WBAUnofficial
Christmas Break - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Christmas Break (/showthread.php?tid=13759)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8


RE: Christmas Break - Derek Hardballs - 11-21-2020

(11-21-2020, 11:35 AM)JOK Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 09:27 AM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(11-19-2020, 09:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No one is forcing them but they are influencing them. The state of the right wing newspapers today hailing Christmas is back on / saved ffs! It’s just a government randomly picking and choosing what measures it takes based on whether it will see them up or down in opinion polls. A truly pathetic way to run a government.
Fucking hell, most people are sensible enough to follow the guidelines. How many times have we been told it will not be a normal Christmas.

The impact of some of our elderly neighbours not seeing loved ones is huge. Sensible meeting up is what we are on about here.

The problem are those that continue to flout the rules and they are not influenced in the slightest by the “right wing” press.

Public Attitude
Cummings and goings
 
Here we go again. Same old Same old let’s ignore facts and follow the ‘Left wing’ press line.
The Cummins story broke on the 20th of May. But surveys from April show that this event “undermined people’s confidence”. Wonder where they got their crystal balls. After the event the percentage of people 1200 only questioned who ‘admitted’ not following the guidelines rose from 4% to 9%. hardly mega. And the reason given was the they didn’t agree with them: “There are two explanations for our findings. It could be that people are more willing to discuss their past breaches of the lockdown or that more people have broken the lockdown in the past week.” The second survey linked was of 200 people again not a great cross section and if you read that linked piece, it states : “They then carried out a follow up survey with 200 people on the 27 May to explore the effect of the news.

"Across all 1,201 people interviewed in both surveys, 69 per cent of people reporting they followed government guidance at all times, while 31% reported breaking the guidance to help others, because of a personal need (e.g. work), or because they do not agree with the guidance itself.”  
Other than suggesting it in the title, where does it conclusively state the Cummins affair altered people’s behaviour?
Here, again, is just a small section of reports from before the 20th of May:
Metro story of crowds in various places ignoring social distancing. 22nd March
Or the thousands that flocked to Durdle Door and Southend in early May.
Treknow on Good Friday.
Crowed London parks reported on the 5th of May.

Crowds on Westminster Bridge on 20th April.
Countless pubs having secret lock-ins.
Or the reports of crowds flocking to markets and shops in London and Leicester on the 3rd of May.
Crowds watching an organised Street Fight in Newcastle. 19th May.
Residents ‘fear for their safety’ as crowds ignore lockdown rules and gather on Sheffield streets. 8th April.

Cops break up crowd for ignoring social distancing rules at vigil for man, 38, who died in motorbike crash.  20th April.
Seaside visitors defy social distancing advice in Hove, Brighton, Skegness… 21st March.
Illegal Rave broken up after 36 hours .
 
Tens of thousands of people NOT following the guidelines and laws well before the Cummins affair. Do tell me, where did these people get their ‘Cummins excuse’ to ignore the government and scientists BEFORE the actions, you claim caused the opening of the floodgates, triggered by one idiot took place?
 
The Sun’s headline on the 18th Nov. HO NO, Now UK faces 25 DAYS of Christmas after medic got it wrong.
On the 24th of October the same rag put; HOPES for Brits having a family Christmas have been bolstered as lifting restrictions for two days would only have a "limited impact" on coronavirus spreading, a top expert has said. Quoting professor Neil Fergusson.  Adding "It risks transmission and there will be consequences of that. Some people will die because of getting infected on that day."
Not quite the “hailing Christmas is back on / saved ffs!”  You claim the ‘Right Wing’ press is promoting, is it?  

Whilst your putting me right on this can you also answer me on my points and examples I cited re: how this government filling roles with like minded people is any different to any other administration. from your thread  ‘The Vote Leave Party’. You seem to have forgotten to, for some reason!

‘Left wing press’ - I’ve linked to a DeMonrford University study and a report in the Lancet!

I quote from the Lancet.

On May 22, 2020, The Guardian and Daily Mirror newspapers in the UK published details of how Dominic Cummings, senior aide to the British prime minister, had broken lockdown rules by travelling 420 km to a family estate with his wife (who had suspected COVID-19) and child. Although some other officials and senior figures had also broken the lockdown rules, this transgression was the first to not immediately be followed by an apology and resignation. The event prompted media condemnation, with concerns about transparency, accountability, and equality,1 and many scientists spoke out about the effect of Cummings' actions and the UK Government's defence of Cummings in undermining essential public health messaging.

