WBAUnofficial
Big Sam poll..... - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Big Sam poll..... (/showthread.php?tid=16545)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9


RE: Big Sam poll..... - Birdman1811 - 04-07-2021

We were 2nd favourite to go up and had one of the largest wage bills in the league.

It wasn't the remarkable job some say.


RE: Big Sam poll..... - Bob Fossil - 04-07-2021

(04-07-2021, 11:24 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 11:00 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 09:28 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-06-2021, 06:43 AM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-05-2021, 10:30 PM)Sliced Wrote: So basically Sam has got promoted at every club he's ever managed that wasn't in the top flight. Were all those at the first time of asking as well? Im asking cause I genuinely don't know.

In that case, why are you seemingly so against it? From your post above it seems both Wilder or Allardyce would be good options. Personally I'd prefer Wilder but both have cracking records in getting teams promoted

I'm not so against it totally. You'll see from my posts on other threads I can see some merit in it but still feel he's been an anticlimax and we've pissed loads of points away in "must win games" (his words) when the team have been too conservative in their approach. Wilders CV is the same if not better than Sam's in terms of promotion. And a much more recent history of the championship too.

The reason I'd want Sam to stay is if he can persuade Okay to stay and try and keep some of the group together. Seeing as the chances of that are slim I think Wilder might be the better bet. There will be plenty of othe managers out there too. Just look at the list of managers that have recently been promoted out of the championship. Hardly any had any experience of the division before being promoted.

The arguement for Sam by some seems to be he'd be a safe pair of hands. I'm just not as convinced that would be the case. As a separate issue I don't think he's got the drive for it either. That's just a gut feeling.

It's all options Slice.

Exactly where I'm at Peachy.

I'm more excited by Wilder as he has a recent record of winning promotion and that's what we need. Sam is the perfect appointment if we need to survive in the PL but winning promotion requires a very different motivation and skill-set and I'm not sure I'm comfortable gambling our best chance of promotion on a man who's only managed in that division / been expected to win more than 1 in 3 to be a success once in 20 years.

Playing devil's advocate, surely it's the other way around? Of promotion and survival, promotion is the easier (we've never finished outside the top 6, regardless of manager) therefore Sam would be the pick, as, once promotion is achieved, we would have the "perfect" man for survival.

Finding a manager to get us up, with our budget, is relatively easy, finding one to keep us, with our budget, is far more difficult.
I wonder whether that last paragraph will come to haunt you and others who seem to think that promotion is a foregone conclusion next season?
Bilic did a great job last season with a squad that was far from nailed on at the beginning of the season.
Plenty of clubs languishing in the lower championship thought they'd be up long before now. Plenty of them will provide stiff competition next season.
Whoever our manager is, I hope they'll be given time and patience.
I'm not holding my breath though.
Not saying it's a foregone conclusion but history says we will be top 6, whoever is in charge. We will have a handsome budget, a decent squad and experience of doing it before. Many of the clubs you allude to didn't have this as they threw all their eggs in the survival basket.
Staying up is by far the harder task, so, as above, if we are factoring that into next season's equation, Sam trumps Wilder, is what I'm saying.

Didn't say it was my choice, but it makes sense.


RE: Big Sam poll..... - Sliced - 04-07-2021

(04-07-2021, 11:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: We were 2nd favourite to go up and had one of the largest wage bills in the league.

It wasn't the remarkable job some say.

I maintain that having Pereira in the Championship is like playing a game on easy mode. Whoever found that gem deserves a world of credit


RE: Big Sam poll..... - Peachy - 04-07-2021

(04-07-2021, 12:29 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 11:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: We were 2nd favourite to go up and had one of the largest wage bills in the league.

It wasn't the remarkable job some say.

I maintain that having Pereira in the Championship is like playing a game on easy mode. Whoever found that gem deserves a world of credit

Massive +1.

On that Norwich held on to both Beuendia and Cantwell last season despite lots of interest. They shut it down straight away and asked them for a season to get them back up. They didn't take the quick money.

We need to do the same. It makes sense too. If we don't get back up at the first attempt we have the fall back position of selling him and funding another push.

I really think with a motivated Grady, Pereira and Grant playing behind a decent striker we should have far too much for many teams.

My only issue is if Pereira haggle for a move and doesn't fancy the Chump.


RE: Big Sam poll..... - Dumbo - 04-07-2021

(04-07-2021, 12:41 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 12:29 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 11:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: We were 2nd favourite to go up and had one of the largest wage bills in the league.

It wasn't the remarkable job some say.

I maintain that having Pereira in the Championship is like playing a game on easy mode. Whoever found that gem deserves a world of credit

Massive +1.

On that Norwich held on to both Beuendia and Cantwell last season despite lots of interest. They shut it down straight away and asked them for a season to get them back up. They didn't take the quick money.

We need to do the same. It makes sense too. If we don't get back up at the first attempt we have the fall back position of selling him and funding another push.

I really think with a motivated Grady, Pereira and Grant playing behind a decent striker we should have far too much for many teams.

My only issue is if Pereira haggle for a move and doesn't fancy the Chump.

Spot on. 

The talk of running to the hills if we get a £17mill offer for Periera was insane. He’s the diffeeemce between promotion and missing out and that’s worth £100mill in itself.

