![]() |
|
Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Fair Play to Callum Robinson (/showthread.php?tid=21847) |
RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - backsidebaggie - 10-06-2021 Why is it a ludicrous comparison DH? Tell me why. It’s putting your bodily autonomy first over others in society. Tell me why it’s ludicrous. You won’t because you can’t. That’s why youve said agree to disagree as you can’t explain what the difference is. You won’t donate a kidney if push comes to shove because you’re selfish. You put yourself over others. Someone is dying and you could donate but you won’t. That’s fucking selfish. That’s putting yourself above saving a life in wider society. Selfish you you you. Now I don’t believe that, I believe it’s your choice. It’s your body. You’ve drawn a line where someone is selfish if they dont have a vaccine, but not selfish if they don’t donate a kidney, despite both things benefitting others. Well guess what, others have a different line. That doesn’t mean they’re any more selfish than you. Accept it. I’ll wait to here why it’s a ludicrous comparison. Both are bodily autonomy vs benefitting wider society. RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - ericlegrisly - 10-06-2021 FWIW - the 'kidney = vaccine' argument is a fairly ludicrous conflation. It isn't the same logic at all. It really isn't. Sorry Backside mate. RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Lightnin - 10-06-2021 (10-06-2021, 11:44 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: Fair play to Callum Robinson, he’s come out and told the world that he’s basically an idiot (same as any other anti vaxxers). Just thinking, if I'm Robinson and I was being tested 2/3 times a week and before every game. Would I see a need to have the vaccine? It's not like I'm going to have chance to spread it and all I'm doing is limiting the symptoms in myself. Plus, having had it twice, what's to worry about if I get it again? From his point of view, it probably makes sense and it is his decision. Don't see how that makes him an idiot. Other anti-vaxxers, I can't speak for as their circumstances will be different and they may well be idiots. RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - bradesbaggie - 10-06-2021 The irony of that press conference is that the journalists have to provide their covid passport to gain entry but dickhead doesn't. RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - backsidebaggie - 10-06-2021 (10-06-2021, 11:50 AM)ericlegrisly Wrote: FWIW - the 'kidney = vaccine' argument is a fairly ludicrous conflation. Why? It’s bodily autonomy vs benefit to wider society. It’s simply where you draw the line. Callum Robinson has drawn his line and that’s that. RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - Derek Hardballs - 10-06-2021 (10-06-2021, 11:49 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Why is it a ludicrous comparison DH? Tell me why. It’s putting your bodily autonomy first over others in society. Last reply from me on this thread, you are equating a complicated, invasive kidney removal and the risks that brings to having a jab that takes barely a second to administer and the overwhelming majority will suffer at most a sore arm and some fatigue after it for a day or two. One will help keep a number of others safer from a potential life threatening virus, and collectively reduce infection rates to a minimum the other will save one persons life. The two scenarios are not comparable. We all have a choice to do or not do things but those choices do have an impact on others and when they do they will be judged. RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - ChamonixBaggie - 10-06-2021 Donating a kidney leaves you permanently kidneyless. The vaccine does nothing to you except stop you dying of covid (probably). They aren't the same. MY point of view is that outside of medical necessity there is absolutely no good reason not to have it. The fertility thing is a total myth and it's been tested to the nth degree. Does Robinson *need* to have it if he's had covid twice already? Maybe, maybe not but it is difficult not to label people like this as anti-vaccine because other than the inconvenience of a 10 minute trip to the clinic, why would you possibly, possibly not have it?! Even if you might not strictly need to. It can only help you and others. This why I am all for vaccine passports etc to go to events and the like. You don't get to enjoy the privileges of living in a society while shirking it's responsibilities. Getting vaccinated against a virus that has devastated most of the world for 2 years is one of those responsibilities IMO. RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - backsidebaggie - 10-06-2021 (10-06-2021, 12:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(10-06-2021, 11:49 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote: Why is it a ludicrous comparison DH? Tell me why. It’s putting your bodily autonomy first over others in society. Right, then it’s ok to judge you and call you a selfish idiot moron for not being prepared to donate a kidney to save a life. You selfish thoughtless self centred “I’m alright jack” attitude you have. You’re prepared to impact someone else and let them die you selfish individual. Well actually that’s not true. You’re well within your rights not to. And you shouldn’t be judged for that. Neither should Callum Robinson. People don’t know if he has a family member had a bad reaction. Or other circumstances. But that doesn’t matter, because he’s simply drawn a different line to you. So judge away, because no one gives a shit about you judging them. (10-06-2021, 12:02 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Donating a kidney leaves you permanently kidneyless. The vaccine does nothing to you except stop you dying of covid (probably). They aren't the same. No good reason? Not true. There’s someone on this board who has had a bad reaction. He has a good reason not to have any more. Robinson has weighed up his risk of covid and doesn’t want it, sane as loads of sportspeople. Folk just need to accept it. Thank god I don’t hang around with judgmental people like DH. RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - clem4england - 10-06-2021 Regardless of the personal choice issue, I can't say I'm particularly happy as a fan that he could come into contact with someone who tests positive and have to self-isolate for however long and miss crucial games. As an employer paying him a handsome wage, can't imagine the club are either. RE: Fair Play to Callum Robinson - ChamonixBaggie - 10-06-2021 (10-06-2021, 12:02 PM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Donating a kidney leaves you permanently kidneyless. The vaccine does nothing to you except stop you dying of covid (probably). They aren't the same. No good reason? Not true. There’s someone on this board who has had a bad reaction. He has a good reason not to have any more. Robinson has weighed up his risk of covid and doesn’t want it, sane as loads of sportspeople. Folk just need to accept it. Thank god I don’t hang around with judgmental people like DH. [/quote] Ahem.. "outside of medical necessity" |