WBAUnofficial
Linekar wins the tax appeal - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Linekar wins the tax appeal (/showthread.php?tid=29368)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7


RE: Linekar wins the tax appeal - Borin' Baggie - 03-29-2023

(03-29-2023, 02:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 01:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Where we probably won't agree is the cause of the failure and the reason as to why they're a good thing.  The current problem is charities are currently providing core services not just the cherry on top.

If the government collected the right amount of tax and distributed it better then we wouldn't need to do sponsored walks and such.

Government's don't and never will allocate resources efficiently and effectively - surely anyone can see that. Governments also raise receipts by coercion.

Charities are (largely) based on the principles of volunteerism and philanthropy. 

I've probably paid as much in charitable donations as I have in personal taxation over the last few years. At least I know half my money is going to where it's needed.

If charities were the silver bullet you're making them out to be then things like the Newcastle programme, Forster's Education Act, Bannerman's welfare reforms and the Beveridge Report would never have been enacted.


RE: Linekar wins the tax appeal - CA Baggie - 03-29-2023

(03-29-2023, 02:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 01:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Where we probably won't agree is the cause of the failure and the reason as to why they're a good thing.  The current problem is charities are currently providing core services not just the cherry on top.

If the government collected the right amount of tax and distributed it better then we wouldn't need to do sponsored walks and such.

Government's don't and never will allocate resources efficiently and effectively - surely anyone can see that. Governments also raise receipts by coercion.

Charities are (largely) based on the principles of volunteerism and philanthropy. 

I've probably paid as much in charitable donations as I have in personal taxation over the last few years. At least I know half my money is going to where it's needed.

There are some charities that shouldn't have or don't need Government funding, these should rely on volunteerism and philanthropic goodwill.  Things like church roofs etc can be paid for by the church or the local congregation.

Charity money so schools can have specialist equipment for disabled children should never be needed, there are no doubt hundreds of these type of examples where it simply shouldn't be required.

The poor doffing their cap, whilst on bended knee, in gratitude to the Lord of the Manor, for their pennies so little Tiny Tim can get a crutch are hopefully long passed.


RE: Linekar wins the tax appeal - Protheroe - 03-29-2023

(03-29-2023, 02:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 02:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 01:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Where we probably won't agree is the cause of the failure and the reason as to why they're a good thing.  The current problem is charities are currently providing core services not just the cherry on top.

If the government collected the right amount of tax and distributed it better then we wouldn't need to do sponsored walks and such.

Government's don't and never will allocate resources efficiently and effectively - surely anyone can see that. Governments also raise receipts by coercion.

Charities are (largely) based on the principles of volunteerism and philanthropy. 

I've probably paid as much in charitable donations as I have in personal taxation over the last few years. At least I know half my money is going to where it's needed.

If charities were the silver bullet you're making them out to be then things like the Newcastle programme, Forster's Education Act, Bannerman's welfare reforms and the Beveridge Report would never have been enacted.

As usual WBA Unofficial reverts to the binary argument.

Both can co-exist. There are some things government does better, some things charities does better and - whisper it - some things the private sector does better.


RE: Linekar wins the tax appeal - Borin' Baggie - 03-29-2023

(03-29-2023, 02:49 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 02:31 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 02:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 01:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Where we probably won't agree is the cause of the failure and the reason as to why they're a good thing.  The current problem is charities are currently providing core services not just the cherry on top.

If the government collected the right amount of tax and distributed it better then we wouldn't need to do sponsored walks and such.

Government's don't and never will allocate resources efficiently and effectively - surely anyone can see that. Governments also raise receipts by coercion.

Charities are (largely) based on the principles of volunteerism and philanthropy. 

I've probably paid as much in charitable donations as I have in personal taxation over the last few years. At least I know half my money is going to where it's needed.

If charities were the silver bullet you're making them out to be then things like the Newcastle programme, Forster's Education Act, Bannerman's welfare reforms and the Beveridge Report would never have been enacted.

As usual WBA Unofficial reverts to the binary argument.

Both can co-exist. There are some things government does better, some things charities does better and - whisper it - some things the private sector does better.

That was the point in what CA said in the reply you dismissed.

Speaking of binary positions, since when did pointing out the need for welfare coincide with the belief of wanting to abolish the voluntary and private sectors?


RE: Linekar wins the tax appeal - Protheroe - 03-29-2023

(03-29-2023, 03:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That was the point in what CA said in the reply you dismissed.

I don't draw that conclusion from the response "If the government collected the right amount of tax and distributed it better then we wouldn't need to do sponsored walks and such."


RE: Linekar wins the tax appeal - Borin' Baggie - 03-29-2023

(03-29-2023, 03:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 03:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That was the point in what CA said in the reply you dismissed.

