I think it is clear that this isn't the case and it was him throwing his toys out of the pram when a business decides it doesn't want to be associated with him (which is their right).

Do I think the bank have acted well throughout this, no clearly not. They have been extremely naive throughout to the point of ignoring their own advice. Once this broke it should have been handled entirely through a press agent that had a full briefing on what could, and couldn't be said. They've played right into his hands with off record briefings and trying to be clever. I see this a lot with senior managers of large organisations, I assume this comes from them being able to dictate the agenda in their own empire.