RE: Well, that was a day. - keef - 12-16-2020
(12-16-2020, 09:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (12-16-2020, 09:46 PM)Olympic Wrote: It’s a results cliche coming out again. Well we overachieved massively in his first season and we are not bottom which all the stats indicate from budget to value of the squad so yet again overachieving.
We didn’t massively over achieve! We were second favourites to go up for a reason with the bookies.
and thats where we finished
RE: Well, that was a day. - HawkingsHalfpint - 12-16-2020
(12-16-2020, 08:02 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: After the sheer pride I had in our club last night, to the amazement at the rumours 10 minutes alter, it's been interesting.
Happy? Not particularly.
Angry? No.
Bilic has got a lot of leeway with fans imo, undeserved if I'm honest, for 12 months we've been bad far, far more often than average, let alone good. It's a results business, not a nice guy contest, if that was the case, Moore should still be here. More respect for him than I have for Bilic who has spent the last couple of months bitching to his agent to leak stuff to the press to cover himself.
Yes he was given 2 years, that changed when Covid hit and we needed to get up, do not under estimate how fucked we would have been had we failed to get up last season. That did certainly add pressure, and he did not manage it very well at all. He was also aware then that the budget was going to be very small, for all his whining, if it was going to make it impossible he could have walked then. He primarily asked to get the loan players back, a 'keeper and Karlan Grant. He was happy to raise funds via selling a Centre Back and Keiran Gibbs, no one wanted Gibbs, and only Hegazi had any interest. Hegazi barely played under Bilic when available, hardly a key player. Maybe he'd have turned Diangana down at the price, but I can also imagine the fans moaning had it been leaked we turned down the chance. Long term we maybe made the right choice, but it made a hard job even harder in the summer no doubt. We most certainly did not need a new 'Keeper, and with Johnstone on the wages he is, unless another team signed him, we wouldn't sign a new Number 1.
So he was hardly hung out to dry in the summer. Fact is he has badly used the resources available, we've been unfit and stupid decisions before and after games have cost us. This is all under the remit of the manager. Bar minimum for me is that the team is organised, defensively sound and fit. We've only looked like that against top teams when all we had to do was defend. He maybe unlucky that he planned to use Field to shield the defence more often, only for him to get injured. However instead of Krov he could have pushed for a defensive midfielder, as much as I like Krov, we don't need him.
So I'm not against his sacking, the way it was done and when.. Yes. But I felt he was a dead man walking for a while. It was great the players were behind him, but losing against teams we needed to get points against made that support futile.
So Big Sam. Not my first choice. However some absolute bollocks has been spouted about him on here and all over social media. He is not a dinosaur, whatever the fuck that means. He is actually one of the most learned coaches in England when it comes to Sports Science and analytics. Fitness levels will increase of that I have no doubt, players will have to develop themselves, and he isn't a Pulis, he wants flair players to have flair. He'll coach Diangana to learn to release the ball and when to dribble, same with Pereira. He'll find every strength and weakness of our players and minimise and maximise what he can.
Yes he builds from the back, that is how to be successful at football, don't concede, you can't lose. He usually struggles more when fans have unrealistic expectations and players aren't buying into him, like Newcastle and Everton. Here I imagine any player who isn't stupid will realise this is a great chance to be in a team that survives in this league, great stock for any player. He'd have seen Ajayi and O'Shea putting their bodies on the line last night and been impressed.
We're still likely to drop, in which case he goes, but our chances have improved a lot in my opinion. Do I like him? No, did I ever want him here? Not really. Is it terrible, an insult? Hardly, that's John Terry or Lee Bowyer.
Great post Birdman. I feel a lot better about it all having read this very succinct compendium of the last year or so.
It is what it is. For me, the timing of the announcement (and leaking of it) amplifies the emotion involved, especially during a period we’re all firstly somewhat benign towards whilst altogether pig-sick of change and transition in our lives, and not least that the emotion that follows a freezing cold shit show isn’t there when you switch off and continue straight back into family life. The last year has softened all of our emotions, especially towards a likeable fellow and his band of merry misfits we all wanted to do well. But for all the hope in the world it was never going to get better, and even less guarantee that the main man would be around to repair the damage afterwards.
As for Sam - the card is clean. Not my choice by a long stretch, but as Fizz said he’s our fat bastard now. He deserves a fresh start, and needs one with the mountain ahead to scale.
RE: Well, that was a day. - Derek Hardballs - 12-16-2020
(12-16-2020, 09:50 PM)sickParrot Wrote: (12-16-2020, 09:23 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: To me, as with all sport, yes it is. I'm competitive in things.
I’m surprised, as you seem to one of the more balanced and level headed people on this dump and never pant wetting or reacting badly when we lose.
Wanting results doesn’t mean you cannot be rational about performances. The most even handed posters on here with regards to football seem to be those who understand we may have to accept pragmatic football because of where we are in the food chain in the Premier league.
(12-16-2020, 09:54 PM)keef Wrote: (12-16-2020, 09:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (12-16-2020, 09:46 PM)Olympic Wrote: It’s a results cliche coming out again. Well we overachieved massively in his first season and we are not bottom which all the stats indicate from budget to value of the squad so yet again overachieving.
We didn’t massively over achieve! We were second favourites to go up for a reason with the bookies.
and thats where we finished
Yes we did?!?!?
RE: Well, that was a day. - yeoman lai - 12-16-2020
(12-16-2020, 08:02 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: After the sheer pride I had in our club last night, to the amazement at the rumours 10 minutes alter, it's been interesting.
Happy? Not particularly.
Angry? No.