It is only now, however, with the benefit of hindsight provided by systematic data, that we can see these negative effects in stark detail. New analyses of 220 755 surveys from 40 597 individuals in England, Scotland, and Wales, completed between April 24 and June 11, 2020, as part of University College London's COVID-19 Social Study, show that these events undermined confidence in the government to handle the pandemic specifically.

We report the change in ratings of confidence in the government to handle the pandemic from the baseline on April 24, 2020 (appendix p 1–3). Participants from England answered about central government, and participants in Scotland and Wales answered about their own devolved governments. Confidence was measured on a scale from 1 (not at all) to 7 (completely). The sample was well stratified across sociodemographic factors and weighted to population proportions for core demographics (appendix p 9). Starting on May 22, 2020, there was a clear decrease in confidence in England, a decline that continued over the following days. Analyses of data from Google Trends showed that public searches of Dominic Cummings' name peaked 3 days later (May 25, 2020; appendix p 4) when he gave a televised statement. This peak coincided with the steepest decline in confidence in government (appendix p 1–3).

To ascertain whether this decrease in confidence was as a result of the Cummings events (a Cummings effect), we carried out analyses using two types of comparisons. First, we compared the responses for people living in England to those of people living in the devolved nations of Scotland and Wales who were asked to rate their confidence in their own devolved governments. There was no evidence of a similar large decrease in confidence in the governments of the devolved nations either descriptively (appendix p 1–3) or statistically (appendix p 5) during the 3 weeks following May 22, 2020. Second, using data from questions identical in format to those about confidence in government, we compared confidence in the health service to cope with the pandemic, and confidence that access to essentials (eg, food and medication) would be maintained during the same time period. There was no evidence of a decrease in confidence in the health system or confidence in acquiring essentials during the same time period, either in descriptive data or when applying statistical tests (appendix pp 1, 2, 5), further showing that the change in confidence in the government was a considerable departure from the weeks preceding the Cummings events.

Public trust in the government's ability to manage the pandemic is crucial as this trust underpins public attitudes and behaviours at a precarious time for public health. Our data show how closely public confidence is related to government announcements regarding COVID-19. After an initial increase in public confidence in the ability of the government to handle the pandemic well between March 21 and March 23, 2020, as lockdown came in, the government's announcement on May 10, 2020, that society would begin to reopen in England through a staged series of lockdown easing measures as part of a new COVID-19 alert level system was followed by a decrease in confidence (appendix p 1–3). Leaders of devolved governments in Scotland and Wales who expressed concern that these measures were risky and premature and who did not change lockdown measures or messaging did not see any clear decreases in confidence from their public.3 Data show that confidence stabilised and even improved slightly in England in the fortnight following these events, until the Cummings effect.

This finding is echoed by data from weekly political surveys, which show that confidence decreased with these announcements but then remained stable for 2 weeks until the Cummings events, when confidence suddenly decreased further (appendix p 6).

Another reason for concern is that trust is related to people's willingness to follow rules and guidelines, both generally and during the COVID-19 pandemic,4,  5 which is fundamental to the control of infection and mortality. There had already been a gradual decrease in public adherence to guidelines before the publicity about Cummings' actions on May 22, but the difference in this decline between England and Wales and Scotland grew in the 3 weeks following (May 22–June 11, 2020; appendix p 7, 8).

Although, as of June 17, 2020, more than a month has passed since the Cummings events, data show there has been no recovery in confidence in the government, with confidence in England remaining low and gaps between confidence in England and confidence in devolved nations growing (appendix p 8). Trust in government decisions and actions relating to the management of COVID-19 is a major challenge worldwide, and these data show the negative and lasting consequences that political decisions can have for public trust and the risks to behaviours.

We declare no competing interests. The COVID-19 Social Study was funded by the Nuffield Foundation [WEL/FR-000022583], but the views expressed in this Correspondence are those of the authors and are not necessarily those of the Nuffield Foundation. The study was also financially supported by the MARCH Mental Health Network, UK Research and Innovation [ES/S002588/1], and the Wellcome Trust [221400/Z/20/Z]. DF was funded by the Wellcome Trust [205407/Z/16/Z]. We are grateful for the support of several organisations in recruitment efforts, including the UKRI Mental Health Networks, Find Out Now, UCL BioResource, SEO Works, FieldworkHub, and Optimal Workshop. The study was also supported by HealthWise Wales (the Health and Care Research Wales initiative, which is led by Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK, in collaboration with SAIL, Swansea University, Swansea, UK). The funders of the study had no role in study design, data collection, data analysis, data interpretation, or writing of the report. The corresponding author had full access to all the data in the study and had final responsibility for the decision to submit for publication.

