![]() |
|
Immigration - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Immigration (/showthread.php?tid=27347) |
RE: Immigration - Derek Hardballs - 11-14-2022 So who are going to do all these jobs we have vacancies for and can’t fill? RE: Immigration - Ournextstriker - 11-14-2022 So 40,000 people have tried to enter our country on small boats from France this year Now bearing mind they are usually in small groups of anything from a handful up to 50max each time thats a hell of a lot of small boats Ive got some questions.. Are most of these small boats seized by UK authorities? If so what do they do with them? If not what happens to them? If there were an average of 20 people on each vessel thats 2000 boats, who is supplying them and cant they be traced and prosecuted? RE: Immigration - Protheroe - 11-14-2022 (11-14-2022, 02:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It hasn't acted as a break on investment in other European countries, so your logic doesn't hold up. I didn't ask you about other European countries, I asked you about here. The UK, almost uniquely already had a sclerotic investment problem - since about 1992 - which hasn't been helped by in the last decade by low interest rates allowing marginal companies to continue to operate, and over the last two decades by the massive supply of cheap labour prior to Brexit (never mind Covid & energy prices). The UK also has (and has had for decades) an output per hour 15% lower than the US, Germany or France - again productivity is not helped by a lack of investment and plentiful cheap labour. If you believe the answer to our investment and productivity problems that have prevailed during the era of mass cheap imported EU labour is a return to mass cheap imported labour then I'm not sure I can say any more. (11-14-2022, 03:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So who are going to do all these jobs we have vacancies for and can’t fill? The leaders of every developed economy are asking themselves the same question. To be fair if the vacancies are for shit jobs / conditions and don't come with commensurate compensation then the vacancies don't get filled. It explains why DPD drivers on £15.75 per hour are walking out of their Crawley depot to become baggage handlers on £39 per hour at Gatwick. And why my mate's daughter is nearly 4 times better off working as a locum junior doctor in a London hospital on £50 per hour rather than taking an NHS training contract on £28,000 that wouldn't allow her to live in the capital. RE: Immigration - Borin' Baggie - 11-14-2022 (11-14-2022, 04:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(11-14-2022, 02:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It hasn't acted as a break on investment in other European countries, so your logic doesn't hold up. How am I supposed to point out the root cause of a problem if I can't rebuff your nonsense that it is FoM that is the issue? It isn't, you've just admitted it. There are underlying problems with UK productivity that have nowt to do with FoM, getting rid of FoM will exasperate the issues because nobody is trying to fix them. Here's a possible solution, why not expand the capacity for major regional cities to be able to invest into infrastructure projects independent to input from Westminster? Because only London can do that. The first point of call in fixing a problem is to identify the root causes of the problem, FoM isn't one of them so getting rid of it doesn't fix the problem. Removing FoM isn't going to stimulate investment in automated procedures, technological development or regional skills development. (11-14-2022, 04:44 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(11-14-2022, 03:48 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: So who are going to do all these jobs we have vacancies for and can’t fill? Biased opinion driven by anecdotal evidence. Real wages are decreasing, isolated incidents do not account for the general trend. That is why the 20th decile in Slovenia is higher than the UK and the trend is that they will overtake us on median pay by 2025. RE: Immigration - Protheroe - 11-14-2022 (11-14-2022, 06:48 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Biased opinion driven by anecdotal evidence. How on Earth would you expect median pay to increase markedly in the UK with an open door policy to EU migrants when so many of our sickly companies only survive by paying poor wages? Let them die. RE: Immigration - Borin' Baggie - 11-15-2022 The funny thing here of course is that a former Eastern Bloc country with freedom of movement is on track to overtake a UK with it. So, as shown by the economic powerhouse that is Slovenia, investment into infrastructure, adapting to new technologies and utilising access to the single market to increase productivity, in turn increasing growth and as a result wages from the bottom up. Funny how you can have freedom of movement of labour and still grow. We've not fallen behind Western European states on median salaries because we had freedom of movement, seeing as they all have it as well. Why don't you think of something other than the lump of labour fallacy? Work isn't fixed, Adam Smith and John Locke explained that perfectly clearly. RE: Immigration - Protheroe - 11-15-2022 FoM does not exist in isolation FFS. The UK has a legacy of outdated companies (particularly in retail) who are only able to survive by paying interest cover on debt and poverty level wages. FoM simply sustained them for most of the last decade. They need to die. If FoM was so good for growth, productivity and wage growth then why on Earth has the UK such a poor record on all 3? FoM was just another contributory factor to kicking the can down the road on the creative destruction the economy has been crying out for since 2008. RE: Immigration - Borin' Baggie - 11-15-2022 Because external factors unique to the UK are hindering growth, that was the case pre EEC, pre single market, pre Lisbon Treaty and now post Brexit. It's took 30 years from first proposal to start building a high speed rail link, 50 years to start building it to connect the two largest cities. We started building a full fibre telecoms network in the 80s before the government blocked it from progressing. Our sewage and water network are at capacity for half the population in England because it was built by the Victorians and not improved on. The National Grid is at capacity and can't support any further housing developments on the M4 corridor. Regional cities like Birmingham, Leeds and Bristol are banned by legislation from raising capital for infrastructure investments so have to ask Westminster for money each time even though all 3 cities are net contributers to the Treasury and a lot of their growth was due to being able to raise capital on their own pre 1939. The apprenticeship programme has been mismanaged into complete failure and there's been little access to trade development for people since the 1970s. The UK doesn't try to promote and grow its technological success stories like ARM. The UK has continually voted for and enacted anti-growth policies. What forward thinking government comes out with shit like wanting to ban encryption for crying out loud? In what sensible country blocks the second biggest economic centre from building offices and forces it to tear up its tram network? What forward thinking country tears up arterial rail freight routes? The UK population and politicians since 1945 have actively pursued anti-growth policies. Even Thatcher taking the shackles off London to enable productivity growth there was balanced out by her putting parts of the country into managed decline and destroying productivity in regional service hubs, leading to net productivity decline as a whole for the UK. We've squandered 12 years of cheap debt to develop infrastructure by pursuing a banal fiscal strategy. As shown by every other western European country, you can have freedom of movement while still growing and developing. That isn't and hasn't been the problem and the very fact we're at severe risk of stagflation I would have thought it would be obvious that blocking critical services from being able to work properly and reduced business output would decline productivity in turn reducing growth rates and damaging the pockets of everyone. The French and Danish are more productive than us and they barely work. RE: Immigration - Protheroe - 11-15-2022 I've read that a couple of times and I still don't see how FoM helps the UK. It only adds to our problems and encourages the features of the economy we'd all rather be rid of - low pay and low productivity. RE: Immigration - Borin' Baggie - 11-15-2022 It helps by ensuring businesses can maintain and increase output levels, greater output = greater productivity = growth. This is especially pertinent when you've got historically low unemployment levels, a declining birth rate already below the replacement rate and an aging population with more people becoming economically inactive each year. Freedom of movement of labour is the very antithesis of low productivity. As for low pay, stop parroting the bullshit lump of labour fallacy - open markets = growth and that works with pay, services and goods. I can point to you stagnant pay in Japan or the Soviet Union if you want an example of how restrictive labour markets lead to suppressed pay, or I can point you to most of Western Europe or the US where open labour markets have resulted in higher wages. The real world doesn't agree with your opinion. We did not need to leave the EU to address domestic productivity issues, they were present before we joined the EEC and they're present now we've left the EU, FoM had nothing to do with them and past precedent suggests that even getting rid of FoM won't make a lick of difference because people keep voting for anti-growth policies. |