Bilic has got a lot of leeway with fans imo, undeserved if I'm honest, for 12 months we've been bad far, far more often than average, let alone good. It's a results business, not a nice guy contest, if that was the case, Moore should still be here. More respect for him than I have for Bilic who has spent the last couple of months bitching to his agent to leak stuff to the press to cover himself.
Yes he was given 2 years, that changed when Covid hit and we needed to get up, do not under estimate how fucked we would have been had we failed to get up last season. That did certainly add pressure, and he did not manage it very well at all. He was also aware then that the budget was going to be very small, for all his whining, if it was going to make it impossible he could have walked then. He primarily asked to get the loan players back, a 'keeper and Karlan Grant. He was happy to raise funds via selling a Centre Back and Keiran Gibbs, no one wanted Gibbs, and only Hegazi had any interest. Hegazi barely played under Bilic when available, hardly a key player. Maybe he'd have turned Diangana down at the price, but I can also imagine the fans moaning had it been leaked we turned down the chance. Long term we maybe made the right choice, but it made a hard job even harder in the summer no doubt. We most certainly did not need a new 'Keeper, and with Johnstone on the wages he is, unless another team signed him, we wouldn't sign a new Number 1.
So he was hardly hung out to dry in the summer. Fact is he has badly used the resources available, we've been unfit and stupid decisions before and after games have cost us. This is all under the remit of the manager. Bar minimum for me is that the team is organised, defensively sound and fit. We've only looked like that against top teams when all we had to do was defend. He maybe unlucky that he planned to use Field to shield the defence more often, only for him to get injured. However instead of Krov he could have pushed for a defensive midfielder, as much as I like Krov, we don't need him.
So I'm not against his sacking, the way it was done and when.. Yes. But I felt he was a dead man walking for a while. It was great the players were behind him, but losing against teams we needed to get points against made that support futile.
So Big Sam. Not my first choice. However some absolute bollocks has been spouted about him on here and all over social media. He is not a dinosaur, whatever the fuck that means. He is actually one of the most learned coaches in England when it comes to Sports Science and analytics. Fitness levels will increase of that I have no doubt, players will have to develop themselves, and he isn't a Pulis, he wants flair players to have flair. He'll coach Diangana to learn to release the ball and when to dribble, same with Pereira. He'll find every strength and weakness of our players and minimise and maximise what he can.
Yes he builds from the back, that is how to be successful at football, don't concede, you can't lose. He usually struggles more when fans have unrealistic expectations and players aren't buying into him, like Newcastle and Everton. Here I imagine any player who isn't stupid will realise this is a great chance to be in a team that survives in this league, great stock for any player. He'd have seen Ajayi and O'Shea putting their bodies on the line last night and been impressed.
We're still likely to drop, in which case he goes, but our chances have improved a lot in my opinion. Do I like him? No, did I ever want him here? Not really. Is it terrible, an insult? Hardly, that's John Terry or Lee Bowyer.
Great post. A sight for sore eyes after some of the absolute shite spouted on social media.
RE: Well, that was a day. - BeijingBaggie - 12-17-2020
Although the squad isn't perhaps what it should be the most telling thing for me has been my perceived fitness of the players. Too many seem to be blowing out their arse in the last third of games. We can't have the most skillful players, but there isn't anything stopping us having the fittest. When you're a squad like our this should be an absolute priority and didn't appear to me like it was.
RE: Well, that was a day. - MGalea - 12-17-2020
Great post Birdmon. Bravo.
RE: Well, that was a day. - Lillwall's left foot - 12-17-2020
One of the best posts I've read in this place and mirrors a number of the conversations had with baggy mates last night, some of whome I hadn't contacted for months. We are a pragmatic bunch and this comes through once the emotions settle.
I'm actually suprised today at how curious I am about what a coach with his experience and pedigree can do with a squad of potentially exciting players. Can he provide a defensive base and team structure for the likes of Perreira and Diang to perform? Can he add to Sawyers game? Will he persist with Grant up top or move him wider where he had his success at Hudds? It's going to be an interesting couple of months.
RE: Well, that was a day. - TartanRug - 12-17-2020
Still think it's an immensely difficult task to keep us up with this squad, IMO the worst in the division, especially if he don't allow him to spend in Jan.
RE: Well, that was a day. - Psalm23 - 12-17-2020
(12-17-2020, 10:05 AM)MGalea Wrote: Great post Birdmon. Bravo.
+1
Well said Birdy.
RE: Well, that was a day. - Squid - 12-17-2020
(12-16-2020, 08:21 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Toon fans -
He’ll erode your love of the game until all you can think about is how much you can’t stand him. If you need any more proof of how horrid a bloke he is, then just look at the fact he’s a Sunderland hero.
An experience we prefer not to talk about. We still haven't recovered.
He’s absolute shite! Better than Bruce, but shite all the same.
The football is boring and turgid and he makes everything about him!
Horrific. Even given what has happened since, I wouldn’t have him back. Turgid football and self-centred, arrogant interviews will make you hate him and football.
Everton fans comments even worse.
I actually went to have a look at what Everton fans had been saying. Aside from many of their forums having a "snow effect", here's what a charming Everton fan had to say about some of our players:
"I've heard that a number of those british lads have serious attitude problems. Furlongs, Gibbs, Livermore, Diangana, Harper, Edwards, Peltier and Grant...all problems in the squad."
No one on the forum challenged that statement.
I am amazed he hasn't also mentioned Bartley, Semi and Sawyers because he seems to have conveniently listed every other black player we have. I have a low opinion of Everton fans anyway, because they are bitter and entitled to a ludicrous degree, but I really hope we get our revenge at the Hawthorns.
|