WBAUnofficial
Corbyn - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Corbyn (/showthread.php?tid=13754)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


RE: Corbyn - Ted Maul - 11-22-2020

Latest polls don't look good for Sir Electable. Perhaps if he spent more time going after the government rather than his predecessor he may have a bit more joy.


RE: Corbyn - Tom Joad - 11-22-2020

Ted Maul Wrote:Latest polls don't look good for Sir Electable. Perhaps if he spent more time going after the government rather than his predecessor he may have a bit more joy.
The government are still barely 12 months in power. There's a pandemic on. I think it would look cheap to the population to hit out at an easy target. I'm guessing there will be a short term plan to gather some ideas for a manifesto and a medium term plan to latch onto the inevitable enquiries into cronyism and incapability. (I hope).  It is no time at all since Labour lost it's main support base and cheap shots at those they chose instead will do nothing to win those areas back at this time. Just my onions, obviously.


RE: Corbyn - JOK - 11-22-2020

(11-21-2020, 06:00 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 04:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote: If believing Islam is a backward creed that fails to separate church and state (the only Islamic country that ever did that has a leader busily rebuilding the "Sultanahmet"), has scant regard for free speech, considers homosexuality a sin punishable  by death and thinks cutting off little girls genitalia is acceptable then I'm proudly Islamophobic.

Though some people might consider me a Western liberal who isn't afraid to speak out for the sake of Western liberal values. Pity there aren't more of us.

Well there you are.

Anyone with half an interest in world history would know that islam is far from a backward creed  and has a record of being far more tolerant of other peoples' beliefs and religions.

For example when there was a muslim presence in the Iberian Penisular, people of the Jewish faith were able to practice their religion in safety. After the moors lost their territory there, the new christian rulers forced jews to convert tp christianity . Those who did not were killed. Wealthy jews escaping Portugal and Spain headed for the Ottoman Empire to seek refuge.

Religions are not of themselves inherently evil. However people who self identify as religious can do evil. Remember the people who put 6 million jews to death would have self identified as of the chrisitian faith - it wasn't their christian faith that led them to these acts, but then neither did it prevent them from carrying them out.

Proth, you seem to forget that the UK has an established church. Why in this day and age, heaven only knows. Also, Judaism mutilates children’s genitalia too. So do secular societies. 75%  of USA males are circumcised. So, you can’t just point to Islam for that. It is wrong and the practices performed on girls is not only detrimental to girls’  wellbeing and  quality of their later life but also barbaric. True.

It is certainly true that at the time the Moors were in Spain Muslims had an ‘Enlightenment’ long before Christian Europe and were far more advanced in the sciences and mathematics. They do seem to have  stagnated, however, and now, as we have seen, ‘seem’ quite content to regress towards the dark ages. I’m not sure now you can say it is tolerant of other creeds
I admit I know very little of the Koran and the teachings of Islam but I suspect many of the evils done in the name of Islam do not conform to the Koran’s tenant. The same, however, can be said for Christianity.

Having written all that, cases such as this do not help the cause of Islam.
(3 sources same story)
https://www.eternitynews.com.au/world/pakistan-court-sends-14-year-old-christian-girl-back-to-alleged-kidnapper/
 
https://www.thetablet.co.uk/blogs/1/1648/the-scandal-of-underage-girls-forced-to-marry-in-pakistan
 
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8973973/Christian-girl-threatened-Islamist-death-squads-Pakistan-fleeing-forced-marriage.html


RE: Corbyn - Protheroe - 11-22-2020

(11-21-2020, 06:00 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(11-21-2020, 04:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(11-20-2020, 05:45 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It's really good to know that there is no such thing as islamophobia, otherwise we would have to describe people who hate islam and muslims as bigots. Phew one less thing to worry about.

If believing Islam is a backward creed that fails to separate church and state (the only Islamic country that ever did that has a leader busily rebuilding the "Sultanahmet"), has scant regard for free speech, considers homosexuality a sin punishable  by death and thinks cutting off little girls genitalia is acceptable then I'm proudly Islamophobic.

Though some people might consider me a Western liberal who isn't afraid to speak out for the sake of Western liberal values. Pity there aren't more of us.

Well there you are.

Anyone with half an interest in world history would know that islam is far from a backward creed  and has a record of being far more tolerant of other peoples' beliefs and religions.

For example when there was a muslim presence in the Iberian Penisular, people of the Jewish faith were able to practice their religion in safety. After the moors lost their territory there, the new christian rulers forced jews to convert tp christianity . Those who did not were killed. Wealthy jews escaping Portugal and Spain headed for the Ottoman Empire to seek refuge.

Religions are not of themselves inherently evil. However people who self identify as religious can do evil. Remember the people who put 6 million jews to death would have self identified as of the chrisitian faith - it wasn't their christian faith that led them to these acts, but then neither did it prevent them from carrying them out.

Well there you are  -  I'm not talking about medieval Spain. I'm talking about the UK and Europe now where Islam is far from tolerant of other people's beliefs. Perhaps European Islam has had a reverse enlightenment?

It dosesn't surprise me that you share the same narrative as most western governments despite the evidence of 3 decades in front of our eyes. I know it's painful admitting that one particular community has made almost no effort to integrate into secular UK society. I know it's painful to admit that UK Muslims attitudes demonstrate that too ICM Survey

In terms of outcomes you couldn't get a cigarette paper between European fascism and modern Islamism. The difference is that Islamic terrorism is undenyably carried out in the name of Islam.


RE: Corbyn - Shabby Russian - 11-23-2020

Reply to Proth - i hate posts with loads of replies.

You are correct in pointing out that some people who claim to be followers of islam are committing abhorrent acts today. But it's not because of their belief in islam that cause them to do so , it's because that's who they are. It's a reason why many people who have been convicted of 'islamic' terrorism have prior convictions for violence.

I think this is a complex, but very interesting topic which deserves more time than i commit to, but i would mention something that is very little mentioned. The upper eschelons of IS's military command, were almost entirel former military leaders in Saddam Hussein's army. An almost seemless move from the secular Ba'athist party to a fundamental islamic organisation. I doubt islam was their main objective, but the control of resource and the re gaining of control f lands that they had previously controlled.


RE: Corbyn - Protheroe - 11-23-2020

(11-23-2020, 09:59 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: You are correct in pointing out that some people who claim to be followers of islam are committing abhorrent acts today. But it's not because of their belief in islam that cause them to do so , it's because that's who they are. It's a reason why many people who have been convicted of 'islamic' terrorism have prior convictions for violence.

Are you suggesting there's no connection between Islam and terrorist acts carried out in the name of Islam?

It's huge leap from having a conviction for 'violence' to cutting off a soldiers head or blowing up little girls at a pop concert.