My opinion, the argument government behaviour and decisions and those media outlets that are friendly to them have no influence on many people’s behaviour is naive. It will certainly come as a big disappointment to them and the millions they spend to do exactly that.

These are academic studies and statistical data from the likes of Google what have others who disagree as a counter argument based on more than belief and a few headlines.


RE: Christmas Break - Jack Halford - 11-21-2020

(11-21-2020, 10:19 AM)Tom Joad Wrote:
Jack Halford Wrote:Fucking hell, most people are sensible enough to follow the guidelines. How many times have we been told it will not be a normal Christmas.

The impact of some of our elderly neighbours not seeing loved ones is huge. Sensible meeting up is what we are on about here.

The problem are those that continue to flout the rules and they are not influenced in the slightest by the “right wing” press.

Is a very good point. It is going to be very hard to get 60M+ people to all follow the same rules (including bubbles etc), after such a difficult year and the police simply don't have the resources or desire to go and tear Granny away from the grandkids she barely sees. Just IMO but, maybe a policy of targeting those that openly abuse the rules (very much a minority),with an understanding that many people have learned to be careful over the last 9 months. No government can win on this.

Exactly Tom. This is the same issue people are facing throughout Europe and none of the governments can win.

The problem is we have too soft on those that have blatantly flouted the rules with mass gatherings etc...


RE: Christmas Break - JOK - 11-21-2020

(11-21-2020, 12:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 11:35 AM)JOK Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 09:27 AM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(11-19-2020, 09:47 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: No one is forcing them but they are influencing them. The state of the right wing newspapers today hailing Christmas is back on / saved ffs! It’s just a government randomly picking and choosing what measures it takes based on whether it will see them up or down in opinion polls. A truly pathetic way to run a government.
Fucking hell, most people are sensible enough to follow the guidelines. How many times have we been told it will not be a normal Christmas.

The impact of some of our elderly neighbours not seeing loved ones is huge. Sensible meeting up is what we are on about here.

The problem are those that continue to flout the rules and they are not influenced in the slightest by the “right wing” press.

Public Attitude
Cummings and goings
 
Here we go again. Same old Same old let’s ignore facts and follow the ‘Left wing’ press line.
The Cummins story broke on the 20th of May. But surveys from April show that this event “undermined people’s confidence”. Wonder where they got their crystal balls. After the event the percentage of people 1200 only questioned who ‘admitted’ not following the guidelines rose from 4% to 9%. hardly mega. And the reason given was the they didn’t agree with them: “There are two explanations for our findings. It could be that people are more willing to discuss their past breaches of the lockdown or that more people have broken the lockdown in the past week.” The second survey linked was of 200 people again not a great cross section and if you read that linked piece, it states : “They then carried out a follow up survey with 200 people on the 27 May to explore the effect of the news.

"Across all 1,201 people interviewed in both surveys, 69 per cent of people reporting they followed government guidance at all times, while 31% reported breaking the guidance to help others, because of a personal need (e.g. work), or because they do not agree with the guidance itself.”  
Other than suggesting it in the title, where does it conclusively state the Cummins affair altered people’s behaviour?
Here, again, is just a small section of reports from before the 20th of May:
Metro story of crowds in various places ignoring social distancing. 22nd March
Or the thousands that flocked to Durdle Door and Southend in early May.
Treknow on Good Friday.
Crowed London parks reported on the 5th of May.

Crowds on Westminster Bridge on 20th April.
Countless pubs having secret lock-ins.
Or the reports of crowds flocking to markets and shops in London and Leicester on the 3rd of May.
Crowds watching an organised Street Fight in Newcastle. 19th May.
Residents ‘fear for their safety’ as crowds ignore lockdown rules and gather on Sheffield streets. 8th April.

Cops break up crowd for ignoring social distancing rules at vigil for man, 38, who died in motorbike crash.  20th April.
Seaside visitors defy social distancing advice in Hove, Brighton, Skegness… 21st March.
Illegal Rave broken up after 36 hours .
 
