WBAUnofficial
VAR - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: VAR (/showthread.php?tid=15937)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: VAR - CA Baggie - 03-11-2021

(03-10-2021, 11:06 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2021, 09:57 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It isn't obvious though. You don't know what is being looked at and what isn't. You don't know how the referees are applying the laws. You don't know how much input either side has in the decision. You don't know the exact point that the error is made. It's far too opaque, it needs to be transparent.

And the knowledge that it isn't going anywhere is a key factor, as it not going anywhere is a core reason why it needs to be more transparent with respect to how decisions are made. Transparency has improved TMO and made it easier to address areas and move away from subjectivity in rugby, the same thing needs to happen with VAR.

I think it’s the move away from subjectivity that’s causing so many problems. Football laws are mainly subjective (obviously not offside, ball out). But fouls are. By trying to make things less subjective, they’ve got in a mess IMO. Same as the handball rule. It works better with subjectivity IMO. Let the ref decide his opinion.

It’s different in cricket and tennis, where the laws are definitive (was the ball going on to hit the stumps, yes or no. Did the ball land in, yes or no). They were the umpire making a judgment on a definitive thing. A foul in football is never definitive. It was a subjective view on whether someone was impeded. Contact never meant it was a foul. Ball touching hand never meant it was handball. The laws were based around subjective views of the ref, and 99.9% of the time it’s fine like that. By trying to move away from that, they’ve got in a right mess. And that’s why VAR will never work IMO.
Excellent post.

I’ve argued before it should only be used for factual decisions, whilst not putting it as eloquently as you have.  It’s why Hawkeye works for goals (unless you switch it off you jammyfisheatingdeludedsealbastards) and why the use of VAR should ideally be scrapped at worst curtailed.  

I don’t have a problem with checking for offside, it maybe needs simplifying to feet position or something else easier to identify.  Gary Neville was right with offside, whatever version you choose there’s still going to be a point of checking to the nearest mm.  I could just about live with in/outside the box too.  Mistaken identity is another.

I’d accept the bad decision of a player diving to win a pen provided there was a similar review regime to red cards/appealing red cards.  

The game needs to get away from contact = foul.  We used to bemoan the cheating  happening on the continent, now diving in the PL is worse than that ever was.  Review every penalty or free kick resulting in a goal and ban the player for a minimum 3 games if in the panel’s view there wasn’t enough to cause the player to go down.  For each offence just step up the ban, Mo Salah will suddenly be strong all the time instead of when he wants to be.

I’m aware this is subjective but this just may stop the histrionics we see know and longer term help the refs referee without the need of VAR, which is only here because of the cheats.


RE: VAR - Bob Fossil - 03-11-2021

If it's really about clear and obvious errors only then they should have 3 independent people view the incident, in real time, and give them 30 seconds to vote yes or no. Majority wins.
This would minimise the waiting time and justify the decision either way,

Doesn't matter if Lineker and his overpaid cronies think different after watching it 1000 times from every angle.

The fact that we hate it is down to them trying to make it perfect and infallible, yet still making mistakes. They should instead admit that it is imperfect but attempt to eradicate clear and obvious errors.


RE: VAR - Borin' Baggie - 03-11-2021

(03-10-2021, 11:06 PM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-10-2021, 09:57 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It isn't obvious though. You don't know what is being looked at and what isn't. You don't know how the referees are applying the laws. You don't know how much input either side has in the decision. You don't know the exact point that the error is made. It's far too opaque, it needs to be transparent.

And the knowledge that it isn't going anywhere is a key factor, as it not going anywhere is a core reason why it needs to be more transparent with respect to how decisions are made. Transparency has improved TMO and made it easier to address areas and move away from subjectivity in rugby, the same thing needs to happen with VAR.

I think it’s the move away from subjectivity that’s causing so many problems. Football laws are mainly subjective (obviously not offside, ball out). But fouls are. By trying to make things less subjective, they’ve got in a mess IMO. Same as the handball rule. It works better with subjectivity IMO. Let the ref decide his opinion.

It’s different in cricket and tennis, where the laws are definitive (was the ball going on to hit the stumps, yes or no. Did the ball land in, yes or no). They were the umpire making a judgment on a definitive thing. A foul in football is never definitive. It was a subjective view on whether someone was impeded. Contact never meant it was a foul. Ball touching hand never meant it was handball. The laws were based around subjective views of the ref, and 99.9% of the time it’s fine like that. By trying to move away from that, they’ve got in a right mess. And that’s why VAR will never work IMO.

I agree with the whole issue surrounding subjectivity and objectivity in decisions, and my preference is for it to be cut back to offside decisions, but on a practical basis it isn't going to be changed in that respect which is why transparency needs to be introduced.

That's why I was referencing rugby as it's the closest sport to football and TMO has been largely a success in rugby.


RE: VAR - wba13 - 03-13-2021

Me again on VAR again, palace one a definite pen but so was one for Burnley hand above head struck arm ref gives no penalty and VAR doesn’t give it . When are they going to get it right they are consistently sitting on there arses and missing easy decisions.
Must admit looking forward to next season when we haven’t got to put up with VAR shit.