![]() |
|
Palmer - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Palmer (/showthread.php?tid=26618) |
RE: Palmer - Remi_Moses - 09-16-2022 The problem with Palmer is Bruce. RE: Palmer - Baggybenny - 09-16-2022 To his credit, he has saved a penalty. Won us a point. RE: Palmer - Noibla - 09-16-2022 (09-16-2022, 10:01 AM)Baggybenny Wrote: To his credit, he has saved a penalty. Won us a point. The only thing he has saved mind RE: Palmer - SW4Baggie - 09-16-2022 I looked at the InfoGol goal maps for our games this season earlier today and it's startling the number of goals we've conceded this season from the quality of chances the opposition have created. We have conceded 4 goals from opportunities with a less than 1 in 20 chance that the player will score (and two of them have been less than 1 in 50), that is either down to massive goal keeping errors - of which there haven't been any - or through the opposition player having a mix of incredible luck and incredible skill. Looking at the data, there are two goals - Blues' third and Hudds' second - where Button could be at fault, but the other goals we have conceded he either couldn't realistically be expected to have prevented the goal, or they have been absolute worldies. We have also seen a fair number of high quality chances not converted by the opposition, suggesting Button makes his fair share of routine stops and there is still the wayward finishing you'd expect in this division. I've also looked at his game ratings on WhoScored where his season average for 9 games is 6.1 - his highest performance was 7.05 vs Hull and his lowest 5.28 against Blues. Overall the stats suggest two things... Button is an average Championship goalkeeper. He is unlikely to cost us many points, but he is unlikely to win us any either, and secondly we have been bloody unlucky in many of the goals we have conceded. We really can't keep on this trajectory and our luck has to change at some point in terms of chances against us resulting in goals it's just not sustainable. Button deserves to come under scrutiny, and if I were Bruce, I'd be considering Palmer next week, but his form hasn't really warranted being dropped. Longer term, Button's position requires improving if we want to be in the top 6 (but we knew that in the summer, but much like Phillips, Livermore, Townsend, Furlong.... you don't actually have to be any good to get a renewal here) RE: Palmer - chasetownbaggie - 09-16-2022 [attachment=689 Wrote:SW4Baggie pid='514674' dateline='1663325378']I looked at the InfoGol goal maps for our games this season earlier today and it's startling the number of goals we've conceded this season from the quality of chances the opposition have created. We have conceded 4 goals from opportunities with a less than 1 in 20 chance that the player will score (and two of them have been less than 1 in 50), that is either down to massive goal keeping errors - of which there haven't been any - or through the opposition player having a mix of incredible luck and incredible skill. Also from Who scored ![]() [attachment=689] Button's shot to saves ratio is at about 50%, the worst in the Championship. That's despite playing behind the defence who have allowed the second fewest shots on target. Give Palmer a chance. RE: Palmer - chasetownbaggie - 09-18-2022 Apologies for being like a dog with a bone but discovered in the 2 games Palmer has played this season, his save ratio is 87% |