![]() |
|
Optimism - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: Optimism (/showthread.php?tid=25717) |
RE: Optimism - WorcsWBA - 07-13-2022 (07-12-2022, 09:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/johnson-accused-of-one-last-try-to-install-ally-hogan-howe-in-plum-police-job-6hjvb6rpb Indeed. There will be no shortage of things like this that he'll try, so the longer he stays around the worse it'll be. The sudden silence of the Tory backbenchers who opposed him so strongly is hugely disappointing. Going back to the OP, there's no reason for optimism whilst there's a Tory govt. Looking at the leadership contenders, whilst they might go about things in a different way to Johnson, their motivation and end result if they become PM will be pretty similar. It's not about their ability, it's about how right wing they are - look at the growing support for Truss, who is just a Johnson lacky at the end of the day and, more importantly, completely hopeless. RE: Optimism - Protheroe - 07-13-2022 (07-13-2022, 09:05 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: It's not about their ability, it's about how right wing they are This is the least right wing Tory government since Heath's in 1974. There's very little of Johnson's programme (such as it was) that couldn't have come straight from the pages of a Miliband or Starmer manifesto. RE: Optimism - Ted Maul - 07-13-2022 (07-13-2022, 09:14 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-13-2022, 09:05 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: It's not about their ability, it's about how right wing they are Therein lies the problem with the current Labour party leadership. RE: Optimism - Protheroe - 07-13-2022 (07-13-2022, 09:28 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:(07-13-2022, 09:14 AM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-13-2022, 09:05 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: It's not about their ability, it's about how right wing they are But I don't think anyone sentient considers either Miliband or Starmer to be right wing. They're as firmly banal and centrist as you can get. RE: Optimism - Derek Hardballs - 07-13-2022 The idea that political solutions lie at the extremes of political parties is nonsense. Both parties lurched to the right and left since 2008. The Conservative party now is a weird mix of UKIP and English Nationalism that is using popularism to garner support. Similarly Corbyn and Momentum dragged Labour far too much to the left to make them electable. Politics in the U.K. at its best is a compromise, a fudge ideas, it always has been. Polarisation of social, economic, cultural and political ideologies will just see the countries splits get bigger and bigger, it will solve absolutely nothing. I appreciate useful idiots, those bought off and those with darker intentions want us to have stupid culture wars as it divides and distracts the Torch people from the Pitchfork people whilst they happily dismantle anything that binds us together in the pursuit of either power or money and in most cases both. Nothing good comes from political extremes and the further we lurch to either side the less the country will prosper, unite or be at ease with itself. Loons like Braverman, Truss, Patel, Baker, I have absolutely nothing in common with them, heck I don’t even respect them on any level. That is because they are driven by not what is best but what they believe in, the two things are not the same. There was a time that I could at least say I had respect for a politician even if I didn’t support their overall political outlook. Those days seem to have gone and now we have this awful Tory leadership contest where many are out doing each other with who wants the hardest Brexit, who wants the lowest tax, who wants to punish the poorest in society for something not of their making. It’s pathetic, vindictive, childish, ideologically driven politics that should have been consigned to the debating society in sixth form. They will say they want to bring the country together, lump everyone together as ‘the people’ but none of them want to compromise. Not one of them have said they wish to take onboard other peoples ideas around Brexit etc. It’s like they think compromise is a weakness when any decent leader will not put ideology before the needs of society as a whole. RE: Optimism - Borin' Baggie - 07-13-2022 Was not expecting the traditional Tory U-turn over blocking Labour's VoNC to be the government tabling a VoNC in itself. RE: Optimism - Protheroe - 07-13-2022 (07-13-2022, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The idea that political solutions lie at the extremes of political parties is nonsense. Both parties lurched to the right and left since 2008. The Conservative party now is a weird mix of UKIP and English Nationalism that is using popularism to garner support. Similarly Corbyn and Momentum dragged Labour far too much to the left to make them electable. Politics in the U.K. at its best is a compromise, a fudge ideas, it always has been. Take a step back and read that third paragraph again. Then ask yourself again who's being extreme. The ends the Braverman, Truss, Patel and Baker are trying to achieve will be much the same as Starmer, Long Bailey, Trickett and Davey et al. The means to the ends are all that's different. It's actually pathetic, vindictive, childish and ideologically driven to suggest that anyone in public life wishes to "punish the poorest in society". In fact, it's laughable. You may believe that certain policies have that effect, but the poorest have always suffered more than anyone else in society, in every society, under any system, anywhere, ever. Because they're poor. RE: Optimism - WorcsWBA - 07-13-2022 There's no cause for optimism in the graphic below either. Anyone who cares about climate change (and everyone should) can never trust the Tories on the issue. The article which features the graphic can be found here if anyone's interested. RE: Optimism - Derek Hardballs - 07-13-2022 (07-13-2022, 01:27 PM)Protheroe Wrote:(07-13-2022, 10:45 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The idea that political solutions lie at the extremes of political parties is nonsense. Both parties lurched to the right and left since 2008. The Conservative party now is a weird mix of UKIP and English Nationalism that is using popularism to garner support. Similarly Corbyn and Momentum dragged Labour far too much to the left to make them electable. Politics in the U.K. at its best is a compromise, a fudge ideas, it always has been. Singling out welfare like Braverman did in an interview this week, is trying to pin the blame or at best target people who can ill afford to take anymore cuts and shows she doesn’t even comprehend that millions of people on welfare work. Childish, politics, trying to other people who receive welfare. RE: Optimism - Protheroe - 07-13-2022 (07-13-2022, 02:25 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Singling out welfare like Braverman did in an interview this week, is trying to pin the blame or at best target people who can ill afford to take anymore cuts and shows she doesn’t even comprehend that millions of people on welfare work. Childish, politics, trying to other people who receive welfare. What she actually said in her launch was: “I think there are too many people in this country, for example, who are of working age, of good health and who are choosing not to work full time and they are taking benefits. Whilst universal credit did a very good amount of work to stamp out that welfare dependency, we still have a stubborn tail of the population that refuses to enter into economy activity. I think we have to introduce much more rigour and incentive to get people into work.” Can you point out to me what you disagree with in that? Or did you think she said something else? That suggests to me that she would change the rules to encourage and incentivise people to work more hours. Is this the only example you have of the various leadership candidates promising to "punish" the poorest? (07-13-2022, 02:19 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: There's no cause for optimism in the graphic below either. Anyone who cares about climate change (and everyone should) can never trust the Tories on the issue. Can you just clarify that you're not counting House of Lords' amendments, Opposition Amendments and Opposition Motions as voting "against" environmental measures? I think you are. If you are that is more misleading than someone else on here claiming "absence" is the same as "abstention". I understand why organisations issue this stuff for propaganda purposes, of course. But fundamentally it misleads on how government / opposition works. For instance Keir Starmer "almost always votes against raising the threshold at which people start to pay income tax". Does that mean that Kier Starmer wants lower earners to pay more tax? Or simply that he votes against Conservative budgets? (it's the latter by the way) |