I don't draw that conclusion from the response "If the government collected the right amount of tax and distributed it better then we wouldn't need to do sponsored walks and such."

His post started with agreeing that the charity sector was a good thing, the comment to me read that it was the over reliance on charity to cover up failings that fall under the responsibility of government. CA then made another comment clarifying that wherein it's pretty explicitly they were referring to what i inferred from their comment (hence "core services" in the first comment).

But it's me who's being binary?


RE: Linekar wins the tax appeal - Derek Hardballs - 03-29-2023

(03-29-2023, 02:46 PM)CA Baggie Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 02:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 01:25 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Where we probably won't agree is the cause of the failure and the reason as to why they're a good thing.  The current problem is charities are currently providing core services not just the cherry on top.

If the government collected the right amount of tax and distributed it better then we wouldn't need to do sponsored walks and such.

Government's don't and never will allocate resources efficiently and effectively - surely anyone can see that. Governments also raise receipts by coercion.

Charities are (largely) based on the principles of volunteerism and philanthropy. 

I've probably paid as much in charitable donations as I have in personal taxation over the last few years. At least I know half my money is going to where it's needed.

There are some charities that shouldn't have or don't need Government funding, these should rely on volunteerism and philanthropic goodwill.  Things like church roofs etc can be paid for by the church or the local congregation.

Charity money so schools can have specialist equipment for disabled children should never be needed, there are no doubt hundreds of these type of examples where it simply shouldn't be required.

The poor doffing their cap, whilst on bended knee, in gratitude to the Lord of the Manor, for their pennies so little Tiny Tim can get a crutch are hopefully long passed.

Is Proth still trying to pretend that charity should replace the role of the state in looking after those most in need so he can get a stiffy about his small state?

(03-29-2023, 03:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 03:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 03:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That was the point in what CA said in the reply you dismissed.

I don't draw that conclusion from the response "If the government collected the right amount of tax and distributed it better then we wouldn't need to do sponsored walks and such."

His post started with agreeing that the charity sector was a good thing, the comment to me read that it was the over reliance on charity to cover up failings that fall under the responsibility of government. CA then made another comment clarifying that wherein it's pretty explicitly they were referring to what i inferred from their comment (hence "core services").

But it's me who's being binary?

He does this every time the subject comes up. He will start saying you’re belittling the charity and third sector next as his last desperate throw of the dice.


RE: Linekar wins the tax appeal - Protheroe - 03-29-2023

(03-29-2023, 03:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 03:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 03:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That was the point in what CA said in the reply you dismissed.

I don't draw that conclusion from the response "If the government collected the right amount of tax and distributed it better then we wouldn't need to do sponsored walks and such."

His post started with agreeing that the charity sector was a good thing, the comment to me read that it was the over reliance on charity to cover up failings that fall under the responsibility of government. CA then made another comment clarifying that wherein it's pretty explicitly they were referring to what i inferred from their comment (hence "core services" in the first comment).

But it's me who's being binary?

Wow. BB & Me in a different interpretation of the written word. When does that ever happen?


RE: Linekar wins the tax appeal - Borin' Baggie - 03-29-2023

(03-29-2023, 04:01 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 03:05 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 03:02 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-29-2023, 03:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That was the point in what CA said in the reply you dismissed.

I don't draw that conclusion from the response "If the government collected the right amount of tax and distributed it better then we wouldn't need to do sponsored walks and such."

His post started with agreeing that the charity sector was a good thing, the comment to me read that it was the over reliance on charity to cover up failings that fall under the responsibility of government. CA then made another comment clarifying that wherein it's pretty explicitly they were referring to what i inferred from their comment (hence "core services" in the first comment).

But it's me who's being binary?

Wow. BB & Me in a different interpretation of the written word. When does that ever happen?

Maybe you should start reading the full comments you replied to instead of selectively quoting them then? Might help you understand the point someone else is making instead of arguing a straw man and then getting offended when someone calls you out on it.

The reference to "core services" is also hardly ambiguous. As is the fact that CA agreed with you in the first place over there being a role for the voluntary sector.


RE: Linekar wins the tax appeal - CA Baggie - 03-29-2023

To clarify as it seems to be my words you're debating.

Charities have a place to do good work in some areas of society that shouldn't be state funded. The example I gave was the local church roof.

Charities should not be needed to support core services that have been consistently underfunded by government. Again I gave an example, this time of a school requiring specialist equipment. This type of financial support should not be provided by volunteers and philanthropists.

I am not an advocate of a small state, hand downs from the rich doing their Smashy and Nicey charidee work and abusing the goodwill of so many socially conscious people who consistently volunteer to make peoples lives better.

I do a lot of charity accounts work and let me tell you there's good and bad in that sector too, plenty money gets wasted. The simplistic concept of government spending = bad and charity spending = good is simply not true. It also misses the point that core services should never be reliant upon charity.