WBAUnofficial
Grant - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Grant (/showthread.php?tid=29937)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11


RE: Grant - Beachboysbaggie - 05-10-2023

(05-10-2023, 01:36 PM)wba13 Wrote: Yes you’re right 5 managers all with different styles and he was nearly always played as a striker. None of them played him the way he played at Charlton and Huddersfield cutting in from the left. Even in the last few matches he stayed out left the majority of the time.
As for Beachboy so if Grant hi fives it’s wrong but as plenty of other players do it it does matter. Leave it out and give him a break. At least his shot was on target others missed easier ones but of course they’re not Grant.
I agree he’s not been good for us but it’s not all his fault.

My point was that most players high five when they score, not just when they have a shot. Seems Grant has a lower threshold


RE: Grant - Huggybear - 05-10-2023

I’ve never had a problem with players who come to our club either on a free or a small fee and are low risk.What I do have a problem with are players like Grant who have come on astronomical fees and wages and have given nothing to the club but have taken a lot from the club.
Grant would probably be in my top five hated players and on reflection one of the worst value for money players we have ever had.No speed,no energy and a poor touch with a I don’t care body language.


RE: Grant - Calgary_Baggie - 05-10-2023

(05-10-2023, 03:02 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve never had a problem with players who come to our club either on a free or a small fee and are low risk.What I do have a problem with are players like Grant who have come on astronomical fees and wages and have given nothing to the club but have taken a lot from the club.
    Grant would probably be in my top five hated players and on reflection one of the worst value for money players we have ever had.No speed,no energy and a poor touch with a I don’t care body language.

But but but, he had a non abysmal last few games so there must be a player in there!

Agreed, completely woeful qnd a disastrous appointment.


RE: Grant - SuperBob2002 - 05-10-2023

(05-10-2023, 03:02 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve never had a problem with players who come to our club either on a free or a small fee and are low risk.What I do have a problem with are players like Grant who have come on astronomical fees and wages and have given nothing to the club but have taken a lot from the club.
    Grant would probably be in my top five hated players and on reflection one of the worst value for money players we have ever had.No speed,no energy and a poor touch with a I don’t care body language.

What relevance has money got to do with it? Ultimately he has no influence on the transfer fee he has commanded. That was between us and Huddersfield. Yes, he may have a bigger wage than some of our players, but I'm pretty sure he'd play the same if he was on £10k a week or £100k a week.


RE: Grant - Duffers - 05-10-2023

(05-10-2023, 03:02 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve never had a problem with players who come to our club either on a free or a small fee and are low risk.What I do have a problem with are players like Grant who have come on astronomical fees and wages and have given nothing to the club but have taken a lot from the club.
    Grant would probably be in my top five hated players and on reflection one of the worst value for money players we have ever had.No speed,no energy and a poor touch with a I don’t care body language.


We're getting into the realms of hyperbole here. At least he's actually contributed a few goals.

Chadli, Burke, Anelka, Ideye, Lambert, McMananaman to name a few are all significantly worse when you consider fee + wages against actual contributions.


RE: Grant - Kit Kat Chunky - 05-10-2023

(05-10-2023, 03:11 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 03:02 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve never had a problem with players who come to our club either on a free or a small fee and are low risk.What I do have a problem with are players like Grant who have come on astronomical fees and wages and have given nothing to the club but have taken a lot from the club.
    Grant would probably be in my top five hated players and on reflection one of the worst value for money players we have ever had.No speed,no energy and a poor touch with a I don’t care body language.


We're getting into the realms of hyperbole here. At least he's actually contributed a few goals.

Chadli, Burke, Anelka, Ideye, Lambert, McMananaman to name a few are all significantly worse when you consider fee + wages against actual contributions.

It's a sad but true indictment.


RE: Grant - Stillclem4england - 05-10-2023

(05-10-2023, 03:02 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve never had a problem with players who come to our club either on a free or a small fee and are low risk.What I do have a problem with are players like Grant who have come on astronomical fees and wages and have given nothing to the club but have taken a lot from the club.
    Grant would probably be in my top five hated players and on reflection one of the worst value for money players we have ever had.No speed,no energy and a poor touch with a I don’t care body language.
Nice. I cannot name one strength apart from cutting in from the left onto his right which yielded a total of zero league goals this season. How many games did he play for his paltry sole goal?

These people on here reckoning there is a player in there or he'll come good - what is that based on? He seems a lovely guy? You shouldn't be critical of Albion players? As much chance as Button becoming the next Buffon.


RE: Grant - Huggybear - 05-10-2023

(05-10-2023, 03:08 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 03:02 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve never had a problem with players who come to our club either on a free or a small fee and are low risk.What I do have a problem with are players like Grant who have come on astronomical fees and wages and have given nothing to the club but have taken a lot from the club.
    Grant would probably be in my top five hated players and on reflection one of the worst value for money players we have ever had.No speed,no energy and a poor touch with a I don’t care body language.

What relevance has money got to do with it? Ultimately he has no influence on the transfer fee he has commanded. That was between us and Huddersfield. Yes, he may have a bigger wage than some of our players, but I'm pretty sure he'd play the same if he was on £10k a week or £100k a week.

I agree he can’t control his transfer fee but when I see supporters having a go at players who have contributed to previous promotions and also contributed in the Premier League then I don’t get it.What has Grant contributed to our club?


RE: Grant - SuperBob2002 - 05-10-2023

(05-10-2023, 04:58 PM)Huggybear Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 03:08 PM)SuperBob2002 Wrote:
(05-10-2023, 03:02 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I’ve never had a problem with players who come to our club either on a free or a small fee and are low risk.What I do have a problem with are players like Grant who have come on astronomical fees and wages and have given nothing to the club but have taken a lot from the club.
    Grant would probably be in my top five hated players and on reflection one of the worst value for money players we have ever had.No speed,no energy and a poor touch with a I don’t care body language.

What relevance has money got to do with it? Ultimately he has no influence on the transfer fee he has commanded. That was between us and Huddersfield. Yes, he may have a bigger wage than some of our players, but I'm pretty sure he'd play the same if he was on £10k a week or £100k a week.

I agree he can’t control his transfer fee but when I see supporters having a go at players who have contributed to previous promotions and also contributed in the Premier League then I don’t get it.What has Grant contributed to our club?

18 goals last year in what should have been a promotion push. That's a fair contribution for a striker over the course of a season.


RE: Grant - Cheshire East Baggie - 05-10-2023

18 goals in 45 games last season. Can't say he didn't contribute.

I don't get this player hatred thing. He was the wrong signing, the wrong type of player and for a ridiculous fee. Bilic gets a share of the blame for that as it goes. Grant isn't a centre forward, although he's been asked to play there a lot. He's not a grafter, so quite rightly gets marked down for that. There isn't a role for him in CC's side, in fact I'm not sure what his best role would be. But none of that is his fault.

By contrast, Daryl Dike is a centre forward who hasn't played there much. Can anyone realistically claim that the unlucky lad has contributed more than (or even as much as) Karlan Grant? It's a futile debate, and another opportunity for keyboard warriors to vent their anger. Grant needs to go, no argument.