WBAUnofficial
Karlan Grant - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Karlan Grant (/showthread.php?tid=29607)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Karlan Grant - Cheshire East Baggie - 04-16-2023

(04-16-2023, 08:53 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 08:27 AM)Bilic's Beard Wrote: Out of all the injured players we gave most are out for the season ,does anyone know how long Bartley ,Okay, TGH expect to out as thse will be the only ones to come backninto the squad along with a few of the youngsters.

Nothing has been mentioned about TGH. I think Yokuslu was doubtful for Blackpool on Tuesday.

I don't expect to see Bartley back again this season. He's been injured pretty much ever since he played enough games to trigger an extra year on his contract and I'm sure he can make it last just until May so he doesn't have to lift a finger again this year.

I think that's a fairly harsh commentary on Bartley's injury woes. But there is a case to answer. If you're never fit to play football, you aren't a footballer. Anyone remember Shaun Cunnington? Thought not - 13 games in three seasons. Phillips has been a regular sicknote, but Dike has stolen his place on the podium. Sick Vic is in danger of falling out of the top three, what with Kean Bryan mounting a strong challenge.


RE: Karlan Grant - Man from delmonte - 04-16-2023

(04-16-2023, 10:06 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 08:53 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 08:27 AM)Bilic's Beard Wrote: Out of all the injured players we gave most are out for the season ,does anyone know how long Bartley ,Okay, TGH expect to out as thse will be the only ones to come backninto the squad along with a few of the youngsters.

Nothing has been mentioned about TGH. I think Yokuslu was doubtful for Blackpool on Tuesday.

I don't expect to see Bartley back again this season. He's been injured pretty much ever since he played enough games to trigger an extra year on his contract and I'm sure he can make it last just until May so he doesn't have to lift a finger again this year.

I think that's a fairly harsh commentary on Bartley's injury woes. But there is a case to answer. If you're never fit to play football, you aren't a footballer. Anyone remember Shaun Cunnington? Thought not - 13 games in three seasons. Phillips has been a regular sicknote, but Dike has stolen his place on the podium. Sick Vic is in danger of falling out of the top three, what with Kean Bryan mounting a strong challenge.
Pretty sure every game I saw at the Hawthorns when Cunnington started he went off injured at half time.

I worry with Dike how his injuries will impact him psychologically as well as physically. It was clearly an issue with Anichebe, and with Daniel Sturridge, that he was always sure he was going to pick up a knock or a strain and was never convinced he was properly fit.

As for Bryan, have we ever had a player who has been injured for pretty much his entire contract at the club? He's a damning example of our recruitment in recent years. No due diligence whatsoever. For a player who is such a risk injury-wise why on earth would you give him a 2 year deal? Particularly when they're without a club and hardly have a list of suitors banging down their door.


RE: Karlan Grant - wbamitch - 04-16-2023

Another issue for Dike is that he’s missing so much football at a pivotal stage of his development. Every injury he picks up seems to be months rather than weeks


RE: Karlan Grant - igorbalis - 04-16-2023

my onions fwiw Grant is a natural goal scorer but is not a centre forward, and is unfairly criticised by many due to the price we paid and the circumstances when we signed him, Dike just doesn't cut it for me as he is supposed to be a centre forward but apart from a few flashes he seems so cumbersome, and although physically strong doesnt have any pace and is injury prone.

I'd choose Grant as a number 10, and Asante playing up top. Wasn't Grant our top scorer last season or am I imagining this?


RE: Karlan Grant - Gzbaggy - 04-16-2023

(04-16-2023, 10:06 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 08:53 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 08:27 AM)Bilic's Beard Wrote: Out of all the injured players we gave most are out for the season ,does anyone know how long Bartley ,Okay, TGH expect to out as thse will be the only ones to come backninto the squad along with a few of the youngsters.

Nothing has been mentioned about TGH. I think Yokuslu was doubtful for Blackpool on Tuesday.

I don't expect to see Bartley back again this season. He's been injured pretty much ever since he played enough games to trigger an extra year on his contract and I'm sure he can make it last just until May so he doesn't have to lift a finger again this year.

I think that's a fairly harsh commentary on Bartley's injury woes. But there is a case to answer. If you're never fit to play football, you aren't a footballer. Anyone remember Shaun Cunnington? Thought not - 13 games in three seasons. Phillips has been a regular sicknote, but Dike has stolen his place on the podium. Sick Vic is in danger of falling out of the top three, what with Kean Bryan mounting a strong challenge.