Tens of thousands of people NOT following the guidelines and laws well before the Cummins affair. Do tell me, where did these people get their ‘Cummins excuse’ to ignore the government and scientists BEFORE the actions, you claim caused the opening of the floodgates, triggered by one idiot took place?
 
The Sun’s headline on the 18th Nov. HO NO, Now UK faces 25 DAYS of Christmas after medic got it wrong.
On the 24th of October the same rag put; HOPES for Brits having a family Christmas have been bolstered as lifting restrictions for two days would only have a "limited impact" on coronavirus spreading, a top expert has said. Quoting professor Neil Fergusson.  Adding "It risks transmission and there will be consequences of that. Some people will die because of getting infected on that day."
Not quite the “hailing Christmas is back on / saved ffs!”  You claim the ‘Right Wing’ press is promoting, is it?  

Whilst your putting me right on this can you also answer me on my points and examples I cited re: how this government filling roles with like minded people is any different to any other administration. from your thread  ‘The Vote Leave Party’. You seem to have forgotten to, for some reason!

‘Left wing press’ - I’ve linked to a DeMonrford University study and a report in the Lancet!


My opinion, the argument government behaviour and decisions and those media outlets that are friendly to them have no influence on many people’s behaviour is naive. It will certainly come as a big disappointment to them and the millions they spend to do exactly that.
The usual misreading,  bending and ignoring then. “The guardian and the Mirror reported” !
Again, how did something that was reported late in May effect what people did in March and April . Please, I ask again, How, do tell.
9% of people questioned! (Many before May 20th) gave various reasons.
The opening Paragraph states “Fewer people report they followed guidance on social distancing and ‘Stay at Home’ following Dominic Cummings’ admission that he drove from London to Durham during lockdown.” Where does it state they cited Cummins? Just that there was an increase in people admitting to ignoring guidelines.
De Montfort’s report states “Across all 1,201 people interviewed in both surveys, 69 per cent of people reporting they followed government guidance at all times, while 31% reported breaking the guidance to help others, because of a personal need (e.g. work), or because they do not agree with the guidance itself.”  Where does that mention the Cummins incident?

The Lancet article says their study  “show that these events undermined confidence in the government to handle the pandemic specifically.”  ‘Undermined confidence in the government’  NOT made them break the rules or affect their view of them.
Now, point me in the direction of the “Right Wing” press which are “hailing Christmas is back on / saved ffs!”. Or shall you ignore that as “usual”.
 
This reply was composed before your edit where you cut some personal response and you included  cut and pasted a whole report. For what reason I don't know as we can all read the report from the link, thanks. 


RE: Christmas Break - Derek Hardballs - 11-21-2020

(11-21-2020, 02:08 PM)JOK Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 12:37 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 11:35 AM)JOK Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 09:27 AM)Jack Halford Wrote: Fucking hell, most people are sensible enough to follow the guidelines. How many times have we been told it will not be a normal Christmas.

The impact of some of our elderly neighbours not seeing loved ones is huge. Sensible meeting up is what we are on about here.

The problem are those that continue to flout the rules and they are not influenced in the slightest by the “right wing” press.

Public Attitude
Cummings and goings
 
Here we go again. Same old Same old let’s ignore facts and follow the ‘Left wing’ press line.
The Cummins story broke on the 20th of May. But surveys from April show that this event “undermined people’s confidence”. Wonder where they got their crystal balls. After the event the percentage of people 1200 only questioned who ‘admitted’ not following the guidelines rose from 4% to 9%. hardly mega. And the reason given was the they didn’t agree with them: “There are two explanations for our findings. It could be that people are more willing to discuss their past breaches of the lockdown or that more people have broken the lockdown in the past week.” The second survey linked was of 200 people again not a great cross section and if you read that linked piece, it states : “They then carried out a follow up survey with 200 people on the 27 May to explore the effect of the news.

"Across all 1,201 people interviewed in both surveys, 69 per cent of people reporting they followed government guidance at all times, while 31% reported breaking the guidance to help others, because of a personal need (e.g. work), or because they do not agree with the guidance itself.”  
Other than suggesting it in the title, where does it conclusively state the Cummins affair altered people’s behaviour?
Here, again, is just a small section of reports from before the 20th of May:
Metro story of crowds in various places ignoring social distancing. 22nd March
Or the thousands that flocked to Durdle Door and Southend in early May.
Treknow on Good Friday.
Crowed London parks reported on the 5th of May.

