![]() |
|
The way forward??? - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Thread: The way forward??? (/showthread.php?tid=13281) |
RE: The way forward??? - billybassett - 10-20-2020 (10-19-2020, 11:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:(10-19-2020, 08:35 PM)billybassett Wrote: I think it says a lot about your thought processes and curiosity that you post that with the obvious intent to scare and shock when you've clearly no clue as to testing or the reporting of covid deaths. What point were you making then RE: The way forward??? - baggy1 - 10-20-2020 One of the things that surprises me throughout this is the amount of people that are willing to ignore the basic facts because it doesn't suit their needs. In this case baggybuckster seems to not know the real basics and argue that this is all some sort of conspiracy for some reason. Just for a bit of context I've only reported certain facts during the last few months because i only want to highlight real data that can be compared with other countries and earlier in the year. This is to show how we are doing as a country in comparison with others and also to use the data from earlier in the year to see if any patterns are repeating. As of yesterday in England there were 5,402 in hospital with coronavirus (this isn't a made up figure this is off the government website and they have no reason to inflate it with people who have scraped their knee included), and that means they are admitted to a bed and receiving treatment for coronavirus. This compares directly with earlier in the year as of the 26th or 27th March when there were 5,045 (26th) and 6,245 (27th) in hospital beds. As you can see the numbers from earlier in the year were increasing at a greater rate than they are today but don't let that take away from the fact that the numbers of people in hospital is increasing. The peak of the numbers in hospital was on the 12th April at 17,172 and using the figures above that shows that in 16 days the number in hospital tripled, we are not running at that rate now. At the current rate of growth (1.5x a week) we will reach an equivalent number (17k) in about 3 weeks, that is roughly half the growth rate as it was earlier in the year. And here is the key point to the above, the growth between the 26th March and the 12th April was completely during lockdown, so it was already out there and took two weeks to stop growing after lockdown. Based on that fact we can say that if we lockdown at the end of this week (when the figure looks like it will be at 6k) then the peak of the numbers of people in hospital will reach about 13.5k, if we wait until the end of next week (with the continued rate of rise) that peak will be at 20k. This is the very point as to why Labour have called for a circuit break now to bring the figures down because of that two week delay. Now it should also be pointed out that the numbers on ventilators and the death rate isn't as bad as it was in the early part of the year, the number of people on ventilators as of the 18th is only 504 which is roughly 10% of those in hospital, on the 12th April the numbers on ventilators was 2,881 (about 16%). Also the number of excess deaths is nowhere near as high as it was earlier in the year (I will update that later today with the latest figures which are delayed by a couple of weeks). So despite the conspiracy theorists around there are some good hard facts to support a circuit break. And by that I mean a couple of weeks where a support package is given to individuals and businesses to bring the numbers in hospitals back down to manageable figures and buy some time for the government to sort out the test and trace system. If this doesn't happen now it will be too late and we are heading into the winter period. This measure is needed to provide some space in our hospital beds and make sure our NHS staff aren't overwhelmed as we head into their busy time of year. RE: The way forward??? - billybassett - 10-20-2020 I think this is where we fundamentally diverge. 5402 in hospital with Coronavirus. You're taking that at face value. We know that all people that are getting treated in hospital for anything are getting tested. We know that a % of those will be positive. We know there is a high false positive error rate. We also know that whilst in hospital for non-covid matters people acquire covid as well - nosocomial. All in all this equates to what we are seeing which is a growing - but now flattening - number of people "with" covid but a much reduced number of people requiring emergency treatment. Spain have now dropped how many tests they are doing and the cases have fallen exactly in line. This is evidence of a false positive pseudo epidemic. 80 people died yesterday with an average age of 82, who had, in the last 28 days tested positive for covid (many of which will have been false positives) 1700 other people died from a variety of other causes. Average age of death for these people was 81. I'm not saying we shouldn't be vigilant and I'm certainly not underplaying the tragedy in March April but to lockdown on the basis of what we currently know of this particular covid flu virus and the numbers would be so much more damaging. RE: The way forward??? - baggiebuckster - 10-20-2020 https://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/politics/hospital-transmission-covid-coronavirus-cases-19092030 What are all these people being treated for? Covid or the original medical complaint they were originally admitted for? RE: The way forward??? - baggy1 - 10-20-2020 (10-20-2020, 07:00 AM)billybassett Wrote: I think this is where we fundamentally diverge. 