Cunnington was his own worst enemy, throwing himself into tackles and getting himself needlessly injured. As you are old enough to remember Cunnington then what about Tony Rees

I think it was Bill Shankley who said good players don't get injured


RE: Karlan Grant - Bob Fossil - 04-16-2023

I imagine Grant feels unloved and unwanted, certainly looked that way when he was waiting to come on yesterday, and who can blame him. If, however, he can get his mindset to think he has 5, maybe 8 games, to prove what he can do, then he has a real chance to completely turn around his fortunes with our club.
Not many teams can turn to a 19 a season striker at this stage of the season. I just hope he has the fitness and hunger.

The way our luck is though, wouldn’t be a surprise to see him hobble off after 15 mins on Tuesday. Cleary has to be on the bench.


RE: Karlan Grant - Derek Hardballs - 04-16-2023

Personally I think the criticism is completely ott but we always need a pantomime villain in the squad as football fans.

(04-16-2023, 12:10 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 10:06 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 08:53 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 08:27 AM)Bilic's Beard Wrote: Out of all the injured players we gave most are out for the season ,does anyone know how long Bartley ,Okay, TGH expect to out as thse will be the only ones to come backninto the squad along with a few of the youngsters.

Nothing has been mentioned about TGH. I think Yokuslu was doubtful for Blackpool on Tuesday.

I don't expect to see Bartley back again this season. He's been injured pretty much ever since he played enough games to trigger an extra year on his contract and I'm sure he can make it last just until May so he doesn't have to lift a finger again this year.

I think that's a fairly harsh commentary on Bartley's injury woes. But there is a case to answer. If you're never fit to play football, you aren't a footballer. Anyone remember Shaun Cunnington? Thought not - 13 games in three seasons. Phillips has been a regular sicknote, but Dike has stolen his place on the podium. Sick Vic is in danger of falling out of the top three, what with Kean Bryan mounting a strong challenge.

Cunnington was his own worst enemy, throwing himself into tackles and getting himself needlessly injured. As you are old enough to remember Cunnington then what about Tony Rees

I think it was Bill Shankley who said good players don't get injured

Brian Clough, Bryan Robson, Martyn Bennett, Micheal Appleton just off the top of my head that suggest Shankley was wide of the mark with this remark.


RE: Karlan Grant - Gzbaggy - 04-16-2023

With the exception of Robson they were all finished by one bad injury, Robson's injuries were mainly in the early part of his career

We seem to sign players with poor injury records and then are surprised when they are injured here (Bryan and Ancihebe) As other have pointed out older players struggle to come back once they get injured and we have been ruthless in the past with players like this (Mulumby). We have been unlucky with both Dike and Mowatt who were injury free prior to joining us

Overall though a lot of this is down to signing older players, it is hardly surprising the likes of Rogic and Kelly are injured often.


RE: Karlan Grant - Birdman1811 - 04-16-2023

(04-16-2023, 12:10 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 10:06 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 08:53 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(04-16-2023, 08:27 AM)Bilic's Beard Wrote: Out of all the injured players we gave most are out for the season ,does anyone know how long Bartley ,Okay, TGH expect to out as thse will be the only ones to come backninto the squad along with a few of the youngsters.

Nothing has been mentioned about TGH. I think Yokuslu was doubtful for Blackpool on Tuesday.

I don't expect to see Bartley back again this season. He's been injured pretty much ever since he played enough games to trigger an extra year on his contract and I'm sure he can make it last just until May so he doesn't have to lift a finger again this year.

I think that's a fairly harsh commentary on Bartley's injury woes. But there is a case to answer. If you're never fit to play football, you aren't a footballer. Anyone remember Shaun Cunnington? Thought not - 13 games in three seasons. Phillips has been a regular sicknote, but Dike has stolen his place on the podium. Sick Vic is in danger of falling out of the top three, what with Kean Bryan mounting a strong challenge.

Cunnington was his own worst enemy, throwing himself into tackles and getting himself needlessly injured. As you are old enough to remember Cunnington then what about Tony Rees

I think it was Bill Shankley who said good players don't get injured

Ronaldo Nazario wasn't a good player? What a stupid thing to say.


RE: Karlan Grant - Pragmatist - 04-16-2023

I think Grant’s poor body language is the main cause of the criticism against him. He’s clearly not a bad player, although currently short on confidence. Needs to be played in the right role - which he hasn’t been over most of the past year mainly through the long-term injury to Dike and us not having had another striker last season.

He has a golden chance now to perform well over the last 5 games. If he does, then we have a realistic chance of the play-offs.