Crowds on Westminster Bridge on 20th April.
Countless pubs having secret lock-ins.
Or the reports of crowds flocking to markets and shops in London and Leicester on the 3rd of May.
Crowds watching an organised Street Fight in Newcastle. 19th May.
Residents ‘fear for their safety’ as crowds ignore lockdown rules and gather on Sheffield streets. 8th April.

Cops break up crowd for ignoring social distancing rules at vigil for man, 38, who died in motorbike crash.  20th April.
Seaside visitors defy social distancing advice in Hove, Brighton, Skegness… 21st March.
Illegal Rave broken up after 36 hours .
 
Tens of thousands of people NOT following the guidelines and laws well before the Cummins affair. Do tell me, where did these people get their ‘Cummins excuse’ to ignore the government and scientists BEFORE the actions, you claim caused the opening of the floodgates, triggered by one idiot took place?
 
The Sun’s headline on the 18th Nov. HO NO, Now UK faces 25 DAYS of Christmas after medic got it wrong.
On the 24th of October the same rag put; HOPES for Brits having a family Christmas have been bolstered as lifting restrictions for two days would only have a "limited impact" on coronavirus spreading, a top expert has said. Quoting professor Neil Fergusson.  Adding "It risks transmission and there will be consequences of that. Some people will die because of getting infected on that day."
Not quite the “hailing Christmas is back on / saved ffs!”  You claim the ‘Right Wing’ press is promoting, is it?  

Whilst your putting me right on this can you also answer me on my points and examples I cited re: how this government filling roles with like minded people is any different to any other administration. from your thread  ‘The Vote Leave Party’. You seem to have forgotten to, for some reason!

‘Left wing press’ - I’ve linked to a DeMonrford University study and a report in the Lancet!


My opinion, the argument government behaviour and decisions and those media outlets that are friendly to them have no influence on many people’s behaviour is naive. It will certainly come as a big disappointment to them and the millions they spend to do exactly that.
The usual misreading,  bending and ignoring then. “The guardian and the Mirror reported” !
Again, how did something that was reported late in May effect what people did in March and April . Please, I ask again, How, do tell.
9% of people questioned! (Many before May 20th) gave various reasons.
The opening Paragraph states “Fewer people report they followed guidance on social distancing and ‘Stay at Home’ following Dominic Cummings’ admission that he drove from London to Durham during lockdown.” Where does it state they cited Cummins? Just that there was an increase in people admitting to ignoring guidelines.
De Montfort’s report states “Across all 1,201 people interviewed in both surveys, 69 per cent of people reporting they followed government guidance at all times, while 31% reported breaking the guidance to help others, because of a personal need (e.g. work), or because they do not agree with the guidance itself.”  Where does that mention the Cummins incident?

The Lancet article says their study  “show that these events undermined confidence in the government to handle the pandemic specifically.”  ‘Undermined confidence in the government’  NOT made them break the rules or affect their view of them.
Now, point me in the direction of the “Right Wing” press which are “hailing Christmas is back on / saved ffs!”. Or shall you ignore that as “usual”.
 
This reply was composed before your edit where you cut some personal response and you included  cut and pasted a whole report. For what reason I don't know as we can all read the report from the link, thanks. 

Neither report follows left wing media. I posted two reports from reputable sources. They both make it very clear who undertook them. They both report a decline in sticking to the rules after Cummings saga. Now you can dismiss or argue your theories why that may have occurred but the reports are more informed than those who for whatever reason want to completely debunk the influence Cummings rule breaking had on trust, adherence and public opinion, have offered.


RE: Christmas Break - The liquidator - 11-21-2020

Thick as pig shit if they done it on that basis just a very poor excuse from the idiots


RE: Christmas Break - JOK - 11-21-2020

(11-21-2020, 03:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Public Attitude
Cummings and goings
 



Neither report follows left wing media. I posted two reports from reputable sources. They both make it very clear who undertook them. They both report a decline in sticking to the rules after Cummings saga. Now you can dismiss or argue your theories why that may have occurred but the reports are more informed than those who for whatever reason want to completely debunk the influence Cummings rule breaking had on trust, adherence and public opinion, have offered.