5402 in hospital with Coronavirus. You're taking that at face value. There is no other way to take it than at face value - these are the same measurements as they were in March / April, these people are in hospital being treated for covid, I have seen no evidence to support this theory that they went in for a broken hip or toothache. These are people in hospital being treated for covid, that is the primary reason they are in hospital. You keep talking about testing - I am ignoring the testing figures because they have no use whatsoever, you seem to think the government want to inflate the figures when inflating those figures make them look bad, what would they do that, it makes no sense whatsoever. Age has no bearing on the figures, this is about people dying - earlier in the year someone on here was saying 'it will just even out as the year goes on, they would have died anyway' - this hasn't happened, we are still at 54k excess deaths compared with the 5YA, And based on the current rate of rise in hospital bed occupancy for covid we will reach the same figure as the peak in April in 3 weeks time, any delay in that lockdown and the peak will be higher than in April (based on the growth rate for the last 6 weeks which has been constant). You are gambling that it might not happen because it isn't flattening I'm afraid. A couple of weeks ago I said at the current rate it will be about 6k by the end of this week, it's at 5.4k as of yesterday. (10-20-2020, 07:07 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: https://www.walesonline.co.uk/news/politics/hospital-transmission-covid-coronavirus-cases-19092030 Your logic is saying that people stop going to hospital which is completely the opposite of what we want - we need people to go back to hospital to get treatment for non-covid issues because the long term damage of that will far outstrip covid. The problem is we haven't got rid of covid, that is the 1st step to getting back to normal. Your point isn't thought out, what are you actually proposing to solve the problem. (10-09-2020, 02:54 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Another Friday and another increase in numbers; 3,044 now in hospital in England compared to 1,995 a week ago and 368 of those on ventilators compared with 285 this time last week so basically 1.5 times increase in a week of those in hospital which was the same for the week before (23rd - 1,381) and the week before that (16th - 894). If we continue like that then we will have issues. On the same curve of the last 4 weeks that gives us 4.5k next week, 6.75k the week after and 10k by the end of the month. Just to clarify a mistake i made earlier - I said that by the end of the week I had predicted the figure to be at the end of this week would be at 6k, in fact on the 9th I had said it would be at 6.75k (see above from the 9th), so Billy is nearly correct that it is flattening but it isn't anywhere near flat yet and still increasing. We ae heading towards that peak figure in hospital with covid compared with April within the next month. RE: The way forward??? - billybassett - 10-20-2020 The March/April compare doesn't stack because people weren't being tested when they arrived in hospital and actually the number of admissions to hospital were only 50% of the story as we saw from private home deaths. Also in March/April covid was reported in a much different way hence the downgrading of all the numbers by phe. A friend of a friend has just this week had a family member pass away. Tragic. He was diagnosed with cancer some time ago. He was admitted to hospital 10 days ago and unfortunately passed away. Whilst there he was tested for Covid. He came up positive. He now has Covid on his death certificate. Shocking. I know this is only 1 case and 1 case doesn't make a story but even if this is just 1 case it is corruption in its own right - not least for the family. As for getting rid of covid - we can't. It's a seasonal covid variant flu. It will become an endemic seasonal flu like the other 4 in circulation. We will all either get it and carry on or not get it because endemic flus naturally terminate in season. After 4-5 years we will get another spike of another variant. It's what happens. So using that as the basis of getting back to normal is flawed because this is normal. In 2018-19 64000 people died in the January the largest recorded since 2006, beds and hospitals were under pressure and the govt was pressed. ONS reported seasonal influenza as the cause. We really need to reset our thinking on what has happened and where we are now. RE: The way forward??? - baggiebuckster - 10-20-2020 Where have I said people should stop going to hospital? All I have said is that when the MSM report the 'number of people in hospital WITH Covid' it gives the impression that those people REQUIRE treatment for Covid which the general public take at face vakue. But going by the Gov stats it says it includes people who are a confirmed Covid case. The definition of a confirmed Covid case is someone who has tested positive (or a false positive) with OR without symptoms. So that leaves the door open for people in hospital for something else entirely who test positive with no symptoms to be included in those figures. So what Covid treatment do you believe they are giving to those people? RE: The way forward??? - baggy1 - 10-20-2020 I'm not certain where you ae getting your figures from BB but these are the figures for January over the last few years and the 5YA: 5YA - 64,179 Jan 20 - 62,770 Jan 19 - 58,461 Jan 18 - 69,249 Jan 17 - 64,678 Jan 18 was only 5k over the 5YA and I have included 5 weeks because of the way the dates fall (it's measured weekly, not monthly), we had 45k excess deaths in May alone because of covid, these are not comparable. RE: The way forward??? - billybassett - 10-20-2020 I think the NSA has intercepted your post. I saw today that Ireland has gone to lockdown. Since June their average daily death toll for covid is 1 per day. Astounding. RE: The way forward??? - baggy1 - 10-20-2020 (10-20-2020, 07:36 AM)baggiebuckster Wrote: Where have I said people should stop going to hospital? believe what you want, i'm just telling you the number of people in hospital getting treated for covid. (10-20-2020, 07:44 AM)billybassett Wrote: I think the NSA has intercepted your post. that's me being lazy and trying to post a bit of a spreadsheet I have rather than type it outAnd that figure is incredible but they do have a much smaller population however it shows how important it is to stamp it out which will in turn stop the growth. |