One season, if we don’t go up, he can leave with our best wishes. Just like Jay Rod. 

Grady - Periera - Grant
——-—Robinson———-


RE: Big Sam poll..... - Ted Maul - 04-07-2021

I'm not too worried about next season, Allardyce would get us back up.

Even if we were to lose Johnstone and Periera there will be enough funds generated to replace them and some.

Similar to Norwich we will have players like Ajayi, O'Shea, Furlong, Townsend, Grant, Robinson, Diangana all with a years PL experience and better players than when we were last in the Championship. Diagne signing on a permanent basis would be a real bonus although his performances might warrant another year in the PL. I think Yokuslu's ship has sailed, we wont see him in blue and white past May.


RE: Big Sam poll..... - Johnnykayeengland - 04-07-2021

(04-07-2021, 11:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: We were 2nd favourite to go up and had one of the largest wage bills in the league.

It wasn't the remarkable job some say.
We'd come 4th the previous season. We lost our 2 strikers, who were the reason we got so high. We had no manager.
We certainly did some shrewd transfer business. Pereira, Grady and, whisper it, Sawyers made the difference.
I think from that start it was an impressive season. Even allowing for the tail off.
I don't think what the bookies say is relevant. But I agree, having the money, especially for wages certainly is.


RE: Big Sam poll..... - Birdman1811 - 04-07-2021

(04-07-2021, 04:13 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 11:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: We were 2nd favourite to go up and had one of the largest wage bills in the league.

It wasn't the remarkable job some say.
We'd come 4th the previous season. We lost our 2 strikers, who were the reason we got so high. We had no manager.
We certainly did some shrewd transfer business. Pereira, Grady and, whisper it, Sawyers made the difference.
I think from that start it was an impressive season. Even allowing for the tail off.
I don't think what the bookies say is relevant. But I agree, having the money, especially for wages certainly is.

We'd come 4th the previous season which was massive under achievement. 

The way we finished last season for me said more than anything else.


RE: Big Sam poll..... - SW4Baggie - 04-07-2021

(04-07-2021, 04:13 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 11:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: We were 2nd favourite to go up and had one of the largest wage bills in the league.

It wasn't the remarkable job some say.
We'd come 4th the previous season. We lost our 2 strikers, who were the reason we got so high. We had no manager.
We certainly did some shrewd transfer business. Pereira, Grady and, whisper it, Sawyers made the difference.
I think from that start it was an impressive season. Even allowing for the tail off.
I don't think what the bookies say is relevant. But I agree, having the money, especially for wages certainly is.

Correct, whilst we had one of the biggest budgets in the division last season, I'm not sure ours was top 2. Whilst it was bigger than Brentford's I'd imagine Fulham in particular had a larger budget, and legacy fees / wages mean the likes of Stoke and Swansea were paying higher wage bills than we were... we also made c£30m in profit in player sales.

Going into that season the bulk of fans felt top 6 would be a stretch, with a fair few on here even reckoning we'd be in the bottom half, so we can't take away from the fact Slav did bloody well to take the club he inherited into the PL. Admittedly he has to carry the can for the total lack of intensity we returned from lockdown with that ALMOST cost us promotion, however we didn't win promotion just because we splashed the cash, we used our advantage to its fullest.

(04-07-2021, 04:54 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 04:13 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-07-2021, 11:40 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: We were 2nd favourite to go up and had one of the largest wage bills in the league.

It wasn't the remarkable job some say.
We'd come 4th the previous season. We lost our 2 strikers, who were the reason we got so high. We had no manager.
We certainly did some shrewd transfer business. Pereira, Grady and, whisper it, Sawyers made the difference.
I think from that start it was an impressive season. Even allowing for the tail off.
I don't think what the bookies say is relevant. But I agree, having the money, especially for wages certainly is.

We'd come 4th the previous season which was massive under achievement. 

The way we finished last season for me said more than anything else.

Was it really? Norwich ran with a larger wage bill than we did that season, as did Swansea, Stoke and Villa... and the cumulative spending of the latter 2 was far more than we managed... after all, we made a decent profit on transfers that summer again.

We should, on paper have finished above both Leeds and Sheff U if it was purely based on financials, but then Villa and Stoke ought to have run away with the league with us, Norwich, Swansea and Frank Lampard's Derby County making up the playoffs. 

Next season, due to the impact of COVID we will be one of the best off 2 sides (provided Watford and Norwich get promoted), and ideally we'll see B'mouth do it too given their external investment and possible player sales... Sheff U have lots of legacy transfer payments following their heavy spending in the last couple windows, however either Fulham or Newcastle will come down with far more money than us. 

The issue for me will be whether we will have the nous to compete as there are some wily managers (Hughton, Warnock, McCarthy) who aren't usually far away from the top 6, some clubs with investment behind them (Stoke, Reading, Derby's new ownership) and some very canny operators (Barnsley, Brentford) who will be looking to erode any advantage our finances will give!


RE: Big Sam poll..... - Bortolazzi's Barnet - 04-07-2021

I think Wilder's record is brilliant but feel Sam is a better manager. Sam knows a signing. With money, Wilder doesn't.