The Left Wing press reference in my first post was in response to your usual ranting comment about the “right Wing” press’, extolling the virtue of putting lockdown on hold over Christmas not about the reports. So, stop deflecting. You still haven’t given links to any paper bigging up and celebrating the idea. Third time of asking, please do so or admit you can’t. I appreciate you want to ignore a previous post (no.36) you can’t back up. As usual. 


The one report and one article, may have noted a decline in people admitting their poor behaviour after May (9% of respondents from 5%) but I can see no definitive correlation mentioned in them to say the Cummins saga is the reason. Or that it actually increased irresponsible behaviour. So, point to the passages which says conclusively people acted how they did because they had the view, ‘if he can do it…’  And you are still to explain how tens, if not, hundreds, of thousands of people can use a future event as their reason for their irresponsible behaviour. The Lancet piece only refers to ‘Confidence’ in the government. It makes no mention of “trust, adherence and public opinion”. Or, indeed to people breaking lock down rules.

An increase in people admitting to doing something is not proof that more people are doing it. Far more people, today, admit to masturbating than they used to but I’m sure the incidence hasn’t increased in centuries.

So, you can “dismiss or argue your theories” as to why people behave irresponsibly but these pieces “informed” as they may be, do not back up your blinkered view.


RE: Christmas Break - Derek Hardballs - 11-22-2020

(11-21-2020, 07:32 PM)JOK Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 03:08 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Public Attitude
Cummings and goings
 



Neither report follows left wing media. I posted two reports from reputable sources. They both make it very clear who undertook them. They both report a decline in sticking to the rules after Cummings saga. Now you can dismiss or argue your theories why that may have occurred but the reports are more informed than those who for whatever reason want to completely debunk the influence Cummings rule breaking had on trust, adherence and public opinion, have offered.

The Left Wing press reference in my first post was in response to your usual ranting comment about the “right Wing” press’, extolling the virtue of putting lockdown on hold over Christmas not about the reports. So, stop deflecting. You still haven’t given links to any paper bigging up and celebrating the idea. Third time of asking, please do so or admit you can’t. I appreciate you want to ignore a previous post (no.36) you can’t back up. As usual. 


The one report and one article, may have noted a decline in people admitting their poor behaviour after May (9% of respondents from 5%) but I can see no definitive correlation mentioned in them to say the Cummins saga is the reason. Or that it actually increased irresponsible behaviour. So, point to the passages which says conclusively people acted how they did because they had the view, ‘if he can do it…’  And you are still to explain how tens, if not, hundreds, of thousands of people can use a future event as their reason for their irresponsible behaviour. The Lancet piece only refers to ‘Confidence’ in the government. It makes no mention of “trust, adherence and public opinion”. Or, indeed to people breaking lock down rules.

An increase in people admitting to doing something is not proof that more people are doing it. Far more people, today, admit to masturbating than they used to but I’m sure the incidence hasn’t increased in centuries.

So, you can “dismiss or argue your theories” as to why people behave irresponsibly but these pieces “informed” as they may be, do not back up your blinkered view.

You carry on lying to yourself that Cummings breaking of the rules didn’t have an affect on some people’s behaviour if it makes you feel better. The fact you can’t give any evidence to back this assertion up is fine by me. You are just playing the man rather than the ball these days JOK.


RE: Christmas Break - The liquidator - 11-22-2020

Derek why would it change if 1 person done it..... Its a piss poor excuse to flout the rules not 1 excuse for it.... I know it and you know it.


RE: Christmas Break - EastMidsBaggie - 11-22-2020

Kill your Granny at Christmas seems a 'go'er' according to much of the Tory client media this weekend !
It only people could be trusted to be sensible and much toned down Christmas this year as the vaccine is in sight BUT NO so many entitled idiots want to behave as normal and continue to put us all at risk health wise and economic wise by spreading the disease.

Derek Hardballs Wrote:
JOK Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:
Derek Hardballs Wrote:Public Attitude
Cummings and goings
 



Neither report follows left wing media. I posted two reports from reputable sources. They both make it very clear who undertook them. They both report a decline in sticking to the rules after Cummings saga. Now you can dismiss or argue your theories why that may have occurred but the reports are more informed than those who for whatever reason want to completely debunk the influence Cummings rule breaking had on trust, adherence and public opinion, have offered.

The Left Wing press reference in my first post was in response to your usual ranting comment about the “right Wing” press’, extolling the virtue of putting lockdown on hold over Christmas not about the reports. So, stop deflecting. You still haven’t given links to any paper bigging up and celebrating the idea. Third time of asking, please do so or admit you can’t. I appreciate you want to ignore a previous post (no.36) you can’t back up. As usual. 


