![]() |
|
Rowett - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Rowett (/showthread.php?tid=27109) |
RE: Rowett - Bob Fossil - 10-13-2022 Simple question I ask myself is, "If Millwall were on telly tonight, would I be getting my beer and popcorn at the ready" Answer is a very quick, "No thanks" It's not about football purism, or the Albion way, I just want us to carry out due diligence and find someone who, at least, believes they can get points without resorting to attrition. I can't believe there is not someone out there who fits that bill and would jump at the chance. RE: Rowett - Derek Hardballs - 10-13-2022 (10-13-2022, 07:13 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:(10-13-2022, 05:49 AM)Pf1ster Wrote: Whether or not it’s Rowett, we are in a position where a “Pulis-style” 1-0 win has to be better than a “nice” draw or loss, surely? Erm he was managing Stoke, Palace and ourselves in the Prem of course he lost more games than he won. Pointless stat. Better record than any of our other managers bar Hodgson in the Prem over a sustained period. The wheels came off at the end for him, and the club but your argument is flawed. RE: Rowett - Cuzer - 10-13-2022 Of all the names linked, this is the most "Classic Albion" appointment you can imagine Absolutely fucking not Cuzer RE: Rowett - richbaggie - 10-13-2022 (10-12-2022, 08:30 PM)MancBaggie Wrote:(10-12-2022, 08:00 PM)richbaggie Wrote: Desperate to get the job I'm hearing. It would be a rather depressing appointment. A mid table championship manager for a mid table championship club. Sadly, after years of mismanagement off and on the pitch, this is where we find ourselves. If we are open to paying compensation, I would much rather someone like Critchley. As for the SB/Gourlay tenure. It was the wrong choice at the time, the wrong choice to not part ways in the summer and then the wrong choice to delay the inevitable. Gourlay was either too close to Bruce, or his hands are just too tied by financial constraints to make the changes he needs to make. RE: Rowett - Ted Maul - 10-13-2022 (10-13-2022, 07:59 AM)Cuzer Wrote: Of all the names linked, this is the most "Classic Albion" appointment you can imagine 100% - it's almost as if Gourlay is trying to piss us off. RE: Rowett - Cunninghamismagic - 10-13-2022 A reputable South London journo (22.5k Twitter followers) believes the links to Rowett are "wide of the mark" [color=#000000FWIW I don't think it's going to happen. All indications I've had are that stories GR is favourite or poised for the job are wide of the mark. RE: Rowett - Cheshire East Baggie - 10-13-2022 (10-13-2022, 07:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(10-13-2022, 07:13 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:(10-13-2022, 05:49 AM)Pf1ster Wrote: Whether or not it’s Rowett, we are in a position where a “Pulis-style” 1-0 win has to be better than a “nice” draw or loss, surely? Pulis never even tried to create the impression that he was building anything for the future. Get to 40 points, relax, don't do anything to build expectations. On the rare occasions he finished in or near the top half it seemed to faze him. On reflection, it's surprising that clubs allowed him to plough his cynical furrow for so long. I don't want to see the Pulis approach at the Albion or anywhere else for that matter. RE: Rowett - Mr vertical - 10-13-2022 (10-13-2022, 08:14 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:(10-13-2022, 07:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(10-13-2022, 07:13 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:(10-13-2022, 05:49 AM)Pf1ster Wrote: Whether or not it’s Rowett, we are in a position where a “Pulis-style” 1-0 win has to be better than a “nice” draw or loss, surely? The wheels coming off at all his clubs coincided with him getting a bigger budget imo - more expensive players had previously received progressive coaching and flagged his up as "dinosaur" (Owen, Tuncay, Chadli, Krychowiak, Gibbs etc. come to mind). The desire to reach the "next level" was his (and our) undoing. RE: Rowett - Shabby Russian - 10-13-2022 On Pulis, is it coincidence that the two clubs he managed for any length of time in the Premier league, have both struggled after he left the club. In both cases for a disconcertingly long period of time. My biggest gripe with him is he seemed incapable of evolving his sides, so what happened was a trusted core of players were kept until they were no longer good enough, and had to be replaced . In our case Foster, Macauley, Ollsson, Fletcher , Brunt, Morriston, Barry, all left the club or retired, in a relatively short period of time, leaving the club needing to fill massive gaps in the squad left by very good players, with little or no resources to replace them. RE: Rowett - B68Baggy - 10-13-2022 Don't think any Albion fan expects Brazil 70 or Pep ball, and historically we are a pretty pragmatic bunch. SGM is revered, particularly by my gen, for being able to win 1-0 at a canter, but that football had its own aesthetic, as at its best it was a team full of strength and leadership all over the park. There was also an acceptance of Pulis ball for a year or so, yes it was anti-football but it got results in the PL until he lost his court case and started managing for a sweet pay off. Val ball was greeted with open arms by most whilst we were winning but it became painful once results fell off the cliff. Even our Uncle Woy, whilst a wonderful coach, was first and foremost a pragmatist with a side drilled to oblivion, but we got results and had some fantastic days. In short, nobody really gives a tuppeny fk if your pragmatic football takes you to the top of the table. Had Val ball's XG been converted to points he'd have been lauded by all but a few purists. However, if your not getting results it can be utterly soul destroying. Can't even tell you why, but those last few months under TTITC were as close to giving up on football as I've ever been. Billic and Moore both played exciting football at times but sections of the crowd still turned and the sack arrived. Bruce was given more time than deserved as the general way of playing was initially more "pleasing on the eye" comparative to Valball but most fans had worked out the team was poorly prepared and coached well b4 Gourmay acted. He may have managed 1000 games, but I've paid to watch a fair few over the last 30 odd years, and I knew it was all BS. So, back to Rowett. On the whole, I don't think Albion fans are too fussed HOW we beat teams we should be beating and if Rowett came in, organised the side, started winning games and climbing the table, his past record or style of play would not be questioned. What I would say is that personality, background and style of football can impact on the amount of time a new manager is given to succeed, and the amount of support he gets from the terraces day one. Would Rowat's name be sung from the terraces on game day one? Probably not. Would Dyche's? Think that would be a yes. For me, I'd be more than willing to give Rowatt a chance based around my, probably rose tinted, worship of SGM (I was a youth bought up on footballing scraps and misery) A pretty modest record on arrival he took things back to basics, made us hard to beat and strengthened positions of real weakness (two full backs and a CB were first on the shopping list if I remember right hmmmm). We lacked leadership so he took the Captains from our rivals and gave us a team who knew how to grind out a win. I'd take that again over some half arsed version of Tikka takka anyday. |