The one report and one article, may have noted a decline in people admitting their poor behaviour after May (9% of respondents from 5%) but I can see no definitive correlation mentioned in them to say the Cummins saga is the reason. Or that it actually increased irresponsible behaviour. So, point to the passages which says conclusively people acted how they did because they had the view, ‘if he can do it…’  And you are still to explain how tens, if not, hundreds, of thousands of people can use a future event as their reason for their irresponsible behaviour. The Lancet piece only refers to ‘Confidence’ in the government. It makes no mention of “trust, adherence and public opinion”. Or, indeed to people breaking lock down rules.

An increase in people admitting to doing something is not proof that more people are doing it. Far more people, today, admit to masturbating than they used to but I’m sure the incidence hasn’t increased in centuries.

So, you can “dismiss or argue your theories” as to why people behave irresponsibly but these pieces “informed” as they may be, do not back up your blinkered view.

You carry on lying to yourself that Cummings breaking of the rules didn’t have an affect on some people’s behaviour if it makes you feel better. The fact you can’t give any evidence to back this assertion up is fine by me. You are just playing the man rather than the ball these days JOK.

Cummings was a game changer in all the outcomes since, make no mistake.
Whilst only idiots (unfortunately we so many in this country) would outwardly so that they are going to go back to normal because of him, a large portion of people more subtly    changed their options and outlooks in minor ways which had a big cumulative affect on the pandemic in this country and, hence, the repeated mess we find ourselves in.


RE: Christmas Break - JOK - 11-22-2020

(11-22-2020, 09:44 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 07:32 PM)JOK Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 09:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Public Attitude
Cummings and goings
 

The Left Wing press reference in my first post was in response to your usual ranting comment about the “right Wing” press’, extolling the virtue of putting lockdown on hold over Christmas not about the reports. So, stop deflecting. You still haven’t given links to any paper bigging up and celebrating the idea. Third time of asking, please do so or admit you can’t. I appreciate you want to ignore a previous post (no.36) you can’t back up. As usual. 
The one report and one article, may have noted a decline in people admitting their poor behaviour after May (9% of respondents from 5%) but I can see no definitive correlation mentioned in them to say the Cummins saga is the reason. Or that it actually increased irresponsible behaviour. So, point to the passages which says conclusively people acted how they did because they had the view, ‘if he can do it…’  And you are still to explain how tens, if not, hundreds, of thousands of people can use a future event as their reason for their irresponsible behaviour. The Lancet piece only refers to ‘Confidence’ in the government. It makes no mention of “trust, adherence and public opinion”. Or, indeed to people breaking lock down rules.
An increase in people admitting to doing something is not proof that more people are doing it. Far more people, today, admit to masturbating than they used to but I’m sure the incidence hasn’t increased in centuries.
So, you can “dismiss or argue your theories” as to why people behave irresponsibly but these pieces “informed” as they may be, do not back up your blinkered view.

You carry on lying to yourself that Cummings breaking of the rules didn’t have an affect on some people’s behaviour if it makes you feel better. The fact you can’t give any evidence to back this assertion up is fine by me. You are just playing the man rather than the ball these days JOK.

How am I lying to myself? I have made no  “assertion”  so there is no proof to be supplied by me. You have provided one study and one article to back up your claims (or more accurately, inferences) but they do not. I have asked you three times to point to the passages in those two pieces where they say people acted as they did BECAUSE of the actions of one incident. You have not done so. I have asked you to explain how one unknown future action  can trigger mass actions prior to said event and how the transgressors can say, “Well Cummings did it so can I” . You have not done so. Unless you deny that these scores of reported incidents didn't happen.

And there you go again with your meaningless phrases. What does “Play the man not the ball “ mean in discussion?  But here is one I can use for you for not answering valid questions asked merely to get you to prove your point. Your like a little child who doesn’t like the questions so you stick your fingers in your ears and make a noise hoping that ignoring the questions makes them go away and people will think you have won your point.

So again, where do those two pieces ,you flourished so dramatically, say conclusively what you are inferring and how do you explain the mass non-conforming to rules prior to the 20th of May  and it’s relevance to Cummings? 

Here is another question for you, using your metaphor. If you don't want to be tackled, why join the game?